Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1986-11-03city council minutesBook 27 Page 205 REGULAR MEETING November 3, 1.986 7:30 p.m. The Meeting was called to order by Mayor Cowles. The Mayor requested that everyone stand for the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members present: Raymond, J. Carter, L. Carter, and Mallea. Absent: Marcus and Marmon. (APPROVAL OF MINUTES) _ MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by L. Carter to dispense with the reading of the minutes of the Regular City Council Meeting of October 20, 1986, and approve them as written. MOTION CARRIED (AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION) The Mayor asked if there was anyone from the audience who cared to bring anything before the City Council that was not on the prepared Agenda. As there was no one, the Mayor declared that the Meeting would continue as outlined. OLD BUSINESS (SECOND READING OF BILL NO. 20 - ESTABLISH HISTORICAL COMMISSION) Mayor Cowles requested Councilman J. Carter read Bill No. 20 by title only as follows: AN ORDINANCE FOR THE CITY OF CALDWELL, A MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF IDAHO, CREATING A NEW SECTION, TITLE II, CHAPTER 13, SECTION 1 THROUGH 7 IN REGARDS TO HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION: PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION; PROVIDING FOR DEFINITION, PURPOSE, ORGANIZATION, DUTIES, RESTRICTIONS, AND SEPARABILITY. The Mayor declared it to be the second reading of Bill No. 20. NEW BUSINESS (HEARING ON COMPREHENSIVE PLAN CHANGE FROM INDUSTRIAL TO COMMERCIAL FOR PROPERTY ON FRANKLIN INTERCHANGE) The Mayor stated that the first item under New Business was a hearing on Comprehensive Plan Change from Industrial to Commercial for property on the Franklin Interchange. He requested that Mrs. Robison, the Planning and Zoning Director, address this item. Mrs. :Robison informed the City Council that there was a hotel complex proposed for lots or parts of Lots 1 and 2, and 5 through L5 of City View Tracts, Franklin interchange. The project on the site as proposed requires the following steps to be taken preparatory to any construction: 1. Comprehensive Plan change from industrial to commercial to accommodate a commercial :coning which would permit hotels. 2. A zone change from M -1 light industrial to C -4(AP) freeway or -- interchange commercial (Airport Overlay) deemed appropriate by virtue of location and intended land use. 3. Annexation of an enclave which is part of Lots 5, 10, and 14 of City View Tracts. 4, Vacation of two unnamed streets which are part of the original plat. Book 27 Page 206 5. A parcel of right of way to be dedicated in Lot 11 to connect Specht Street with Commercial Way. Public hearings have been held by the Planning and Zoning Commission on the Plan and Zone changes and also to establish a Plan and Zone designation upon annexation of the parcel adjacent to I -84 which is not in the City. Testimony received was positive and plans to extend water and sewer to the area were reviewed. Planning and Zoning's recommendation is to proceed with the Plan and zone changes, as requested, and to vacate the unnamed streets in anticipation of project plans showing different street alignments. The Mayor then read the following rules for speaking at a public hearing: No person shall be permitted to speak before City Council at a Public Hearing until recognized by the Mayor. All persons speaking shall speak before a microphone in such a manner as will assure that the recorded testimony or remarks will be accurate and trustworthy. At the commencement of the Hearing, the City Council shall establish a time limit to be observed by all speakers. When the Public Hearing is quasi - judicial in nature or one after which the City Council is required by law to make Findings of Fact, each speaker must swear or affirm that his testimony will be true and correct_ Any person refusing to comply with rules will be prohibited from speaking during the Public Hearing. Mayor Cowles requested that the City Council establish a time limit for those signing to speak to the hearing on the Comprehensive Plan Change from Industrial to Commercial for property on Franklin interchange. MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by L. Carter that a time limit of five minutes be set for those addressing the City Council. MOTION CARRIED Mayor Cowles then opened the meeting; for the Public Hearing and called on Tom Doerr, the first name on the sheet. Mr. Doerr, 103 South 7th Street, informed the Council that in three hours he could not possibly express the positive aspects of the hotel project, not only for the City, but for the County and the surrounding communities. It was critically important to have the Plan and zone change so to have the appropriate construction that would house the facility that was needed for the community. The City Clerk noted the arrival of Councilwoman Marcus. Tom and Ross Butler stated that they would not comment at this time. Mayor Cowles then closed the Public Hearing and asked for action from the City Council. MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by J. Carter that the Mayor and the Planning and Zoning Director be directed to draw up the Resolution for the Comprehensive Plan Change as indicated. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Raymond, J. Carter, and L. Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: Marmon. MOTION CARRIED (HEARING ON ZONE CHANGE FROM M -1 LIGHT INDUSTRIAL TO C -4(AP) FREEWAY OR INTERCHANGE COMMERCIAL) Book 27 Page 207 As there was no one signed to speak: at this hearing, Mayor Cowles opened and closed the public hearing. The Mayor then asked Mrs. Robison if she had anything to add with regard to this zone change. Mrs. Robison explained that the zone change was deemed appropriate by virtue of location and intended use. MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by L. Carter that the Mayor and the Planning and Zoning Director be directed to prepare an ordinance with regard to this zone change as indicated. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Raymond, J. Carter, L. Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: Marmon. MOTION CARRIED (ANNEXATION OF AN ENCLAVE - CITY VIEW TRACTS) Mayor Cowles requested that Mrs. Robison address this annexation. Mrs. Robison stated that this portion of property was surrounded by City limits. Along with the project, the request was made to the City that the enclave be annexed into the City. Mayor Cowles opened and closed a hearing on this request. Action was requested from the City Council with regard to this annexation. MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by L. Carter that an ordinance be prepared to annex the enclave which is part of Lots 5, 10 and 14 of City View Tracts. MOTION CARRIED (HEARING ON VACATION OF TWO UNNAMED STREETS - CITY VIEW TRACTS) Mayor Cowles opened and closed the Hearing as there was no one asking to speak to this Vacation. The Mayor then called on Mrs. Robison to update the Council on this vacation. Mrs. Robison explained that this vacation was also part of the hotel complex project and pointed out the streets on the map for the benefit of the City Council. The vacation of the unnamed streets was in anticipation of project plans showing different street alignments. The City Engineer added that it appeared that there would be no adverse effects from the vacation of the streets. The City Clerk noted the arrival of Councilman Kent Marmon. It was then MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by J. Carter that the proper documents be prepared to allow for the vacation of the two unnamed streets in City View Tracts,. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, J. Carter., L. Carter, Mallea, Marcus, and Marmon. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED (HEARING ON COMPREHENSIVE PLAN CHANGE TO ANNEX PROPERTY AT HAPPY DAY BUSINESS CENTER SUBDIVISION - FRAME AND SERVICE COMMERCIAL LAND USE) Mayor Cowles reminded those in the audience that if they cared to speak to this item on the Agenda, they must sign the paper allowing them to do so. The Mayor then requested that Mrs. Robison report with regard to this annexation request. Mrs. Robison presented the following report: Book 27 Page 208 The City of Caldwell has received a request from Duane Wolfe for annexation of a parcel of land containing approximately 3.81 acres on Cleveland Boulevard adjacent to and northwesterly of Block 2 of Happy Day Business Center Subdivision. Prior to annexation, a Comprehensive Plan land use designtion and a zone are to be established by the City. The Council must receive a recommendation from Planning and Zoning before proceeding with the annexation. The applicant has requested a frame and service commercial land use on the Comprehensive Plan and a C -3 service commercial zone on the Official Zoning Map. Use of the property will be for the sale of new and used vehicles, which is permitted in the C -3 zone. The property is shown as Frame and Service Commercial on the Comprehensive Plan: and is zoned commercial in the County, so there is no change under consideration other than the boundaries of the City limits. The appropriate hearings have been held by Planning and Zoning and they have recommended that the property be annexed with the stated commercial designations in conformance with the Cleveland Boulevard area. Mayor Cowles requested that the Council establish a time limit for those caring to address the City Council. It was MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by Raymond that five minutes be allowed. MOTION CARRIED The Mayor then opened the meeting for the Public Hearing on the proposed annexation. Al McCluskey was recognized by the Mayor and stated that he had no reason to address the City Council unless there was questions. As there was no comment from the Council, the Mayor closed the public hearing and asked the Council to take action. MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Marmon that a Resolution be prepared for the Comprehensive Plan as requested. