HomeMy WebLinkAbout1984-10-23city council minutesBook 25 Page 236
REGULAR MEETING
October 23, 1984
12:00 Noon
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor McCluskey.
The Mayor requested that everyone stand and give the Pledge of
Allegiance to the Flag.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following
members present: Carter, Mallea, Marcus, Raymond, and Norman.
Absent: Cowles.
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
The Mayor asked if there was anyone from the audience who cared
to bring anything before the City Council that was not on the
prepared Agenda. Dee Naumann was recognized by the Mayor and
requested an audience with the City Council.
Mrs. Naumann stated that she was present at the meeting to
discuss the controversial water wheel. A great deal of time has
been spent on this project securing information that was felt was
pertinent. After the research, it was found that in excess of
$10,000 was needed just to get started. This does not have
anything to do with the actual wheel. There was a lot of weeds
that need to be destroyed, the diversionary house does not have a
bottom which is causing leaks in the bank which will cause
problems, the bank also needs ground cover. Mrs. Naumann further
informed the Council that they were unable to find the water
wheel. There was a rumor that the College of Idaho was going to
repair the wheel, but no one seems to know anything about it,
Her question was whether there was money available for this type
of budget and who will accept the responsibility for liability in
this area. This was the main objection she has run into when
talking to those who have expressed inerest in helping. She had
talked with the Koch family and they have been helpful and
supportive due to the fact that the area for the most part was
theirs. The City does have an easement. Mrs. Naumann stated
that the purpose of the project needed to be addressed and she
thought that if the liability question was answered more people
would be willing to help. At this time, she had about $5,000
pledged verbally.
This project was discussed at some length by the City Council and
the Mayor. It was pointed out that this was planned to be a
community involvement project with the City participating with
manpower. It was then MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Norman that
unless a firm commitment towards the $10,000 is received by
December 1, 1984, that the project be postponed.
MOTION CARRIED
Ms. Sheila Andrews was then recognized and expressed concern over
a pay check that was not received by her son while working at the
swimming pool this last summer. After considerable discussion,
it was agreed that this matter would be discussed by the Finance
Chairman and the Payroll Office.
(OLD BUSINESS)
The Mayor requested permission to conduct the Public Hearing at
this time which was listed as the first item under New Business
so those in attendance at. the Meeting would not have to wait any
longer. Council gave their approval..
(PUBLIC HEARING ON THE VACATICN OF THIRD STREET)
The Mayor called the Public clearing open and requested that the
City Engineer, Ron Redmond, address this item. Mr. Redmond
stated that he did hand out to the members of the City Council a
Book 25
Page 237
report on the vacation of 3rd Street. lie proceeded by explaining
that they were talking about that !section of 3rd street that was
situated between Aven and Indian Creek and also between Caxton
Printers and what used to be the old Harmon Cabinet Shop. Mr.
Redmond further informed the Council that he would hit the
highlights of the report. The general description was an 80 foot
wide by 175 foot long section of 3:cd Street which was essentially
unimproved. it was improved to the point of providing access to
both the cabinet shop and Caxtons. There was a number of
utilities in there and also telephone and power in the area. !iis
Department talked these over with Mr. Gipson and for the most
part their Proposed improvements can be located where it will not
interfere with the utilities. The storm drain will have to be
relocated and some waterline surfaces will have to be relocated.
The City Council would have to make the determination that the
vacation was in the best interest of the City of Caldwell so an
estimate was made as to the value of the property which came to
$39,200. Mr. Redmond further stated that for the record; A
petition from the adjacent property owners for vacation of the
street was received on August 8th, 1984; all property owners
within 300 feet have been notified of the proposed action and
public hearing to be held on October 23, 1 984.
The proposed vacation was discussed and several questions were
directed to Dave Gipson who was present at the meeting. As there
was no one else who cared to speak towards this vacation, the
Mayor declared the hearing closed.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Norman that the City proceed as
directed by law towards the vacation of 3rd Street.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes; Raymond, Marcus, Mallea,
Carter, and Norman. Those votincf no: none. Absent and not
voting: Cowles.
MOTION CARRIED
OLD BUSINESS
(BILL NO. 11 - FIRST READING OF CHILD CARE LICENSING)
The Mayor declared that the first item, under old Business was the
first reading of the Child Care Licensing Bill.
Councilwoman Marcus explained that the City Attorney requested
that the Council. again consider this the first reading as there
was some major changes made since the last reading. She did
appreciate the work that has been done by Mr. Connolly in writing
this Bill. Councilwoman Marcus further said that she would like
to have the City Council give consideration to Section 4-23-1
under Child Care Facility where it states that any facility
providing care, maintenance and supervision of children under the
age of - This age needed to be stated and she
would like assistance in determining this age. Councilwoman
Mallea suggested that the people from the Health and 'Nelfare be
contacted for their recommendation.
