Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1986-07-21city council minutesBook 27 REGULAR MEETING July 21, 1986 7:30 p.m. The Meeting was called to order by Mayor Cowles. Page 129 The Mayor requested that everyone stand for the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members present: Raymond, J. Carter, L. Carter, Mallea, Marcus, and Marmon. Absent: none. (APPROVAL OF MINUTES) MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by L. Carter to dispense with the reading of the minutes of the Regular City Council Meeting of July 7, 1986, and approve them as written. MOTION CARRIED (AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION) The Mayor asked if there was anyone from the audience who had an item to be presented to the City Council at this time that was not on the prepared Agenda. Councilman Marmon introduced his daughter, Amanda, who was celebrating her birthday on this date and was attending the meeting with her Father. As there was no one else, the Mayor declared that the Meeting would continue. (OLD BUSINESS) (REQUESTS FROM BUSINESSES IN DOWNTOWN AREA FOR EXCLUSION FROM THE IRRIGATION SYSTEM) Mayor Cowles introduced Mr. Herb Rettig, who was present at the meeting representing a number of downtown businesses requesting exclusion from the Pioneer Irrigation District. Mr. Rettig informed the City Council that he was present to address some petitions he filed on behalf of his clients seeking for their property to be removed from Pioneer Irrigation District. He understood that it was the City's practice to present them to the City Council, a .recommendation was made to the Pioneer District, and subsequently action was taken by Pioneer. Mr. Rettig stated that he would like to point out each of the properties to the City Council on a map. Those properties included the following: Vic and Robert Asqueta, B & M Car Wash, Inc., Bill's Service Parts Company of Caldwell, Inc., Burns Financial, Inc., Canyon Abstract & Title Co., Ltd., The Caxton Printers, Ltd., Commercial Ventures, Custom Woodcraft, Inc., Dairymens Creamery Association, Thomas L. Edmark, Inc., Thomas L. Edmark and Helen D. Edmark, Paul F. Ernst and Ruth Ernst, Executive Plaza, D. L. Feller Trucking, Inc., R.L. Franklin, Jr. and Gloria Franklin, J. Alan Hochstrasser and Carol R. Hochstrasser, Home Federal Savings Loan Assn., Irrigators Lumber Company, Inc., Ives E. Jones and Nina M. Jones, Ernest F. Keys and Mary M. Keys, Koch, Inc., Lodge Bros., L.H. Navis and Neva B. Navis, Enoch Ogstad and Eleanor Ogstad, Jerry Ogstad and Kathy Ogstad, Rettig, Rosenberry, Lovan & Morfitt, Scotts Food Distribution, Leslie W. Summers, (toward K. Vaughn, J.C. Vermaas and Carolyn Vermaas, and H.R. Vinson and Joanne M. Vinson. The Petition filed to exclude land from irrigation district as submitted by the above - named was as follows: 1. The Petitioners are the owners of the parcels of lands described on the attached Exhibit "A ". Book 27 Page 130 2. The lands described above are located within the boundaries of Pioneer Irrigation District but are not agricultural or farming land. The said lands are also within the boundaries of Caldwell Municipal Irrigation District, but Petitioners' said lands are not served by said District or any community ditch, or by a Lateral Ditch User's Association, or any other like entity, or if served by any such entity, the exclusion of Petitioners' lands will not injure said entity. 3. The lands sought to be excluded is improved commercial property and is not benefited by the water rights, or by the irrigation in, or drainage by the Pioneer Irrigation District, or I rom subterranean waters in the Pioneer Irrigation District. 4. The exclusion of Petitioners' said lands will be for the best interest of Petitioners as owners of said land and of the Pioneer Irrigation District. 5. The required filing fee, bond for costs, and exclusion fee required by Idaho Code 43 -1101 accompanies this petition. 6. Evidence of Petitioners' ownership of the lands involved in this petition is attached. 7. The holder of any mortgage, deed of trust, or any other kind of lien against Petitioners' lands as descented to this petition in writing is attached. 8. That this petition has been filed with the City of Caldwell and Petitioners' lands should be excluded from Caldwell Municipal Irrigation District, should said lands be excluded from Pioneer Irrigation District. 