HomeMy WebLinkAbout1986-08-18city council minutesBook 27
REGULAR MEETING
August 18, 1986
7:30 p.m.
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor Cowles.
Page 147
The Mayor requested that everyone stand for the Pledge of
Allegiance to the Flag.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following
members present: Raymond, J. Carter, L. Carter, Marcus, and
Marmon. Absent: Mallea.
(.APPROVAL OF MINUTES)
MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by L. Carter to dispense with the
reading of the minutes of the Regular City Council Meeting of
August 4, 1986, and approve them as written.
MOTION CARRIED
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
The Mayor asked if there was anyone from the audience who cared
to address the City Council at this time. As there was no one,
the Mayor declared that the meeting would continue as outlined.
OLD BUSINESS
(RECOMMENDATIONS FROM ENGINEERING ON STREET VACATIONS)
Mayor Cowles recognized the City Engineer, Ron Redmond, who
presented the following written recommendation that was submitted
to the City Council members:
The recommendations of the Engineering Department with regard to
how this area of the City should be developed are as follows:
The basic conceptual layout of maple, Idaho and the western
cul -de -sac for Walnut Street as presented at the public
hearing on August 4th was our recommended street layout.
The only change that would be appropriate would be the
requirement that prior to impovement of Walnut between Idaho
and Washington (30 -foot half right of way), at least 10 to
12 feet in additional right of way be obtained so that a
full -sized street could be constructed.
I attempt to state my reasons for these recommendations.
Initially, it should be noted that we attempted to persuade Mr.
Sweaney to submit a complete plan for the area. This he chose
not to do.
In evaluating a development, we attempt to review from a basis of
what is reasonable. There are minimum standards that must be
upheld; therefore, the layout of the property is critical in
attempting to minimize development costs. Generally speaking,
the higher the development costs, the more units must be
constructed in order to make that development financially
feasible. (In some areas this may be impossible.)
By eliminating Oregon along the Dixie Drain, a tier of potential'
double - fronted lots is eliminated. (This tier is currently
between Robert and Oregon now, and would fall between Oregon and
Idaho if Oregon were relocated.) By eliminating Oregon and
introducing cul -de -sacs at Maple and Walnut, we have eliminated
the improvement costs for Oregon, eliminated double - fronted lots
and retained adequate access to all future parcels.
Book 27
Page 148
The purpose of stopping the Maple cul -de -sac substantially short
of the Dixie Drain is to eliminate the proximity hazard of the
ditch at the end of a road, plus leave sufficient area that the
owners would keep it landscaped and maintained. The location can
be adjusted so that proper access ca.n be provided the back part
of the Sheppard property and prohibit the construction of
dwelling units close to the Sheppards by the 55 -foot Dixie Drain
setback and the 20 -foot front setback.
This approach on these streets gives the lowest development costs
and makes single family development in the area more feasible.
Walnut Street between Idaho and Washington has 30 feet of
existing right of way. Thirty feet of street was and is commonly
given for a half street right of way. Thirty feet is not
sufficient to construct an adequate residential street.
Minimum street requirements are:
2 paved lanes at 11 feet each 22 ft.
Side parking at 7 feet each 14 ft.
Travel way 36 ft.
Sidewalks at 4 ft, each 8
Utility area at 6 ft. each 12
6.
In the case of Walnut, this could be reduced to a 32 -ft. travel
way and two 4 -foot allowances for sidewalk and two 6 -inch
thicknesses for curb for a total of 41 feet.
The reasons for not improving a street unless it can be improved
to a curb and gutter situation are several. Maintenance is a
prime reason. On a curbless street the shoulders have to be
graded. The edge of asphalt not being protected by concrete
continuously breaks off and must be repaired. The additional
runoff generated by the paved condition has no facility other
than a bladed ditch to drain.
A narrow street with prohibited parking requires signing, curb
marking and police monitoring in order to be effective. We have
difficulty in maintaining our current restricted area.
