HomeMy WebLinkAbout1970-12-07city council minutes,440
Treatment Plant, Cap --------- $ .
Water, General Office---- - - - - -- 58.84
Sewer Maintenance-------- - - - - -- 4.00
Warrants Numbers 899 thru 950, Special Funds: Fire --------------------------- 567.21
Cemetery-------------- -- - --- - 62.89
Street ----- ---- -- ---- --- - -- $, 402.06
A rmory - -- -------- ------ --- ---- 173.03
Irrigation-------- -------- -- --- 20.04
LID #66--- --- ---- ---- --- --- ---- 21.00
l , 7.1
A vote was taken and the motion carried.
It was moved by Councilman McCluskey, seconded by Councilman Dakan, that the meeting adjourn. A
vote was taken and the motion, carried. The meeting adjourned a -30 P.M.
Mayor
Z4414city Clerk L_
CCUNCIL CHAMBERS
DECEMBER 7, 1970
8 :00 P. M.
The regular monthly meeting of the City Council met in the Council Chambers of the City Hall with
Mayor Charles W. Carpenter presiding.
Upon Roll Call, the following Councilmen answered present: Charles C. Banks, Alfred H. McCluskey
James W. "Bill° Keys, and C. A. "Chet" Davenport. Absent: V. Jay Martin and James R. Dakan.
Variance granted to the Caldwell Memorial Hospital
As the first order of business, Mayor Carpenter called upon the City Building Inspector, Mr.
George Dufur, who explained to the Council that plans had been submitted to him for the new Medical Train -
ing Center at the hospital and he had found that they did not have the parking space required by the City
Codex that they needed one square foot of parking space for every square foot of building space on the
ground floor and one square foot parking space for every two square feet on the second floor. He said he
had discussed this with the City Engineer and briefly with Councilman Martin but could not issue the permit
without a variance from the City Council.
Mr. John Hayman addressed the Mayor and Council and said that their problem concerning the park-
ing area was one where they do not have the right to condemn property and therefor had to wait until people
were willing to sell; and, the Board of Directors of the hospital, for several years, had been buying up
property and they own six residences in the area; they had an oral agreement on one full block as soon as
they would like to sell, and, they had several other areas that they would purchase as soon as the owners
were willing t0 sell. He said that, what they were attempting to do, was to build this building which free
a couple of their houses and they would probably be able to dispose of those and put parking into that
vacant area; and then, as soon as their second program of construction got underway, the remaining houses
would all be moved out and they hoped by that time that they would have other areas that they were contem-
plating so that they should have sufficient parking; not only for their present needs but for their future
needs. Mr. Hayman stated then, that for this reason, they would like to have the Council consider going
along with this program and, as they had indicated in their letter, their Architects were drawing up a
master plan which would probably be available to the City by this spring at the latest and this would out-
line all this in detail; that it was the wishes- of the Board to get more than sufficient parking in that
particular area because they were hurting real badly right at the present time.
Councilman Banks stated that he and Councilman Davenport and Councilman Martin had attended a
meeting the other day when this was explained in that thev have fifty -five or sixty students now and they
were aware of the problem and were making plans to take care of this. He said that as this had been talked
over the other day they had felt that the variance should be granted as it was just a matter of order in
which it had to be done.
Mayor Carpenter pointed out that these persons who would be using, this building were all ready
parking out in the area provided for this and the new building would not require any increase in this;
however, he stated that he would like to suggest here that, until adequate parking and more parking in the
441
area was available, the use of the auditorium be somewhat restricted.
It was then moved by Councilman McCluskey, seconded by Councilman Keys, that we grant a variance
to the Caldwell Memorial Hospital for the construction of the new Medical Training Center. A vote was
taken and the motion carried.
Agreement with State Highway Department tabled until next meeting
Mr. Norman S. Crossley and Mr. Andy Nielson, the Assistant District Engineer, were present re-
presenting the State Highway Department and they were recognized at this time.
Mr. Crossley stated that perhaps the Council didn't want to waste too much time in briefing but
in order to bring everyone up to date, they did have the project on Blaine street ready to go to Contract
and expected to have the funds available shortly after the first of the year; that, as soon as that occurs,
they would put it up for Contract; however, before they could to that, they needed an Agreement with the
City and he had forwarded over a copy of such a proposed agreement last week, he said they did not have to
have the Agreement tonight but he would prefer to make sure that everything was acceptable to the City and
there were some things in it that would be of particular interest to the Council in making up the budget
for the coming year.
Mr. Crossley then reviewed in that basically they were going to reconstruct from Tenth to Avon
i and that section had been added to the State Highway System and would become a part of a couplet with west-
bound traffic on Blaine and east -bound traffic on Cleveland; that, once it was 'ouilt, the State would be
responsible for the maintenance of it along with the other State Highways in the City. He said they would
rebase and surface the entire project; that some of the curb and gutter was good enough so they could
leave it in but others they would take out and re -do; the traffic signals would be improved and up -dated
as well as the median arrangements on Tenth at Blaine and at Cleveland, He said one of the major items
of interest to the City would be the new structure over the canal which would allow Blaine Street to go
through a nd he referred to a previous discussion on this last fall when they had offered the City the
opportunity to cover the creek along by the fire station property to provide parking and, he said they had
worked things out on the basis talked about and this would be built right along with the project; that he
thought they had talked about, in the neighborhood of $12,000.00 of City matching money. Mr. Crossley
then stated that he thought Mr. Lewis had discussed with the Council some of the City's obligations so far
as project activities; one of which would be dealing with the railroad in improving the crossing at Avon
and to have them do the work within the tracts; that the section between Aven and Cleveland would not be
constructed at this time because they were not quite sure what would be necessary in that area, in order
to tie in with the Northwest Connector, nor were they prepared to get the right -of -way through there at
the expense of time in holding up the project; so it had been worked out so that the couplet could be put
into operation without going into any great reconstruction on Aven at this time. Mr, Crossley pointed out
a couple of things which he said they would like the City to do and this was to get the right -of -way clear
so that construction could take place$ that the building owned by the auto company in the next block ex-
tended into the right -of -way about four or five feet and this would have to be cleared from the right -of-
way in order to get approval by the Bureau of Public Roads, and, since the City had the police power to do
this, they would request as they did in all the new construction projects in the cities, that the City get
the owner to cut the building tack. Also, there was an awning at the department store on Kimball Ave, and
because they were moving the curb back in order to have a little wider street, the awning would be out too
far for trucks or large vehicles and they would like to have the City talk to them about moving the awning
back and it should be back about two feet from the curb. Mr. Crossley Shen referred to one question which
had been concerning the right hand turn from Blaine Street towards the overpass which had apparently been
giving trucks considerable trouble and they had worked out a way to get a much 'better radius in there and
be thought it would take care of that problem. He said they were going to take another look at the median
arrangement between Cleveland and Blaine on Tenth to see if they could get that a little more functional.