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, J. Carter, L. Carter, Mallea, Marcus, and Marmon. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED (HEARING ON ZONE CHANGE FOR HAPPY DAY PROPERTY ANNEXATION - C -3 SERVICE COMMERCIAL ZONE) Mayor Cowles stated that this request for a zone change was for the same property as just discussed on the Plan Change. As there was no one requesting to speak to this zone change, the Mayor opened and closed the hearing. MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by L. Carter that an Ordinance be prepared for the zone change as stipulated. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, Raymond, J. Carter, and L. Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED (ORDINANCE DECLARING INTENT TO SELL LAND AT PUBLIC AUCTION) Mayor Cowles requested that Councilman Marmon read Bill No. 21 by title only as follows: AN ORDINANCE GIVING NOTICE TO ALL CITIZENS OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL COUNTY, IDAHO, THAT THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL INTEND TO SELL THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY THE CITY OF CALDWELL, CANYON COUNTY, IDAHO; AND WHICH PROPERTY IS SITUATED IN CANYON COUNTY, IDAHO; THAT SAID SALE IS MADE UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF TITLE 50, CHAPTER 14, IDAHO CODE; THAT SAID SALE OF SAID PROPERTY SHALL BE AT PUBLIC AUCTION AND SHALL BE Book 27 Page 209 SOLD TO THE HIGHEST BIDDER AND THAT' NO BID SHALL BE ACCEPTED FOR LESS THAN THE APPRAISED VALUE; SAID PROPERTY BEING DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS, TO -WIT A parcel of land in the Northwest Quarter of the Northeast Quarter of Section 21, Township 4 North, Range 3 West of the Boise Meridian, more particularly described as follows Councilwoman Mallea asked if provisions could be established to get the tiling done. The City Engineer explained that this Ordinance would establish the sixty day waiting period before the City Council can do anything. In about thirty days, the City can advertise the auction of the property so when the sixty days has passed, the property can be auctioned. At the time of the advertising for the auction of the property, conditions could be placed on the sale of the property. MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by J. Carter to dispense with the rule requiring that a Bill be read at three separate times and that Bill No. 21 be read by title only for the one reading. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, Raymond, J. Carter, and L, Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by J. Carter that Bill No. 21 be passed and entitled Ordinance No. 1736. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, Raymond, J. Carter, and L. Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED (REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL - JEAN BRUEGGESTRASS) Mayor Cowles recognized Jean Brueggestrass who requested to address the City Council at this time. Ms. Brueggestrass explained that she was present at the meeting in the capacity of Chairman of Board of Directors of the Community Involvement Program Inc. which was a sponsoring entity for R.S.V.P. She distributed material to the Council for their purusal and then continued with her presentation. Ms . Brueggestrass expressed to the Council her concern with regard to the fact that funds have been cut at a .local level for the R.S.V.P. Program. Her purpose in coming to the City Council was to state how important the R.S.V.P.. Program was and their need for funds at this time. Mary Lou Cooper, the Director of R.S.V.P., also spoke to the City Council emphasizing the need of the Program and asking for any help the City Council might be able to give them. (RESOLUTION FOR AGREEMENT WI'1H BUREAU OF RECLAMATION AND PIONEER IRRIGATION DISTRICT) The City Engineer, Ron Redmond, was requested by the Mayor to discuss this Resolution. Mr. Redmond informed the Council that this was an Agreement that= the City has been working on for about a year. The language was modified some by the City, the Bureau of Reclamation has modified the language as far as they are willing to do so, and a copy of the Agreement was sent to the City Attorney