-Mrs. Robison explained that the Planning and Zoning Commission
discussed the Bill and were hoping that everyone will come in and
apply for their City licenses and will also contact P & Z to get
a location as far as the zone. One or two public hearings would
be planned all at the same time although each will be treated as
a separate hearing. Two time periods were also established in
order for them to accomplish this with the last one ending
January 15th. Also agreed was a $50 special use permit Lee rather
than $100 to make it easier.
The Mayor then read Bill No. 11 by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND TITLE IV OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE CITY
OF CALDWELL, COUNTY OF CANYON, STATE OF IDAHO, BY -ADDING THE
FOLLOWING NHICE SHALL BE DESIGNATED AS CHAPTER 23 OF SAID TITLE
Book 25
Page 238
IV REGARDING CHILD CARE FACILITIES; PROVIDING DEFINITIONS;
LICENSES REQUIRED; EXEMPTIONS AND SPECIAL APPLICATIONS;
INVESTIGATION OF FACILITIES; STANDARD FOR ISSUANCE OF LICENSE;
LICENSES; INSPECTION; PENALTIES: REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES,
RESOLUTIONS, ORDER OR PARTS THEREOF IN CONFLICT HEREWITH.
The Mayor then declared that this would be considered reading No.
1 for Bill No. 11.
(BILL NO. 21 - FORM STADIUM COMMISSION;
The Mayor explained that this Bill was not changed at all since
the first reading. It was sent to the City Attorney, but no
comments were received as yet.
The Mayor then read Bill No. 21 by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE MUNICIPAL CITY CODE OF THE CITY OF
CALDWELL, IDAHO, BY CREATING A NEW SECTION: TITLE II, CHAPTER
12, SECTION 1 THROUGH 6 IN REGARDS TO MULTI - PURPOSE STADIUM
COMMISSION: SETTING FORTH CREATION, MEMBERSHIP AND TERMS OF
OFFICE, ORGANIZATION; RULES, RECORDS, AND MEETINGS; AND POWERS
AND DUTIES.
The Mayor then stated that this would be the second reading of
Bill No. 21.
NEW BUSINESS
(ACCEPT BID FOR M0WER FOR GOLF DEPARTMENT)
The Mayor read a memo from Gordy Crockett, the Golf
Superintendent as folows:
On October 16th, 1984, 11:00 a.m. at City Hall sealed bids were
opened on a 7 -Gang Self Contained Fairway Mower. We would like
the City Council to approve the low bid of $25,500 from Turf
Equipment Company over the high bid of $25,900 from Boyd Martin
ComToany. This mower will be bought on a lease purchase
agreement.
The Mayor explained that this was to be a lease purchase with the
First Interstate Bank of Idaho, N. A., as Lessor for a period of
three years with the payment amount being $9,240.51 at an annual
percentage rate of 8.98 %. The Mayor was authorized to sign the
lease documents.
MOVED by Norman, SECONDED by Mallea to accept the low bid from
Turf Equipment Company in the amount of $25,500.
MOTION CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE
Those voting yes:;Norman, Mallea,Carter,Marcus,Raymond. No: none.
(REPORT ON AIRPORT) Absent; Cowles.
The Mayor read the following letter addressed to Whit Smith from
Mark A. Beisse, Community Planner of the F.A.A.:
We have formulated an airport improvement program for 1985. The
proposed - master planning update for Caldwell Industrial Airport
has been selected as a potential project subject to appropriation
of sufficient funds by Congress.
This year we have an objective of issuing planning grants by
March 31, 1985, so that our end of the year workload is reduced.
Please let us know at your early convenience whether you are
interested and able to meet that schedule.
The scope of the project, costs, and other details should be
discussed with us prior to entering into any consultant
contracts, Please call if you have questions.
Book 25
Page 239
Mr. Redmond commented that this would mean that the grant
submitted by Steve Hosack was approved pending financing.
(COMMITTEE REORTS)
Councilwoman Mallea stated that she was concerned with regard to
the health insurance for the City. The City Council by vote
authorized the Mayor to enter into an agreement with Washington
National. She understood that sore of the Council members may
have changed their minds on this matter so in an attempt to
clarify this, Councilwoman Mallea stated that she would MOVE that
the Mayor be directed to enter into an agreement for the purposes
of obtaining health insurance as directed for the City. SECONDED
by Carter.
