HomeMy WebLinkAbout8-24-1989 P&Z MINUTES • •
�
a
PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
August 24, 1989
The regular meeting of the Cald�!ell Plannin� and Zoning Commission
was called to order by Chairman Bili Fre? at 7:3t� p.m,, Thursday,
August 24, 1989 in the ri�y Hall Council Chambers. Members
present were Les Carter, Wanda Anthvny, Tam Ensley, Terry Durbin,
Ron Myers, and Chuck Randolph, Jr. Garret Nancolas was absent.
T�m Ens1Ry mvwPd, �¢candPJ by L�s Carter, tv dispen�e with tl�e
reading o the minutes �f tt�� �perial meeting held at 1i:4�4� a,m.,
August ic7th, and approve them as printed and �istributed, Motion
carried.
The first item on the a enda was fc�r th? ��ntinuation vf the ublic
9 P
hearing on the applicati�n submitted by Ju�n Garcia rp��sesting a
special use permit for an electronic gam� roam at 417 Ri. 5th
Avenue.
At the public hearing held on August lnth, the �vmmission felt that
more information was needed from the Police Department and Staff
to answer questions that arose from testimony given.
Sylvia, the Planning and Zoning Director, said shP contacted the
Chief of Pol ice regarding the r?�uesteJ �sse vf t!?e b{�i 1 Jing and a
copy of his memv was given to the Commi=si�n members, 5ylvia said
she also had a meeting with the Ghief of P�lice and a�ked him ai�out
the lighting and parking.lvt. = He told her th�t there arP two
street lights which provide good li�hting, and three flood lights
on the buiiding, and these lights shvuld be kept in working order.
Also, he recommend�d two mor� f1aoJ lights ta be installed on the
Denver side of the building to light the cvrn�r next tv the
residences. Anott�er suggestion was to make the ?mployee �arking
lot on the Denve� side of the building only and ti�is would
eliminate youngsters and excessive traffic noise next to th�
residential area. Sylvia said the Chief of Pvlice indiceted that
burgiaries in this area did not e�cceed other areas anJ he didn't
know of any relationship that would occur between tl�is type of
establishment and having more burglaries in the ar?a. T;�e �hief
of Police stated to her that it may be better to have a place for
the youngsters to go than have them wandering around the streets,
but he felt that 11:t�t� p.m. may be toa lat� in thp evening for this
type of establishment to be open fior the age ofi the youngsters that
would be there. With adeqtsate li�hting of th? parking 1Qt and
adequate supervision he would not give a negative recommendation.
5ylvia said other inspections have been made by the Fir? (�tarshal
and Building Official. They determined the occupant load vf 5t� fior
the restaurant and 5v fior the eiPCtronic game room and parking ofi
25 spaces.
Chairman Free explained the pr�cedure fior givin� public testimony
and opened the floor to cantin�Je tt?e public hearing vn the special
use request fior an electronic game room,
�
• -2- �
`
Anna Plasencia, 155 ist Str�et N. Ext., �ampa. Ms. Plasencia said
she wes speaking in behaif of Juan Garcia. She said the twv
additivnal lights may be too much lighting fQr the residents on
Denver Street. Ms. Plasencia said �?r testimony is the same as
given last time and if it is recommended th�t they close earlier
than i1:Q4 p.m., they would be willing tv go alang with that.
Camilo Lopez, 7Q2 Chicago Stre?t, G�ldwell, Mr, Lopez said he
obtained a copy of th� repnr± hy th? G�ief �f Pvlice an� he is
concurring with his �ecommendati�n�, Lvpe� said the game r�om is
not canducive to that neighborhv�d, but if the CQmmission spes fit
to approve it, he would ask that they do so with some control.
Lopez said if any of you have gone hy Circle K on lOth late at
night, there are crowds hanging around there and many. cvmplaints
?�ve been made by folks who will not go there late at night because
they do not like this type ofi crowds and this is not the kind of
environment that he wants transferred tv 5th Street. Lopez said
he would ask for some restraints and in one year ifi it is prove�
that they don't have the problems, maybe then the restrictions
could be changed. He does concur with the re�ommendations of the
Chief of Police and he feels they are quite fair,
With no additional testimony offered, the public hearing portion
was closed.
Several items of concern, such as closing time �f the g�me room,
especially in the summer wl�en it gets dark later, the Gity's
curtew, supervision, and type vf beverages they planned to sell in
the game room, were discussed by�the Commissi�n, Randolph said one
of his concerns that was brought �ut at tl�e August iQth meeting was
on supervision, and he asked if the Ghief vf Police feels there
will be enough supervision far 5c? pe�Rl? that will be �llawed''
In response to the question above, Sylvia said it w�uld be hard to
say as they don't know t1�e ciientele at this �nint. Tt?e Chief of
Pc�lice did tell �er that hP was familiar wi}h tt�e crowds at the
Circle K on l��th and the police haue b�en calle� ❑ut ta dispe�se
them. They police would be watcning this n?w business and try to
avoid any problems, but a l�t of problems can be avoided witt� gvod
supervision.
Ms. Plasencia res onded h sa in st�e knows man people in the
P Y Y 9 Y
neighborhood and has worked with people, She said she worked fior
Community Health and other organizations and thPy do not want any
problems.
