HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-6-1990 P&Z MINUTES , ,
i E .. � ,
� �
.
� MINUTES
i PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
Meeting of December 6, 1990
Present: Chuck Randolph, Chairman Pro—tem, Rita Earl, Les
Carter, Wanda Anthony, Tom Page, Tom Ensley and Mary
Higdem.
Chairman Randolph called the regular meeting of the Planning and
Zoning Commission to order in the City Hall Council Chambers at
7:00 p.m. The agenda was presented with one addition. Dennis
Crooks presented the item to the Commission involving an
initiation of an amendment to the City Zoning Map and an
amendment to the Caldwell Zoning Ordinance. With no ob�ection
from the Commission the item was added to the %agenda as a
miscellaneous item.
The next item of business was approval of the Planning and Zoning
Commission minutes from the r�egular meeting of November 15, 1990.
With no additions or corrections offered by the Commission, Les
Carter made a motion to approve the minutes as distributed.
Wanda Anthony seconded the motion. A vote was taksn and the
motion passed unanimously.
The next item of business was the scheduled public hearings.
The first public hearing was a Variance application to allow a
reductien or the required street side setback of 20 teet and the
side yard setback of 4 feet to accommodate the placement of a
wall for the Canyon County Juvenile Detention Faciiity. Canyon
County, applicant.
The first person to offer public testimony was Mr. Glen Koch,
Canyon County Commissioner, 23306 Freezeout Road, Caldwell. Mr.
Koch stated the reason for the request was to utilize the land
surrounding this facility in the best possibie way. He further
stated that law enforcement officia?s have concerns about
loitering near the rear of the facility should the 20 foot
setback regulation be enforced.
Dennis briefly outlined the Staff's concerns and terms and
conditions associated with this request. Some of the issues of
concern include the height of the wall, maintenance of the
property and the effect t placement of the wall would have on
the surrounding residential neighborhood.
Chairman Randolph opened the hearing to receive questions from I
the Commission. Chuck Randolph asked Mr. Koch if the design of
the facility and placement of the wall had been changed since the
public hearing held November 15 regarding the Special Use Permit
application. Mr. Koch stated that the design of the wall has not
changed.
1
R�
• i
, With no further questions Tom Page made a motion to approve the
Variance request with the terms and conditions recommended by i
Staff. Les Carter seconded the motion. T'om Ensley stated for
the record that he was abstaining from discussion and voting.
With no further discussion a vote was taken and the motion passed
unanimously, with Tom Ensley abstaining.
The next public hearing was a Variance application to allow a
waiver of City sign ordinance to accommodate the installation of
4 freestanding identification signs for a new automotive
dealership. Duane Wolfe, applicant.
Dennis explained the request, Iocation of the sub.]ect property
and proposed placement of the signs. Dennis further stated that
the placement of the monument sign wili need readJustment due to
the fact that it has been determined that the signs are placed
within utility easements. One sign is iocated over;a City Water
line and the other within Pioneer Irrigation District easement.
Dennis further stated that one of the terms and conditions
recommended by Staff states that the placement of the monument
signs shall be located outside of the easements, subject to the
review and approval of the City Engineer and Pioneer Irrigation
District.
Tom Page questioned if the monument signs would inhibit the
sight distance in any way. Dennis responded that the sight
distance would not be a factor.
Mary Higciem questioned Dennis if the temporary signs approved in
a previous pubi;c hearing would be removed. Dennis stated that
another term and condition recommended by Staff indicates that
the temporary signs are to be removed within 10 days after the
installation of the new freestanding signs.
The first person to offer public testimony was Rory Needs, 7917
Willbeth Lane, Nampa, Id., Chief Financial Officer for Wolfe
Automotive Group. Mr. Needs stated that the purpose of the
addiiional signs was to aid the consumer in better identifying
the different types of automobiles located on the property. i�Ir.
?Veeds indicated that the dealership is opposed to the removal or
the used car sign and the readerboard and would like tne
Commission to consider deleting this condition to allow these
signs to remain in their present location.
Chuck Randolpn questioned Mr. Needs regarding a relocation or
possibie alternate placement of the used car sign. Mr. Needs
indicated that the used car sign would remain in its present
location, as would the readerboard.
Chuck Randolph asked Mr. Needs if the temporary signs would be
removed. Mr. Needs stated that these signs would be removed
after installation of the monument signs.
2
, .
Chuck Randolph as�d i�Ir. Needs if the ter� and conditions,
' including the amendment ot the tarm stating that the placement of
one sign be approved by tne Pioneer Irrigation District was
agraeable to the applicants. Mr. Needs stated that, other than
the condition regarding the removai �f the used car sign and the
readerboard, the other conditions recommend�d by Staff were
agreeable.
