HomeMy WebLinkAboutORD 1918L]
C�
CITY OF CALDWELL
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ORDINANCE
Bill No. 28
ORDINANCE NO. 1918
BY COUNCILMAN
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE I OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE
CITY OF CALDWELL, CANYON COUNTY, STATE OF IDAHO, PERTAINING
TO ADMINISTRATION BY ADDING A NEW CHAPTER 26, SECTIONS 1 -11,
TO PROVIDE A TITLE TO BE KNOWN AS, THE CITY OF CALDWELL
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ORDINANCE; PROVIDING CERTAIN
DEFINITIONS, TO WIT: AGENCY, CONTESTED CASES, LICENSE,
LICENSING, PARTY, PERSON, QUASI- JUDICIAL; PROVIDING THE
APPLICABILITY OF THE ORDINANCE TO ANY AGENCY OR TO THE CITY
COUNCIL WHEN THE AGENCY OR CITY COUNCIL ARE ACTING IN A
QUASI- JUDICIAL CAPACITY; THE APPLICABILITY TO THE GRANTING,
DENIAL, OR RENEWALS OF LICENSES AND IN CONTESTED MATTERS
BEFORE THE PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION; PROVIDING A
PROCEDURE BY WHICH LICENSE APPLICATIONS SHALL BE PROCESSED,
SETTING FORTH CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS WHEN AN AGENCY DENIES AN
APPLICATION; DEFINING WHEN A LICENSE EXPIRES, PROVIDING FOR
GIVING NOTICE OF REVOCATION, SUSPENSION, ANNULMENT, OR
WITHDRAWAL OF A LICENSE; PROVIDING FOR EMERGENCY
CIRCUMSTANCES WHEN PUBLIC HEALTH, SAFETY, AND WELFARE ARE
IMPERATIVE; PROVIDING FOR APPEALS TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF
AGENCY DETERMINATIONS; DEFINING INTERESTED PARTIES;
PROVIDING A NOTICE AND HEARING AND RECORDS PROCEDURES FOR
HEARING CONTESTED CASES; PROVIDING A PROCEDURE FOR THE
ADOPTION OF DECISIONS BY HEARING OFFICERS; PROVIDING FOR THE
APPOINTMENT OF A HEARING EXAMINER; PROVIDING FOR POWERS OF
THE HEARING EXAMINER; PROVIDING FOR THE HEARING EXAMINER'S
REPORT TO THE CITY COUNCIL; PROVIDING FOR A PROCEDURE FOR
THE ADOPTION OF THE REPORT OF THE HEARING EXAMINER BY THE
CITY COUNCIL; PROVIDING FOR AND REQUIRING DECISIONS TO BE IN
WRITING AND STATED ON THE RECORD, INCLUDING FINDINGS OF
FACT; LIMITING EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS; AND PROVIDING FOR A
RETENTION OF THE RECORD FOR SIX (6) MONTHS.
SECTION 1 - THAT TITLE 1 OF THE CITY CODE OF THE CITY OF
CALDWELL BE, AND THE SAME IS HEREBY AMENDED BY THE ADDITION
OF CHAPTER 26, SECTIONS 1 -11, TO READ AS FOLLOWS:
1 -26 -1: TITLE: This Chapter shall be referred to and
known as "The City of Caldwell Contested Hearing
Procedures Ordinance ".
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ACT - 1
1 -26 -2: DEFINITIONS, AS USED IN THIS CHAPTER:
A. 'AGENCY' means each City Board, Commission,
Department, or Officer, including the Council,
authorized by law to make rules, grant licenses, or
to determine contested cases and quasi - judicial
matters, except legislative matters.
B. 'CONTESTED CASES' means a proceeding, including but
not restricted to, licensing, in which the legal
rights, duties or privileges of a party are required
by law to be determined.
C. 'LICENSE' means the whole or part of any permit,
certificate, approval, registration, charter or
similar form of permission required by law, but does
not include a license required solely for revenue
purposes.
D. 'LICENSING' means the agency process respecting the
grant, denial, renewal, revocation, suspension,
annulment, withdrawal or amendment of a license.
E. 'PARTY' means each person or agency named or admitted
as a part, or properly seeking and entitled of right
to be admitted as a party.
F. 'PERSON' means any individual, partnership,
corporation, association, governmental subdivision,
or public or private organization of any character
other than an agency.
G. 'QUASI- JUDICIAL' means the action of any agency in
applying general laws, ordinances, rules or policies
to specific persons and /or parties, interests or
situations.
1 -26 -3: APPLICABILITY:
A. Except for Section 4 of this Chapter, the provisions
of this Chapter shall apply to the procedures
employed by an agency or the City Council when that
agency and /or the City Council are acting in a
quasi - judicial capacity involving an appeal of an
initial determination of an agency.
B. When licensing is required to be preceded by notice
and opportunity for hearing by ordinance or State
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ACT - 2
0 0
statute, the provisions of this Chapter apply, unless
specifically in contravention to State statute; or
when the provisions of this Chapter are specifically
excepted by city ordinance or where a specific
procedure is prescribed by another city ordinance.