9. There are parties owning separate tracts or parcels of land within Pioneer Irrigation District who are united in interest with Petitioners, and the same set of facts apply to said persons as do your Petitioners. These persons are named on the attached Exhibit "B" and these persons have filed petitions at the same time as this petition, and said petitions are deemed incorporated herein to the extent appropriate. This petition shall be deemed a joint petition with those parties named in Exhibit "B" and is separate to the extent of furnishing the individual information relating to the identification, ownership, and character of Petitioners' lands and petitions should be found not properly joinable with this petition, then such petition should be disregarded. WHEREFORE, Petitioners' pray for a hearing upon this petition jointly with those joined herein, with the right to furnish any and all additional proofs which may be appropriate, and upon such hearing, that the lands of the Petitioners and others named be excluded from the boundaries of Pioneer Irrigation District, except as to payment of charges provided by Idaho Code 43 -1103, and for such other relief as may be permitted by law. Mr. Rettig further commented that all of these people have one thing in common: All have properties that are Commercial devoted to Commercial use as they do not use water, have no need for water, and have no way of getting water and are not served by water. Idaho Code makes provision for exclusion of property from irrigation districts. This Section provides that non- agricultural or non - farming land if not served by an irrigation district may get out of the district. The Idaho Supreme Court made a ruling in Caldwell with a case involving the College Heights Apartment Complex off 20th Street. The Court found that this property was not served by an irrigation district and the property should be excluded from Pioneer Irrigation District and Caldwell Municipal Irrigation District. If this property was eligible, certainly the properties named above should be eligible as they were not served by Pioneer Irrigation Book 27 Page 131 District, are not intended to be served, will not be served, and have no use for it. Therefore, he would ask that the City Council recommend to the Pioneer Irrigation District that they release these properties from their District. Mayor Cowles stated that he gave to each member of the City Council a letter dated July 17th from the City Attorney. On page four of that letter, there was some information he hoped the Council had the opportunity to review. Based on this information, the Mayor said he would ask the Council for direction as how they wish to proceed with those petitions filed. The petitions have been in the City's possession since Mr. Rettig submitted them. At Mr. Rettig`s request, the presentation of the petitions to the Council was delayed until this time. Councilman Raymond MOVED that the City acknowledge the request of the businesses represented by Mr. Rettig and recommend to Pioneer Irrigation District that those businesses be allowed to withdraw from the District. SECONDED by L. Carter. Councilman J. Carter said that as he understood the motion, it was a recommendation to Pioneer itself and the City is not denying or approving their exclusion from the Caldwell Municipal Irrigation District. Councilman Raymond stated that the motion states that they be allowed to withdraw and petitions forwarded to Pioneer Irrigation District. Councilwoman Marcus said that the letter from the City Attorney states as follows, "It is my opinion that the City Council really has not authority to deny or grant the exclusion petitions." Councilwoman further stated that it was her impression that the Council should turn the petitions over to Pioneer Irrigation District. Mayor Cowles agreed with Councilwoman Marcus that ultimately the decision was to be made by Pioneer Irrigation. After their decision is made and it appears necessary, it could be brought back to the City Council. Basically, the Council has no authority to deny or take action on the requests. Councilman Raymond stated that he read the letter and he understood what the City Attorney was saying; but requests for exclusion in the past have been presented to the City Council, the Council has made a recommendation to Pioneer Irrigation, and the petition sent to them. If the Council decides to change this process, he would have no problem. Since no change has been made at this time, Councilman Raymond stated he would just as soon have Pioneer Irrigation District know the feelings of the City Council. The petitions are going to be presented to Pioneer Irrigation District regardless of what action the Council takes. if the procedure needs to be changed, then Council should consider doing so. Councilwoman Mallea commented that at least one of the properties asking for exclusion does have irrigation available and has used it for many years. where the City does not have authority, she would be unwilling to change the ordinary and accepted procedure which has been to deny the request for exclusion and leave the ultimate decision with Pioneer Irrigation District. The Mayor asked that the City Clerk read the motion again and then asked for a roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond and L. Carter. Those voting no: J. Carter, Mallea, Marcus, and Marmon. