HomeMy WebLinkAbout1989-10-02city council minutesBook 30
REGULAR MEETING
October 2, 1989
7:30 p.m.
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor Cowles.
Page 214
The Mayor requested that everyone stand for the Pledge of
Allegiance to the Flag.
The roll of the City Council was called with the following
members present: Raymond, Winder, Houchins, Mallea, Jarboe,
and Straight. Absent: none.
(ADDITIONS TO THE AGENDA)
Mayor Cowles advised the City Council that item No. 7 under
New Business would be deleted from the Agenda. Otherwise,
there was no additional changes and the meeting would
continue as outlined.
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
Mr. Bob Weygandt asked the Mayor if input would be allowed
from the audience during the presentation of the third
reading of Bill No. 32, Mt. View Subdivision Rezone.
After discussion, the Council agreed that Mr. Weygandt be
allowed to speak at this time.
Robert E. Weygandt, 2506 Cherry, made the following
statement: As a resident and concerned citizen of the City
of Caldwell, I am astounded and amazed that the Planning and
Zoning Commission and the City Council have taken the stand
that commercial development outweighs the needs and desires
of the residents of Caldwell. Making the decision to allow a
change in the zoning, just because it is believed that a
project is viable, is not a justification of that rezone as
required under Idaho Law. Caldwell's government cannot serve
the people who have elected them if they choose to ignore the
pleas of the residents who will most be affected by decisions
made by that government. The disregard for the concerns of
its citizens shows that some of Caldwell's officials have
made the decision that commercialization of this City is more
important than its citizens. If the City chooses to take the
stand that it does not have to follow the Comprehensive Plan,
as is required by Idaho Law, then we as citizens have no
choice but to ask the State's Attorney General to investigate
the possibility that the City has violated the laws of the
State of Idaho. In my opinion, they certainly have violated
the trust of the people and I hope that the voters of Caldwell
will remember who those are that are concerned more with the
quantity of money in Caldwell than the quality of life.
RECOGNITION OF THE HANDICAPPED
Mayor Cowles recognized Tony Wieczorek, stating that he was a
gentleman who has done a great deal of work for the City of
Caldwell and for the Mayor's Committee for the Employment of
Handicapped and Older Workers.
Mr. Wieczorek stated that he was this year's Chairman of the
Mayor's Committee for the Employment of Handicapped and Older
Workers. The group was designed to assist the handicapped and
older workers in the City. During the last few months, the
Committee has recommended two individuals that deserve
special recognition as well as an employer who has made
special accomodations to serve the handicapped.
The following were introduced by Mr. Wieczorek and presented
an award of merit in recognition of their efforts by the
Mayor: Bill Zechman, parttime custodian at Paul's Market;
Lyman Olinger, parttime custodian at the Blaine Street
Book 30
Page 215
Albertsons; and Blaisdell Dental Center for providing
handicapped rooms and lifts for wheelchair patients.
(CONSENT CALENDAR)
The Mayor presented the Consent Calendar as follows:
Dispense with the reading of the minutes of the September
25th Regular City Council Meeting and approve them as
written; Accept the minutes of the Aviation Commission
Meeting of September 7, 1989, the Caldwell Senior Center
Citizen's Committee meeting of September 18, 1989, and the
Historic Preservation Commission minutes of September 7,
1989; Approve Catering Permits for The Corral to cater at the
Events Center on October 7, 13, 14, and 15 for the Valdez
Wedding, the Cruisin Classic Car Show, and the Snaffle Bit
Futurity.
MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Houchins to approve and accept
the Consent Calendar as presented by the Mayor.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Jarboe, Straight,
Raymond, Winder, and Houchins. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
OLD BUSINESS
(THIRD READING OF BILL NO. 25 - CONFLICTING INTEREST AND WORK
HOURS FOR MAYOR)
The Mayor asked the Council President to read Bill No. 25 by
title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND TITLE I, CHAPTER 4, OF THE
MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, COUNTY OF
CANYON, STATE OF IDAHO, PERTAINING TO MAYOR BY DELETING
AND ADDING LANGUAGE IN SECTION 3, REGARDING CONFLICTING
INTERESTS AND SECTION 4, REGARDING WORK HOURS:
REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, ORDERS OR PARTS
THEREOF IN CONFLICT HEREWITH.