With reference to the Agreement, Mr. Crossley stated that the State basically agrees to build
the entire project at State expense with certain exceptions which would be noted and to add to the State
Highw System, Blaine Street. He said the City's obligations of real importance were the encroachments
d
44 2
which he had mentioned, and there were some financial involvements such as the covering of the waterway at
the City's share of the cost in an amount of S12,160.00 and, the previous agreement by the City with the
Highway Board a couple of years ago to furnish tLO,000.00 in the interest of advancing this project in the
program, and, the City's portion of the signalization in an amount of $2,400.00. He said these were the
City's total fiscal obligations and were probably the more important items that the City would be concerned
with.
In answering questions as to when they planned to start construction, where they planned to start
and how long would it take, Mr. Crossley stated that they would advertise right after the first of the year
providing the funding acts would have the money for them and, this would mean that they would have a contract
within about a month to six weeks but the contractor probably would not do any physical work until spring
except for getting his aggregates and materials together. Mr. Crossley referred the balance of the question
to Mr. Nielson who stated it was a little difficult to second -guess what a contractor may do but they would
let the contract to give the contractor enough time that the project would have to be completed within the
coming season and it would not run over into the winter season of 1971 - 1972; that the contractor probably
wouldn't do anything except perhaps start on the structure before about May or June. Also, in answer to
the question, Mr. Nielson stated that there would be entirely new construction of the pavement from Tenth
Avenue to Fifth Avenue and they would keep the existing pavement from Fifth Avenue to Aven they would keep
the existing pavement and curb and gutter but would overlay the pavement with another 2/10 of pavement
I thickness.
With regard to signals, Mr. Crossley stated that at Blaine and Kimball there would be a complete
new installation; at Cleveland and Kimball, at Cleveland and Ninth, Blaine and Tenth, and Cleveland and
Tenth, there would be reconstructed, improved, and brought up to current standards; that there would be no
additional signals at Blaine and Ninth or Blaine and Seventh until such time as these two intersections
would meet warrant. Mr. Corssley stated that usually they would ?enerally have signals in before they meet
warrant and usually started moving when they got up to about 70% or 80? of warranty.
Mayor Carpenter reported on informatics from the City Engineer in that Blaine Street would be 54
feet from Tenth Avenue to Seventh Avenue and would accomodate three traffic lanes and two parking lanes wit
the widening of the street in this section oceuring on the south or southerly side and it would narrow the
sidewalk between Seventh to Ninth about five feet, leaving the sidewalk width at about ten feet. Tn the
section between Sixth and Seventh, the roadway width would be h6 feet and the agreement provided that there
would be no parking on the southerly side of Blaine Street from Sixth Avenue to Seventh Avenue which would
provide for three traffic lanes and one parking lane on the northerly side of the street; that at Sixth
Avenue the southerly traffic lane would have to turn left onto Sixth Avenue and proceed towards Cleveland.
With reference to the structure, the agreement provided that the City would become responsible for the
maintenance of the structure from Sixth Avenue to the point where it would angle through the Blaine and
Seventh Avenue intersection; however, the Engineer thought any maintenance on the concrete structure would
be extremely minimal. The new section to be built between Fifth and Sixth Avenue provided for curb and
gutter on each side of the street with a width, curb tc curb, of 40 feet and this would provide for a park-
ing lane on either side of the street and two traffic lanes which was the same width as the section of the
street from Aven Street to Fifth Avenue. The City's involvement with the railroad company entailed the
widening of the crossing at Aven such that it would accomodate traffic across the rails for the full width
of the street. The new traffic light installation would be made at Kimball and Blaine using three of the
existing poles with the pole base on the old Kinney building corner to be removed and replaced as reouired
by the widening of the street; that the agreement set forth as one of the responsibilities of the City the
requirement that the marquis extending over the Blaine Street right -of way be removed or narrowed so that
it would not interfere with the signal installation and the City Engineer had indicated that it appeared to
him, at this time, that the marquis could not extend more than four feet from the building to accomplish
this and in all probability the City would transfer this responsibility to the oroperty owner. The
existing signal light installation at Tenth and Blaine, Tenth and Cleveland, Ninth and Cleveland and
443
Kimball and Cleveland would also be changed to accomodate the one -way traffic on each street and the
agreement required the City to participate 50% in all of these changes, as well as 50Z in the change of
the signals at Blaine and Kimball.
With reference to the money involved, Mr. Crossley stated the City could do whatever was the most
convenient for the City in this regard and said that he would imagine the items other than the $40
would be in the next year's budget so they could be paid after the first of the year.
Mayor Carpenter stated that he thought the $40,000,00 amount and the $2,1:00.00 amount was in the
1970 budget which would leave the amount of $12,160.00 for next year's budget.
Councilman Keys commented on previous discussions in Committee for possible one-way streets on�i
Ninth, Kimball, Seventh and Sixth, and, he inquired if this would tie in with the signalling they now had
proposed.
Mr. Crossley stated that it wouldn't be any trouble to re- arrange it but there would have to be
some changes made and they would probably have to add a couple more heads in order to give indications to
both lanes. Mr. Nielson stated that the signals were designed now for two -way traffic and unless some
Other decision was made right away, this was the way the bids would he advertised but they could be con-
verted later without too great an expense. Mr. Crossley stated that they could alter this at any time
between now and the time the work on the signals started although they would need to know in time to get
the proper equipment as it sometimes takos from three or four months to get some of this now.
Mr. Glenn Koch inquired if the State Highway Board had decided what they were going to do from
Aven on towards Wilder and he received a negative answer. Mr. Nielson stated that the planning section
was evaluating the situation and were making some ground water studies in the area with hopes of putting
a route study together and be able to conduct hearings sometime right after the first of the year.