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION FAILED Mayor Cowles then asked that the City Council consider another motion as to the direction they wished to proceed. Councilwoman Mallea stated that in lieu of the fact that the Council has denied the petitions from the businesses, she would MOVE that this matter be remanded to Pioneer Irrigation District for their action. SECONDED by Marmon. Book 27 Page 132 Councilman L. Carter stated that this was basically what Councilman Raymond's motion was. Councilman J. Carter agreed and said that he felt the proper procedure would be to deny this motion and let the matter go to Pioneer Irrigation District for their ultimate decision. Councilman. L. Carter and Councilwoman Mallea both felt that this was what Councilman Raymond's motion stated. Mayor Cowles stated that Councilman Raymond's motion was to accept the petitions and recommend that Pioneer allow the businesses to get out of the District. What you are saying now is to deny these and let them be submitted to Pioneer and let them act accordingly. This is what has been done in the past. Councilwoman Mallea then said that she would MOVE to deny the petition and remand this matter to Pioneer Irrigation. SECONDED by J. Carter. Councilman Raymond then stated that there was a motion on the floor. The Mayor agreed that there was a motion which was seconded by Councilman Marmon. Councilwoman Mallea then withdrew both motions and asked for approval of the seconds, Councilman Marmon and Councilman J. Carter. Both seconds agreed. Mayor Cowles requested that the City Clerk again read the motion made by Councilman Raymond. It was then MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by Marmon that the City of Caldwell deny the petitions and a negative recommendation be given to Pioneer Irrigation District. Councilman L. Carter commented that according to the legal opinion from the City Attorney, the Council really has no authority to deny or grant the exclusion petitions. Therefore, he felt the Council should just refer to the Pioneer District. Mayor Cowles agreed stating that Council should accept the petitions and simply forward them on to Pioneer with no recommendation. After further discussion, the Mayor asked for a roll call vote on the motion. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, and J. Carter. Those voting no: Raymond and L. Carter. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED Mayor Cowles informed Council that the petitions would be forwarded to Pioneer Irrigation District. Councilman Raymond MOVED that the Mayor share with Pioneer by letter the City Attorney's opinion and that in the future requests for withdrawal from the District will be passed direct to them without action by this body. SECONDED by L. Carter. Councilwoman Mallea stated that she would agree with Councilman Raymond's motion if he would leave out the part where it says the Council will send with no recommendation. She felt that the City had an interest in this as a deliver of the product. Councilman Raymond said that he wanted to determine whether the Council was supportive of the City Attorney's opinion. Councilman Marmon commented that the Attorney's letter indicated that the Council could not say yes or no; it does not say that the Council cannot pass on an opinion. The Council was the Board for the Caldwell Municipal Irrigation system and he believed that the Council knowledgeable in what properties are served and could pass on a recommendation to Pioneer. It was an opinion and not a decision. Some of the properties involved in this case are served by irrigation water and have it available. It would be ridicules to grant a blanket approval for removal from the District. Book 27 Page 133 Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, J. Carter, L. Carter. Those voting no: Mallea,, Marcus, Marmon. The Mayor then voted yes as there was a tie vote. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED NEW BUSINESS (PUBLIC HEARING TO VACATE EASEMENTS IN TRACTS 14 AND 15 OF MOUNTAIN VIEW SUBDIVISION #k2) The Mayor asked if there was anyone in the audience who cared to speak to the public hearing to vacate easements in Tracts 14 and 15 of Mountain View Subdivision #k2. He explained that if there was anyone who cared to speak either for or against, it was necessary for them to sign up on a sheet provided. Councilwoman Marcus was requested to read the policy established for this sign up. As there was no one who cared to speak, the Mayor declared the Public Hearing open. No comments were received from the audience or the City Council. The Mayor then declared the public hearing closed. (BILL NO. 13 - ORDINANCE FOR THE ABOVE VACATION) Mayor Cowles requested that Councilman