MOVED by Winder, SECONDED by Raymond that Bill No. 25 be
passed and entitled Ordinance No. 1825.
Councilwoman Mallea was recognized and stated that this Bill
would change the hours of the Mayor to forty hours. These
hours are not designated as business hours, regular hours,
just designated forty hours. One of the problems with a City
is that the Board cannot fire the Administrator if they don't
like what he is doing. The Mayor is elected by the people
and subject to recall. Mrs. Mallea further said that she
spoke with the only announced candidate for this position and
he indicated that it was not a problem with him. She felt
that this Bill weakens any direct responsibility of a Mayor.
It was her request that the Council Members consider how this
Bill would effect their private business.
Councilman Winder stated that he favored the Bill as he
thought it would open up City Government rather than restrict
it. Very few candidates have considered running for Mayor
due to the fact that they could not afford to give up their
lifetime business. He would hope that there would be a
number of candidates so the people would have a choice. The
change to forty hours was an effort to define the Mayor as a
full time position. To be a successful candidate, they have
to be a responsible one.
Councilman Jarboe was recognized and informed Council that he
did not favor changing the rules of an election just a short
time before that election. He did. not believe this was quite
appropriate.
The Mayor then requested a roll call vote. Those voting yes:
Book 30
Page 216
Winder, Houchins, Straight, and Raymond. Those voting no:
Mallea and Jarboe. Absent and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(THIRD READING OF BILL NO. 32 - MT. VIEW SUBDIVISION REZONE)
The Council President read Bill No. 32 by title only as
follows:
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING THE ZONING OF CERTAIN PROPERTY
WITHIN THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, FROM R -3 MULTI-
FAMILY HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL TO C--3 SERVICE
COMMERCIAL; DETERMINING THAT SAID CHANGE IN ZONING IS IN
CONFORMANCE WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN; INSTRUCTING THE
CITY ENGINEER TO DESIGNATE SAID PROPERTY AS C -3 SERVICE
COMMERCIAL ON THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP; REPEALING ALL
LAWS, ORDINANCE AND RESOLUTIONS IN CONFLICT HEREWITH,
AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE..
The Mayor asked for action from the City Council reminding
them that it was third reading.
MOVED by Raymond that Bill No. 32 pass. Mayor Cowles
declared that the motion died due to a lack of a second.
Councilman Raymond was recognized and stated that he
personally notified Mr. Weygandt that tonight would be the
third reading of this Bill. Since the third reading was
delayed at the last meeting, he felt the people should know.
Mr. Raymond further said that once the Public Hearing process
has been completed and the Council has taken testimony, there
could be a legal question as to the status of additional
testimony.
The Administrative Assistant suggested that Council make a
negative motion so a vote could be taken.
The Mayor added that when a second is not made and the Chair
recognizes this, it does become a dead issue. Mrs. Brandt
stated that clarification could be requested from the City
Attorney. Mayor Cowles further stated that he would like for
the Council to take some action so the record would reflect
something other than a dead bill.
Councilman Winder said that from a procedural standpoint, if
a second was not received, you can't vote on it and you
cannot bring it back. Another motion cannot be made as it
must be made by someone on the prevailing side.
After further discussion, the Mayor stated that his action
was prompted by the inaction of the City Council. The fact
that the Council failed to second this motion indicated to
him that they did not want to pursue this Bill further.
NEW BUSINESS
(APPEARANCE OF WILLIAM J. BRAUNER REGARDING NOISE)
Mayor Cowles noted that Mr. Brauner was not present at this
time. The Administrative Assistant stated that Mr. Brauner
regeusted to be on the Agenda for this meeting. However, Ms. _.