Mr. Ron Blakley inquired about his understanding that, as now planned, there wouldn't be any
signalling on Fifth and Mr. Crossley stated that he thought that, with a one -way couplet arrangement that
it would be easier to get across on Fifth than with Traffic going both ways on each street. Also, the
amount of traffic would be reduced by one -half on each street as there is now, however, that, if signals
were warranted, they would certainly put them in.
Mr. Crossley then thanked the Council for their time and said he would leave three copies of the
Agreement and, if they were satisfactory, the Resolution could be adopted at a suitable Council meeting wit]
two to be returned and one retained for the City's interim file.
It was moved by Councilman Keys, seconded by Councilman Banks, that action on the Agreement be
tabled until the next meeting of the Council. A vote was taken and the motion carried.
Bids opened for purchase of one (1) 1970 _four (4) door automobile for ?olice Department
The next order of business was the opening of bids for the purchase of one (1) 1970 four (4)
door automobile for the Police Department with a maxi of fifteen thousand (15,000) miles in accordance
with the following specifications:
SPECIFICATIONS
It is the intention of these specifications to provide the City of Caldwell
Police Department with one (1) 1970 four (L) door automobile in accordance with the
following specifications:
1. Maximum of fifteen thousand (15,000) miles.
2. Clean and mechanically sound throughout.
3. Wheelbase - not less than 119 inches.
4. Engine:
a. Eight (8) cylinders - V -8 type.
b. Minimum of 350 cubic inches and 250 horsepower.
5. Electrical System (12) twelve volts.
6. Transmission: Automatic with at least 3 speeds forwa ^d.
7. Air conditioning - factory installed and refrigerated.
8. Power brakes and steering.
9. All other standard equipment that is for that model vehicle being bid.
444
GENERAL BIDDING INFORMATION::
This will be a straight purchase without any trade -in.
The bid price shall not include any Federal Tax. The City of Caldwell will furnish all
Federal Tax exemption certificates as needed. Price shall not include any Idaho State
Sales Tax. Under the Idaho State Law - Municipalities are exempt from the Idaho State
Sales Tax.
Bidder shall specify time required for delivery.
The invitation for bid shall be part of the SPECIFICATIONS.
Exact mileage at time of bid: 12,882
Bid Price $ 3,090.00
11 -24 -70
Curt 9, Hal, Inc.
By: /s/ Curt Beukelman
"This bid is on a Cornet (white exterior - blue interior)
4 -Door with a 383 cubic inch (2- barrel carb.) engine that burns
regular gas; this unit is a Chrysler Credit Car and therefore it
will carry the remainder of the 50,000 mile warranty just as if
you had purchased the unit new."
It was noted that this bid did not meet specifications.
Exact Mileage at time of bid: 13,500
Bid Price $ 2,975.00
12 -4 - Curt 3 Hal, Inc.
By: /g/ Curt Beukelman
"Remainder of 5 yr. 50,000 mile warranty shall apply on this unit
as it is a Chrysler Corporation Lease car.
Spare tire has never been on the ground. Both front tires have
about 2,000 miles on them. Both rear tires have about 60% tread
remaining. Attached is a repair order showing what we have
done to the car since we received it from Chrysler Corp."
Exact Mileage at time of bid: 13,371 1970 Impalla -4 -door
Hardtop
Bid Price $ 3,234.60
11/27/70
Edmark Motors, Inc.
By; /s/ W. E. Ziegenbein
Bales Manager
Opts: This unit meets all specifications except item # 4 -13 - unit
has 350 cubic inch 250 horse power v/8 motor, rag, fuel.
Unit Also has: all tinted glass, white wall tires, radio, all
vynal interior. Balance of new car warranty with no deductible
charge and no charge to transfer warranty.
Exact mileage at time of bid: Aoprox. 20,000
Bid 'rice $ 2,761.00 (including
four(4) New tires
November 11, 1970
GAPBER MOTOR COMPANY
By: /s/ Bill Garber
1970 FOR "POLICE INTERCEPTOR" FCRDOR SEDAN equipped as follows:
ZL29 cubic inch, 370 H.P. v/8 engine
Automatic Transmission
Power disc brakes
Power steering
Police spotlight
"INTERCEPTION POLICE" package includes the following additional
special Police vehicle equinment:
Heavy duty, 42 -amp. alternator
Calibrated eppedometer, with 2 -mile- per -hour increments
Extra heavy duty cooling package
Heavy duty, 80 -Amp, battery
Disc brakes on front & self adjusting brakes on rear
445
Heavy duty front and rear black rubber floor mats
High ratio (3.00) rear axle
Special 6 -inch wheel rims
Police handling package (extra control shocks - front stabiliser
bar and heavy duty front and rear
springs,)
Extra life front seat
Rear stabiliser bar
Heavy duty frame (no "S" frame)
This vehicle has approximately 20,000 on it. It has been used only
by Ford Motor Co. demonstrating to Police Departments in the Salt
Lake Area and been serviced exclusively by Ford Motor Co.
Exact Mileage at time of bid: 13,958
Bid Price 8 2,925.00
12 -5 -70
Bundy Buick - GM
By: /s/ Howard E. Dobbs
P.S. On a used car there is no way that we knot; for you to
recover federal tax, however that's your problem.
Exact mileage at time of bid: i4 t 496 - Stock #997A - Beige
11,726 - Stock #998A - Turquoise
12,915 - Stock #1000A - Blue
12,286 - Stock #993A - Gold
Bid Price $ 3,161.00
(choice of above listed)
December 7, 1970
BURNS C'.-EVROLET COMPANY
By: /s/ Geo. F. Sweet
Sales Manager
Each of the cars listed is a Chevrolet Impala L or hard top
In answer to the question as to whether he had a recommendation for the Council at this time,
Police Chief Charles W. Astleford stated that he would like to take a look at the cars first and he excused
himself from the meeting.
Plat of Green Acres Subdivision No. 2 approved with recommendations from Planning Commission
Mr. Ron Blakley was then recognized and he presented a Preliminary Plat of Green Acres Subdivision
No. 2 drawn on a small scale map witch he said had been presented to the Planning Commission at their last
meeting and approved by them with some changes which were to be incorporated. He said the area was where
Carl Hanson was building at the end of College Avenue, that he had previously platted the Hanson Subdivision
and Green Acres Subdivision No. 1, and this property proposed here was actually owned by Cal Blood. The
changes that the Planning Commission had requested was the temporary culdesacs at the end of South Ohio,
1plsconsin, and Illinois until the streets were extended to the south, however, the one on Illinois Avenue
would be permanent in that there was no right -of -way extending through Montana Manor nor had there been any
provision for right -of -way in the Hanson Subdivision however he still had control of this and could provide
right -of -way through there if necessary but they couldn't connect anything on south from there.