Councilman Raymond questioned as to what the motion was
previously. Councilman Carter read the motion as follows; "That
subject to the Mayor's ability to confirm that those retirees can
continue under this health insurance and that the Mayor be
authorized to enter into a Comprehensive Major Medical Life
insurance Policy with Washington National." This motion was
passed by the City Council at that meeting.
Councilwoman Mallea stated that she was concerned as there would
not be another meeting before the Policy now in existence
expires. The Mayor said that he had some problems with this
directive as after the meeting it was discovered that it would
eliminate some of the benefits by entering into the Washington
National Policy. It would cause some reduced benefits for the
employees and every indication showed that it would cause an
increase in manpower in City Hall. There would be $5,000 saved
through Washington National, but this would not compensate for
the extra employee.
There was a great deal of discussion among the City Council
members with regard to the insurance coverage. Councilman
Raymond stated that he was not capable of sitting here and
listening to figures thrown around and analyzing what was best
for the employees. The decision made previously was based on the
information available at that time. If there was new
information, he would prefer having an opportunity to study the
information to be sure the right decision was made.
Councilwoinan Mallea again pointed out that there was a deadline
to consider, but she would at this time withdraw her motion with
the consent of the second. She would request that something be
done immediately as November 1st was the end of the City's
coverage. The second, Councilman Carter, gave his approval for
the withdrawal of the :notion as made by Councilwoman Mallea.
The Mayor then stated that he would set the time of 4 1:00 p.m.
that afternoon to meet to further discuss the insurance for the
City of Caldwell,
(COMMITTEE REPORTS)
Councilman Norman reported that he :net with the Golf Board and
they have ended the year in good shape. There was some
discussion regarding rules and regulations for the clubhouses.
Councilman Raymond said that he talked with Mrs. Baird, 901
Denver, spoke to him about the vacation that was approved for
Denver Street for construction of the store. Apparently, that
building was going to be very close to where the curb and gutter
now is on her side of Denver. There was no curb and gutter on
the 9th Street side -- will it leave no curb and guttered parking
for that property?
Mr. Redmond, the City Engineer, answered that one of the
conditions placed on the vacation was curb and gutter on 9th
Street. The developer intends to purchase her property and then
turn around and give her a life estate type of approach. In
Boole 25
Page 240
order for him to put the size store he wants there, he is going
to have to encroach 20 feet into her property on the portion of
Denver that would be vacated. The developer is attempting to
situate the store in order to minimize the impact on her house.
lie was aware of the situation and attempting to address it.
Councilwoman Marcus asked the City Engineer if they could have a
report from him on the Curtis Park situation discussed several
meetings previous.
(MAYOR'S COMMENTS)
The Mayor reported that the State has changed the speed limit on
Cleveland to slow down the traffic.
The Mayor stated that he was requested by Mr. Mulkey to inform the
City Council that if any of 'them would care to tour the State School,
they were to call him.
On Thursday, at Noon at the 131 Gringo, there was to be a meeting with
Darrel Manning in response to the letter he sent to the Mayor
completely eliminating any possibility of having a Tourist Information
Stop.
(AGREEMENTS AND RESOLUTIONS -- REL,INQUISHMENT AND MAINTENANCE WITH THE
IDAHO TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT)
Mr. Redmond, the City Engineer., explained to the City Council
that these agreements were the ones previously discussed at
Council Meeting. There was two agreements; one is relinquishment
of Tenth Avenue and the other_ the overall maintenance agreement
for all of the State highways within the City. Mr. Redmond
further stated that he had done some research in the areas where
concerns were expressed.. Mr. Redmond stated that as he identified
to the Council at the October 9th meeting, the new maintenance
agreement places added responsibility on the City on three
different State routes within the City. The City has already
chosen to accept this additional responsibility, however, when
certain sections of street have been improved. The three areas
in question are: 1. Aven (Highway 19 from Main Street to City
limits) . Agreed to maintain Apri'_.21, 1981. 2. Centennial Way
(Northwest Connector). Maintenance of this section is a part of
the 10th Avenue relinquishment and has been verbally accepted by
the City since the inception of the Connector. 3. East
Cleveland. The responsibility for snow removal and maintenance of
storm drains from Wilson Drain to Ustick has always been the
State's. No previous agreement has committed us to accept same in
this section. A discussion with Ted Gwin of the State Highway
Department has indicated that they would agree to modify the
agreement back to the way it was and the State would continue to
provide snow removal.
Mr. Redmond stated that the Council could proceed to approve the
maintenance agreement subject to the change of deleting the Gast
Cleveland section. On the 10th Street relinquishment, there is a
clause that the City would be accepting maintenance for
Centennial way.