Brandt said that she informed him that the Bill on noise
would be on the Agenda for October 16th. Mr. Brauner may
have determined that it was not necessary to attend tonight's
meeting, but would be here for the meeting on the 16th.
The Council President commented that there was people in the
audience at this time who might want to speak to the Council
on this issue. The following were recognized: Art Honey,
1115 North 5th, who suggested that when the Bill is
considered that they include "any noise uncommon to a
neighborhood "; Camilo Lopez, 1721 Roosevelt; Ruth Miller,
Chairman of the Committee from the Mobile Estate Park. Mrs.
Book 30
Page 217
Miller stated that she carried the petition pertaining to
this noise problem and wondered if the Council had received
the petition.
The Mayor informed her that the petition was received and
would be included as part of the record as Exhibit A.
The City Council discussed and asked questions with regard to
the noise problem submitted by the group from the mobile
park. Councilwoman Mallea suggested that the two groups meet
and try to work out their differences.
The Administrative Assistant explained the methods
anticipated to establish the levels of noise and informed
Council that a demonstration was planned with a noise meter
for their information. She also stated that an officer would
have to be trained, but no additional personnel would be
necessary.
(RESOLUTION - AGREEMENT WITH RIPLEY DOORN AND CO. FOR THE AUDIT)
The following Resolution was read by Councilman Raymond:
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE AN
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CALDWELL AND RIPLEY, DOORN
AND CO. TO PERFORM THE MUNICIPAL AUDIT FOR THE YEAR
1988 -89.
BE IT, RESOLVED That the Mayor of the City of
Caldwell be, and the same hereby is, authorized to
execute that certain Agreement attached hereto and made
a part hereof as if set forth in full by and between the
City of Caldwell and the Certified Public Accountant
Firm of Ripley, Doorn & Co.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Winder that the Resolution be
passed authorizing the execution of the Agreement with
Ripley, Doorn and Co. to perform the Municipal Audit for the
year 1988 -89.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, Winder,
Houchins, Jarboe, and Straight. Those voting no: none.
Abstain: Mallea. Absent and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(ACCEPTANCE OF BIDS FOR R.V. DUMP STATION)
The City Engineer, Mr. Redmond, stated that the R.V. Dump
Station was rebid since only one bid was received. Two bids
were received this time with the low bid being $9,425.00
submitted by T & S Construction in Nampa. It was his
recommendation that the Council accept this low bid.
MOVED by Houchins, SECONDED by Raymond that the low bid
submitted by T & S Construction in the amount of $9,425 be
accepted.
MOTION CARRIED
(SHORT PLAT - FILLMORE SQUARE)
The following information was submitted by the Engineering
Department referring to this item:
The subject plat, which is being considered as a short plat,
is a 4 -lot townhouse subdivision located on Fillmore Street
between 7th and Kimball Avenues across from M and W Market.
It is a replat of Lots 5, 6 and 7„ Block A of Memorial Park
Addition. The plat contains approximately 9,000 sq. ft. or
.2 acres. A special use permit was approved by the Planning
and Zoning Commission. in December of 1988 for the 4 units in
the R -2 zone and for the common party wall development.
Variances were approved for the front and rear setbacks.
Book 30
Lot Dimensions
Page 216
Since this is a townhouse subdivision with common party
walls, the lot sizes are substandard. Variances are required
for the lot sizes, frontage, and side setbacks between units.
Street
Frontage to the subdivision will be on Fillmore, but all of
the residences will face the existing 15 -foot alley. The
present subdivision ordinance calls for a 20 -foot alley. A
variance is also being requested for the substandard 15 -foot
alley. A 5 -foot easement will be required along the 15 -foot
alley side for private utility lines and provision must be
made through dedication on the plat either of right of way or
easement to facilitate an adequate turning radius from the
15 -foot alley into the 20 -foot alley. The alleys adjacent to
the subdivision will be paved and sidewalk will be installed
along Fillmore Street. Drainage will be coordinated with the
Engineering Department.
Irrigation
The property is in the Municipal Irrigation District. Plans
are to sprinkle with city water.