It was moved by Councilman Banks, seconded by Councilman McCluskey, that we approve the preliminary
Plat of Green Acres Subdivision No. 2 subject to the recommendations of the planning Commission. A vote was
taken and the motion carried.
Classic Hills Subdivision referred to and discussed
Mr. Blakley then referred to the Classic Hills Subdivision which had beer, approved and signed but
not filed as yet and they were working on the construction details for it. He said that on the north and
of the Subdivision was Roosevelt Street with Indiana being along the west ad Polk Street along the south,
that the developers were proposing to put in the streets, curbs & gutters, and sewer, and doing the grading
on the sites but they were going on FHA approval and had run into two requirements which cause an expense
problem that they were having a hard time getting around. He pointed out tnat the property was surrounded
by streets on three sides that were not improved and, in order to improve the streets and have any method
1
446
of collecting for the development of the opposite aide of the street from the property would be through a
i
Local Improvement District; however, FHA would not allow Local Improvement Districts in that the work had
to be done before they would approve. Re stated further that he had discussed this with the City Engineer
and under the City's policy, they wouldn't have to build any streets there other than what they need to get
access to the houses but, if they build the streets, they have to build both sides of them; on the other
hand, FHA says they have to build the streets but you don't have to build both sides. He said this would
require the developers to build the three streets and complete both sides which would throw a cost penalty
on this property for costs that would normally be assessed or charged to the adjacent owners; that ha
didn't know the answer but the developers would like to develop and only build their half of the street;
blacktop it of course but only curb & gutter on one side rather than on both sides.
After some discussion, it was agreed that this should be given some study by the Council and see
if something might be worked out.
Bid awarded for purchases of automobile for Police Department
Police Chief Charles W. Astleford reported back to the Council relative to the previous bids
opened at this meeting for purchase of a used automobile for the Police Department and said the automobile
bid by Curt & Hal had about 400 miles less mileage than the car bid by Bunny Buick and, he didn't know
what kind of an automobile was being bid by Bunny Buick although there was $50.00 difference in the prices
bid; that, if it was a Dodge vehicle, they might have problems in furnishing a warranty and there was a _
50,000 mile warranty on the automobile bid by Curt & Hal which he was sure there wouldn't be any problem
with. He then recommended that the bid be awarded to Curt & Hal at the price of $2,975.00.
It was moved by Councilman Davenport, seconded by Councilman McCluskey, that we accept the bid
of Curt & Hal for the purchase of the Dodge Folara at a price of $2 A vote was taken and the motion
carried.
Bill No. 18 - Ordinance No. 1201
Mayor Carpenter then referred to an action at the previous meeting declaring the intent for
vacation of the alley sixteen feet in width in Block 101 according to the Revised Map of Caldwell which
was an alley between Everett and Fillmore and between Seventh and South Kimball; that the Ordinance had
been published as required by law and he inquired if there was anyone present to show cause against the
vacation of the alley. It being determined that no one was present for this purpose and no claim or claims
having been filed; Councilman Keys introduced Bill No. 18, entitled:
AN ORDINANCE RECITING TEE PASSAGE, APPROVAL AND PUBLICATION OF ORDINANCE NO. 1200; DETERiINING THAT NO OBJE
TICNS TO THE VACATION OF THE ALLEY SIKT °EN FEET IN WIDTH IN BLOCK 101 ACGORDING TO THE REVISED MAP OF
CALDWELL, IDAHO, FILED JULY 29, 1891, AND NOW OF RECORD IN BOOK 1 OF PLATS, PAGE 20, IN THE OFFICE OF THE
COUNTY RECORDER, CANYON COUNTY, IDAHO, HAVE BEEN MADE 01 FILED AND TART NO CLAIM OR CLAIMS FOR DAMAGES
WHICH WOULD BE SUSTAINED BY REASON THEREOF HAVE BEEN FILED; DETERMINING THAT THE VACATION OF THE ALLEY
SIXTEEN FEET IN WIDTH IN BLOCK lol ACCORDING TO THE REVISED MAP OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, FILED JULY 29, 1891, ANI
NOW OF RECORD IN BOOK 1 OF PLATS, PAGE 20, IN THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER, CANYON COUNTY, IDAHO,
HEREINBEFORE DESCRIBED IN THIS CAPTION, IS TO THE BEST INTEREST AND ADVANTAGE OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, ITS
CITIZENS AND PROPERTY OWNERS, DETERMINING THAT NO DAMAGE 11ILL BE SUSTAINED BY ANY CITIZENS OR PROPERTY
OWNER BY REASON OF THE VACATION OF THE SAID SIXTEEN -FOOT ALLEY AEREINBEFORE DESCRIBED IN THIS CAPTION; PRO -,
VIDING THAT THE TITLE TO SAID ALLEY SIXTEEN FEET IN WIDTH AND HEREINABOVE DESCRIBED, AS VACATED, SHALL RE-
VERT TO THE PERSONS DEDICATING TIE SAME, THEIR SUCCESSORS, HEIRS AND ASSIGNS, SUBJECT TO THE CITY OF
CALDWELL RESERVING UNTO ITSELF AND TO ALL UTILITY COMPANIES ALL EXISTING EASEMENT RIGHTS IN THE AREA CON_
ARISING SAID ALLEY FOR SEWER LINES, POWER LINES, TELEPRONE LINES AND GAS LINES, TOGET?-ER WITH ACCESS TO AND
FROM SAID AREA TO MAINTAIN, REPAIR OR ?EPLACE THE SAME; REPEALIN, ALL ORDINANCES OR PARTS OF ORDINANCES IN
CONFLICT HEREWITH AND PROVIDING FOR THE PUBLICATION OF THIS ORDINANCE AND ITS EFFECT.
which was read for the first time and the Council proceeded to consideration of Bill No. 18 . It was
moved by Councilman Keys, seconded by Councilman McCluskey, that the rules requiring the reading of a Bill
on three separate days be suspended and that Bill No. 18 be read the second time by title and the third
time in full, section by section. The Mayor directed the Clerk to call the roll on the above motion with
the following result. Those voting in the affirmative were: Banks, McCluskey, Keys, and Davenport.