C. This Chapter applies to contested matters before the
Planning & Zoning Commission.
1 -26 -4: LICENSE PROCEDURE:
A. No license shall be granted until there has been an
investigation by the appropriate agency upon the
application submitted pursuant to the terms and
conditions of the Ordinance applicable. After the
investigation, the application shall be forwarded to
the appropriate agency, which if provided by
Ordinance of the City of Caldwell, shall act upon the
license request, or the agency shall submit its
recommendations to the City Council for appropriate
action. If the agency recommends or if it determines
the application be denied, the agency shall state in
writing:
1. The statutes, ordinances and standards used in
evaluating the application;
2. The reasons for the denial; and
3. The actions, if any, that the applicant could take
to obtain the license, transfer or renewal
thereof.
B. When a licensee has made timely and sufficient
application for the renewal of a license, the
existing license does not expire until the
application has been finally determined by the
agency; and in the case the application is denied or
in the case the terms of the new license are limited,
the license does not expire until the last day for
seeking review of the agency order.
C. No agency revocation, suspension, annulment or
withdrawal of any license shall be effective until
the agency shall have served personally and /or by
mail notifying the licensee of the intended action.
The notice shall state the facts or conduct upon
which the intended action is based. The notice shall
also state that the licensee may show cause that the
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ACT - 3
licensee is in compliance with all lawful
requirements and why the intended action should not
be taken. If good and sufficient evidence is not
shown the intended action becomes effective on the
fifteenth day after notice has been personally served
or from the date of mailing of the notice which fact
shall also be stated in the notice. If the agency
finds that the public health, safety, or welfare
imperatively requires emergency action, the agency is
empowered to order a summary suspension of a license
pending proceedings for revocation and /or other
intended action. The order and notice shall specify
the facts and findings relied upon for summary
suspension.
1 -26 -5: APPEALS TO THE CITY COUNCIL:
A. Any action by an agency, when acting in a
quasi - judicial capacity, or when licensing shall
become final unless within fifteen (15) days after
notice as provided in Section 4 of this Chapter, a
Notice of Appeal to the City Council has been filed
with the City Clerk by a party.
B. All interested parties, that is all parties entitled
to notice either pursuant to city ordinance or
pursuant to state statute, or persons who are
considered applicants under city ordinance or state
statute, shall be entitled to service of notice as
set forth in Section 6 of this Chapter.
1 -26 -6: CONTESTED CASES: NOTICE, HEARING, RECORDS:
A. In a contested case, or in an appeal of agency
action, all parties shall be afforded an opportunity
for a hearing after reasonable notice.
B. Notice:
1. The notice shall include:
a. A statement
hearing.
of time, place and nature of
b. A statement
jurisdiction
held.
of the legal authority and
under which the hearing is to be
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ACT - 4
C. A reference to the particular sections of the
statutes and rule involved.
d. A short and plain statement of the matters
asserted.
2. If the agency or other party is ui
the matters in detail at the time
served, the initial notice may be
statement of the issues involved.
upon application, a more definite
statement shall be furnished.
cable to state
the notice is
limited to a
Thereafter,
and detailed
C. Opportunity shall be afforded all parties to respond
and present evidence and argument on all issues
involved.
D. Unless precluded by law, informal disposition may be
made of any contested case by stipulation, agreed
settlement, consent, order or default.
E. The record in a contested case shall include:
1. Applications, staff reports and decisions of
agency action which is being appealed.
2. All pleadings, motions, intermediate rulings.
3. Evidence received or considered.
4. A statement of matters officially noticed.
5. Questions and offers of proof, objections, rulings
thereon.
6. Proposed findings and exceptions.
7. Any decision, opinion or report by the officer
presiding at the hearing.
8. All staff memoranda or data submitted to the
hearing officer or members of the agency in
connection with their consideration of the case.
F. Any party may request in writing five (5) days before
any hearing, in a contested case that the oral
proceedings thereof be taken in the form of
stenographic notes at their own expense.
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ACT - 5
i •
G. Findings of fact shall be based exclusively on the
evidence and on matters officially noticed.
1 -26 -7: APPOINTMENT OF A HEARING EXAMINER: The City
Council may appoint a hearing examiner to hear appeals to
the City Council made pursuant to this ordinance.
A. A hearing examiner shall fix a time and place for the
beginning and closing of the hearings and for the
filing of the hearing examiner's report to the City
Council. The hearing examiner shall have and
exercise the power to regulate the proceedings and
every hearing before the examiner and to do all acts
and to take all measures necessary or proper for the
efficient performance of the examiner's duty under
this ordinance. The hearing examiner shall have all
powers of the City Council vested upon the City
Council for the hearing of these matters and may rule
upon the admissibility of evidence to put witnesses
under oath and may examine them and may call the
parties to the action and examine them upon oath.
B. The hearing examiner shall prepare a report upon the
contested case submitted to the examiner and make
findings of fact and conclusions of law as
appropriate and shall set them forth in a report
separately stated. He shall file the report with the
Clerk of the City along with the recordings, minutes,
evidence and original exhibits made and received at
the hearing. A copy of the reports shall be served
upon all parties to the contested case by the City
Clerk.