Water
Water is available to serve all units. Each unit will have a
separate meter. The water main extension policy will not
apply as there has been a service for 712 Fillmore.
Sewer
There is a 10 -inch sewerline in the center of the 20 -foot
alley along the southwesterly side of the property.
Protective covenants and homeowners' association documents
are required setting forth any common areas and maintenance
of any common areas and utility lines.
Recommendation from the Planning and zoning Commission is to
approve the plat with a variance for the 15 -foot alley
provided a 5 -foot easement and adequate easement for turning
are designated on the plat. Improvements required are paving
of alleys adjacent to the plat and sidewalk along Fillmore.
Mr. Redmond also recommended that the approval be given
subject to a turning radius being identified on the Plat.
MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Raymond that the Council accept
the recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission to
approve this plat with the variances, easements, and turning
improvement and all improvements required by the City
Engineer.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION APPOINTING JUDGES AND CLERKS FOR THE ELECTION)
Councilman Winder read the Resolution in full as follows:
A RESOLUTION APPOINTING JUDGES AND CLERKS IN THE GENERAL
ELECTION OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL TO BE HELD ON NOVEMBER
7, 1989-
BE IT RESOLVED by the Mayor and City Council of
the City of Caldwell, Idaho:
Section 1. That the following persons are
appointed to serve as Judges and Clerks for the nine
voting precincts of the City of Caldwell, Idaho, with
compensation being the minimum hourly wage.
Book 30 Page 213
FOR THE FOURTH PRECINCT: Carole L. Munn, Judge; Audrey
R. Birnbaum and Bessie Cole, Clerks.
FOR THE FIFTH PRECINCT: Barbara J. Rankin, Judge;
Harriet C. Berenter and Bernice G. Brooks, Clerks.
FOR THE SIXTH PRECINCT: Dona Ison, Judge; Fred S.
Freeman and Faye Long, Clerks.
FOR THE SEVENTH PRECINCT: Lena S. Tyson, Judge; Irma A.
Brunmeier and Lois L. Hall, Clerks.
FOR THE EIGHTH PRECINCT: Irma M. Cox, Judge; Joyce A.
Nancolas and Judith C. Priest, Clerks.
FOR THE NINTH PRECINCT: Phyllis Jewett, Judge; Margaret
A. Hopkins and Shannon R. Robertson, Clerks.
FOR THE TENTH PRECINCT: Beverly J. Larsen, Judge; W.
Gene Doolittle and D. Colleen Malison, Clerks.
FOR THE TWELFTH PRECINCT: Nathelle B. Oates, Judge;
Virginia Devlin and Nancy G. Ostler, Clerks.
FOR THE FIFTEENTH PRECINCT: Betty L. Kessler, Judge;
Myrtle Johnston and Charlotte. M. Sandifer, Clerks.
Section 2. That in the event any of the herein
designated persons should become ill or otherwise unable
to serve in their capacity as either Judge or Clerk at
said election, the Mayor is hereby authorized to
designate persons to succeed either as Judge or Clerk,
as the case may be, provided said persons meet the
qualifications required by law to serve in such capacity
at the General Election of the City of Caldwell.
MOVED by Winder, SECONDED by Houchins that the Resolution be
passed as presented.
Roll Call vote. Those voting yes: Winder, Houchins, Mallea,
Jarboe, Straight, and Raymond. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(AMEND THE CODE REGARDING SIDEWALKS)
The Administrative Assistant was recognized and asked to
address this item on the Agenda. Ms. Brandt explained that
this Bill addresses two different areas concerning sidewalks
- sidewalk replacement and snow removal. Sidewalk
Replacement - in the past, the code implied that a sidewalk
need not be replaced unless the property owner was directed
to do so by the City. This has caused many problems as
evidenced by the condition of our sidewalks in town. One of
the most serious is an observation by our insurance company
who feels that as long as the Code remains with that working,
the City could be held solely liable for injuries occurring
from faulty sidewalks. The changes will give the property
owner the responsibility to recognize hazardous conditions
and repair such, while still allowing the City the right
order repairs.