Tom Page asked Dennis the justification for condition #5 in
Staff's recommendations. Dennis stated that Staff concern was
the quantity of signs al�ng a particular fr�ntage and the generai
issue of fairness and equitability to other businesses along the
Boulevard.
Tom Ensley asked �ennis the amount of excess square footaqe of
these signs in relationship to the Code requirements. Dennis
rererenced the total sign area as stated in th� report and
indicated that the total area of the proposed signs substantialiy
exceeds the Code requirements. ;
Chuck Randolpn stated tnat a consideration must be mada for
setting a�recedent in allowing the variance ror other commercia?
property nwners along this major boulevard.
Mary Higdem aske� if signs could �e placed further back on the
facility that wouid not violate the int�nt of tne Zoning Code
advertising u�ed c�rs. Dennis stated �ha± there could be
additionai signir.g on The nu�ldinq idenLifying the ditferent
dea�erships.
�r. Needs stated that he did not feel a precedent was being set
when consiaering the other dealerships in the area that have
excess siqnage on their frontage. He further stated that sign�ge
is very important ir. attracting consumers to the property and the
use of the used car sign is very important to indicate to the
customer passing by that use� cars exist on the property. He
rurther stated that the readerboard �romotes �;fferent activities
in the dealership and feeis that when tak;rg the entire facility
into consideration the number and size or the proposed signs,
leaving the used car sign and ihe readernoard, sh�uld not �e a
h�ndrance in any way.
Chuck P.andolph �sked Mr. Neeas if the dealership would consider
mo�ring the readex further to the interior of the facility.
Mr. rleeds stated that iec�ting the sigr. further back would
necessitate �lacing it higher and makyng it much larger to enable
the passing traffic to be able to ses the message on the si�gn.
Mary Higdem commented that this fac�izty has improved but has a
reluctance to vary fr�m the condition as suggested by Staff in
item #5.
Rita Earl commented that this particular area on the Boulevard is
extr�mely busy and has a history of frequen� traffic accidents
in this area. She questioned if the aa�itional signs would
distract consu�ers and facilitate more of a traffic hazard. Mr.
Needs statad that nP does not believe the additiona� signage •
c�ntributes t� �h;s �:oblem.
3
, .
With na *urther di�cussion Mary Higdem made a to approve
, �
the Variance with the five (5? terms and conditions recommended �
by Staff. Les Carter seconded th� motion. With no further ',
discussion a vote was taken and the motion passed. Tom Page '
abstained from voting.
Chuck Randolph asked Dennis to explain to the applicant the
rights of appeal. Dennis indicated to the applicant that anyone
has the right to appeal the decision and/or par�, of the terms
and conditions recommended by the Planning and Zoning Commission
to the City Council. It is required that this appeal be filed
with the Planning and 2oning Department within 5 working days of
the Commission's decision.
Tom Page explained the reason for his abstention. He stated that
he was not in support of condition number 5 which required the
removal of two t2) signs within eighteen months. Mr Page
further stated that he does not find the used car sign and
readerbeard sign to be objectionable.
The next public hearing was a Code amendment to the Caldwell
Zonir.ct Ordir.ar.ce for consideration or change in land use
classification for child care facilities in residential zones.
City of Caldweli, applicant.
Dennis explained tne r and possible options that the
Commission could consider in amending this ordinance.
The first person io offer public testimony was Karen Taylor, 305
�iV. I�a� Lane, Ca?dwell. Ms. Tay3or commented t�at she operated a
day care facility withir. the City limits of Caidwell for 11 years
and feels there is a great need for in—house daycare in Caldwell.
MS. T�u-ylo�' further urged the Commission not to restrict home
operated daycares with of;—street partcing requirements as most
homes are not built in areas that can accommodate off—street
parking.
The next person to orfer �ublic testimony was Pam Silveria, 717
N. LaCresta, Ca:dwell. Ms. Silveria stated that she has operated
a day care raciiity in Caldwell for "� years. She further stated
�hat there has r.ot been a traffic or parking problem related to
her daycare faciiity and urged the Commission to look at each
request on an individual basis regardless of zoning.
The next person to offer public testimony was Ronica Kester, 1417
�,T. LaCresta, Ca'_dwell. Ms. Kester stated that she owns �nd
operates a daycare facility in hsr home and takes children that
have handicaps trat other daycare centers will not take.
The next person to offer public testimony was Michelle Mitche??,
206 Blaine St., Caldwell. Ms. Mitchell stated that she has a
handicapped child and had extreme difficulty finding a daycare
cente:, other than one that is home based, that wauld accept her
child and meet his needs.