In an area that wants to maintain high standards for its
residential development, it is inappropriate to shortchange the
streets.
Mr. Redmond demonstrated the recommendations on a _Photo of the
area for the benefit of the Council and audience.
The Planning Director informed the City Council that another
Public Hearing would have to be scheduled for the vacation.
After further discussion, it was MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by J.
Carter to Proceed with the vacation of that area under the new
alignment and another hearing be scheduled.
As to the time frame with regard to this decision from the
Council, Mrs. Robison stated that she would have to consult with
Mr. Sweaney, the developer, to see what direction he wants to
take. Mr. Sweaney did anticipate platting the lots adjacent to
Idaho and he may not wish to proceed with the vacation of the
streets. Councilman L. Carter said that he would prefer delaying
until Mr. Sweaney °s plans were known. Councilman Raymond pointed
out that the platting was not the issue; the vacation of streets
was the issue.
The Mayor requested a roll call vote on the motion as stated.
Those voting yes: Raymond, J. Carter. Those voting no: L.
Carter, Marcus. Abstain: Marmon. The Mayor then voted yes
breaking the tie.
Book 27
MOTION CARRIED
NEW BUSINESS
Page 149
(PUBLIC HEARING - REZONE PROPERTY AT 2024 BLAINE - JIM THOMAS)
Mayor Cowles stated that the first item under New Business was a
Public hearing on the rezone of property at 2024 Blaine. He then
requested that Councilwoman Marcus read the rules for signing up
to submit testimony at a public hearing. The Mayor then asked
the Council to set a time limit for each sneaker.
It was then MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by J. Carter that a time
limit of three minutes be established.
MOTION CARRIED
Mayor Cowles opened the public hearing and recognized Mrs.
Robison who presented the Findings of Fact for the rezone request
at 2024 Blaine Street as follows:
1. Jim Thomas had filed an application requesting a zone change
under Section 6- 4- 3(A)2, Caldwell Code.
2. Mr. Thomas is the valid option holder of property described
as the southeasterly 50 fet of Lot 2, Block 15, Washington
Heights, Steunenberg and Hands Addition to Caldwell, Idaho, also
known as 2024 Blaine Street.
3. The application filed is for an amendment to the Official
Zoning Map by expanding the boundaries of the C -2 Community
Commercial zone to include the property, which is presently zoned
R -2 medium density residential.
4. The existing land use is residential. Proposed use of the
property is for a professional /insurance office.
5. The property is adjacent to the C -2 commercial zone on two
sides.
6. Properties northerly on 21st and Blaine were rezoned in the
past few years for office /retail and barber shop uses.
7. Twenty -first Avenue is a main artery to and from the freeway
to Cleveland and Blaine and accommodates an average of
approximately 5,000 cars per day.
3. Land uses in the vicinity include victor's and the bowling
alley, other commercial uses to the northeast, and residential
uses on the south and west:.
9. The property is shown as medium density residential on the
Plan. Land use is commercial easterly of 21st Avenue,
10. The zone change is being considered under the flexibility of
zoning boundaries to reflect gradual changes in use where zoning
districts adjoin.
11. A public gearing was held July 1.1, 1986, by the Planning and
Zoning Commission, The hearing was duly advertised in accordance
with 6 -4 -3B, Caldwell Code.
12. No oral or written testimony was received at the public
hearing.
CONCLUSION OF LAW
1. Application and proceedings for this request were carried out
as provided in 6-4 -3, Caldwell Code, for amendments to zoning
district boudaries.
2. The request is not in conflict with the intent of the
Comprehensive Plan.
3. The zone change requested is consistent with other land uses
in the area.
RECOMMENDATION
The Planning and Zoning Commission recommends approval of the
described property to be rezoned from R -2 medium density
residential. to C -2 community commercial.
