HomeMy WebLinkAbout1981-08-11city council minutesBook 22
REGULAR MEETING
August 11, 1981
12:00 Noon
Page 223
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor McCluskey.
The Mayor requested that everyone stand and give the Pledge of
Allegiance to the Flag.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members
present: Williams, Raymond, Mallea, Hopper, Carter, and Betts.
Absent: none.
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
The Mayor asked if there was anyone from the audience who cared t('
bring anything before the City Council that was not on the prepared'
Agenda. Since there was no one, the Mayor declared that the Meeting
would continue as outlined.
OLD BUSINESS
(THIRD READING OF BILL NO. 16 - ZONING AND ANNEXATION OF HAPPY DAY FORD)
The Mayor stated that the first :item under Old Business was the
third reading of Bill No. 16 which was the zoning and annexation of
Happy Day Ford. It was the Mayor's request that this reading be
delayed based on the City being able to come up with their
commitment with regard to this Bill,
MOVED by Betts, SECONDED by Carter that the third reading of Bill
No. 16 be delayed as requested by the Mayor.
MOTION CARRIED
(THIRD READING OF BILL NO. 18 - ORDINANCE NO. 1608 - VACATION OF ALLEY
BY PIZZA HUT)
The Mayor informed the Council that the next item under Old
Business was the third reading of Bill No. 18 which was the
vacation of the alley by the Pizza Hut. The Mayor stated that
this Bill had not been read in its entirety and he would read it
in full unless the City Council would. care to make a motion that it
not be read in full. It was the Mayor's recommendation that a motion
be made to this effect.
Councilwoman Williams was rec ognized and questioned as to whether
there was clarification as to the questions the City Engineer
presented at the last reading. Mr. Redmond had not arrived at the
meeting as yet and it was her suggestion that action on this Bill
be delayed until later in the meeting when the City Engineer arrived
and could answer the Council's questions.
(BUMPER STICKERS FOR M.A.D. RECEIVED)
The Mayor reported that he had received the bumper stickers for
his Mobile Awareness Dispatchers. The idea was to have people, who
were willing and have CB sets, to cruise the City of Caldwell and
report anything that appeared suspicious to the Police Department.
The Mayor further commented that he had paid for these stickers and
was going to contribute the money he paid for them to another fund
called C.A.R. which was Crime Awareness Reward. This was where
a person responsible for an arrest and conviction of a criminal
would. get a reward.. The Mayor will charge $5.00 for the stickers
and that money will go into this Crime Award Fund. There was
already $700 pledged to this fund.
(BILL NO. 18 - ORDINANCE NO. 1608 - VACATION OF ALLEY BY PIZZA HUT)
The City Engineer, Mr. Redmond, arrived in the Council Chambers
and the Mayor asked him if everything was taken care of with regard
to the questions discussed previously concerning the vacation of
the alley by the Pizza Hut. Mr. Redmond assured the Mayor and City
Council that it was taken care of.
The Mayor then requested a motion to dispense with the reading in
full of Bill No. 18.
Book 22
Page 224
MOVED by Betts, SECONDED by Carter that the City Council dispense
with the reading of Bill No. 18 in full and that it be read by
title only.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Betts, Williams, Raymond,
Mallea, Hopper, and Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and not
voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor then read Bill No. 18 by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE RECITING PETITION FOR VACATION AND RECITING
APPROPRIATE NOTICE THEREFOR WAS GIVEN: DETERMINING THAT
VACATION OF TIIE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED REAL PROPERTY SHALL BE
MADE, TO -WIT
MOVED by Betts, SECONDED by Carter that Bill No. 18 be passed and
entitled Ordinance No. 1608.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Betts, Williams, Raymond,
Mallea, Hopper, and Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION NO. 49 -81 - EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT WITH HARRISON FRANK
INSURANCE AGENCY)
The Mayor reminded the City Council that there was no Resolution
prepared at the last City Council. Meeting to accept the bid for the
City's insurance. It was to be presented at this meeting and the
Mayor read Resolution No. 49 -81 in full as follows:
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE AN
AGREEMENT WITH HARRISON FRANK INSURANCE AGENCY.
BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and Clerk of the City of
Caldwell be, and the same hereby are, authorized to execute
that certain Agreement attached hereto and made a part hereof
as if set forth in full by and between the City of Caldwell
and Harrison Frank Insurance: Agency for insurance coverage for
the City of Caldwell.