Negative votes none. Absent and not voting: Martin and Dakan. The Mayor declared the motion had
passed by the necessary one -half plus one of the members of the full Council and directed the Clerk to read
Bill No. 18 the second time by title and the third time in full, section by section. The Clerk read the r
Bill as directed. It was moved by Councilman Keys, seconded by Councilman McCluskey, that Bill No. 19 pass
The Mayor directed the Clerk to call the roll on the above motion which resulted as follows: Those voting
in the affirmative were; Banks, McCluskey, Keys, and Davenport. Negative votes: none, Absent and not
voting: Martin and Dakan. Thereupon, the Mayor declared that Bill No. 18 had passed and the Mayor in open)
447
session of the Council duly signed and approved the Bill and the Clerk duly signed and attested the same
which became Ordinance ivo. 1201.
The Mayor directed the Clerk to make proper entry of the same and to cause Ordinance No. 1201 to
be published in the News- Tribune, the official newspaper of the City of Caldwell, Idaho.
Leave of absence granted for Loyd Miller
Mayor Carpenter informed the Council in that the City Engineer had requested that Mr. Loyd Miller
be placed on leave of absence from October 15, 1970 to April 15, 1971 so as to maintain his status in the
Public Employee Retirement System; that Mr. Miller works for the City during the summer and is laid off
during the winter months,
It was moved by Councilman Davenport, seconded by Councilman Banks, that a leave of absence be
granted for Mr. Loyd Miller from October 15, 1970 to Anril 15, 1971. A vote was taken and the motion carrie
Mayon authorized to execute "Certificate of Authorization" for Federal grant for sewage treatment works
Mayor Carpenter then informed the Council that in the past week or so the City had received from
CA an application to be filed with the State Health Department to request Federal participation in the
City's sewer development program and, as the Council was aware of in past meetings, the Council had made it
possible to continue the study and to make application for the funds; that now the paper work had all been
completed and at the last Canyon Development Council meeting this had been presented by representatives of
, X as well as by Mr. Lewis and the Canyon Development Council had approved the study and recommendations
that the City apply for Federal funds in regards to this project. The Mayor then presented a 'Certificate
of Authorization" which he said was necessary to have executed in order to proceed with the delivering of
the document to the State 9oard of Health and, the Certificate was read as follows:
CERTIFICATE CF AUTHORIZATI00
Mayor Charles W. Carpenter of the City of Caldwell ,
Idaho, is hereby authorized to act as the official representative of the Cit
City or 9ewar Distr�at)
of Caldwell for the filing, processing, and administration of the application of
this City or sewer district for a Federal Grant for sewage treatment works pursuant to the
Federal Water °bllution Control Act (33USC 466 at seq.).
Members of the Board (Council)
Mayor
City of Caldwell
ity or Sewer District
Notary or Seal
It was moved vy Councilman Banks, seconded by Councilman McCluskey, that the Mayor be authorized
to represent the City of Caldwell in the matter of this application. A vote was taken and the motion carried
The Certificate of Authorization was then presented to the Councilmen present for.their signatures
and Mayor Carpenter further explained that this did not have to do with the application in regards to the
Sewage Treatment Plant but was in connection with the study and work done in cooperation with the Simplot
Company and the development of that study, that actually this was designed to get the City's name on the list
and to obtain the necessary information to know whether or not to proceed in a cooperative agreement with
the Simplot Company and whether Federal funds would be available for the ,joint venture.
Continuous Service Appraisal Agreement with General Appraisal Company renewed
Mayor Carpenter then presented for consideration of the Council a renewal of the continuous
service appraisal agreement with the General Appraisal Company and said the last Agreement began in September
of 1958 with the schedule providing for times for complete appraisals and for interim appraisals of all
city property in order to keep insurance adjusted to the values involved. Mayor Carpenter also stated that,
since the construction of the Sewage Disposal Plant, there hadn't been an appraisal made of the Plant and
the Insurance Carrier suggests that this be done. He said that this agreement was nearly the same as the
previous agreement with the fee value being based on the same per thousand, however, there would be an in-
crease due to the addition of the appraisal of the sewage treatment plant facilities and this appraisal was
to be made shortly after the first of the year. The service dates of the Agreement would begin with
January, 1971, and extend through November, 1986, with services to be provided every two years where the
443
services under the previous agreement had been performed every eighteen months. It was also noted that the
agreement was subject to cancellation on sixty (60) days' written notice by either party prior to the date
of next schedule service.
It was moved by Councilman Davenport, seconded by Councilman Banks, that the Mayor be authorized
to execute the Agreement with the General Appraisal Company in behalf of the City. A vote was taken and the
notion carried.
Appointment of James V. Vizzini as Assistant Building Inspector
Mayor Carpenter then presented the name of James V. Vizzini for appointment as the Assistant
Building Inspector and said that Mr. Vizzini resided at 2217 Rice Road in Caldwell. The Mayor stated that
both he and Mr. Dufur had interviewed Mr. Vizzini and they felt that he was qualified to carry out the duties
necessary to provide the relief needed for Mr. Dufur in his office, and his salary would he set at $460.00
per month with this subject to review at the end of six months. Mayor Carpenter added that, in discussing
this with the Salary Committee and, if Mr. Vizzini was doing a good Job, then consideration would be given
to a raise in wages to $475.00 per month.
It was moved by Councilman Banks, seconded by Councilman Davenport, that the appointment of Mr.
James V. Vizzini as Assistant Building Inspector be confirmed. A vote was taken and the motion carried.
Marie Palmer appointed as Deputy City Treasurer
Mayor Carpenter then presented the name of Marie Palmer for appointment as Deputy City Treasurer
and said that Mrs. Palmer was presently employed at the Idaho First National Bank in Caldwell. The Mayor
stated that he was sure the Council was aware that the present City Treasurer was retiring in March of 1971
and he thought Mrs. Palmer was well qualified.
It was moved by Councilman Banks, seconded by Councilman McCluakey, that the appointment of Marie
Palmer as Deputy City Treasurer be confirmed. A vote was taken and the motion carried.
