HomeMy WebLinkAbout1984-07-17council minutesBook 25 Page 159
REGULAR MEETING
July 17, 1984
7:30 p.m.
The Acting Mayor, Jack Carter, called the Meeting to order.
The Acting Mayor requested that everyone stand and give the
Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following
members present: Cowles, Raymond, and Norman. Absent: Mallea
and Marcus.
(APPROVAL OF MINUTES)
MOVED by Cowles, SECONDED by Norman. to dispense with the reading
of the minutes of the Regular City Council Meeting of July 3,
1984, the Regular City Council Meeting of July 10, 1984, and the
Special City Council Meeting of July 12, 1984, and approve them
as written.
MOTION CARRIED
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
The Acting Mayor asked if there was anyone from the audience who
cared to bring anything before the City Council that was not on
the prepared Agenda. As there was no one, he declared that the
meeting would continue as outlined.
OLD BUSINESS
(FIRSTREADING OF BILL NO. 11 - PROPOSED CHILD CARE LICENSING
ORDINANCE)
The Acting Mayor stated that the first order of business under
0ld Business was the first reading of Bill No. 11.
Councilman Raymond stated that he had some concerns with respect
to a first reading of a Bill that obviously has some public
interest. From the news media that day, he understood that there
was people invited to this meeting to present their input.
Councilman Raymond further said that he felt it was inappropriate
to consider this the first reading if there was to be public
input. His choice would be to move this item to the last item to
be discussed and make it into a form of public discussion on the
particular bill and not be a part of the Regular Meeting.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Cowles that the first reading of
Bill No. 11 be delayed until a later meeting and that it be
discussed at the end of the Regular Meeting and allow input from
the public.
MOTION CARRIED
NEW BUSINESS
(AWARD BID ON PUMP AND MOTOR FOR WELL #13)
Mrs. Robison reported that three bids were received and reviewed
by the City Engineer and the Water Superintendent. The bids were
received from Agri -Lines Irrigation, Inc., in the amount of
$15,069.33; Priest Electric in the amount of $13,588.00; and
Layne of Idaho, Inc., in the amount of $14,100.00. The
recommendation was to award the bid to Priest Electric in the
amount of $13,588.00.
MOVED by Cowles, SECONDED by Norman to award the bid to the low
bidder, Priest Electric, in the amount of $13,588.00.
MOTION CARRIED
Book 25
Page 160
(PUBLIC HEARING ON VACATION OF EASEMENTS AT HAPPY DAY BUSINESS
CENTER)
The Acting Mayor asked if there was anyone from the audience who
cared to sign the paper distributed to the audience in order to
speak for or against this vacation. As there was no one to sign
the paper, the Acting Mayor declared the Public Hearing open and
asked if any of the City Council members cared to discuss this
vacation of easements.
Councilman Raymond stated that the only comment he had was that
it was all within his own property and all he was doing was
changing what the original plan was on where to put some water
and sewer lines or provide for public easements.
Mrs. Robison was recognized and displayed the area on the
projector for the benefit of Council and the audience. The
following report from the City Engineer was also read:
The proposed vacation of the irrigation and utility
easements within Lots 1 thru 6 of Block 1 of the Happy Day
Business Center subdivision present only a couple of
problems. They concern both telephone and irrigation
facilities that have been previously installed wiihin the
easements for which vacation has been proposed.
1. Telephone - The telephone company has indicated that
they can abandon the telephone lines within the subject
easements and provide adequate service to the Happy Day
Center without relocating or replacing lines that will be
abandoned. Apparently the telephone company has sufficient
other circuitry to provide the service that the abandoned
lines would have provided. They are requesting
reimbursement from the developer to cover the installation
costs of the telephone lines they are abandoning. A letter
from the telephone company is attached.
2. Irrigation - The proposed development will construct a
structure over the existing alignment of a 15 inch
irrigation line. The developer has corrected this problem
by rerouting the irrigation fine around the perimeter of
their building and lot, for the portion of irrigation system
that will be in conflict. The construction of the relocated
irrigation line has been virtually completed. A problem has
been potentially created by this new construction as it
presently exists. The contractor, in installing the
relocated line, did not match the flow line grades of the
existing system and created a flow line differential of
approximately 15 inches where the old and new pipes correct
on the upstream junction point, (this will necessitate
reconstruction of a manhole), to reduce the potential for
debris blocking the pipe. This, should enable the system to
operate as efficiently as before.