MOVED by Williams, SECONDED by Ma.11ea that Resolution No. 49 -81 be
passed authorizing the execution of an Agreement with Harrison
Frank Insurance Agency.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Williams, Raymond, Mallea,
Hopper, Carter, and Betts. Those voting no: none. Absent and not
voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
NEW BUSINESS
(PUBLIC HEARING ON APPEAL OF SPECIAL USE PERMIT FOR GOLF COURSE
CONDOMINIUMS)
The Mayor declared the City Council Meeting open for a Public
Hearing on appeal of special use permit for Golf Course Condominiums.
Councilwoman Williams was recognized and stated that the City
Attorney advised her that she had. a conflict of interest on this
issue and she would ask to be excused and go into the audience 'so
she could have an opportunity to testify. The Mayor excused
Councilwoman Williams as requested.
The Mayor called on Mrs. Robison to give the explanation for this
appeal. Mrs. Robison explained that this was an appeal on a
decision of the Planning and Zoning Commission to grant a special
use permit to construct three ssxplexes on a half block area
South of the Golf Course. Mrs. Robison then read the appeal as
follows:
TO THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL:
The following people are appealing the decision made by
Book 22
Page 225
the Planning and Zoning Committee, July 16th, 1981, in
allowing the 18 units to be built on the half block
between Halstead and Morrison Streets, along Fairview
Avenue for the following reasons:
No. 1 The Zoning.allows for from 7 to 9 units per acre
and this area is a little less than one acre and this
permit would allow 18 units, which is 506 more than the
zoning regulations allows.
No. 2 The inadequacy of the sewer line to accomodate the
units that are now on this line and the plan would be
for 3 times more than the present number in this area.
No. 3. There are many other reasons - the narrow
street - the fact that Fairview is the only access in aiff
out of this area and numerous other reasons as were
expressed at the Planning and Zoning hearing on the 18th.
Thank you for your considerationof this appeal.
There was sixteen signatures on this appeal.
Mrs. Robison stated that the appeal concerns the sewer, the
variances, and the density as granted by the Planning and Zoning
Commission. The variances that were granted were as follows:
1. An encroachment into the 20 -foot side setback on Morrison
Street of 5 feet with the building and 9 feet with the
balcony or deck.
2. An encroachment into the 20 -foot side setback on Halstead
Street of 8 feet with the building and 12 feet with the
balcony or deck.
3. An encroachment into the 20 -foot rear setback of 12 feet
with the building and .16 feet with the balcony or deck.
4. The location of 7 visitor parking spaces in the front
setback.
The Mayor then read a letter addressed to the members of the City
Council from John and Josephine Willmorth and also a letter
addressed to the Mayor and members of the City Council from the
Board of Directors of the Caldwell Chamb?r of Commerce and signed
by Roger I -I. Horton, Executive Director. Both letters are attached
to the minutes.
The Mayor then asked if there was anyone in the audience who cared
to speak in opposition to the decision of the Planning and Zoning
Commission to allow this condominium project. The Mayor further
stated that he would hope that those who cared to speak would keep
their remarks to a minimum.
Wayne Englehorn, 1415 Fairview, was recognized and stated that he
had been asked by eight homeowners in the area surrounding the
proposed project to voice their concerns pertaining to this project.
Mr. Englehorn's report was as follows:
I have been asked by eight homeowners in the area surrounding
this proposed project to voice their negatives and concerns
pertaining to this project.
The following subjects are covering letters from:
Helen Rastler
Louise Roedel
Ruth Englehorn
Clem and Zelma March
Everett and Francis Evans
Ted and Alta Williams
Kathryn Baxnos
Cecil and Edith Marshall
Wayne Englehorn
1406 Fairview
1509 Fairview
1503 Fairview
1508 Fairview
1318 Fairview
1404 Fairview
1513 Fairview
1420 Fairview
1415 Fairview
First May I say it has been quoted several times in the paper,
"The developers have options to buy four of the houses and
verbal agreements with the owners of the other two ". The
Book 22
Page 226
owners of the other two seem to have a difference of opinion
as of noon this past Monday, the 10th of August.
Also, for anyone to state what kind of individual would be
buying these units is only speculation. It's illegal to
restrict buying to only certain people or types of people.
This of course includes millionaires, wealthy widows and
widowers.