and a letter of review was received from him. There was some worry about_ the responsibility being assumed by the City, but after all the discussions it was found that the City already adopted a similar agreement about ten years ago with regard to the Dixie Drain. Therefore, the City may not be Book 27 Page 210 signing off as much as originally thought, The bottom line was that the City needed the Dixie Drain to implement the City's drainage plan. To implement the plan, the City will have to agree to the terms the Bureau has issued. The crossings at Linden, Ash and Logan would be improved and some water detention ponds would be provided on Fairview Golf Course. Council discussed this Agreement with the City Engineer at some length after which the Mayor requested that the Resolution be read by Councilman J. Carter as follows: RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CALDWELL AND THE BUREAU OF RECLAMATION AND PIONEER IRRIGATION DISTRICT. BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and Clerk of the City of Caldwell be, and the same hereby are, authorized to execute that certain Agreement attached hereto and made a part hereof as if set forth in full by and between the City of Caldwell and the Bureau of Reclamation and the Pioneer Irrigation District for the purpose of discharging drainage water into the Dixie Drain. MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Marcus that the Resolution be passed authorizing the execution of the Agreement between the City of Caldwell and the Bureau of Reclamation and Pioneer Irrigation District. Roll call vote. Those voting yes:: Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, Raymond, J. Carter, and L. Carter„ Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED (DISCUSSION REGARDING THE B.M.X. TRACK) Mayor Cowles introduced Bob Collins who was present at the meeting to bring the City Council up to date on the B.M.X. Track at the Complex. Mr. Collins stated that a couple of months ago he expressed to the City his concern about what was happening at the B.M.X. Track. Since that time, Mr. Martin, who had the original contract with the City, has become ill. A group was formed by Dick Percifield as a nonprofit organization to take over the operation of the track. The organization proposed a rather extensive upgrading of the track. As a result, he was asked to investigate as to what they were doing in relation to what plans were already made for the track. Mr. Percifield met him at the track and he sketched out his plans which the Council did receive a copy of. Mr. Collins further said that it was an improvement over what they have now and he felt all of Mr. Percifield's plans were favorable. He was satisfied with the fences and the access that the RVs will have. Mr. Percifield was then introduced to the Council by Mr. Collins. A financial report was submitted to the Council as requested and Mr. Percifield stated that there was a lot of young people depending on this track. It was his hope that an agreement could be reached with the City as soon as possible so the improvements could be accomplished before the bad weather. Al McCluskey spoke to the City Council encouraging them to support Mr. Percifield in his endeavor. He felt that it was a positive project for the City. MOVED by L. Carter, SECONDED by Raymond that the City proceed with the lease with the B.M.X. for one year with an option to renew under the terms of the present lease. Councilman Raymond stated that the present lease expires in April of 1987 so the City would be extending from April of 1987 until April of 1988. Book 27 MOTION CARRIED (CLAIM FROM KATHY YOUNG) Page 211 Mayor Cowles recognized Gene Enebo to explain this particular claim. Mr. Enebo explained that copies of the claim from Ms. Young and the letter from the insurance company were placed in the Council's boxes. Mr,. Frazier, the insurance adjuster, stated that the damage from the break in no way exhibited negligence from the City. He told Ms. Young that a settlement would not be offered to her. It has been the City's policy to submit the claims to the insurance company as soon as they are received, If the claim is justified and beyond the deductible, the insurance company will pay for the damage. If the claim is justified, but under the deductible, the insurance company will still pay and then bill the City. In this case, the insurance adjuster stated that there was not a justifiable claim. Mr. Enebo assured the Council that he also investigated the damage and agreed with Mr. Frazier's decision. Councilman J. Carter stated that after looking over the claim and the adjuster's memo, he would MOVE, and it was SECONDED by Marmon that the claim submitted by Kathy Young be denied. MOTION CARRIED (TRAFFIC SIGNS) The City Engineer