The Mayor then read Resolution No„ 28 -84 as follows:
WHEREAS, the Idaho Transportation Department, Division of
Highways, hereafter called the "State ", has submitted an
Agreement stating obligations of the State and the City of
Caldwell, Idaho, for removal of sections of highway from the
State Highway System and from the U.S. Route Numbering System, to
be relinquished to the City of Caldwell.
Book 25
Page 241
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED
1. That the System Action Relinquishment and Maintenance
Agreement is hereby approved,
2. That the Mayor and the City Clerk are hereby authorized
to execute the Agreement on behalf of the City.
3. That duly certified copies of the resolution shall. be
furnished to the State.
MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Norman that Resolution No. 28 -84 be
passed authorizing the execution of the System Action
Relinquishment and Maintenance Agreement with the Idaho
Transportation Department.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Norman.
Those voting no: Raymond and Carter. Absent and not voting.
Cowles.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor then read Resolution No. 29 -84 as follows:
WHEREAS, the Idaho Transportation Department, Division of
Highways, hereafter called the "State ", has submitted an
Agreement stating obligations of the State and the City of
Caldwell, Idaho, for cooperative Agreement or Maintenance of
State Highway SH -19, U.S. 30, and I -84.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED:
1. That the Cooperative Agreement or Maintenance of State
Highway SH -19, U.S. 30, 1 -84 is hereby approved.
2. That the Mayor and the City Clerk are hereby authorized
to execute the Agreement on behalf of the City.
3. That duly certified copies of the resolution shall be
furnished to the State.
it was noted that Councilman Raymond was excused from the City
Council Meeting.
MOVED by Marcus, SECONDED by Norman that Resolution No. 29 -84 be
passed authorizing the execution of Cooperative Agreement or
Maintenance of State Highway SH -19, U.S. 30 & I -84.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Marcus, Mallea, and Norman.
Those voting no: Carter. Absent and not voting: Cowles and
Raymond.
MOTION CARRIED
(LETTER WITH REGARD TO THE CITY POLICE UNION
The Mayor read the following letter addressed to the City
Attorney from the Office of the Attorney General for the State of
Idaho:
You have asked us several questions about the City's obligations
when City police employees agree to form a union. Specifically,
you have asked:
1, Whether the City must officially recognize and negotiate with
the union, and
2. what, if any, procedures should the City adopt in dealing
with the union?
Generally, there is no legal obligation on the part of cities to
recognize or negotiate with public employee organizations or
unions, Rhyne, Local Government Law, p. 323, unless required to
do so by statute, ordinance, or contract. In Idaho, collective
bargaining between local governments and public employees is only
required in the cases of fire fighters, Idaho Code 44 --1801 et
seq., and teachers, ?daho Code 33 -1272, et sect. There is no such
statutory requirement covering police officers.
Book 25
Page 242
A number of Attorney General's Opinions and letters have dealt
with these issues. We are enclosing them for your information.
They generally state the same propositions as set out above. As
to procedures, no particular ones have been established for
dealing with public employee organizations except as set :f=orth in
the statutes dealing with fire fighters. There are a number of
books available on the subject of negotiation. In addition, the
Association of Idaho Cities may be able to advise you on the
matter.
The Mayor stated that he read the letter for Council information.
(BEER LICENSE FOR SUPER QUICK)
The Mayor read the following letter addressed to the Mayor and
City Council from the Police Chief:
Barbara Downing, Route 6, Box 62, Caldwell -, has applied for a
city license to sell beer at the Super Quick Market, 3604 East
Cleveland Boulevard, Caldwell. Mrs. Downey has no criminal
record which would preclude the issuance of a city license.
All the necessary documents and the fee was submitted. The Mayor
then asked for action from the City Council.
MOVED by Marcus, SECONDED by Mall.ea that approval be given for
the beer license at Super Quick as requested.
MOTION CARRIED
(TREASURE VALLEY CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE DINNER)
Councilwoman Marcus informed the City Council that the Treasure
Valley Chambers of Commerce was having a Honored Civic Leader
Night on the 30th of October at the Elk's Lodge in Caldwell. The
Mayor was among those being honored at that time and she wanted
the Council to be aware of this so they could plan to attend.
Reservations were to be made with the Chamber of Commerce.
There being no further business, the Meeting was adjourned at
1:20 p.m.
APPROVED AS
November
written
1984.
C c 1pers n �J
' Councilperson
Councilperson
AT'T`EST:
DAY OF
City C1 =�
THIS 6th