To state the number of people who would be living in these
units is only speculation. Yes, there could be as few as
eighteen people living there or as many as 55 to 63, which falls
within the national average of 2.75 to 3.50 people for two
bedroom condo's. Density is the main issue here, and we are
against that large increase.
The variances requested not only infringe on people living
in that area, who they themselves are restricted to the zoning,
but push to have changes made to our golf course on the second
green end ninth fairway, which we are very much against.
The sewer facilities may not be the main issue, as pointed out
in the Planning and Zoning meeting on July 16, 1981, but it is
a problem the city will have to deal with, if and when this
project is built.
The increase of property values goes hand in hand with the
increase of taxes. The majority of people in the immediate
area are retired and cannot afford an undue added tax burden.
Looking at a model of these buildings on a board is one thing,
but placing them full size in all their boxes glory aesthetically
in that area is poor at best. They do not blend with the
homes in that area.
The purpose of the Zoning Ordinance passed on December 13, 1977
states in Section 1.3 line 3 "To prevent the overcrowding of
land ". Line 4 reads "To avoid undue concentration of
population ". We feel this is in conflict with the proposed
zoning change and variance request.
May I add, the wombing effect the home plays in our lives is
very important. With our economy as unsettled as it is,
higher prices and even the Social Security System in question,
the home is all important as a solid base for our lives. There
is no reason why the lifestyles of these people should be turned
upside down or changed in any way. It can be a very traumatic
experience. None of these people are against progress unless
to an extreme. I firmly believe the requested increase in
density and the number of variances falls in that extreme
category. The density should be no more than what it is zoned
for with no changes that would effect the golf course or the
people living in that area.
It has been asked by those I have spoken for that you, the
City Council, consider this project as if it were being put
directly across from your home and what these increases and
variances would do to your lives. Only then can you understand
their very sincere concern. Thank you.
The Mayor further commented that there was several letters attached
to this written statement to substantiate the concerns.
The Mayor then asked if there was anyone else who cared to speak
in opposition to the decision made by the Planning and Zoning
Commission.
Robert Payne, 1501 Arlington, was recognized and stated that he lived
one block West of the proposed condominiums. He further commented
that he was well acquainted with the 1400 block of Fairview as he
had lived there for twenty -six years. He stated that he thought
eighteen families in this small area would create a high population
density. Such an increase would be a constant drain on the facilities
and he felt that it would increase their taxes. The R -2 Zone that
was existing does permit for the construction of rental income
property up to twelve units. He thought that twelve condominiums
Book 22 Page 227
might be acceptable, but not eighteen.
Ted Williams, 1404 Fairview, was recognized and stated that he had a
number of oppositions. One was the high density and another was the
many variances. One of the main variances that he objected to was
the parking lot directly across the street from his home. The
parking lot was facing the street and right up to the property line,
if not over the property line.
L. E. Burrell, 615 South Kimball, and stated that he was there as
a golfer. His concern. was where the property line will be with
regard to the Golf Course and what will happen to Number Two Greer -
It was his understanding by looking at the drawings that the
Number Two Green would. have to be moved and there was really no
place to move it. Mr. Burrell further commented that it would be
a detriment to the Golf Course if it was moved and would make that
Hole Par two. I-Ie further said that the right of way line if
extended would be right on the bunker of the green.
Mr. Redmond explained that the stakes placed by the golf course wouli
represent the curb line if the street was constructed to City
standards. The curb Line comes out about four to five feet off the
edge of the green and the right of way line would be probably to
the edge of the green. The street width would be:;thirty -four feet
wide. Mr. Redmond explained further the location of the stakes
and poles placed at the construction location.
Gordy Crockett was recognized and stated that they would have to
move the green. His question was whether they would have to go
from a thirty -two foot road to a sixteen foot alley. Mr. Crockett
asked why they needed this road. It was explained by Mr. Redmond.
that this was another possibility for a variance. Mr. Crockett
further said that if they did move the green, he did not know where
they would put it. I-Ie also mentioned that consideration would have
to be given to moving the trees and the sprinkler system.
Mr. Everett March, 1508 Fairview, was recognized and stated that
it appeared to him that a project that requires this many
variances was asking for trouble. He had heard a various number
as to the amount of variances and with this in mind, it was his
feeling that the project was going in the wrong place. He
questioned why the City of Caldwell had zoning rules if there had to
be so many variances to get around them.
Mrs. Everett March was .recognized and asked if the power poles and
the trees would have to be moved if the alley was widened.
