HomeMy WebLinkAbout1984-09-11city council minutesBook 25
REGULAR MEETING
September 11, 1984
12:00 Noon
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor McCluskey.
Page 197
The Mayor requested that everyone stand and give the Pledge of
Allegiance to the Flag.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following
members present: Mallea, Marcus, Cowles, Raymond, Norman, and
Carter. Absent: none.
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
The Mayor asked if there was anyone in the audience who cared to
bring anything before the City Council that was not on the
prepared Agenda. Since there was no one, the Mayor declared that
the meeting would continue as outlined on the Agenda.
OLD BUSINESS
(DECISION ON THE CORNER BAR)
The Mayor stated that the first order of business under Old
Business was the decision on the Corner Bar. The City Council at
their Regular Meeting on August 28, 1984, conducted a hearing
with regard to this matter and the motion made was to submit a
written decision to be rendered at this time stating the Findings
of Fact and Conclusions of Law. The Mayor then requested
permission from the City Council to read the following letter
addressed to Richard Rosenberry, Attorney at Law, and Aurora
Sanchez, the Licensee of the Corner Bar:
The following are the Findings of Fact which the City
Council finds on the basis of testimony provided at the
hearing regarding the revocation for the Corner Bar to sell
beer on August 14, 1984.
1. That Aurora Sanchez is the holder of License No. 404 to
sell beer at the Corner Bar which is located at 224 Paynter
Street, Caldwell, Idaho 83605.
2. That a license to sell beer is required in the City of
Caldwell, Idaho, under Title I'V, Chapter 7, Section 3 of the
Caldwell City Code and Idaho Code, Title 23, Chapter 10.
3. That the Corner Bar is regularly frequented by
intoxiated persons.
4. That the Corner Bar is regularly frequented by
disorderly persons.
5. That Aurora Sanchez, the Licensee, has not been
operating the Corner Bar.
6. That Herman Sanchez, the Licensee's husband, has been
operating the Corner Bar.
7. That Herman Sanchez is not a citizen of the United
States and is therefore, ineligible to be a licensee under
Caldwell City Code, Section 4-7-5 (a) (1).
8. That Aurora Sanchez is the licensee of the Corner Bar
because her husband is ineligible to hold said license.
9. That live music, via band, has been performed every
night that the Corner Bar has been opened in 1984.
10. That adequate security of the interior of the premises
of the Corner Bar has not been provided in 1984, except on
the two weekends in August when uniformed security guards
were on site.
11. That adequate security of the exterior of the premises
of the Corner Bar has not been provided in 1984, except on
the two weekends in August when uniformed security guards
were on site.
12. That the Licensee in 1981 stipulated that she would
provide adequate security guard or guards for the interior
of the establishment now known as the Corner Bar.
Book 25 Page 198
13. That the Licensee in 1.981 stipulated that she would
provide a vision window at such height that a Patrol Officer
could adequately inspect the interior of the building at the
establishment now 'known as the Corner Bar.
14. That the Licensee has not provided a vision window in
the wall of the Corner Bar as she promised to do in 1981.
15. That the Licensee has not provided adequate security
guard or guards as she promised to do in 1981.
15. That due to the nature of the marital relationship
between Aurora and Herman Sanchez, they own the Corner Bar
in a partnership relationship.
17. That Caldwell City Code., Section 4-7 -5 (a) (1) requires
all partners in a partnership to qualify under the
citizenship prerequisites.
18. That under Caldwell City Code, Section 4 -7 -5 (b), -
Aurora Sanchez no longer qualifies for a license because she
has a partner, Herman Sanchez, who is not a citizen of the
United States.
19. Herman Sanchez, due to the nature of his marital
relationship with Aurora, had (prior to this time) an
undisclosed financial interest in the Corner Bar prohibited
under Caldwell City Code, Section 4 -7 -11 (B) and (D).
20. Aurora Sanchez has failed, neglected, or refused to
report the changes regarding undisclosed financial interest
or undisclosed partnership interest as required under
Caldwell City Code 4 -7 -12.
Based upon the above conclusions, the City Council holds:
1. That the License of the Corner Bar shall be suspended
for two weeks starting the first weekend after the date of
this notice or longer if the following prerequisites to
reopen have not been complied with.
2. That the Licensee, Aurora Sanchez, shall provide a
statement in writing to the City of Caldwell stating that
she will agree to the following conditions to reopening the
Corner Bar:
a. One uniform security guard shall be hired to
provide security for both inside and outside of the Corner
Bar. The security guard shall wear a uniform which shall
identify his position. The security guard shall be present
every night that the Corner Bar is in operation from 10:00
p.m. to 2:00 a.m. The name of the security guard shall be
provided to the Chief of Police prior to that individual
being hired by the Corner.Bar to provide security.
b. A security observation window shall be provided in
the wall of the Corner Bar to provide Police Officers with
the ability to observe the activities within the Corner Bar
from the outside of the building. The dimensions and size
of the observation window shall be established by the Chief
of Police.