C. Within fifteen (15) days of the date of the filing of
the report of the hearing examiner with the City
Clerk, any party to the contested case may serve a
written objection to the findings which original must
be served with the City Clerk, copies upon all
parties to the contested case.
D. In the event no objections are filed, the City
Council shall adopt the report of the hearing
examiner at the next regularly scheduled meeting of
the City Council and in the event an objection is
filed, the City Council shall hear oral argument of
the parties upon the record in support of their
objections, but unless specifically ordered by the
City Council, no new evidence shall be presented at
such hearing. The Council shall decide the matter
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ACT - 6
r •
upon the hearing examiner's report, the oral
arguments, written objections submitted, and upon the
record of the case. The City Council shall adopt the
findings and conclusions and recommendations of the
hearing examiner unless those findings of fact are
not based on substantial evidence and /or the
conclusions of law are erroneous statements of law.
1 -26 -8: RULES OF EVIDENCE, OFFICIAL NOTICE: In contested
cases:
A. Irrelevant, immaterial or unduly repetitious evidence
shall be excluded. The rules of evidence as applied
in non -jury civil cases in the District Court of this
State shall be followed. When necessary to ascertain
facts not reasonably susceptible of proof under those
rules, evidence not admissible thereunder may be
admitted, except where precluded by statute, if it is
of a type commonly relied upon by prudent men in the
conduct of their affairs. Agencies shall give effect
to the rules of privilege recognized by law.
Objections to evidentiary offers may be made and
shall be noted in the record. Subject to these
requirements, when a hearing will be expedited, and
the interests of the parties will not be prejudiced
substantially, any part of the evidence may be
received in written form.
B. Documentary evidence may be received in the form of
copies or excerpts, if the original is not readily
available. Upon request, parties shall be given an
opportunity to compare the copy with the original.
C. A party may conduct cross - examinations required for a
full and true disclosure of the facts.
D. Notice may be taken of judicially cognizable facts.
In addition, notice may be taken of generally
recognized technical and scientific facts within the
agency's special knowledge. Parties shall be
notified either before or during the hearing, or by
reference in preliminary reports or otherwise, of the
material noticed, including any staff memoranda or
data, and they shall be afforded an opportunity to
contest the material so noticed. The agency's
experience, technical competence and specialized
knowledge may be utilized in the evaluation of the
evidence.
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ACT - 7
6 0
1 -24 -9: EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE BY AGENCY: When in a
contested case a majority of the officials of the agency
who are to render the final decision have not heard the
case or read the record, the decision, if adverse to a
party to the proceeding other than the agency itself,
shall not be made until a proposal for decision is served
upon the parties, and an opportunity is afforded to each
party adversely affected to file exceptions and present
briefs and oral arguments to the officials who are to
render the decision. The proposal for decision shall
contain a statement of the reason therefore and of each
issue of fact or law necessary to the proposed decision,
prepared by the person who conducted the hearing or one
who has read the record. The parties, by written
stipulation, may waive compliance with this Section.
1- 26 -10: DECISIONS AND ORDERS: A final decision or order
adverse to a party in a contested case shall be in
writing or stated in the record. A final decision shall
include findings of fact and conclusions of law as
required by ordinance or state statute, and shall be
separately stated. Findings of fact, if set forth in
statutory language, shall be accompanied by a concise and
explicit statement of the underlying facts supporting the
findings. If, in accordance with agency rules, a party
submitted proposed findings of fact, the decision shall
include a ruling upon each proposed finding. Parties
shall be notified either personally or by mail of any
decision or order. Upon request, a copy of the decision
or order shall be delivered or mailed forthwith to each
party and to his attorney of record.
1- 26 -11: EX PARTE CONSULTATIONS: Unless required for the
disposition of ex parte matters authorized by law,
members or employees of an agency assigned to render a
decision or to make findings of fact and conclusions of
law in a contested case shall not communicate, directly
or indirectly, in connection with any issue of fact, with
any person or party, nor in connection with any issue of
law, with any party or his representative, except upon
notice and opportunity for all parties to participate.
An agency member may communicate with other members of
the agency and may have the aid and advice of one or more
personal assistants.
1- 26 -12: RETENTION OF RECORD: In all contested cases
where there has been a hearing, a transcribable, verbatim
record of the proceedings shall be made and shall be kept
for a period of not less than six (6) months after a
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ACT - 8
final decision on the matter. Upon written request, and
within the time period provided for retention of the
record, any person and /or party may have the record
transcribed at his or their expense. The City Council
shall also provide for the keeping of the minutes of the
proceedings. Minutes shall be retained indefinitely, or
as provided otherwise by law.
PASSED BY THE COUNCIL THIS 4th day of
1991.
November ,
PASSED BY THE MAYOR THIS 4th day of November ►
1991.
ATT
y Clerk
12/13/91
CONTESTED HEARING PROCEDURES ACT - 9