The City Engineer answered that the power poles would probably have
to be moved. The trees were on the Golf Course and appeared to be
about three or four feet on to the Golf Course. There would be a
question as to whether the trees would have to come down and he'did
not believe it would. be necessary for access.
Helen Rastler was recognized and said that she had heard that the
trees would have to come down so the buyers of the condominiums coul
have a view. The Mayor stated that he could not see why they would
state that they were going to move the trees when they were on City
property.
Alta F. Williams, 1404 Fairview, was recognized and stated that
she had lived there for forty -three years. Mrs. Williams further
said that there was many people present who had lived in this
area for twenty -five to forty years. These people built that
area; the streets, the curbs and gutters, and the sidewalks and
everything was built according to City specifications. There was
not one variance requested to build the area. There was not one
person in the area who opposed to a building on that street if it
fits the area without a variance. Mrs. Williams further commented
that she counted the variances with the City Engineer that morning a
there was nine variances and she felt that was too many.
Edith Marshall, 1420 Fairview, was recognized and stated that
when cars were parked on both sides of the street now you cannot
pass without difficulty.
The Mayor then stated that he would ask for any discussion from
Book 22
Page 228
those who cared to speak in support of the decision made by the
Planning and Zoning Commission.
Jeff Jensen was recognized and stated that he would be glad to
answer any questions that those in the audience might have. The
Mayor stated that first of all he would request that Mr. Jensen
answer the questions with regard to the removal of the trees.
Mr. Jensen answered that the trees were on City property and that
they would do whatever the City wants them to do with regard to the
trees. As far as the North end, the Planning and Zoning Commission
recommended that they improve on both sides and they will once again
do what the City wants.
Councilman Raymond asked Mr. Crockett if the street was not
widened the full width would it interfere with hole number two. Mr.
Crockett stated that he did not think so. The alley was there now
and does not interfere.
The Mayor then asked members of the City Council if they would care
to ask Mr. Jensen any questions with regard to the project.
Councilman Carter pointed out that with the alley so narrow there
could be some problems getting trucks and other large vehicles in
there. Again, Mr. Jensen stated that they would do whatever the
City required.
Councilman Carter also stated that there seemed to be some question
as to the capabilities of the sewer. He asked Mr. Jensen if he
would be willing to run a sewer line from his proeprty down to the
other sewer on Fairview Street as the present sewer serves quite a
few people. Mr. Jensen stated that this was a very difficult
question for him as he was just the representative and not the
developer. The City Engineer had stated to them that the sewer
system was adequate. Again, Mr. Jensen said that they would do
whatever was required. Mr. Jensen also state d that the appraiser
stated that the property values would go up with the project going
in that area and they felt that the whole neighborhood would
benefit.
The Mayor read a report from the Treatment Plant which indicated
that the sewer was adequate. It was mentioned that a couple of
willow trees on the Golf Course could be causing some of the
problems that have occurred previously. The Treatment Plant had
received some calls regarding the flow running slow.
Ruth Englehorn was recognized and stated that everyone they have
had come to their home with regard to the sewer has found refuse
at the end of the sewer line where it dumps into the main line. It
was her feeling that this should not happen.
Councilman Hopper stated that there was some question as to whether
the road and alley could handle Large trucks, such as garbage trucks
and fire equipment, particularly at the turn. The City Engineer
stated that the way it was laid out now there probably would be
enough room. In order to minimize the impact on the Golf Course, an
option would be for the City to vacate Halstead which would give
half of the street to the Golf Course and half would go to the
property owners. Also, possibly vacate the alley and get easements
for the utilities. This would then become a private access.
Since there was no one else who cared to testify with regard to
this appeal, the Mayor declared the Public Hearing closed. Mayor
McCluskey then stated that he would like to read from the City Code
the section pertaining to Appeals to the Council in order to clarify
the vote before any action was taken. The Code stated as follows,
"The Council shall hear all appeals from a decision of the Planning
and Zoning Commission concerning special permits and variances and
shall have the power to permit special exceptions to the terms of the
zoning regulations. All decisions of the Council too either uphold
or reverse a decision of the Planning and Zoning Commission
concerning special permits and variances shall be by a majority vote
of one -half (1/2) plus one of the number of Council members. It is
not necessary for all six (6) Council members to be in attendance at
the Council meeting when an appeal is presented."