C. The Licensee shall agree to enforce reasonable
regulations to maintain peace within the establishment known
as the Corner Bar as well as on the leased premises
surrounding the Corner Bar specifically including the
parking lot.
d. Proof shall be provided by the Licensee, Aurora
Sanchez, establishing that Herman Sanchez no longer holds
any proprietary or ownership interest in the Corner Bar and
will, in the future, act only as an employee of Aurora
Sanchez.
e. Proof shall be provided that the Licensee, Aurora
Sanchez, shall own the Corner Bar as her separate property
and shall operate pursuant to City Code the business known
as the Corner Bar.
f. The document described in this paragraph above
shall be provided to the Chief of Police prior to reopening
the establishment known as the Corner. Bar after the license
suspension.
Book 25
Page 199
The Mayor then asked for any remarks from the City Council.
Councilman Raymond stated that he 'had a question with regard to
item No. 12 which reflected the interior of the establishment.
As he remembered, in their discussion with regarding to Findings
of Fact, most of the problems may have been generated inside but
were moved outside. Councilman Raymond further said that he
reviewed the document signed by Mrs. Sanchez in 1981 and it
refers to interior and the parking lot. He would, therefore,
suggest that the parking lot be included in No. 12. Councilman
Raymond also said that he had a question with regard to No. 14
where reference was made to a vision window in the wall. It was
his understanding that it should be in the door. After some
discussion, it was decided that this item should state that the
window site would be at the discretion of the Chief of Police.
The Mayor also pointed out that in the first paragraph of the
letter, he felt that it should state the Corner Bar beer license.
Council agreed with this change. The mayor further stated that
since corrections need to made prior to the City Council members
signing, he would request that a motion be made to accept the
Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law with the corrections as
requested. The City Clerk was then excused to make the
corrections as stipulated before the signatures on the document.
MOVES by Raymond, SECONDED by Norman to accept the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law in the document just read by the
Mayor with corrections as stated.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, Norman, Carter,
Mallea, Marcus, and Cowles. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(BILL NO. 11 - SECOND READING - CHILD CARE LICENSING)
The Mayor stated that since there had been so many revisions made
in the proposed Bill on Child Care Licensing, it was suggested
that this Bill be reverted back to the first reading. The mayor
then read Bill No. 11 by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND TTTFE !V OF T' MUNICTPAL CODE OF THE
CITY OF CALDWELL, COUNTY OF CANYON, STATE OF IDAHO, BY
ADDING THE FOLLOWING WHICH SHALL BE DESIGNATED AS CHAPTER 23
OF SAID TITLE IV REGARDING CHILD CARE FACILITIES: PROVIDING
DEFINITIONS; LICENSE REQUIRED; EXEMPTIONS AND SPECIAL
APPLICATIONS; INVESTIGATION OF FACILITIES; STANDARD FOR
ISSUANCE OF LICENSE; LICENSES; INSPECTION; PENALTIES:
REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, ORDER OR PARTS
THEREOF IN CONFLICT HEREWITH.
There was a great deal of discussion with regard to the changes
made in this Bill with the Mayor and Councilwoman Marcus making a
number of comments as to the particular changes and questions
regarding the Bill. It was then declared that this would be the
first reading of Bill No. 11.
NEW BUSINESS
(PUBLIC HEARING - REZONE LOTS IN BLOCKS 42 AND 48 OT - PAUL ZATICA)
The Mayor stated that the first order of business under New
Business was a public hearing on the rezone of lots in Blocks 42
and 48 OT - Paul Zatica. The paper was passed out for those who
wished to speak to this matter by the City Clerk and submitted to
the Mayor. The Mayor then declared the Public Hearing open and
requested that Mrs. Robison give a short explanation to this
request.
Mrs. Robison pointed out the area on a map for the benefit of the
City Council members. She explained that Mr. Zatica worked
extensively in the City to find property on which to construct a
grocery store. The site had to be large enough to accommodate
Book 25
Page Zoo
the size of the building he had in mind and the parking
requirements. He located a section between 9th and 10th and
Chicago and the alley between Denver and Elgin which he felt
would be appropriate. At least half of that property was already
zoned Commercial. Mr. Zatica was asking that the City complete
the Commercial zoning so he will have the area for the project
site. A public hearing was held by the Planning and Zoning
Commission and they felt that the use was generally compatible
with the Comprehensive Plan. It was the Commission's
recommendation that approval be given for the rezone.