Snow Removal - In 1978, for some reason, the snow removal
ordinance was repealed. Thus, the City had no mechanism to
require sidewalks be clear of snow in a timely manner. This
addition will allow us to do that, protecting us from
liabilty if it is not done. This change, in part, answers
the concerns voiced by Mr. Renstrom last May.
It was MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Mallea that this be
considered the first reading of Bill No. 34.
Book 30
Page 220
Councilman Raymond read the Bill by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND TITLE VIII, CHAPTER 1, OF THE
MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, COUNTY OF
CANYON, STATE OF IDAHO, PERTAINING TO SIDEWALKS BY
DELETING AND ADDING LANGUAGE IN SECTION 1, REGARDING
MAINTENANCE RESPONSIBILITY; SECTION 2 REGARDING COUNCIL
DIRECTED REPAIRS; AND WEED REMOVAL REPEALING ALL
ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, ORDERS OR PARTS THEREOF IN
CONFLICT HEREWITH,
The Administrative Assistant commented that some concerns
were expressed during the Pre - Council Meeting. She was sure
that Staff would like some direction at this time.
Councilwoman Mallea stated that she would like for Staff to
research the possibility of adding that when the snow is
removed that it not be placed in front of a neighbor's
driveway or pedestrian crossings.
Councilman Winder also commented that any kind of debris
should be covered by the same Ordinance.
(AUTHORIZATION TO BID SEWERLINE - OLD JEFFERSON)
The following memo from the Engineering Department was
distributed to the Members of the City Council:
Recently we tried to televise the sewer line running
under the Old Jefferson Jr. High School building, but we
couldn't get the T.V. camera through the line. About
halfway under the building, the sewer line is broken and
crumbling.
This section of sewer line serves an 8 -block area from
12th to 20th Avenue. If it were to collapse suddenly,
the houses in this area would be without sewer until it
could be repaired. Also, the City could be responsible
for damage claims from flooded basements if the sewer
were to collapse and back up.
In order to avoid the situation described above, we are
proposing to reroute the sewer around the old JJHS
building and put it out for bid by competitive bidding
process. This should save a considerable amount of
money as opposed - to having - to reroute the sewer under
emergency situations.
MOVED by Winder, SECONDED by Straight to approve the
authorization to bid the sewer reroute around the old
Jefferson Junior High School building.
MOTION CARRIED
(HOUSING REHAB POLICY)
The Administrative Assistant explained that the City has been
approached by a realtor in Caldwell to consider a HUD
approved building incentive plan to encourage new residential
development. In reviewing the plan, it was Staff's feeling
that Caldwell could benefit more from an incentive plan to
encourage renovation or reconstruction of older housing stock
rather than new construction. With that in mind the
following proposal was given to the Council Members:
One of the main concerns of a community is the decay of the
older residential areas of town. Many times, because of
depressed property values, ongoing maintenance and upkeep are
deferred. This deferral adds to property devaluation and
augments to the deterioration of the neighborhood. In order
to attempt to turn this trend around, the City could offer an
incentive for house rehabilitation, or removal and
reconstruction.
Book 30 Page 221
The types of incentives could be:
1. Cost sharing in sidewalk replacement.
2. Reduction or waiver of building permit fees.
The amount of the incentive could be variable with a maximum
value of $750 per house ($600 towards sidewalk; $150 for
building permit waivers).
The criteria for eligibility:
1. Remodels: A committee consisting of the Building
Inspector, Planning Director and member at large would review
proposed plans and determine incentives given. The committee
could adopt criteria to standardize incentive award.
2. No restrictions on a demolition, removal and
reconstruction of a new residence.
3. Incentive to be based upon 50 of proposed improvement
costs (new construction /remodel) up to the maximum of $750.
4. Houses must be in excess of twenty years old and in the
central /older part of Caldwell.