Book 27
Page 150
The Mayor recognized Mr. Jim Thomas, who was the only one signed
to give testimony. Mr. Thomas was the one requesting the
rezoning and gave his reasons for the request, The "ape of the
Public Hearing proceedings is on file in the Office of the City
Clerk for reference.
After a short discussion, the Mayor closed the Public Hearing and
requested that Councilman Marmon read Bill No. 14 for this rezone
by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING THE ZONING OF CERTAIN PROPERTY WITHIN "HE,
CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, FROM R-2 MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL TO
C-2 COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL; DETERMINING THAT SAID CHANGE IN ZONING
IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO;
INSTRUCTING THE CITY ENGINEER TO DESIGNATE SAID PROPERTY AS C-2
COMMERCIAL ON THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP; AND REPEALING ALL LAWS,
ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS IN CONFLICT HEREWITH.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by L. Carter to suspend the rule
requiring the reading of a Bill at three separate times and that
the Bill No. 14 be read by title only for the one reading.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, J. Carter, L. Carter,
Marcus, and Marmon. Those voting no: none. Absent and not
voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Marmon that Bill No. 14 be passed
and entitled Ordinance No. 1729.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, J. Carter, L.
Carter, Marcus, and Marmon. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION AND BILL NO. 15 FOR VACATION OF BELMONT)
Mayor Cowles requested that Councilman Raymond read the
Resolution of adoption of vacation ordinance as follows:
RESOLUTION STATING FINDINGS OF FACT AND RECITING INTENT FOR
PASSAGE, -APPROVAL AND PUBLICATION OF BILL NO. 15.
WHEREAS, the City of Caldwell has received a petition for
vacation of Belmont Street between 11th and 12th Avenues and 12th
and 13th Avenues; and,
WHEREAS, the City has held a public hearing for public input
on said vacation request; and,
WHEREAS, the City Council does hereby make the following
findings of fact:
1. The consent of the adjoining property owners and valid
option holders has been obtained in writing as of June 9, 1936.
2. Notification has been given for public input and a
public hearing was held on August 4, 1986, at which time
testimoney was received.
3. Alternate routes of travel have been identified and are
available.
4. Testimony and information presented indicate that the
community needs for the expansion of Canyon County Courthouse
facilities more than offset the value of the property being
vacated.
5. maintaining current utility facilities and easements can
be made with minimal effect on same by execution of easements to
avoid any structures being built over them; and,
WHERE, this vacation is premised upon the future expansion
of Canyon County Courthouse facilities, the following conditions
shall occur prior to the vacation ordinance becoming effective:
1. Proper easements for utility relocations or for
preservation where necessary.
Book 27
Page 151
WHEREAS, the City Council does hereby conclude that the
vacation of Belmont Street as described above is in the best
interest of the City of Caldwell:
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Mayor and Council of
the City of Caldwell, Idaho, that Bill No. 15 be passed, approved
and published.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by L. Carter that Resolution no, 24 -85
be passed.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, J. Carter, L.
Carter, Marcus, and Marmon. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
Councilman J. Carter read Bill No. 15 by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE RECITING PETITION FOR VACATION AND RECITING
APPROPRIATE NOTICE THEREFOR WAS GIVEN, DETERMING THAT VACATION OF
THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED REAL PROPERTY SHALL BE MADE
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Marmon to suspend the rule
requiring a that a Bill be read at three separate times and that
Bill No. 15 be read by title only for the one reading.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, J. Carter, L.
Carter, Marcus, and Marmon. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Marmon that Rill No. 15 be passed and
entitled Ordinance No. 1730.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, J. Carter, L. Carter,
Marcus, and Marmon. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting:
Mallea.