Councilwoman Mallea questioned as to access for the householder
that will remain in residence in the area. Mrs. Robison said
that she would like Mr. Zatica explain this particular question.
Mr. Zatica stated that he met with Mrs. Baird and her attorney
and they informed him that they did not have any problem. She
did want them to provide curb off Ninth Street so she could have
parking there which Mr. Zatica agreed to.
The Mayor then called on Audie Terry, 601 Denver, who requested
by his signature to speak to this issue. Mr. Terry stated that
he was opposed to this request for vacating the street because of
the school children usacle of the street, the school buses use the
street, and there was a lot of traffic on Denver Street. As far
as the zoning, he was not particularly opposed to the zone change
except for the fact that we have to look out for the children.
You put a Commercial area there and there is going to be
problems. That was about all he had to say; he just wanted to
voice his opinion.
Tony Gabiola was then recognized and stated that he would not
comment at this time as he had no objections. He owned four lots
on Denver and was just curious.
The Mayor asked if there was any discussion from the City Council
at this time. Councilman Norman questioned Mr. Zatica as to
whether all of the property owners in the area had agreed to this
project. Mr. Zatica answered that he had options on all of the
properties, only two houses there are owner occupied.
Mrs. Robison stated that there was no testimony received at the
Commission Meeting and no correspondence with regard to the
rezone.
The Mayor then closed the Public Hearing.
(BILL NO. 19 - ORDINANCE NO. 1681 - REZONE OF PROPERTY)
The Mayor then read Sill No. 19 addressing the above rezone of
properties by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING THE ZONING 017 CERTAIN PROPERTY WITHIN THE
CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, FROM R -3T MULTI- FAMILY HIGH DENSITY
RESIDENTIAL TO C -2T COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL AND DETERMINING THAT
SAID CHANGE IN ZONING IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITY OF
CALDWELL, IDAHO; REPEALING ALL LAWS, ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS
IN CONFLICT HEREWITH.
MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Cowles to suspend the rule requiring
the reading of a bill at three separate times and that Bill No.
19 be read one time by title only.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Cowles,
Raymond, Norman, and Cartier. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Cowles that Bill No. 19 be passed
and entitled Ordinance No. 1681.
Book 25
Page 20.1
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Cowles,
Raymond, Norman, and Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(PUBLIC HEARING ON VACATION OF DENVER BETWEEN 9TH AND 10TH)
The Mayor questioned Mr. Terry as to whether he would like to
testify at this hearing as it was the same as the last hearing.
Mr. Terry did say he would like to make one comment.
The Mayor then opened the Public Hearing and recognized Mr. Audie
Terry. Mr. Terry stated that there was only one thing that was
kind of contradictory and that was the fact that there was no
buses that go down Denver Street on the North side. Buses go
down by my place at 6th and Denver every school morning and pick
up children there and down Chicago to pick them up as well.
As there was no one else from the audience who cared to speak,
the Mayor asked if the Council members cared to comment. Since
there was no comments, the Mayor closed the Public Hearing.
It was then MOVED by Norman, SECONDED by Cowles that an Ordinance
be prepared to vacate Denver between 9th and 10th as it was found
to be in the best interest of the City and a profitable program
for the City and for the particular area.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Norman, Mallea, Marcus,
Cowles, and Raymond. Those voting no: none. Abstain: Carter.
Absent and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION FOR AGREEMENT WITH LIGHT AFRO, INC.)
The Mayor read the following Resolution in full:
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE A LEASE
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CALDWELL AND LIGHT AERO, INC.
BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and City Clerk of the City of
Caldwell be, and the same hereby are, authorized to execute that
certain Lease Agreement attached hereto and made a part hereof as
if set in full by and between the City of Caldwell as Lessors and
Light Aero, Inc., as Lessee.
MOVED by Carter, SECONDED by Norman that the Resolution
authorizing the execution of the Lease Agreement with Light Aero,
Inc. be passed.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Carter, Mallea, Marcus,
Cowles, Raymond, and Norman. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(CATERING PERMIT)
The City Clerk presented one catering permit for City Council
approval. This was for The Corral to cater at the Barrel Race
Futurity at the Fair Building at the Simplot Complex on September
15th and 16th, 1984. The Police Chief submitted his approval and
the fee was paid.
MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Norman that approval be given for
the Catering Permit as presented.
MOTION CARRIED
(AUTHORIZATION TO PROCEED ON AERIAL PHOTOS)
Book 25
Page 202
The Mayor called on Mr. Redmond, the City Engineer, to address
this item.