The developer should be required to periodically clean the
basin to maintain its effectiveness. I contacted Dick
Suttle (upstream property owner) and discussed settlement
basin concept. He indicated this would be acceptable.
Recommended final conditions of vacation are:
1. Settlement with telephone company.
2. Relocation of irrigation line (done) and
construction and maintenance of settlement basin.
3. Dedication of new easement for new relocated
irrigation line.
4. Dedication of easement for existing irrigation line
parallel to Laster Lane for which a previous easement was
not filed.
Book 25
Page 161
As there was no other comments from the City Council members, the
Acting Mayor closed the Public Hearing. Acting Mayor Carter
informed the Council that there Bill No. 13 was prepared reciting
the petition for vacation as presented.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Cowles that the rules be suspended
requiring the reading of a Bill at three separate times and
reading the Bill in full, and that the Bill be read by title only
for one time and that Bill No. 13 be passed and entitled
Ordinance No. 1675 according to recommended final conditions of
the vacation as presented.
Acting Mayor Carter then read Bill No. 13 by title only as
follows:
AN ORDIANNCE RECITING PETITION FOR VACATION AND RECITING
APPROPRIATE NOTICE THEREFOR WAS GIVEN: DETERMINING THAT
VACATION OF THE UTILITY, DRAINAGE AND IRRIGATION EASEMENTS
ON THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED REAL PROPERTY, TO -WIT
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, Carter, Norman, and
Cowles. Those voting not none. Absent and not voting: Mallea
and Marcus.
MOTION CARRIED
(PUBLIC HEARING ON REZONE OF 2023 BLAINE FROM R -2 TO C -2 - JIM
VERMAAS)
Acting Mayor Jack Carter stated that he would open the Public
Hearing on a rezone of 2023 Blaine from R -2 to C -2. The Acting
Mayor then read the statement included as the heading to the
sign -up sheet that was distributed to members of the audience.
It was necessary for those who cared to speak to this issue to
sign the sheet when passed around.
The Acting Mayor stated that these was two signatures on the
sheet - Dr. McKinnon and Richard D. Suttle. Both gentlemen
stated that they would pass as they did not care to make any
comments. The Acting Mayor then asked for a presentation by Mrs.
Robison.
Mrs. Robison pointed out the property on a map for the benefit of
the Council members and the audience. Her staff evaluation and
analysis was as follows:
Applicants justification statement
A. Corner has become a heavy traffic area. 21st is a main
artery to and from the freeway to Cleveland and Blaine and
no longer desirable place for residence.
B. Public streets are adequate to use as a business due to
the proximity of other businesses utilities are also
adequate for business uses.
C. Land used as offices would be compatible with the
surrounding area because it would create more cosmetic
appearance as well as off street parking. More off - street
parking would create more street for traffic and less of a
hazard. Residents presently back out onto 21st street and
have to wait due to traffic waiting at the stop sign.
Administrative conclusions concerning
a) How land uses in the requested zone are related to the
Comprehensive Plan: The property is shown as medium density
residential on the Comprehensive Plan. It is adjacent to a
frame and service commercial designated area which includes
all of the land between 21st, the railroad tracks, Linden
and Cleveland and also from 21st at Arthur and northwesterly
to 18th. The zone change was considered under the
flexibility of zoning boundaries to reflect gradual changes
in use where zoning districts adjoin.
Book 25 'Page 162
b) Public facilities: Sewer, water 8 inch line in 21st are
adequate. Traffic pattern shown by Mr. Vermaas of entering
on 21st and exiting on Blaine should create smoother flow
than to exit onto 21st with the stop sign traffic.
c) Blaine and 21st are arterials. Blaine carries traffic
from many commercial uses such as Safeway, Red Steer, Coast
to Coast, Taco Time and Stadium and Fieldhouse activities.
d) Compatibility of allowable uses with the surrounding
area: Mr. Vermaas is requesting the zone change for an
office but this would open up the property to anything
allowable in the C -2 zone. These uses would be limited by
the size of the property from anything that would impact the
neighborhood by creating a lot of traffic.
e) Taking into consideration the location of the property
across 21st from Victor's and down from the bowling alley,
commercial and industrial uses on 21st, there are generally
mixed uses where the commercial and residential zones join.