MOTI0N CARRIED
(RESOLUTION FOR ELECTRICAL CONTRACTOR'S AGREEMENT)
The City Engineer explained that this was a proposed Contract
with Allen Emery of A.M.E Electric to do a limited portion of the
City's electrical work. The purpose is that the 'Treatment Plant
and the water well houses have a certain amount of master control
work that the Department would like to have only one person work
on. Allen Emery worked for the Contractor that installed the
electrical work at the Treatment Plant when it was originally put
in. He has also been worI4 :ing with the Water Department with the
change over to - the master computer control network for Water
System. It was, therefore, the Engineer's recommendation that
the City enter into a Contract with Allen Emery so he would be
doing the work relative to the controls into the pump for the
Sewer Plant as well as the Water Department.
The Resolution for this Agreement was ready by Councilman Raymond
as follows:
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE AN
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CALDWELL AND ALLEN EMERY.
BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and City Clerk of the
City of Caldwell be, and the same hereby are authorized to
execute that certain Agreement attached hereto and made a part
hereof as if set forth in full by and between the City of
Caldwell and Allen Emery.
MOVED by L. Carter, SECONDED by Marmon that the Resolution be
passed authorizing the execution of the Agreement with Allen
Emery.
Book 27 Page 152
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: L. Carter, Marcus, Marmon,
Raymond, and J. Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and not
voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION - LEASE WITH WARHAWK AVIATION)
Councilman Marmon read the Resolution for this Agreement as
follows:
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK 'TO EXECUTE A
HANGAR AND GROUND LEASE AGREEMENT E3ETWEEN THE CITY OF CALDt^aELL
AND JOHN PAUL DBA WARHAWK AVIATION.
BE IT RESOLVED That
City of Caldwell be, and the
execute that certain Lease Agra
part hereof as if set forth in
Caldwell as Lessor and John
Lessee.
the Mayor and City Clerk of the
same hereby are authorized to
cement: attached hereto and made a
full by and between the City of
Paul, dba Warhawk Aviation as
MOVED by Marmon, SECONDED by Raymond that the Resolution be
passed authorizing the execution of the agreement with Warhawk
Aviation.
Councilman Marmon discussed briefly the changes that were made
with regard to this Agreement. These changes were negotiated
when talking with Mr. Paul and have been agreed to.
The Mayor asked for a roll call vote on the passage of the
Resolution. Those voting yes: Marmon, Raymond, and L. Carter.
Those voting no: Marcus. Abstain: J. Carter.
MOTION' CARRIED
(SECURITY TRAILER AT GEM POOL CARE - 2813 EAST CLEVELAND BOULEVARD)
Mrs. Robison informed the Council that a request was received
from Brad Vezzoso of Gem Pool Care to install a security trailer
at the propery 2813 East Cleveland Boulevard. There was an
Ordinance that allows these trailers in Commercial and Industrial
Zones subject to an annual fee. Mr. Vezzoso indicated that the
main reason for the trailer would be to secure the large and
expensive inventory that is stored in the back especially in the
summer months. Tom Wheeler, the Building Official, inspected
the site and submitted the following report:
I have inspected the site and found water and electrical services
available. The building is now using a septic tank for sewage
disposal so an approval from Southwest District Health would be
required before adding a security trailer. If the sewer problem,
can be resolved, it would be physically possible to locate a
security trailer at this location, but I question the need since
the property is visable from Cleveland Blvd. It is possible to
see behind the building while driving, down Cleveland Blvd. Since
the purpose of a security trailer is to protect properties with
potential or previous security problems, there should be an
identifiable problem before granting the permit.
Mr. Vezzoso also spoke to the City Council explaining his need
for the security trailer. There was not an immediate problem at
this time. Someone would be staying in the trailer part of the
year. During the winter months, they were only open one or two
days a week which left the business vacant. The trailer would be
located within the fenced in property at the back of the existing
building.
After discussion, the Mayor stated that he could understand the
comments from Mr. Wheeler, but his suggestion was that approval
be given for the trailer for a year and then the City would check
Book 27
Rage 153
with Mr. Vezzoso to determine if the trailer was helpful. having
the trailer there would do no harm and would certainly assist the
Police Department.
MOVED by L. Carter, SECONDED by Raymond that approval be given
for the Security Trailer as requested by Gem Pool Care.
