HomeMy WebLinkAbout1981-06-02city council minutesBook 22 Page 150
REGULAR MEETING
June 2, 1981
7:30 p.m.
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor McCluskey.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members
present: Williams, Raymond, Hopper, Carter, and Betts. Absent:
Mallea.
(APPROVAL OF MINUTES)
MOVED by Williams, SECONDED by Carter to dispense with the reading
of the minutes of the Regular City Council Meeting of May 19, 1981,
and the Regular City Council Meeting of May 27, 1981, and approve
them as written.
MOTION CARRIED
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
The Mayor asked if there was anyone in the audience who cared to
bring anything before the City Council that was not on the prepared
Agenda. The Mayor explained that if there was anyone present who
cared to address the pornography issue, it was on the prepared
Agenda. Also, the raw milk was to be discussed. Since there was
no one else who cared to discuss an issue with the City Council, the
Mayor declared that the Meeting would continue as outlined.
OLD BUSINESS
(BILL N0. 12 - MILK ORDINANCE RECOMMENDED CHANGE)
The Mayor explained that he had put together a sample ordinance
and amendment of the present Ordinance the City now has which does
not allow raw milk in the City of Caldwell. The Mayor then read the
Bill in full as follows:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND TITLE VII, CHAPTER 2 OF THE MUNICIPAL
CODE OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, STATE OF IDAHO, REGARDING MILK CODE
BY DELETING AND ADDING CERTAIN LANGUAGE PROVIDING FOR ADOPTION
OF CODE; PERMITS; AND FEES; AND REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES,
RESOLUTIONS, ORDERS OR PARTS THEREOF IN CONFLICT HEREWITH.
BE I.T ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, COUNTY OF CANYON, STATE OF IDAHO:
Section 1. That Section 1, Chapter 2, Title VII of the
Municipal Code of the City of Caldwell be repealed.
Section 2. That Section 2, Chapter 2, Title VII of the
Municipal Code of the City of Caldwell be amended to read as
follows:
7 -2 -1: PERMITS: From the date on which this Chapter takes effect,
no milk or milk products shall be sold to the final consumer,
or to restaurants, soda fountains, grocery stores, or similar
establishment, except certified pasteurized and Grade A
pasteurized milk. Certified raw milk may be sold to the final
consumer rowed a sign be posted in a prominent place stating,
"This case contains raw milk. Raw milk sold in this store must
be labeled so the consuming public can readily distinguish raw
from pasteurized milk pravided;- that -w ex If any milk
distributor fails to qualify far- one -of- the - above - grades under
above stipulations the Health Officer is authorized to
suspend his permit.
Section 3. That Section 3, Chapter 2, Title VII of the
Municipal Code of the City of Caldwell be amended to read as follows:
7 -2 -2: FEES: A distributor of milk or milk products sold to the
final consumer, or to restaurants, soda fountains, grocery
stores, or similar establishments shall pay to the City of
Caldwell an annual fee of five - dollars- ($5-983 ten dollars
($10.00) on January 2 of each year for a permit to distribute
milk or milk products within the corporate limits of the City
of Caldwell for the calendar year in which the permit is issued
or any portion thereof.
Book 22 Page 1S1
Section 4. All ordinances or parts of ordinances
inconsistent herewith are hereby repealed.
Section S. This ordinance shall be in fullforce and
effect from and after its passage, approval, and publication
according to law.
Councilman Carter informed the Mayor that he did not receive a
copy of the proposed change in the Code. The Mayor explained that
he gave copies to the members of the Committee that were asked to
study the raw milk issue and present the Bill to the City Council.
Councilman Hopper stated that he understood that it was not
necessary to have three readings of an Ordinance that was
intended to repeal an existing Ordinance. On that premise, he
would MOVE that the Ordinance pass; SECONDED by Raymond.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Hopper, Betts, Raymond. Those
voting no: Carter and Williams. Absent and not voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
(REVEREND GREENE ON PORNOGRAPHY)
The Mayor asked if Reverend Richard Greene would come forward to
present his discussion with regard to pornography. The Mayor
further commented that he would like to bring before the City
Council and the audience information that he had received from the
City Attorney with regard to pornography.... There was
feeling that the City Council was unable to accept the proposed,
ordinance that Reverend. Greene was going to present because of
these portions. Reverend Greene had given the Mayor a copy of his
suggested Ordinance and the Mayor reported that he had taken a copy
over to the City Attorney. Mr. Morrison, the City Attorney, came
back to the Mayor stating that the proposed. Ordinance could not be
passed and explained why. Further, the Mayor said that Reverend
Greene convinced him before this meeting that this might not
necessarily be true. What Reverend Greene said to him was very
convincing.