Resolution No. 22
Councilman Keys sponsored the following Resolution and moved its passage:
RESOLUTION NO. 22
BY COUNCILMAN KEYS
A RESOLUTION ACCEPTING THE ASSESSMENT ROLL OF LOCAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT N0. 66 FOR THE CITY OF CAIDWELL,
CANYON COUNTY, IDAHO; AUTHORIZING THE CLERK TO GIVE NOTICE OF THE TIME AND PLACE FOR NEARING AND CONSIDER-
ING OBJECTIONS TO THE SAID ASSESSMENT ROLL; FIXING THE TIME FOR HEARING AND CONSIDERING SAID OBJECTIONS AND
PRESCRIBING THE FCRM OF NOTICE.
WHEREAS, The assessment roll of Local Improvement District No. 66 for the City of Caldwell,
Canyon County, Idaho, has been completed in compliance with the provisions of the laws of the State of Idaho.
in such cases made and provided, and the ordinances of the City of Caldwell, Canyon County, Idaho, said
assessment roll having been p repared and made out by the Committee on Streets, together with the City
Engineer, containing the number of assessments, the name of the owner if known, and if not known, that the
name is unknown, a description of each tract assessed and the total amount of the assessments, and said
assessment roll having been so prepared was certified to the Council of the City of Caldwell by the Co:msittec
on Streets and the City Fngineer;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED By the Mayor and the Council of the City of Caldwell, Idaho:
Section 1. That the assessment roll of Local Improvement District No. 66 for the City of Caldwell,
Canyon County, Idaho, be, and the same in hereby accepted and placed on file in the office of the City Clerk
of the City of Caldwell, Canyon County, Idaho. That the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to
give due and legal notice, in compliance with the provisions of law, to the owner or owners of property
which is assessed in said assessment roll, whether named or not named, by publication in three successive
issues in the News- Tribune, a daily newspaper printed and published in the City of Caldwell. Said notice
shall state that the said property owners may, before the date and time fixed for the hearing, file with the
City Clerk objections in writing to said assessment, and that objections will be considered by the Mayor and
Council on the 4th day of January, 1971, at BIOO otclock P.M.
J
Section 2. That said notice shall be in substantially the following form, to wit.
NOTICE OF RECEIPT OF ASSESSMENT ROLL OF LOCAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT NO. 66 FOR THE CITY OF CALDWELL, CANYON
COUNTY, IDAHO, By THE CITY CLERK 2ND OF THE TINE AND PLACE FOR FILING PROTESTS TO SUCH ASSESSMENT ROLL AND
OF THE TIME SET FOR BEAF_7NG PROTESTS BY THE CITY COUNCIL.
449
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN That the assessment roll of Local Improvement District No. 66 for the
City of ',aldwell, Canyon County, Idaho, is now on file in my office in the City Hall of the City of Caldwell
r Canyon County, Idaho, and that the same was filed at 5:00 o'clock P.M. on the 7th day of December, 1970,
and that the City Council will meet on the 4th day of January, 1971, at 8:00 o'clock P.M., at the City
Council Chambers in the City Hall in said City of Caldwell, Canyon County, Idaho, to hear and consider
objections to said assessment roll by the party or parties aggrieved by such assessment. The owner or
owners of any property which is assessed in said assessment roll, whether named or not named in such assesa-
ment roil, may, before the date and time fixed for the hearing, Pile with the City Clerk his objections in
writing to said assessment roll to which objection is made as well as the specific ground for such ob-
jection. The assessment roll will be open for inspection at the office of the City Clerk of the City of
Caldwell, Canyon County, Idaho, on each and every day except Saturdays, Sundays and holidays between the
hours of 9:00 o'clock A.M. and 5:00 o'clock P.M.
City Clerk
The motion for passage was seconded by Councilman McCluskey. A roll call vote was called for
when the following Councilmen voted in the affirmative: Banks, McCluskey, Keys, and Davenport. Negative
votes: none. Absent and not voting: Martin and Dakar. Mayor Carpenter declared that Resolution No. 22
had passed.
' Indemnity Agreements approved (m32, #33 & #34)
The following Indemnity Agreements were presented for the consideration of the Councils
Indemnity Agreements to indemnify and save harmless the City, its Mayor and Council
against any and all loss, damage, costs and expenses by reason of the use of the
following property in Canyon Hill Cemetery:
For Space 2 in hot h3, Block 60 from Gracie Altizer Akers for the burial
of Laura E. Martin.
For Space 5 in Lot 43, Block 60 from Evelyn E. Scott for burial of Forest L.
Shumaker.
It was moved by Councilman McCluskey, seconded by Councilman Ranks, that the Indemnity Agreements
be approved. A vote was taken and the motion carried.
Applications for renewal of Beer Licenses presented and approved
Applications for renewal of Beer Licenses for 1971 were presented for .he consideration of the
Council with each application having been approved by the Chief of Police and accompanied by a receipt from
i
the Clerk for the required fees. The applications were as follows:
Adelina M. Pedraza d/b /a E1 Tice Tico at 714 Main Street - Fee, $100.00
Trumbull's Inc. d /b /a Holiday Motel and Sultans Table at Hiway 8 -at 5th St., - Fee $100.00
Joel Stone d/b /a Saratoga Hotel at 624 Main St., - Fee, $75.00
President Enterprises, Inc, at 612 Main St. - Fee $100.00
Elmer W. Dooms d/b /a East Cleveland Self Service at 2518 Cleveiand Blvd - Fee, $25.00
Richard A. Beam d/b /a Beem's Food Center at 1905 Summit Dr. - Fee, $25.00
Kenneth L. Stover d /b /a The Cimaron at 70) Main St. - Fee, $100.00
Sportsman Bar & Cafe, Inc, at 117 Everett St. - Fee, w100.00
Talbot Farms Inc. d /b /a Talbot Lanes at 506 :.van - Fee, $100.00
Smorquets, Inc. at 1015 No. Kimball - Fee, $100.00
Don G. Viennstrom d/b /a Super Save Market at 321 N. Kimball - Fee, $25.00
Shirley Kinley d/b /a Freda's Cafe at 216 No. 5th - Fee, $75.00
SPOE Elks #1448 at 815 Arthur - Fee, $100.00
Paul G. Hanley d /b /a The Tavern at 117 So. Kimball - Fee, $100.00
It was moved by Councilman McCluskey, seconded by Councilman Davenport, that the applications
for renewal of Beer Licenses for 1971 be approved and that the licenses be issued. A vote was taken and
the motion carried.