Lopei stated that crowds who gather araund Paul's and the Circle
K are a lot ofi young spanish kids, and he likes kids; but �e was
beaten by three spanish kids in firont of his hause. Ne said that
the Spanish have no monvpoly on crime. +�n bad �r Q�4� and their
community is just like anybody else's communitya but he just wants
to make sure this business doesn't cre�te a prc5lem with kids out
late at night. Most ofi the families he works with are home at
night because at five o'clock in the morning, t�?ey �re out working. j
II �
i
" . -3- •
�
Ghair Free e?�plaineJ �t?�t if the Gammissi�n were to decide
fiavorably on the spe�ial +�se permit, t�?pn pa.rt of the decision
would be what consJitions wvuld be established. A special use
permit could be granted s�JbJ��t tv review in a ypar, or just for
the duration of a year. There are differ�nt ways it could be done
with conditions and if at a later timP it was determined that those
conditians were tva tight Qr tva loose, then the Commission could
act in such a way to leave tt�ose open fior review,
Sylvia said she keeps tr�c�� vf speci�I use permits subject to
review in one year. At that time n�tices wo��ld be sent vut again
to the property owners, the applicant wo�sld b? notifi?d, as well
as the Commission Mem�ers. This wo�.sld giv� those falks an
opportunity to come in and testifiy. If any difficulties were
experienced in that year, they could be discussed. �
Chuck Randolph said he was hesitant about making a mvtion, as he
left the August lOth meeting feeling the testimony of Mr. Valdez
was very compelling to him on the relationship of this to his
business and some of the other discussion. He was nvt convinced
that this is the answer for having people in a p13ce wher� they
have something to do. He wished he believed totally that it was,
but in the testimony given tonight he s�es a real willingness to
compromise and tv look at giving this � try and he sees that in the
letter from the Chiefi of Police.
gc��� Randolph then moved to �r��t a speci�l ��se p2!^rttlt f�1r +�ne year,
conditional upon two additional lights ta be added on the Denver
Street side and that parking 2c+t�lighting be apprvved by the Chief
of Police before this business opens; that the L�enver Street
parking slots be reserved for ert�ployees; that a year ar��lnd 1t�c��Q
p.m. closing for the video game room be observed; and that the
management be very sensitive to this issue ofi su�?rvision; that
they agree to work with the Police Department because this is an
unknown and if additional supervision bec�mes necess�ry, that they
will provide that supervision. T�m Ensl?y seconded the mvtion,
After a short discussion on thP mati�n, Wan�a A!?t!?c+ny �skPJ t� add
to the motion that they have adult sup?r�rision at all times, It
was agreed to add this conditian. Ron Myers commented that maybe
the time period could be judged by the Chief nf Police after the
establishment is open for a while. He questianed that pvssibly
they need a variable. Afiter a discussivn on some kind of structure
fior expanding the hours, the Commission agreed that stipulated
conditions in closing nay,}�e. modified by the Commission d�Jring this
year of the permit upon request by t#�e ap�licant �nd a
recommendation by the Chief of Police, The motion was amended tv
include these two items and a vote was called for on the amended
motion. Motion carried.
Findings of Fact: �
1. The application was properly filed with the Commission in
accordance with the procedures of the Zone Ordinance 6-4-�}(H).
w
� -4- •
�
2. The public hearing was published and praperty owners within 300
feet of the property �t 427 N. 5th Avenue were notified in
accordance with Zone Ordinance b-4-4(C).
3. The public hearing was �eld and public testimvny was given both
in favor of and against the request.
4. The building will house b�th the rp�t��rant an� t�e P1PCL�O�ZC
game room. The electroni� game �oom will b¢ �peratin� un�er the
conditions stipulated in the special use permit.
5. T�e granting of a�perial �sP permit, incl��ding all
requirements for this �equest, �ill not c�us? any damage, hazard,
nuisance, or other detriment to per��ns or pr�pe.rty in the
vicinity. � ,
I
Conclusions of Law:
As the request is in accordance with the Zoning Ordinance 6-4-4(B),
6-4-4(C), and no adversQ effect on the surrounding area has been
shown, the special use permit c�n he �r,�ntQ� with the attached
conditians stated above in the matian tc► grant the special use
permit.
The next item of business was pr?s?nteJ by Sylvia, ShQ talked
about the Comprehensive Plan and re�+vr±ed that she h�� been working
with Rita Earl �nd they h�ve maJe f�w chan�es in the Plan. A draft
copy with the revisions vf th? �vmprpt�ensive Plan was given to
Commission members for� reyiew, .Sylvia said th?�� pian to add new
pictures of the greenbelt, th? cvurtho�ase, and af the library, e�:c.
They would appreciate any cvmments as the}j want to make it a more
ositive document. Alsv st�e Q " p
p , saiJ the Cvmpr_hensiv_ Plan will be
advertised to take public testimony on it September 5th.
The last item of business �aas on the sign code amen�ment. Sylvia
said a briefi review of tl�� prop�sed ame�dm�nt was +�15�l1552� at the
last meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commissicn. She said it
was a simple amendment to remove the c�+mmercial table for signs and
insert a square footage factor fior allawable si�ns. Also, they
would be adding an abatement fior business signs where businesses
have been vacant fior a period of time. A public hearin� will be
set on sign code amendment also September 5th.
With no fiurther business the meeting was adjourned at 8:17 p.m.
Respectfiully submitted,
Leona L. Nix
Secretary pro tem