Staff recommends the zone change from R -2 to C -2 as the property
would be suitable for limited commercial uses.
The Acting Mayor then asked for any comments from the City
Council. Councilman Cowles asked Mr. Vermaas what type of office
use he was planning for the location. Mr. Vermaas stated that he
did not have a specific tenant in mind as yet. He did say that
he planned to make it an attractive building and had visited with
all the neighbors in the area regarding the zone request.
Councilman Cowles expressed concern about the fact that Mr.
Vermaas had made improvements with the property before any
decision was made with regard to the zoning. Mrs. Robison
explained that Mr. Vermaas was told that anything he did with the
property, he did at his own risk because if the zone change did
not go through, it would be money clone.
The Acting Mayor then closed the Public Hearing and asked for
action from the City Council.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Norman to dispense with the rules
requiring the reading of a Bill at three separate times and that
it be read in full and read Bill No. 14 by title only for one
reading and the Bill be then passed and entitled Ordinance No.
1676.
The Acting Mayor then read Bill No. 14 by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING THE ZONING OF CERTAIN PROPERTY WITHIN THE
CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, FROM R -2 MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL TO
C -2 COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL AND DETERMINING THAT SAID CHANGE IN
ZONING IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO;
REPEALING ALL LAWS, ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS IN CONFLICT
HEREWITH.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, Carter, Norman, and
Cowles, Those voting no: none. Absent and not voitng: Mallea
and Marcus.
MOTION CARRIED
(FINANCIAL REPORT)
Councilman Norman reported that t'.�e bills were gone over very
closely by the Committee. There was a total accounts payable for
$287,034.57; total payroll of $220,562.31. All was in order.
MOVED by Norman, SECONDED by Cowles that the checks be issued and
the Requests for Payment be filed in the Office of the City
Clerk.
Book 25 Page 163
MOTION CARRIED
(COMMITTEE REPORTS)
Councilman Norman reported that he met with the Golf Board and
their budget was put together. All was in order as far as the
Golf was concerned.
Councilman Raymond informed the Council that he represented the
Mayor and the City at a luncheon for Miss Rodeo of America and
Idaho.
(MAYOR'S COMMENTS)
Acting Mayor Carter stated that a letter was received from the
County Commissioners requesting that the City release the phone
numbers they have been holding for the 9 -1 -1 Program, Councilman
Raymond said that he and Councilwoman Mallea had not had an
opportunity to meet yet and discuss this item. He assured the
Council that he would contact Councilwoman Mallea when she
returned from vacation and they would meet with the County
representatives.
The Acting Mayor further said that there was a request for
appointment of Gary Carpenter to the Appeals Board and Loren
Turner as an alternate to the Board.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Cowles that the appointments as
stated be approved.
MOTION CARRIED
(GENERAL DISCUSSION AND WORKSHOP ON PROPOSED CHILD CARE FACILITY
LICENSING)
The Acting Mayor then opened the meeting for discussion from the
audience with regard to the proposed child care facility
licensing. A number of people spoke both pro and con including
Gene Betts, Ida Mae Whitman, Donna ;tenor, Anita Friscopp, Carey
Howe, Lisa Morrow, Annie Smith, and Marta Jensen. The main
points discussed were with regard to the types of facilities, the
number of children allowed, it was stated that the staff child
ratio was difficult to comprehend, insurance should not be
required, it was too complicated as written now, whether it will
be tied in with the State License and the resulting complications
if it was, the fee was too high.
The Acting Mayor thanked those who were in attendance and for
their remarks. The Council would take into consideration all
suggestions made and the Bill would be addressed again at a
future meeting.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at
8:45 p.m.
APPROVED AS written
August. , 1984.
o 1p
Cou" nc
Coun l�
ATTEST:
i, Q
/ nn
DAY OF
Cite lerk