Book 22 Page 229
The Mayor further stated that the City Attorney's opinion was
that the City Council must have four people vote for or against
the issue. In other words, the City Attorney stated that the action.
must be handled just the way the Code states.
Councilman Kopper was recognized and stated that this was one of
the political decisions that we all hear so much about, but don't
have the opportunity to address too often. He was very much in
sympathy with the problems at hand. There was an economic situation
where you can't hardly afford to buy anything because of the high
cost; not only the original investment, but the construction. It
seems like there was some problems with the fringe areas, such
as the alleys and the roadways to the North. He thought that
the City Engineer's comments to vacate that street had a lot of
merit and maybe would resolve the problems of the Golf Course
as well as letting the construction begin. It seemed to him that`'
the community was right for a face.,lifting.. Many of them had toured
that area and had a lot of input as to the age of it and maybe it
was time for an upgrading. It did bother him that so many exception:
had to be made to the general rules that were established in
building the community. :AL this point, he felt that he was
sympathetic to the developer in upgrading that area.
Councilwoman Mallea was recognized and stated that she was in favor
of the improvements in. this area. She had viewed the area and
arranged for a conference there. The sewer was not a big problem
according to the information, that the City.Council has received
from two engineers. The encroachment of the buildings on the right
of way was a problem. The property values were really not to be
considered. The value to the Golf Course was a consideration. If
the City did lessen the street to one half, the Golf Course would.
not be affected. But the modifications that would have to be made
to allow our emergency vehicles into the area, according to the
engineers were so great that it would push this.building facing the
Golf Course back so there would be a question as to access. Council
woman Mallea :further commented that she would support the building
of two or these, but could not support the building of three.
Councilman Raymond was recognized and stated that he found that
where there was high -rise buildings with a lot of people in a
limited area, it made the area much more attractive. Triplexes
and duplexes bring a lot of visitor traffic. IIe felt that these
types of living units created more of an uncomfortable environment
than the project that was being proposed here tonight. He tried
to view it with respect to how he would feel personally if it was
across the street from him. Councilman Raymond further commented
that he was going to support the developer as he :Celt it would.
improve his neighborhood if this type of project were going in across
from him.
Councilman Carter was recognized and stated that he felt there was
too many "ifs" that should be cleared up. The way it stands now,
according to the Planning and Zoning recommendation, the street
would be widened which would cut off the number two hole of the
Golf Course. The trees also posed a question and he also felt that
there was too many units for the area. He also had some concern wit:
regard to the utility trucks. He just :Celt that there was too many
problems and would suppott.twelve units, but in no way could he
support eighteen units. `Councilman Carter also stated that he did
not want to see the Golf Course interfered with in any way.
Councilman Betts was recognized and stated that there was
certainly a lot of question marks. He felt that it was a nice
looking complex and would not mind having it across the street
from him, but as Councilman Carter stated there was a lot of "ifs"
and too many questions.
MOVED by Betts, SECONDED by Carter that the City Council overrule
or reject the Planning and Zoning Commission's decision.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes:,.Betts, Mallea, and Carter.
Those voting no: Raymond and Hopper.
MOTION DENIED
Book 22
Page 230
The Mayor explained that the motion would not pass due to the fact
that there was not four votes. Therefore, the Planning and Zoning
Commission's recommendation stands.
It was then MOVED by Carter that this issue be tabled and referred
back to the Planning and Zoning Commission to correct the "ifs"
and "whys" so they would have a clear understanding as to what they
were voting on.
Councilwoman Mallea questioned as to whether this motion could be
made. Councilman Hopper stated that this was still under the control
of the staff. There was still no building permits issued or any
procedures to start construction. He felt that if they gave the
staff guidance with regard to their concerns that they presently
had, they would still be safe. The staff also had some concerns as
to what to do with regard to some matters and he felt that it was
upt to them to come up with some recommendations and then the Council
could reject or accept their recommendations.
The Mayor declared a one minute recess while he looked into the
Robert's Rules of Order with regard to the motion made by Councilman
Carter.
The Meeting was reconvened and the Mayor stated that as far as he
could tell it was probably out of order to make the motion as
stated by Councilman Carter as a motion was already made and passed.
Councilman Carter then stated that he would withdraw his motion.
It was then MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Mallea that the City
Council ask the Engineering Department to hold in abeyance any
building permits, any construction orders and anything that would.
allow these people to proceed until the Council has addressed the
matters of concern relative to this Planning and Zoning Commission
recommendation and those matters of concern of the City Council.