reminded the Council that he put a draft of a Traffic Regulatory Sign Policy in their boxes. The reason for this was that the Chief of Police called him with regard to requests made over the years to the City to put up specialty signs. This could include stop signs, traffic control signs and etc. specifically requested by individuals. The City wanted to establish some guidelines so that everyone would be treated on a similar or uniform basis and also to avoid placing too many signs around the City. Generally, the City has to replace twenty -five to thirty percent of the signs every year. There was approximately three thousand traffic control signs in the City of various types. Mr. Redmond further said that he sat down with several members of the Police Department to draft up a fair policy on how to address street and traffic control signs. This was the draft that he distributed to them for their study. They were hopeful to adopt this policy soon to have guidance for sign placement. He would like to have the Council submit their input or ideas with regard to this proposed policy. If Council had any questions, he would be happy to discuss the policy with them. (PROPOSAL FROM U.P.R.R. ON THE TRAIN DEPOT) The Mayor read the following letter which was also copied for the members of the Council: As you are aware, the Union Pacific Railroad no longer needs or uses the Depot in Caldwell. Since this Depot no longer has any operational value to us, it has become quite costly to maintain, in fact, prohibitive. By this letter, the Railroad formally proposes to you and the City Council that Union Pacific Railroad, upon future management approval, would be willing to donatE; the Depot to your City and lease the property on which it sits for a nominal fee. If the City Government is interested in this Depot, would you please let this Office know so that the necessary negotiations can begin. Your earliest response would be most appreciated since the Railroad would like to dispose of this matter by December 1, 1986. Book 27 s/s Charles G. Clark Page 21.2 Mayor Cowles further informed the Council that he talked with Mr. Clark on several occasions. From all indications, it appeared that the building does not have to be moved. There would be need of a fence for security purposes. The Mayor stated that it was not necessary to make that decision at this time, but he hoped that the Council would do so in the near future. There was some discussion about the building. The City Engineer said that Mr. Clark agreed to bring the keys by for the Depot so that the City could look at the building to determine its condition. Councilwoman Marcus stated that she inspected the building about a year ago. There was a person in the audience at this time that would like to address the City Council about the Depot. The Mayor recognized Ginger Anderson, who was present at the meeting representing the Snake Basin Drama Guild. She explained that the Guild needed a permanent home for their group in order to host workshops, performances, to store their props and etc. They were anxious to expand their performances, but needed a place to work from. Ms. Anderson further explained the Guild and their purposes. It was her hope that the City Council would consider allowing them to use the Despot as a home for Snake Basin Drama Guild. The City Council agreed that they would like to look at the building and determine whether it could be used and also the costs that would occur to keep the building in use. Council agreed to notify Ms. Anderson after they looked at the Depot. (RESOLUTION - CITY STREET FINANCE REPORT) The Mayor explained that once a year a City Street Finance Report must be approved by the City and published in the newspaper. That report was as follows: CITY STREET FINANCE; REPORT For Year Ended 9/30/86 REVENUE Taxes 219,728 Intergov °t 532,382 Misc. 50,703 Non Rev Rec 25,810 Total 82'8,623 EXPENSES M & 0 536,741 Equip 38,792 Const. 184,873 Total 760,406 Net addition to fund balance 68,217 Beginning Balance 10/1/85 325,642 Ending Balance 9/30/86 393,859 I, Peter B. Cowles, Mayor of the City of Caldwell, State of Idaho, do hereby certify the aove is a true account of the Street revenues and expenditures for the budget year ending 9/30/86. Councilwoman Mallea read the Resolution in full as follows: REVOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, TO EXECUTE THE CITY STREET FINANCE REPORT FOR THE CITY OF CALDWELL. Book 27 Page 213 BE IT RESOLVED, That the Mayor and City Clerk of the City of Caldwell be, and the ssame hereby are, authorized to execute that certain City Street Finance Report attached hereto and made a part hereof as if set forth in full in accordance with Idaho Code 40 -137. MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by L. Carter that the Resolution be passed authorizing the execution of the City Street Finance Report. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, Raymond, J. Carter, L. Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. (COMMITTEE REPORTS) MOTION CARRIED Councilman Raymond reported that the Search Committee for a Manager at the Stadium were in possession of six job descriptions from various areas so they will proceed to develop a job description. The Committee was still looking in the salary range of $20,000 - $25,000 which will depend on the background of the person selected. At a previous report, the Mayor reported to Council that the position would be opened to City personnel and residents first. Councilman Raymond further said that he had talked with one person who was involved at one time in scheduling activities at a rather large Convention Center. An ad was placed in the IAAM with regard to the position which was a nationwide organization. Councilman Raymond also stated that the City received the report back from the Fact Finders Committee. The next decision the Council needed to act on was whether they wanted to re -enter contract negotiations with the Firefighters. For purposes of discussion, it was MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by L. Carter that the City agree to re -enter negotiations with the Firefighters immediately. There was considerable discussion with regard to this issue. Councilwoman Mallea stated that she was under the impression that the Council would meet in Executive Session. Councilman Raymond stated that publicly the Council needed to determine whether they were going to go back into negotiations. There would be no need for an Executive Session if there was not an intent to re -enter negotiations. MOVED by J. Carter that the motion be tabled until after the Executive Session. The Mayor said there was a motion before the Council now. Councilman J. Carter stated that the motion to table takes precedence. SECONDED by Marcus. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: J. Carter, Mallea, Marcus, Marmon. Those voting no: L. Carter and Raymond. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by Marmon that pursuant to Idaho State Code, Section 67- 2343, the City Council convene into an Executive Session as soon as the Regular Council Meeting Agenda is completed and the meeting recessed for the purpose of discussing labor negotiations after which the Council will reconvene into a Regular Meeting to take action. -- Roll call vote. Those voting yes: J. Carter, Mallea, Marcus, and Marmon. Those voting no: L. Carter and Raymond. Absent and not voting: none. MOTIO14 CARRIED Boob 27 Page 214 Councilman J. Carter informed the Council that he was meeting with a representative from a management company for lunch on Friday with regard to the salary and wage survey. He also requested a delay on the tenant agreements at the Airport until he received a report from the seminar conducted by the Idaho Airport Management Association Meeting where there was an extensive discussion on leases. Councilman Carter also stated that he would like to call a Finance Committee Meeting sometime soon. Councilwoman Mallea reminded the Council of the A.I.C. Legislative dinner on November 20th. It was important for Council people to invite the County officials and the Legislatures. Councilwoman Marcus reported that she attended a conference on Small Business last week. She was also working with the Committee regarding Child Care Facilities. There was to be a Library Board Meeting this coming Thursday. (MAYOR'S COMMENTS) The Mayor stated to the City Council that he received a letter from Dick Winder with regard to the old City Hall. A copy of that letter was placed in the Council's mail boxes. The Mayor also informed the Council that he 'met with a representative from the Idaho Employer's Council and he would set up a meeting so the Council could also visit with him. Some decision needed to be made as to what the Council desired to do. As there was no other Agenda business, the Regular City Council Meeting was recessed at 9 :10 p.m. and the City Council convened into an Executive session. Mayor Cowles reconvened the Regular City Council Meeting at 9:40 p.m. MOVED by Raymond, that the City Council agree to re -enter negotiations with the Caldwell Firefighters. SECONDED by L. Carter. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, L. Carter, Mallea. Those voting no: J. Carter, Marcus, Marmon. Absent and not voting: none. As there was a tie vote, the Mayor cast his vote as a yes. MOTION CARRIED There being no further business the Meeting was adjourned at 10:00 P.M. APPROVED AS written THIS 17th DAY OF November , 1986. Councilberson .�. r... % %L'41 1..,. Cbuncilperson ATTEST: City Cl6r