The Mayor then proceeded to discuss portions of the Idaho Code
beginning with one section entitled, "Who may maintain action
The attorney general, prosecuting attorney, or any private resident
citizen' and does not mention a City. The only possible fallacy
in this was that the City does not try its own cases. If the City
was to file a complaint, it would go to the Prosecuting Attorney
regardless. Another section that states, "Costs - If the action is
brought by a private person and the court finds that there were no
reasonable grounds or probable cause for bringing said action, and
the case is dismissed for that reason before trial, or if the action
is dismissed for want or prosecution, the costs may be taxed to such
person." The Mayor stated that frankly this was one of the
things that the City was afraid cf. The last time that the City
fought one of these cases it cost them $14,000 and that was with
regard to two films. This was an. affort on the City's part that
they really could not .afford at that time, and the City really could
not afford it at this time. There was also additional County costs.
The City was, therefore, very apprehensive about fighting a battle
for the State of Idaho. The Mayor stated that he personally was
one hundred percent in favor of what the group of ministers
advocate. His reason was slightly different as it was based on
good sound business judgment in that these places were very
detrimental to the community as they depreciated property values.
The Mayor stated that both he and the Council felt that the State.___,
should be carrying the ball as they were the ones that passed it.
In addition to passing this law, they also stated that this was their
law and the City could not pass anything tougher than theirs.
Under the section on obscene materials, the City Attorney underlined
the portion where it states "to minors ". Another section underlined
by the City Attorney was with regard to Uniform enforcement -
"Abrogation of existing ordinances - further local ordinances
banned - In order to make the application and enforcement of this
act uniform throughout the state, it is the intent of the
legislature to preempt, to the exclusion of city and county
Book 22
Page 152
governments, the regulation of the sale, loan, distribution,
dissemination, presentation or exhibition to a minor of material
which is obscene or which is harmful to minors and depicts in whole
or in part nudity, sexual conduct or sado - masochistic abuse. To
that end, it is hereby declared that every city or county ordinance
adopted before the effective date of this act which deals with the
regulation of the sale, loan, distribution diseemination, presentatior
or exhibition to a minor of material which is obscene or which is
harmful to minors and depicts in whole or in part nudity, sexual
conduct or county ordinance adopted before the effective date of
this act which deals with the regulation of the sale, loan,
distribution, dissemination, presentation or exhibition to a minor
of material which is obscene or which is harmful to minors and
depicts in whole or in part nudity, sexual conduct or sado-
masochistic abuse shall stand abrogated and unenforceable on or
after such effective date; and that no city or county government shall
have the power to adopt any ordinance relating to the regulation of
the sale, loan, distribution, dissemination, presentation or
exhibition to a minor of material which is obscene or which is
harmful to minors and depicts in whole or in part nudity, sexual
conduct or sado - masochistic abuse, on or after such effective date."
The Mayor further informed them that what the Attorney was trying to
bring forth was that of the city was to try to improve on this
State Code as it stands now and make it tougher the City would not
be allowed to doso by State Code itself. What it was saying was
that the City could not make the Statute any tougher than the State
has already enacted.
The Mayor then recognized Reverend Greene who stated that he
appreciated the opportunity of being able to appear before the City
Council to give his presentation. He explained that he had spent
several months educating himself as to what material was available
in Caldwell with regard to pornography. During this time, he had
become sick, angry and determined. The proposed Ordinance he
wanted to present was not trying to define obscenity, but was a
minor's display law.