MOTION CARRIED
(ADOPT TENTATIVE. BUDGET)
The Finance Chairman was requested to present the Tentative
Budget for the year 1986 -87.
Councilman J. Carter staged that City Council members received a
summary printout of the Tentative Budget for the coming year.
The budget was as follows:
PROPOSED EXPENDITURES
General Fund
$ 3,061.643
Cemetery
105,495
Library
212,651
Street
896,236
Airport
231,020
Recreation
187,825
Insurance
135,125
Fire Bond
14,000
Pool Bond
21,000
Water Cap Imp
263,126
Rev Sharing
893,590
Sewer Cap Imp
602,000
Cap Imp Levy
195,645
Water
1,064,766
Treatment Plant
955,992
Stadium Complex
301,560
Golf
343,346
Sanitation
692,500
Cemetery Cap Imp
6,600
Irrigation
298,711
HUD Rehab
130,000
Airport Grant
755,187
Total 11,368,018
ESTIMATED REVENUE
General fund
$ 2,651,351
Cemetery
105,495
Library
212,651
Street
834,290
Airport
89,310
Recreation
173,020
Insurance
210,125
Fire Bond
14,000
Pool Bond
6,407
Water Cap Imp
83,000
Rev Sharing
50,797
Sewer Cap Imp
102,000
Cap Imp Levy
90,145
Water
717,500
Treatment Plant
551,000
Stadium Complex
243,932
Golf
282,750
Sanitation
692,500
Cemetery Cap Imp
5,600
Irrigation
258,710
HUD Rehab
10,000
Airport Grant
755,187
Cash Carryover
3,228,248
Book 27
TOTAL 11,368,018
Page 154
Councilman J. Carter further explained where the increases were
for this year and the reason why. Councilman Raymond also stated
that he and the Mayor met with the employees that afternoon to
advise them that there was no proposal for a wage increase for
this year. The Step and Grade was funded and there was some
monies budgeted for a bonus for the employees later on this
Fall.
The Mayor said that he appreciated the efforts made by the
Finance Committee in the many hours they have worked. He did
not, however, agree with some areas of the budget. The next year
the budget would be handled differently, but he would support the
budget at this time. I-3e felt that the City employees were some of
the best in the State and he hoped next year to offset the lack
of salary increase this year.
It was then MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by Marcus that the
Tentative Budget be adopted by City Council.
Councilman Raymond also pointed out that this was just the
Tentative Budget adoption. A public hearing was to be scheduled
for the budget and Revenue Sharing,
The Mayor then asked for a vote on the vote to accept the
Tentative Budget.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: J. Carter, L. Carter, Marcus,
Maranon, and Raymond. Those voting no: none. Absent and not
voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
(SET PUBLIC HEARING FOR REVENUE SHARING AND BUDGET FOR SEPTEMBER 2ND)
It was MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by Marmon that the date of
September 2, 1986, be set for the time of the Public Hearing for
Revenue Sharing and the Budget.
MO'T'ION CARRIED
(DECISION ON CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT LEVY)
Councilman J. Carter requested a delay on this decision until the
next Regular City Council Meeting.
(ACCEPTANCE OF GRANT OFFER - AIRPORT IMRPOVEMENT GRANT)
Mayor Cowles requested that Councilman Raymond read the
Resolution authorizing the execution of the Grant from the
Federal Aviation Administration for the improvements at the
Caldwell Airport as follows:
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE A
GRANT AGREEMENT WITH THE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION.
BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and City Clerk of the City of
Caldwell be, and the same hereby are, authorized to execute that
certain Federal Aviation Grant Agreement attached hereto and made
a part hereof as if set forth in full to the City of Caldwell for
the purpose of improvements at the Caldwell Industrial Airport
(Project No. 3- 16- 0045 -02).
The City Engineer, Mr. Redmond, informed the City Council that
the total amount of the grant was $679,668.00. There was ninety
percent Federal participation and the City will match with ten
percent.