�
. -
� � •
, The next person to offer public testimony was Camillo Lopez, 1721
Roosevelt, Caldwell with an office at �02 Chicago, Caldwell. Mr.
Lopez stated that he feels that daycare facilities should be
regulated and they should be eliminated in the R-1 zone to
protect the rights of those neighbors in surrounding homes from
these facilities. Mr. Lopez also stated that these in—home
facilities have an advantage of not paying the same rate of taxes
as daycare centers and other businesses. ,
The next person to offer public testimony was Pat Webb, 11530 '
Edna, Boise, Id. Ms. Webb stated that she was representing I
Uniteci Kidd Care, an organization representing parents and
businesses to make people aware of providers a:�d child care �
problems and to improve the quality of daycare in the I
communities. Ms. Webb stated that there is a need for daycare �
centers in the communities where the children live but feels that
there is a need for regulating these facilities. ;
The next person to offer public testimony was Diane Terwilleger,
100 S. Maple Grove Rd., Boise, Id. Ms. Ter stated that
sne appeared before the Commission on request of someone else to
read a letter for that person. Ms. Terwilleger read the
correspondence to the Commission in support of home based daycare
facilities and signed by Pat Duncan, parent representative for
United Kidd Care.
The next person to offer public testimony was t�iachelle Ferguson,
a e
� 1418 Teton Caldwell o erator of the Kinder Cotta e Da c r
. , p J Y
Center at 1923 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell. Ms. Ferguson stated
that she began a daycare facility in her home 13 years ago before
moving to a center on Cleveland Blvd. Ms. Ferguson continued by
stating that she feels the system that is in effect now is
adequate and does not ses a need to amend or modify the process
as it naw regulates daycare facilities.
Dennis indicated that there had been other phone calls and
correspondence regarding this issue.
Chairman Randolph asked Dennis to briefly explain the differences
between the zones. Dennis explained the three basic residential
�oning classirications, the R-1, R-2 anci R-3 zones, the
differences between them and which zones require a Special Use
Permit to allow daycare facilities to operate.
Tom Ensley stated that he would like to hear further testimony
from other agencies that may be afrected by this amendment such
as real estate agencies, etc.
Chuck Randolph questioned Dennis regarding the notification
process that was used prior to this public hearing. Dennis
stated that legal notice was published in the newspaper as
required by law and that the newspaper did an article regarding
the issue, Staff notified all yellow page listings of daycare
operators in the Caldwell phone book and other organizations that
would have an interest in this public hearing. Also the Chamber
of Commerce and the Board of kealtors were notified.
5
r ' �
�
� �
, Rita Earl commented that she felt a consideration should be made
for the existing land use on a piece of property in the R-1 zone.
Many R-1 zone properties are developed with uses other than
single family residences.
Tom Page made a motion to continue the hearing to the regular
meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission scheduled for
January 17, 1991. Tom Ensley seconded the motion. With no
further discussion a vote was taken and the motion passed
unanimously.
The next item of business was the miscellaneous items on the
agenda. The first miscellaneous item was initiation of a Code
amendment to Off-street Parking and Loading Schedule (Section 6-
2-1, Table 3 of the Caldwell Zoning Ordinance}.
Dennis indicated that the purpose of this amendment as to review,
re-evaluate and possibly amend sections of the Code pertaining to
the construction and development of parking lots and to look
specifically at the possibility of adopting landscaping standards
for parking iots.
Tom Ensley made a motion to schedule this item for public hearing
at a future date, yet undetermined. Wanda Anthony seconded the
motion. With no further discussion a vote was taken and the
motion passed unanimously.
The next miscellaneous item was a report on City Council action. '
Dennis indicate� that the Council had approved the Code amendment
pertaining to lot development standards as recommended by the
Commission and that on December 17th, the Council would be
considering the Olson Zone Change and the Subdivision Ordinance
Amendment.
The next miscellaneous item was the proposed agenda for the
January 17th regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning
Commission. Items tentatively scheduled include: a variance
request from Caldwell High School, a Spscial Use Permit for a
Warehouse in a C-3 zone, a Prsliminary Plat request, and
continuation of the daycare facility code amendment.
The next miscellaneous item involved an �mendment to the Caldwell
Zoning Ordinance involving a zone change from M-1 to I-P and a
code amendment to review I-P zoning development standards.
Mary Higdem made a motion for staff to initiate a study on these
items. Wanda Anthony seconded the motion. A vote was taken and
the motion passed unanimously.
With no further business the meeting adjourned at 9:40 p.m.
Respectfully submitted, Approved by,
� ��� ��
Sus Mullen, Chuck Randolph,
Recording Secretary Chairman - Pro-tem
6