The Supreme Court recognized in 1968 that parents, City fathers, and
Legislatures and anyone else involved in Government in this country
have a responsibility to protect the welfare of the children. In
other words, we could take more stringent action to protect our
youth by having to be confronted by materials that show multiple
sex acts, homosexuality, lesbians, and etc. The material that was
available in the City of Caldwell was shocking and it was a problem
that was being addressed all over;the country at this time. In
the State of Rhode Island they have passed a display law that
was worded exactly as the one he would like to present. It was
Reverend Greene's feeling that pronography will leave when the
people were ready to have it leave. The problem he wanted to
address was convenient stores, grocery stores, and novelty stores
here in Caldwell with sexually explicit material where minors have
availability to the area. Things that he believed could be violating
the State Code by their covers.
Reverend Greene then read the following letter addressed to the
elected officials:
In light of the amount of materials available in the Caldwell
area of an objectionable nature in areas frequented by minors
I have attached a suggested City Ordinance Display Law for
your consideration.
1 am familiar with the Idaho State Statutes on obscenity, but
point out to you that this is a Public Display- Minors Law
dealing with "objectionable" publication, pictures, articles.
I urge you in light of the materials you yourself have had
an opportunity to see that are available in our city to take
the most immediate action on this matter.
Reverend Greene read through the proposed ordinance regarding the
sale or exhibition to minors of ind_�cent publications, pictures, or
articles and explained that each member of the City Council was
given a copy for study. Reverend Greene pointed out that this
ordinance does not try to define obscenity and that he felt this
was a law that was enforceable. The Supreme Court has already
Book 22
Page 153
determined that the City can pass more stringent legislation
suppressing the reading material for children.
The Mayor then stated that he would open the meeting for discussion
from the audience. Among those recognized were Steve Bonde who
objected as he felt it was discriminatory to pick on businesses
with the magazines when they should be fair and to it to everyone.
Others recognized were Reverend. Crane, Shirley Neville, Pat Doogan,
Jack Cook, and Jim Win.'�igler.
The Mayor then stated that he would now confine the conversation
to the City Council. After discussion, the Mayor informed the
Council that this issue would have to go back to the City Attorne;
for his opinion as the State Code deals with obscenity. The
Supreme Court has not made it clear as to what obscenity was.
Councilwoman Williams asked if it would be in line to make a motion
that the Mayor and Reverend Greene work with the City Attorney to
see if this proposed ordinance was legal and if not, what was legal.
The Mayor stated that this would be in line and he would encourage
the City Attorney to direct the City of Caldwell to the Attorney
General. Councilwoman Williams further commented that the Council
has to rely on the opinion that the City Attorney has given them.
MOVED by Williams, SECONDED by Carter that the Mayor and Reverend
Greene take the proposed ordinance to the City Attorney to see if
he actually feels that it would be legal and that the City Attorney
pursue it to the Attorney General's Office.
MOTION CARRIED
NEW BUSINESS
(CERTIFICATES OF APPOINTMENT)
The Mayor stated that he was pleased to have the opportunity
to appoint two young adults to the Cougar Connection. He further
explained that this was a group of young people consisting of
about twelve young men and women who will be responsive to the "
City of Caldwell, not only for the needs of the City, but also in
their needs. During the last year, it has worked out very well as
they were involved in getting the new lights at the park. The
Connection has collected about $8,000 to help with the Preserve Our
Parks Program. The Mayor then presented Pat Collins, Bryan. Stanwood,
and T. J. I- Iopper with Certificates of Appointment to the Cougar
Connection.
The Mayor stated that in addition to the Cougar Connection, there
was also members of the High School that serve as members of adult
Commissions in the City. One of them was the Planning and. Zoning
Commission and the other was on the Recreation Commission where the
young members have a voting right. The student member of the
Planning and Zoning Commission was not allowed to vote. The Mayor
then stated that he would like to present a Certificate of
Apppointment to T. J. hopper for the Planning and Zoning Commission
and a Certificate of Appointment to Bryan Stanwood for the Recreatior
Commission.
The Mayor also asked Bryan Stanwood to introduce to the Council
the two young ladies that were attending the meeting with him.
They were Angela Braun and Jennifer Memmelaar. The Mayor asked .
if the girls would have any interest in becoming members of the
Cougar Connection and they did indicate an interest.
(RECESS CALLED)
It was then MOVED by Carter, SECONDED by Hopper that a five minute
recess be called.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor reconvened the City Council Meeting at 8:30 p.m.