Raymond read Bill No. 13 in full as follows: AN ORDINANCE RECITING PETITION FOR VACATION AND RECITING APPROPRIATE NOTICE THEREFOR WAS GIVEN; AND DETERMING THAT VACATION OF SEWER EASEMENT DESCRIBED IN EXHIBIT A ATTACHED IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO. BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO: Section 1. That an application has been presented to the Mayor and Council of the City of Caldwell, Idaho, requesting passage and approval of an ordinance vacating the sewer easements described in Exhibit A attached and located in Tracts 14 and 15 of Mountain View Subdivision No. 2, the Plat of which is on file in Book 2 of Plats, Page 66, in the office of the Recorder of Canyon County, Idaho and through a portion of vacated Oregon Avenue; and that statutory notice was given to citizens and owners of property in the City of Caldwell, Idaho, in accordance with 50- 1306A, Idaho Code,; and, Section 2. That it is hereby determined it is in the best public interest that the sewer easements described in Exhibit A be vacated. Section 3. Be it ordained and established that the sewer easements described in Exhibit A and located in the City of Caldwell, Canyon County, Idaho, shall be vacated and shall no longer be subject to the use of the public; and thereupon title to said sewer easements shall pass and revert to the persons dedicating the same or their successors, heirs and assigns. Said sewer easement shall be vacated and shall pass and revert to the persons dedicating the same, or their successors, heirs and assigns in the manner in which they were so dedicated. Mrs. Robison presented some background for the City Council with regard to the vacation. The area was pointed out on a map as part of the explanation. The Shephards were planning to build a home on the corner of Maple and Idaho and in reviewing the building permit, it was noted that an easement ran through the middle of the property. Probably the 100 foot section in the middle was never obtained,. The sewer was put in on a different alignment along the other side of the Drain and does cross the Drain at Maple. The utilities were completed in L.I.D. 68. There was no need for the easements at this time, but you cannot build on an easement so there was a need for the vacation. The recommendation was that the vacation be approved. Book 27 Page 134 MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by L. Carter to dispense with the reading of a Bill at three separate times and that the Bill be passed on the first reading. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, Raymond, J. Carter, and L. Carter. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Mallea, SECONDED by L. Carter that Bill No. 13 be passed and entitled Ordinance No. 1728. Roll call vote. Those voting yes„ Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, Raymond, J. Carter, and L. Carter., Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED (AWARD BID FOR LINDEN DRAIN .PROJECT) Mayor Cowles informed the City Council that the request for bids was submitted and a firm from Nampa, Brown Construction, was the low bid. The City Engineer's recommendation was to award the bid to Brown Construction. MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Marmon that the low bid submitted by Brown Construction be accepted as recommended by the City Engineer. MOTION CARRIED (REQUEST FOR AUTHORIZATION TO BID 5TH STREET AND 9TH STREET DRAIN) Mayor Cowles informed the City Council that authorization was requested by the City Engineer from the Council to bid 5th Street and 9th Street drain. MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by Marmon that authorization be given to the City Engineer to bid 5th Street and 9th Street drain. MOTION CARRIED (RESOLUTION FOR PETITION ON REVISED CEMETERY RATES) The Mayor requested that Councilman J. Carter present the Resolution approving the revision of Cemetery fees. Councilman J. Carter stated that Council members received a copy of the petition adjusting the Cemetery fees. There was several very minor changes in the language made since the Council received their copy. A new section was going to be opened at the Cemetery in the next couple of years., The money in the Capital Improvement Fund was not sufficient enough to complete the platting and surveying. Therefore, the increase in costs was necessary and the change also cut down on the number of categories addressed previously. The Resolution was as follows: Be it Resolved that the fees and regulations set forth in the Petition attached hereto and made a part hereof as though set forth in full are hereby adopted by the Council, City of Caldwell. MOVED By J. Carter, SECONDED by Marcus that the Resolution be passed authorizing the adoption of the petition setting forth the Cemetery fees subject to the several minor changes. Book 27 Page 135 Roll call vote. Those voting yes: J. Carter, L. Carter, Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, and Raymond. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED (PLAT OF CREEKSIDE PATIO HOMES ON RAY AVENUE SOUTH OF LOGAN STREET) Mayor Cowles requested that Mrs. Robison address this item. Mrs. Robison passed out a drawing of the patio homes for the Council-Is purusal and explained that this represents completion of a development that was started about five or six years ago by Mr. Bushnell. This was located South of Logan, fronting on Ray Avenue. It was a planned unit development, a special use permit was issued by the Planning and Zoning Commission in 1981 and renewed .last year. There will be nine single family living units and a few will be attached by a common wall. Mrs. Robison further said that this presentation was for both the Preliminary and the Final Plat. All utilities were in, streets improved, and a sidewalk will be required along Ray Avenue. It was located in Pioneer Irrigation District and approval has not been forwarded as yet. City Council asked several questions with regard to the Plat after which it was MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by J. Carter that approval be given for the Preliminary and Final Plat as presented subject to approval from Pioneer Irrigation District. MOTION CARRIED (RESOLUTION ON 1986 AUDIT PROPOSAL) Mayor Cowles asked that the Finance Chairman, Councilman J. Carter, address this item on the Agenda. Councilman J. Carter read the Resolution as follows: RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CALDWEL,L AND MESSURI, BATES, AND GIBBONS TO PERFORM THE MUNICIPAL AUDIT FOR THE YEAR 1985 -86. BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and Clerk of the City of Caldwell be, and the same hereby are, authorized to execute that certain MUNICIPAL AUDIT - LETTER OF UNDERSTANDING Agreement attached hereto and made a part hereof as if set forth in full by and between the City of Caldwell and the Certified Public Accountant Firm of Messur:i, Bates, and Gibbons to be completed ninety days from receipt of records. MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by Raymond that the Resolution authorizing the execution of the Municipal Audit - Letter of Understanding be passed. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: J. Carter, L. Carter, Mallea, Marcus, Marmon, and Raymond. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED (REQUEST FOR MOBILE HOME CLASSROOM AT LINCOLN SCHOOL) Mrs. Robison explained to the City Council that she had talked this request over with Roy Payne from the School District. Basically, they would like to have a temporary classroom which will be situated between buildings at Lincoln School. It is not a unit that will require restrooms and they intended to use it for about a year. Councilman Raymond read the letter from the School as follows: Due to an additional program in our School District and a temporary shortage of classroom space, the District is requesting Book 27 Page 136 permission to locate a mobile unit at Lincoln School. The location to be between the main building and the kindergarten building. This is a temporary solution to the space problem and should be for the use of 86 -87 school year only. Both the City Building Inspector and the Assistant Fire Chief have inspected the site with me and have given their preliminary approval. Additional classrooms are planned for Wilson School in the summer of 1987. Your approval will allow us to adequately serve the hearing impaired students scheduled to use the mobile unit. The Council discussed the request and determined that they be allowed this unit until June 1, 1987. MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Marmon that the City Council grant the request for usage for the 1986 -87 school year. MOTION CARRIED (DISCUSSION WITH REGARD TO STREET LIGHTING DISTRICT ORDINANCE) Mayor Cowles stated that this item was included on the Agenda for information. Copies of a similar Ordinance from Coeur d'Alene were distributed to the Council and the Mayor asked that the City Council members review this document. Consideration of an Ordinance for the City of Caldwell would be brought to the Council at a later date. (RULES AND REGULATIONS FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF SEWER USE ORDINANCE) Councilman Raymond reminded Council that they were given copies of some definitions with respect to Rules and Regulations for implementation of sewer use ordinance. This issue goes back to when the new Treatment Plant was built when a recommended rate schedule was presented to Council. This was based on what it cost to treat certain types of waste. At that time it was considered too expensive to implement. The decision then was that the City would use the water flow to establish