Applications for renewal of Liquor Licenses presented and approved
Applications for renewal of Liquor Licenses for 1971 were presented for the consideration of the
Council with each application having been approved by the Chief of Police and accompanied by a receipt from
the Clerk for the required fees. The applications were as follows:
Talbot Farms, Inc, d/b /a Talbot Lanes at 506 W. Aven - Fee, $562.50
Trumbulls, Inc. d /b /a Holiday Motel and Sultan's Table at Hiway 80 at 5th - Fee, $562.50
Joel Stone d/b /a Saratoga Hotel at 624 Main St. - Fee $562.50
President Enterprises, Inc. at 612 Main St. - Fee, $562.50
Kenneth L. Stover d/b /a The Cimaron at 709 Main St. - Fee, $5o2.50
Smorquets, Inc. at 1015 N. Kimball - Bee, $562.50
Paul G. Hanley d /b /a The Tavern at 117 S. Kimball - Fee, $562.50
BPOE 911148 at 815 Arthur - Fee, $562.50
It was moved by Councilman McCluskey, seconded by Councilman Banks, that the applications for
renewal of Liquor Licenses for ly71 be approved and that W:a licenses be issued.
1-1-1
450
A vote was taken and the motion carried.
Applications for Bartender Permits approved
Applications for Bartender Permits from David W. Freer, Thomas R. Lyons, Larry Grant Dana, Paul S.
Salazar, Valerie Toney, Larry D. Davis, and Rosemary Susan ?hillips were presented for the consideration of
the Council. Each application had been approved by the Chief of Police and was accompanied by a receipt
from the Clerk for the required fee.
It was moved by Councilman Davenport, seconded by Councilman McCluskey, that the applications
for Bartender Permits be approved and the Permits be issued. A vote was taken and the motion ca rried.
Applications for renewal of Junk Shop Licenses approved
Applications for renewal of Junk Shop Licenses for 1971 were presented for the consideration of
the Council with each application having been approved by the Chief of Police and Building Official, and
accompanied by a receipt from the Clerk for the required fee. They were as follows:
Ira L, Ekart d/b /a Hid Salvage & Metal at 309 Main St. - Pee, $10,00
United Iron & Metals, Inc. at 3rd & RR - Fee, $10.00
It was moved by Councilman Keys, seconded by Councilman McClus'rey, that the applications for re-
newal of Junk Shop Licenses for 1971 be approved and that the licenses be issued. A vote was taken and the
motion carried.
Applications for renewal of Pool and of pool & Card Licenses approved for first euarter of 1971
Applications for renewal of Pool and of Pool & Card Licenses for the first quarter of 1971 were
presented for the consideration of the Council with each having been approved by the Chief of Police and
accompanied by a receipt from the Clerk for the required fee. They were as follows:
Pool Licenses:
George T. Haines d /b /a Sportsman Bar & Cafe at 117 Everett St. - Fee $15.00
Yosie Ogawa d/b /a Pocket Billiard & Snooker at 713 Main St. - Fee, 415.00
Freda M. Stout d/b /a Waldorf Cigar Store at 121 So. 7th - Fee, $15.00
Gerald Talbot d/b /a Talbot Lanes at 6o5 W. Aven - Fee, $15.00
Pool & Card Licenses:
Adelina M. Pedraza d/b /a E1 Tico Tico at 711 Main St. - Fee, $30.00
It was moved by Councilman 9anks, seconded by Councilman McCluskey, that the applications for
renewal of Fool and of Pool Pr Card Licenses for first quarter, 1971, be approved and the licenses be issued.
A vote was taken and the motion carried.
Need for truck route discussed
Councilman Davenport then told the Council that he would again like to mention what he considered
a very urgent need for the City and this was a truck route, that it had been brought up a few months ago to
the Council and he had since had numerous persons talk with him and they were wondering if anything was
being done. He said he thought Caldwell was large enough to have designated truck routes skirting the
residential areas and he referred to the new facilities now being constructed by the hospital on Tenth
Avenue and said this was going to add new congestion to that area with their having a long range plan that
would continue this pressing need for the elimination of heavy traffic through that area. Councilman
Davenport then stated that he thought that if they didn't de something definite before too long, there
would be a group of citizens down before the Council in the not too distant future, requesting that the
Council take action on this. He then said that he didn't know if anything had been done but, if it hadn't
his suggestion would be that some members of the Council meet with the Street Committee of the Chamber of
Commerce and attempt to work out a workable truck route, that he suggested working with the Chamber because
merchants were definitely interested in how traffic moves through the City and again, he thought the need
was here and it wasn't going to go away, and the quicker they did something, the better it was going to be
for everyone concerned.
Mayor Carpenter reported that there had been considerable discussion on this at the 1 ?st Planning
Commission meeting when they had representatives present from CH and one of their representatives from
Portland had spent three and a -half days over the Thanksgiving Holiday develoning a map which was present
at this meeting, The Mayor stated that there were some interesting things brought out from his findings
and suggestions to the Planning Commission with one of the things he was concerned with was the traffic
flow through the City, that, first of all, he conldntt understand why there were two arterial streets
going north and south through the City such as Tenth 4venue and South Kimball Avenue which were only two
blocks apart and his recommendations were that Tenth Avenue be de- emphasized and South Kimball Avenue be
451
used as the arterial street with traffic coming in on South Kimball Avenue to continue on to Paynter Avenue
to where the couplet would end at Aven Street and the Northwest By -pass would be located. Mayor Carpenter
stated that this man hadn't talked to any of the City people at all but had come into the City cold and
went to work on this; that Marsing Boulevard didn't enter into his program at all; also, he hadn't known of
the planned overpass at Fifth Avenue and had suggested that the logical movement of traffic should be an
interchange on Boise Avenue. He also couldn't understand why there was an arterial street by the Hospital
and through a Golf Course.
Mayor Carpenter then stated that this was why t:ie City needed a transportation study in connection
with the land use study, etc., and he emphasized the important things abcnt planning was that first the City
had to decide if they wanted a plan; secondly, they had to take the steps to get a plan and thenj thirdly,
they had to have the intestinal fortitude to carry out the plan.
After some further discussion with regards to the map present and some of the thoughts presented
concerning traffic and planning in general, it was agreed that members of the Council should get together
with the Street Committee of the Chamber of Commerce and discuss the situation.