Book 22
Page 154
(RESOLUTION N0. 25 -81 - ESTABLISH MEXICAN AMERICAN ADVISORY COMMITTEE)
The Mayor presented the following Resolution which he read in
full as follows:
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ESTABLISH A COMMITTEE
KNOWN AS THE MEXICAN AMERICAN ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor of the City of Caldwell,
and the same hereby is, authorized to establish a Committee
known as the Mexican American Advisory Committee for the
purpose of establishing better relations and understanding of
the Mexican American Community in the City of Caldwell.
MOVED by Carter, SECONDED by Raymond that Resolution No. 25 -81 be
passed establishing a Committee known as the Mexican American
Advisory Committee.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Carter, Betts, Williams,
Raymond, and Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent and not
voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
(PRELIMINARY PLAT OF DE LA CHERIE TOWNHOUSES)
The Mayor called on the City Engineer, Mr. Lewis, to give his
report with regard to the Preliminary Plat of De La Cherie
Townhouses.
Mr. Lewis explained that the Plat was located on Brookside Drive
South of Ash. The Planning and Zoning Commission reviewed the
Preliminary Plat and recommended that the Preliminary Plat be
adopted by the City Council subject to the Engineer's report. The
Engineer's report was as follows:
A special use permit has been issued by the Planning and
Zoning Commission for a planned unit development within the
boundaries of the proposed plat. The plat is one of the
conditions of the issuance of the permit.
Under the variance procedure of the subdivision ordinance,
approval of the preliminary would approve the following
variances:
Inside lot frontages less than 60 feet.
Inside lot areas less than 6,000 square feet.
Lot 6 -11 will front on a private r/w to be constructed
and maintained in accordance with the covenants
required on the property.
The right of way of Brookside Drive is to remain 50 feet
in width as deeded many years ago and to remain the
same width as the r/w of Brookside Drive, both north
and south of the proposed plat.
Acceptance of the final plat will require the owner to provide
the following improvements:
Extension of the sanitary sewer in Brookside Drive.
The improvement of Brookside Drive with curb, gutter,
pavement and sidewalks.
Subject the properties to the water main extension policy
and the policy for prepayment of 850 of the water
services at the time of installation.
Provide a separate water service for every separate
ownership.
Provide a storm sewer in Brookside Drive and Ash Street
from the north side of the platted area.
Approval of Pioneer Irrigation District for the irrigation
system.
Underground electric power and telephone.
The application states that it is the intention for completing
Book 22 Page 155
the improvements by the L.I.D. financing method. A
petition has been filed with the City for the purpose of
determining the desire of the property owners, not only within
the platted area, but also involving other owners adjacent to
Brookside Drive from Ash Street to the presently improved secti.o
of Brookside Drive in Sunnybrook Village Subdivision to the
south.
Acceptance of the plat by the City means the improvements will b
provided irrespective of the L.T.D. The enforcement of the
improvements would eventually be provided by issuance of
building permits.
MOVED by Williams, SECONDED by Betts that the City Council accept
the Preliminary Plat o'f De La Cherie Townhouses subject to
provisions explained in the City Engineer's report.
MOTION CARRIED
(COMMITTEE REPORTS)
Councilwoman Williams stated that she would request the Mayor notify
the Canyon County Organization on Aging his recommendation for a new
member to their Organization by July Ist.
Councilwoman Williams also reported that she attended the Library
Meeting and they will not be on line with the Computer as soon as
planned. Their budget was done and approved. Mrs. Dunlap was
planning to retire and a new Librarian would be selected sometime
in August.
Councilman Hopper stated that he was unable to make it to the
Airport Commission Meeting and would defer a report to the Mayor.
The Mayor reported that the Standard Operating Procedures were
approved by the City Attorney and he stated that the City did a
fine job writing them.
(DECISION TO BID POLICE CARS)
Councilman Raymond staged that he would
bills on the police cars as they have b
understanding that it was the intention
purchase new police cars and it was not
goes in to purchase them or waits until
year, it seemed to him that the bidding
like to discuss the repair
yen very high. It was his
at the first of the year to
done. Whether the City
going into the new budget
should begin.
It was then MOVED by Raymond that the Police Chief be authorized
to bid three new patrol cars.