John Pilote was recognized and stated that it was the intent of
the Planning and Zoning Commission to push for the improvements of
the thoroughfares. The idea was to make sure that it was improved.
The Mayor then requested a roll call vote. Those voting yes:
Hopper, Carter, Betts, Raymond, and Mallea. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
Councilwoman Williams asked if the Engineering Department can
satisfy all of the questions, does that mean they can go ahead with
the construction and the appeal was denied and the people have no
other chance to appeal. The Mayor stated that this was right.
(RECOMMENDATION FOR APPOINTMENT OF KEN BATT AS PARK SUPERINTENDENT)
The Mayor stated that he would not discuss the recommendation of
Ken Batt as Park Superintendent, but would ask the City Council
to let him know how they felt about this item.
(ADDITIONS TO THE AGENDA)
The Mayor requested that the City Council approve the addition of
several items to the Agenda.
MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Raymond that the Mayor be allowed to
add several additions to the Agenda.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION NO. 51 -81 - INTENTION TO ESTABLISH LOCAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT
NO. 81)
The Mayor stated that the next item on the Agenda was a Resolution
for intention to establish Local Improvement District No. 81 which
involved Brookside and Nixon. The Mayor read the Resolution by
title only as follows:
A RESOLUTION DECLARING THE INTENTION OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL
TO CREATE AND ESTABLISH A STREET LOCAL IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT NO.
81 FOR THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, FOR THE PURPOSE OF
Book 22
Page 23.1
CONSTRUCTING STREET IMPROVEMENTS, STATING THE STREETS UPON
WHICH THE SAID IMPROVEMENTS ARE TO BE MADE, TIIE GENERAL
CHARACTER OF SAID STREET AND SEWER IMPROVEMENTS, TIIE ESTIMATED
COST OF THE SAME AND THAT SUCH COST IS TO BE AFFIXED AGAINST
THE ABUTTING, ADJOINING, CONTIGUOUS AND ADJACENT LANDS ALONG
AND UPON WHICH SAID STREET AND SEWER IMPROVEMENTS ARE TO BE
MADE AND UPON THE LOTS AND LANDS BENEFITED BY SUCH IMPROVEMENTS
AND INCLUDED IN THE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT FORMED, AND THE
METHOD OF WHICH TIIE COSTS AND EXPENSES OF THE IMPROVEMENTS
I1iITI-IIN TIIE INTERSECTIONS ARE TO BE PAID, FIXING THE TIME WITHIN
WHICH PROTESTS AGAINST SAID PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS MAY BE
FILED IN TIIE OFFICE OF TIIE CITY CLERK, AND FIXING THE TIME
WHEN SUCH PROTEST SHALL BE HEARD AND CONSIDERED BY THE
COUNCIL.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Betts that Resolution No. 51 -81 be
passed as presented by the Mayor.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, Mallea, Hopper, Carter,
Betts; and Williams: Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting
none:
MOTION CARRIED
Ron Redmond, the City Engineer, was recognized and stated that
putting together this L.I.D. was:a joint effort with Mel Lewis and
Alpha Engineers_ who have done a lot of the :engineering. The City
will be doing the inspection and keeping track of the project. To
get all the proper procedures completed and get the construction
started before the cold weather, the rest of the engineering work
will have to be done by the time the Ordinance was approved. There
was an agreement with Alpha Engineers prepared so to get them on
board to get everything ready to go at the time the-Ordinance will
be passed. Should the Ordinance not be passed, the City would be
liable for the costs, but it would be expediting the project. This
was a requested L.I.D. by the property owners and not a forced
L.I.C. so no problems were expected.
(RESOLUTION NO. 50 -81 - EXECUTE GRANT AGREEMENT WITII DEPARTMENT OF
HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT)
The Mayor then read the following Resolution in :Cull as follows:
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK -TO EXECUTE
GRANT AGREEMENT FOR TIIE CITY OF CALDWELL WITH THE DEPARTMENT
OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT.
BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and City Clerk of the City
of.Caldwell be, and the same hereby are, authorized to execute
that certain Grant Agreement attached hereto and made a part
hereof as if set forth in full for the City of Caldwell to the
Department of Housing and Urban Development for a grant for
housing rehabilitation, street improvements and Senior Citizen':
Center improvements in the amount of $500,000.00.