MOVED by Marmon, SECONDED by J. Carter that the Resolution be
passed authorizing the execution of the Grant Agreement for the
improvements at the Airport.
Book 27
Page 155
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: J. Carter, L. Carter, Marcus,
Marmon, and Raymond. Those voting no: none. Absent and not
voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
(AWARD CONTRACT FOR CRACK SEALING AND SCURRY SEAL AT AIRPORT)
The City Engineer explained that this Contract was for a portion
of the work that will be funded by the Grant. It was to routing,
cleaning, sterilizing, and sealing pavement cracks and slurry
seal. Mr. Redmond further said that he would also include in
this explanation the next item on the Agenda which was to approve
change orders for the Airport Contract as it seemed appropriate.
There was three bids submitted. The low bid was from i?terna -Line
Corporation from Boise in the amount of 571,001.60. The high bid
was $91,129.50. The bid was substantially lower than the
Engineer's estimate. For example, unit prices on the slurry seal
on the low bidder was approximately 79 cents and last year at
this time, Nampa paid $1.45 and McCall $1.65 for the same item.
The bids were so favorable that there was now more money to do
further work. That was the purpose of the Change Order to
expand the limits of the work to be done.
There was one problem which the Council should take into
consideration in awarding the bid. The Contractor of the low bid
has had a problem in meeting his insurance requirements. As of
this time, he has not met that requirement. However, a phone
call late today indicated that he should be able to meet that
requirement in time. The bid abstracts were reviewed with the
F.A.A. and they have agreed to the City's recommendation to award
to sterna -Line which was the low bidder. The award should be
made contingent upon the Contractor filling the requirements of
the bid specifications relative to insurance. Mr. Redmond stated
that at this point the City would like to proceed as if
everything was in order, but he would ask Council to qualify
their action based on 1 - he Contractor providing adequate
insurance.
MOVED, by Raymond, SECONDED by Marmon that the project be awarded
to the low bidder, sterna -Line Corporation along with the Change
Order subject to the providing of adequate insurance requirement
prior to Friday, the 22nd of August, 1986, at 3:00 p.m.
MOTION CARRIED
(FINANCIAL REPORT)
The Finance Chairman, Councilman J. Carter informed the Mayor and
Council that the Committee has reviewed the Requests for Payment.
The Accounts Payable amounted to $481,772.40; Payroll along with
fringe benefits in the amount of $240,813.25 making a total of
$722,585.65.
MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by Marcus that approval be given for
the financial report, the bills be made, and the Requests for
Payment filed in the Office of the City Clerk.
MOTION CARRIED
(COMMITTEE REPORTS)
Councilman Raymond asked John Pilote, who was present at the
meeting, to report briefly on the Caldwell Night Rodeo. Mr.
Pilote informed them that the Rodeo was a success and they were
hopeful that they would be in the black.
Councilman Raymond also reported that the negotiating team was
meeting with the Firefighters and they felt it would be completed
very soon.
Book 27 Page 156
Councilman L. Carter stated that he attended the Library Board
meeting and all was going well. 'Ie also attended the Senior
Citizen's Board Meeting. They were about to get their roof fixed
and now have $7 ® 000 in their Building Lund.
Councilwoman Marcus reported that the Library's annual picnic of
appreciation for the Volunteers was held at Sylvia Hunt's house
and was a success.
Councilman Marmon stated that he attended the Airport Meeting and
they were excited about the new business coming out there. He
felt that the lease was a good one and Mr. Paul was satisfied
with it.
Councilwoman Marcus reported that the Air -A -Fair was successful.
The attendance was good. She thanked the Civil. Air Patrol and
others for all of their help.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at
8:45 o.m.
APPROVED AS Written THIS 2nd DAY OF
, 1986.
ncilperson
Councilperson
ATTEST:
L" A c �c
City Clerk
y (0�)
,
Councilperson
Councilperson