Some discussion pursued with regard to looking at the leasing of the
cars as well as the purchase. The Mayor stated that he would. like to
have the Police Chief look at both possibilities.
Councilman Raymond then amended his motion to state that the Police
Chief be authorized to receive bids and /or check on leasing three
patrol cars. SECONDED by Carter.
Councilman Hopper questioned as to whether it should not be stated
that this would be subject to funds available. Councilman
Raymond stated that his intent was to bid them in order to see
what monies it would take. The Mayor suggested that there was to
be a budget workshop the first of the week and that the
feasibility of purchasing the patrol cars be discussed at that time.
Councilman Hopper called for the question.
The Mayor asked for a vote on the motion.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION NO. 26 -81 - CHANGE ORDERS TO AGREEMENT WITH VIPCO)
The Mayor called on Mr. Lewis, City Engineer, to discuss this item.
Mr. Lewis stated that following the noon discussion regarding change
Book 22
Page 156
orders, he drew up a Resolution authorizing the Mayor to execute
change orders to the Agreement with Valley Inland Pacific
Constructors, Inc. Mr. Lewis read Resolution No. 26 -81 in full as
follows:
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING MAYOR TO EXECUTE CHANGE ORDERS TO THE
AGREEMENT WITH VALLEY INLAND PACIFIC CONSTRUCTORS, INC., FOR
WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT EXPANSION.
BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor of the City of Caldwell,
Idaho, be and the same hereby is authorized to execute Change
Orders Number 2, 7, 12, 15, and 16 to the Agreement for
Wastewater Treatment Plant Expansion E. P. A. Project Number
C -16- 0201 -03 attached hereto and made a part hereof as if set
forth in full by and between the City of Caldwell, Idaho, and
Valley Inland Pacific Constructors, Inc.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Betts to pass Resolution No. 26 -81
as presented by Mr. Lewis.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, Hopper, Carter,
Betts, and Williams. Those voting no: none. Absent and not
voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
Mr. Lewis also stated that he had written a memorandum to Herb
Shearmire with regard to the authorization to pay change orders
for the Treatment Plant Update Project. Mr. Lewis read this memo
for the City Council as follows:
After lengthy and involved discussion with Jim Walker, Project
Engineer from Parametrix, and Dan Baer of the Idaho Department
of Health and Welfare regarding the change orders listed
below and in accordance with the discussions with the Council
at the noon meeting June 2, 1 would recommend that the change
orders be paid..
These change orders and identification of the amounts are listed
below:
Change Order
Number Descript Amount
2 Excavation and backfill - $ 16,135.00
chlorine contact basin and
sand filer.
7 Re -route conduits and wiring 2,464.00
to trickling filter pump.
12 Delete louvers in chlorine 1,255.00
building doors, etc.
14 Substitute pumps in relocated -0-
irrigation wells.
15 Relocate boiler. 40,595.00
16 Install new style circuit 575.00
breakers in MCC "P"
6. 014.00
Since the change orders are being paid prior to final approval by
the State Health Department and by E.P.A. and prior to the submission
of the May estimate to the City by Parametrix, it is my recommendation
the Council give specific approval for the payment.
All of the change orders with the exception of No. 15 have been
executed by the City and sent to the State Health Department (the
approving agency). Change order 15 was previously approved by the
Council in their discussions with representatives of the State Health
Department, Parametrix and City personnel.
Book 22
Page 157
Mr. Lewis :Further commented that he would recommend that there be
a minute entry that this was being paid.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Carter that authorization be given
for payment of the change orders as discussed out of the Sewer Fund.
MOTION CARRIED
(EXECUTIVE SESSION CALLED)
The Mayor then stated it would be necessary to convene into an
Executive Session to discuss personnel.
MOVED by Carter, SECONDED by Hopper that the City Council convene
into an Executive Session pursuant to the Idaho Code as requested
by the Mayor.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Carter, Betts, Williams,
Raymond, and Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent and not
voting: Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
There being no further business, the Meeting was adjourned at
9:20 p.m.
APPROVED AS written THIS 16th DAY Or June 1951.
Councilman
C- n ilman Councilman
A
ouncilman Councilman
f /
Mayor
ATTEST:
:- ��
City Cler<