The Mayor explained to the City Council that he did receive a letter
that day stating that the City of Caldwell's application was
approved.
MOVED by Carter, SECONDED by Raymond that Resolution No. 50 -81 be
passed as presented by the Mayor.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Carter, Betts, Williams,
Raymond, Mallea, and:Hopper.. Those voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(MAYOR'S REPORT)
The Mayor reported that he and Pauline Bell, the Press Tribune
reporter, attended the M:A.A.C: meeting at the Labor Camp the night
before: When they first arrived, there was not a good attendance, bi
some of the members of the Commission went out into the camp and
gathered about thirty people who attended the meeting. There was a
great deal of discussion and they felt that the meeting was
Book 22
Page 232
successful. They seem to have a greater crime program than we do here
in the City of Caldwell. It was suggested that the Sheriff's
Department be present at their next meeting.
The Mayor also reported that the meeting with regard to North
Indiana was satisfactory and everyone was contacted except for one.
The City Engineer had presented the Mayor with an idea which the
Mayor presented to the group. At this time the Mayor said that he
would like to have Mr. Redmond present this recommendation to them.
Mr. Redmond stated that the City originally indicated that they
-- would be willing to put forth about $30,000 for construction of
North Indiana to get the street paved. It was approached from the
standpoint that they would like to get a full street width, curbs,
and etc., and still not put a heavy impact on the individual property
owners. To go in and do it with the City crews, and disregarding the
salaries, rentals on trucks and gas, the approximate costs would. be
about $25,000. In order to get the individual property owners
involved in this, since there was a lot of big property owners in
the area, it was suggested that they take what an average City lot
would be and figure what the curb frontage would be and the asphalt
cost. This amounted to about $500 for each property owner. They
approached the property owners from the standpoint that if they would
give the City of Caldwell the right of way and the $500 for each
property, the City would do the work. As the properties develop,
they will be required to pay a $500 access fee and after a time the
City would recover the monies for the project. Mr. Redmond further
stated that the property owners would be asked to sign a covenant
to this effect when the agreement was -= signed.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Hopper that support be given to this
plan to improve North Indiana.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor asked the City Council if they would support a town
hall meeting to discuss water rates, and etc. The City Council
agreed that they would be in favor of this and the Mayor stated
that he would pursue this possibility.
The Mayor also informed the City Council that he would meet with
Anne Berblinger from E.D.A. to discuss the project on the 18th of
August.
(CLARIFICATION WITH REGARD TO INSURANCE BIDS)
Councilwoman Mallea was recognized and stated that she would like
the minutes to reflect why the low bidder did not get the bid for
the City insurance when the bid was awarded. It was determined
that this full report was not given at the meeting when the bid was
awarded and Councilwoman Mallea said that she would like to quickly
make that report. Councilwoman Mallea stated that Blaine Company
was not accepted as low bid because the City of Caldwell was not
held without liability for suits that were done for punitive damages
and therefore, the Police and the Mayor would be liable for punitive
damages. The next low bidder was Graves Holden Insurance and it was
not awarded to them because they did not come up high enough on the
amount of liability required for public officials and the Police
Department. Their coverage was only $500,000.00 and it would have
taken them unitl Monday to have confirmed whether or not there would
have been an umbrella covering that amount of insurance which was
required in the bid specification. The last insurance that was not
awarded was Jack Cline Insurance which was far more expensive
than any of the others. Therefore, the low bid which satisfied the
specifications was Harrison and Frank.
(MEETING WITH HELEN WILSON)
The Mayor said that the meeting with Helen Wilson was satisfactory
and the City Council had indicated that they would support her
in her endeavors on a County /City dog pound not only morally, but
also financially.
Book 22 Page 233
(FURTHER DISCUSSION WITH REGARD TO THE APPEAL FOR THE CONDOMINIUMS)
Mrs. Robison asked for some guidance with regard to the decision
.Trade by the City,C . ouncil with regard to the appeal made. The
Council stated that there was some questions with regard to the
roads, trees and other concerns expressed during the meeting.
It was explained that the City staff would address the concerns
that were discussed. Perm ts.will not be issued until
some of the concerns were addressed.
There being no further business, the Meeting was adjourned at
1.:45 p.m.
APPROVED AS written THIS 18th DAY OF August 1981
f
ayor
!/. /Co n iI' n Co' o' cilman
C " ,
n mia Councilman
Cou cilman Councilman