Mr. Redmond informed the City Council that this was to be the
last phase of the aerial photography project. The pictures were
taken, the ground control and vertical control were almost done.
There was only approximately $43,000 left to work with on about a
$55,000 project. Therefore, he had been negotiating through
Aerial Mapping and J.U.B. Engineers. Aerial Mapping is the
company that did the two previous aerial surveys for the City.
If they could use some of the preliminary work from the two
previous jobs, which they indicate they can do, they will proceed
for the rest of the aerials with the funding left which would be
about a $7,000 saving. This was a good price and he would like
to have Council permission to proceed and approach it as
professional services.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Carter that the City Engineer be
authorized to proceed with the aerial photography project.
MOTION CARRIED
(COMMITTEE REPORTS)
Councilwoman Mallea reported that she attended the Library
Meeting along with Councilwoman Marcus. Their total budget in
the amount of $250,000 was complete. The use of the Library was
up and the new Sunday hours were .instituted.
Councilwoman Mallea also stated that she has talked with the City
Engineer with regard to the Mayor. appointing a review committee
for the bids that will come in September 28th at 11 :00 a.m.
concerning the City's involvement in Warren's Store commitment.
The reason for the review committee with the power to either
accept or reject these ;bids is so that it can come out of this
year's budget. The amount was allocated in this last year's
budget under Revenue Sharing for sidwalk construction.
MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Carter to authorize the Mayor to
appoint a review committee with the power to reject or accept the
bids concerning Warren shoe Store.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor then appointed Councilwoman Mallea, and Councilman
Norman to be the review committee. The bids will be opened on
September 28th at 11:00 a.m.
Councilman Carter stated that he attended an Airport Commission
Meeting last week. Most of the items discussed at the Meeting
were taken care of, but he would report that Hosac Engineering
has the grant application ready for signatures. This was for the
update of the Airport Master Plan„
Councilman Norman stated that both he and Councilman Carter met
with the Firemen on their contract, but have not heard back as to
whether they accepted the proposal or not. He also met with
Darrel Deide and should have their contract ready by the next
City Council Meeting.
Councilman Raymond said that he met with the Recreation
Commission the night before. They only meet every three months
now, but all was going well. There was some discussion when it
was reported by the Director that the pool revenue was down. -
Councilman Raymond further said that he did have one comment he
would like to make with regard to the Corner Bar. A gentleman
informed him that he was present: at the bar during one of the
incidents and according to him when several patrons in the bar
tried to interfere with two police officers, he informed them
that they should stay out of it. Councilman Raymond felt this
Book 25
Page 203
was worthy of note as it was a positive comment with regard to
the management. He would ask the Mayor to check on this
incident.
Councilman Cowles stated that he attended the Historical
Commission Meeting and the Council would get copies of the
minutes. He also reminded the City Council of the dedication
services for Symms Field on September 18th at 11:30 a.m.
Councilwoman Marcus reported that she attended the Stadium Board
Meeting. The stalls were just about finished, but they have
exceeded their original cost estimate. They are trying to sell
enough advertising space to help with the costs. Mr. Deide was
requesting a five percent increase in all rentals this year which
will be about a $600 increase for the College. A fence bill was
paid by Mr. Deide which will be turned back to the City. The old
basketball floor will be sold and the new one has been
refinished.
Councilwoman Marcus said that she would like a response from the
City Council on one item in the Child Care Ordinance. There was
a time limit with regard to those applying for a license having
previously had a license suspended or revoked. The Council stated
that the Police Chief should be asked as to how long Police
records are kept. The Mayor stated that he thought it was five
years, but they would check on it.
(MAYOR'S COMMENTS)
The Mayor informed the City Council that he received a memo
regarding purchase of land for a well site. Councilman Carter
stated that he did go to look at this piece of ground. His
question was whether there was other ground available in that
area. He would hope that the City would get the best buy they
could.
The City Engineer said that the land purchased should be in the
City limits. The Water Superintendent did investigate the
properties in that area. Some available land out there has some
problems with septic fields being too close. This particular
site under Oiscussion appears to be clear of problems. The only
other option would be to go across the street into Sylvan Manor.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Mallea that a decision be made on
this offered well site at the next meeting.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor informed the City Council that he was getting
complaints with regard to the political signs on the right of
way. After discussion with the Council, it was determined that
the Mayor would write to the Chairman of the Political parties
stating to them the restrictions for placing signs.
There being no further business, the Meeting was adjourned at
1:10 P.M.
APPROVED AS written THIS
1989.
4C o"
C
- uncf p rso
f
��
ATTEST:
September
l8th DAY OF