5. Eligible improvement costs shall be for items of long
term structure improvement (painting, landscaping, etc., not
eligible). Exterior siding and other substantial
improvements to the exterior should be included.
This proposal was discussed at some length with the City
Engineer giving a more detailed explanation. It was agreed
that Staff would prepare a policy for Council approval. Staff
would also request input from builders in town, work on a
sidewalk policy, and check with the Building Inspector as to
fiscal impact on the General Fund.
(CONSIDERATION OF BILL NO. 35 PERTAINING TO DOOR TO DOOR SALES)
The Administrative Assistant explained that for several years
the City has had interpretive problems concerning what
constitutes "door to door" sales and who should obtain a
license from the City versus who should not. This is because
the Code is vague and outdated. We, therefore, obtained
numerous samples of other City Codes in this area and have
come up with a more clear version of what we would like to
see concerning this area. Bill No. 35 basically clarifies
who should get a license and provides for a better system to
check applicants. It does not change the fee system.
The Bill was read by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE TO REPEAL CHAPTER 4, TITLE IV, SECTIONS 1
THROUGH 11, OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE CITY OF
CALDWELL, STATE OF IDAHO, PERTAINING TO DOOR -TO -DOOR
SALESMEN, AND ADDING A NEW CHAPTER 4, TITLE IV, SECTIONS
1 THROUGH 11 REGARDING DOOR -TO -DOOR SALESMAN: REPEALING
ALL ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, ORDERS OR PARTS THEREOF IN
CONFLICT HEREWITH.
Councilman Raymond questioned the reasoning for Section A)
under 4 -4 -3 which states as an exception, "Any sales under
court order." Staff stated that this would be clarified by
the next reading.
MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Raymond that this be considered
the first reading of Bill No. 35.
MOTION CARRIED
(REQUEST FOR AUTHORIZATION FOR INCREASE OF SEPTIC DUMPING RATES)
The following Resolution was read in full by Councilman
Jarboe:
WHEREAS, on or about July 19,. 1983, the City Council of
the City of Caldwell, enacted Ordinance No. 1644 which
said Ordinance requires the City Council to establish
Book 30
Sewer Service User Rates by Resolution; and,
Page 222
WHEREAS, said Ordinance has been in effect since July
19, 1983; and,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, That the City establish
fees as follows:
$18.00 per 1,000 gallons (.0J,3 /gal.) based on full load
capacity of vehicle. Maximum capacity of tank 3,000
gallons.
$3.00 for recreational vehicle dumping.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED That this Resolution shall take
effect and be in full force upon its passage and
approval.
MOVED by Jarboe, SECONDED by Houchins that the Resolution
authorizing this increase in costs be passed.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Jarboe, Straight,
Raymond, Winder, Houchins, and Mallea. Those voting no:
none. Absent and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(REQUEST FOR AN EXECUTIVE SESSION)
Pursuant to Idaho State Code, Section 67 -2343, it was MOVED
by Raymond, SECONDED by Straight that the City Council
convene into an Executive Session immediately following the
adjournment of the Regular City Council Meeting for the
purpose of discussing personnel.
Roll call vote: Those voting yes: Raymond, Winder,
Houchins, Mallea, Jarboe, and Straight. Those voting no:
none. Absent and not voting: none. A
y
MOTION CARRIED
(COMMITTEE REPORTS)
Councilman Winder reported that he attended the Ida -Ore
Meeting in Boise last month.
Councilwoman Mallea gave a report on the Legislative Caucus
for the Association of Idaho Cities which included public
records, the possibility of establishing four election dates,
the change of procedures for liquor licenses, competetive bid
contracts, and the energy code and Uniform Building Codes.
There being no further business, the Regular City Council
Meeting was adjourned at 8:45 p.m. and the City Council
convened into an Executive Session which was adjourned at
9:15 p.m.
APPROVED AS wri THIS 16 t h DAY OF October 1 1989.
. 2
M
C ncil er C uo nczlperson
Court ilpe Councilperson
�,-Ccuftdilpgrson Councilperson
ATTEST'
City Clerk-C7