Ray Padget addressed the Mayor & Council concerning obstructions on Hannibal
Mr. Ray Padget addressed the Mayor and Council and said he 14 -ved on Hannibal Street; that he
understood that the State was going to turn over Hannibal Street to the City to enforce traffic. He said
there were an awful lot of cars parked down there at the garage and service station; that they block traffic
and the cars don't just park there but stay parked and one car had sit there for two months] trucks of all
kinds are parked there with the road blocked half of the time and they were going the wrong way. He said
he was speaking of between Fifty Avenue and Kimball Avenuej that he had talked to Lieutenant Gowen who had
come down and marked the tires on a Rambler with a Boise License two months ago and they hadn't moved it
since. Mr. Padget then said that he had talked to a State man over on Chicago Street and he had said that
the City was supposed to patrol it but couldn't take any cars off of it because the State owned the ground;
however, on December 7th the State was going to turn that ground over to the City and then they could move
the cars off or impound them, or put three or four hour parking signs .:p or do something.
After some further discussion, Mayor Carpenter stated that he didn't know anything about the
State turning the property over to the City but they would see if there was anything the City could do up
Police Chief Charles Astleford told the Mayor and Council that he would check and see what they
could do legally there and have a report for the next Council meeting.
Suggestion to pursue the possibility of one -way grid down town
Councilman Keys stated then that he thought the City should pursue the possibility of a one -way
grid down town in connection with the Agreement presented by the State at this meeting, and, if it was
feasable, get it into the planning for the contracts on Blaine Street.
B111s for End - November
It was moved by Councilman Keys, seconded by Councilman Banks, that the warrants for claims and
evrolls be approved as per list and filed in the City Clerk's office. Such warrants being in the totals
s follows:
Warrant Numbers 943 thru 1010, General Fund:--------------------------------- - - - - -- $ 5,761.23
Warrant Numbers 535 thru 564, Water & Sewer 'rand: Water-------------------- - - - --- 2,231.24
Treatment Plant----------- - - - - -- 1,069.48
Treatment Plant(Capital) -- - - - - -- 340.00
Water, General Office----- - - ---- 346.90
Sewer Maintenance--------- - - - --- 2,19
Warrant Numbers 951 thru 1001, Special Funds- Fire --------------------------- 224.38
Cemetery------------------ - - - - -- 1,069.91
Cemetery ,(capital)-------- - - - - -- 395.00
Street ------------ ------- - - - - -- 4,118.67
Sanitation ----- --- ------ -- -- ---- 356.24
Sanitation Contract ---------- _.- 6,748.47
Armory ------- --- -------- --- -- - - 120.00
Irrigation---------------- - - - - -- 260.38
Irrigation (Capital)------ - - - - -- 249.31
LID #65------------------- - - - - -- 42.48
$ 23,335.8$
Warrant Numbers 1844 thru 1908,(excepting #1844 & #1846)General Fund payroll, - - - - -- 31,434.21
Warrant Numbers 1909 thru 1967,(including #1846)Special Fund payroll,-------- ---- -- 19,618.84
Warrant Numbers 1968 thru 1994,(including #1844)Water & Sewer Funds payroll,- - - ---- 8 ' 190 .39
$ 2, 79.3
A vote was taken and the motion carried.
452
It was moved by Councilman McCluskey, seconded by Councilman Davenport, that the meeting recess
until 8:00 F.M. on December 21, 1970. A vote was taken and the motion carried. The meeting recessed at
10:25 P.M.
-- Mayor
CtyC e c
MAYOR'S OFFICE
DECEMBER 17, 1970
4:00 P.M.
The Council met pursuant to call and acknowledgment of notice in the following forme
We„ the undersigned Mayor and Members of the City Council of the City of Caldwell, Idaho, do here-
by acknowledge notice of a Special Meeting of the said City Council to be held in the Mayor's Office in the
City Hall in the City of Caldwell, Idaho, at the hour of 4 -.00 P.M. on the 17th day of December, 1970 for the
transaction of all business in connection with the following objects: to consider the application for a
liquor license for the remainder of 1970 submitted by Ieo M. Kunz and Robert Leo Kunz, dba See - I
Restaurant.
Witness our signatures this 17th day of December, 1970-
Mayor
c
Counc loran
Councilman
Mayor Charles 1J. Carpenter presiding.
Upon Roll Call, the following Councilmen answered present: Alfred H. McCluskey, James W. "Hill"
Keys, V. Jay Martin and James R. Dakan. Absent: C. A. "Chet" Davenport, and Charles C. Banks.
Application for retail Liquor License
Mayor Carpenter announced that this special meeting was called in order to hear the application
from the See -I Restaurant for a retail liquor license, and he then presented to the Council Members an Oath
from the Secretary of State shcwing the official census for the City of Caldwell to be 14 for the year
1970. This increase, be stated, allows another liquor license to be issued within the City. He then pre-
sented the application for liquor license for the remainder of 1970, signed by Leo M. Kunz & Robert Leo
Kunz, dba See -I Restaurant, accompanied by the necessary documents required by the city ordinance, and a
receipt from the City Clerk in the amount of $46.88 for the pro -rated fee, also the liquor license which
had been issued by the State of Idaho to the See_I Restaurant and a letter of approval signed by Captain
Elwood Siegmann, Acting Chief of Police.
Mayor Carpenter then stated he had been chatting with Police Captain Siegmann a few minutes
the meeting, and he felt there was something the Council members should know before they acted upon this
application. He then presented Captain Siegmann who stated that this afternoon Mr. Rex Nelson, who is in
charge of investigation for this District for the Idaho Liquor Law Enforcement Department, came into his
office and inquired about the See -I Restaurant, as to whether they had obtained a retail liquor license and
if not, if they had had a catering permit from another firm that was licensed. Captain Siegmann stated he
had checked with the City Clerk and learned that no such permit had been issued. He said Mr. Nelson then
went on to say that he had received word from a reliable source, which he could not divulge, that the See. 1
I Restaurant this past week -end had a party where hard liquor was disbursed. It was learned that the party
had been for the Government Radar Site located near Wilder, and that one of their men had bought hard J
liquor in Boise and brcaght it over here and one of their men had served it at this place. Captain
Siegmann stated, "According to my understanding, if this is true, then it would appear to me that they are
guilty of two offenses - No. 1, of serving liquor in a house or business that is unlicensed for serving
liquor they don't have a catering permit or a license for, and No. 2, selling, serving or allowing to be I