base sewer rate for Residential and one for Commercial. Residential users would be charged a sewer rate all year long based on their water usage in the winter months. Commercial was charged a sewer rate on their water usage at each billing period. This has brought about some inequities. Councilman Raymond said that he met with the City Engineer and the Water Department and discussed how to correct the inequities. A decision needed to be made as to applying the current rules as they are written, make a rate adjustment that would be equal by category of user, and establish a final rate structure. Councilman Raymond further suggested that he felt the City would have to go back to the categories and limit them to five. The Committee recommended Residential, those the City has contracts with (Dairymens), and the balance of the business community would be in three other categories. Their charge would be based upon water usage, but with the rate applied to the type of discharge put into the system. The City Council further discussed this report from Councilman Raymond. It was determined that Staff would be advised to proceed to establish the rules and the rate structure and present to the Council for action at a later time. (FINANCIAL REPORT) Councilman J. Carter reported that the bills were reviewed by the Finance Committee. The accounts payable for June totaled $330,566.97; salaries and fringe benefits totaled $238,596.70 making a total of $569,162.67. MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by Marcus that the report be accepted, the checks issued, and the Requests for Payment filed in the Office of the City Clerk. Book 27 MOTION CARRIED (COMMITTEE REPORTS) Page 137 Councilman Raymond asked Council members when they could meet to discuss the issues involving the contract with the Firemen. City Council agreed to meet on Thursday at 4:00 p.m. Councilman J. Carter reminded Council of the Stadium Board meeting the next day at Noon. Councilman Carter also said that there was a letter to the Council from the City Engineer with regard to sewer and water for the subdivision by Indian. Creek. Fie met with Mr. Redmond and was asked to present some figures and recommendations at this time to - -- see if the City could do part of the work. It was suggested that the City pay for the boring underneath both Indian Creek and the railroad tracks not only for the Lasher Subdivision but for future expansion. The estimated cost would be about $25,000 to do the boring under both of them. Money was budgeted in the Capital Improvement Fund for this fiscal year. MOVED by J. Carter, SECONDED by Marmon that the City proceed with the boring under Indian Creek and the Railroad with money as budgeted. MOTION CARRIED Councilman J. Carter also reported that they were still working on the budget and would have figures soon. Councilman L. Carter stated that he met with the Senior Citizens that morning. Their building fund is progressing and they are still hoping for a grant to finish the one room. Councilwoman Mallea said that the Committee appointed by the Mayor to entertain motions for a Pro at Purple Sage are in the process of doing so. It was found that a letter must be sent through the P.G.A. to notify Pros in the District of the position. Resumes are to be in City Hall by the 5th of August at which time the Committee will meet to review the resumes with the intent of setting up interviews. Councilwoman Marcus reported that she attended a Library Meeting on July 10th. There was 420 children signed of up for the summer reading program which is much higher than last year. Work was continuing on the doors at the Library. (MAYOR'S COMMNETS) Mayor Cowles reminded the City Council that on July 30th, at 11:00 a.m. at the Chamber of Commerce office, there will be a flag dedication in honor of Harry McCluskey. After the dedication, there was to be a luncheon at Simplot ball on the College of Idaho campus and a press conference at 1:20 p.m. that afternoon regarding Harry McCluskey and also for Mr. Simplot. The final report from CSHQA was available in his Office and he would ask Council to pick one up. August 14th, was the date selected for the Mayor's Rodeo dinner which will be held at the City Park at the Bandshell. Invitations have been sent out. On August 21st, the City of Caldwell will be sponsoring the Business After Hours. The Canyon County Fair will begin on August .1st. The Little Britches Rodeo was the 30th of July through the 2nd of August. Councilwoman also informed Council that the Buckaroo Breakfast was on the 9th of August, at 7:00 a.m. at the Park. The Caldwell Air Fair was the 10th of August. Book 27 Page 138 There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 9:00 P.M. APPROVED AS written THIS 4th DAY OF August I q A rl undilperson coun� z er 75E n i 1 e r slo n ATTEST: City C16rk