Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1972-05-25city council minutes09N COUNCIL CHAMBERS May 25, 1972 7:00 P.M. The Council met pursuant to call and ackndo-ledgement of notice in the following form: We, the undersigned Mayor and Members of the City Council of the City of Caldwell, Idaho, hereby acknowledge notice of a Special Meeting of the said City Council to be held in the Council Chambers in the 'City Hall of Caldwell, Idaho, at the hour of 7:00 o'clock P.M. on the 25th day of May, 1972, for the trans- action of all business in connection with the following object: Presentation of the Sewer System Planning by CH2M and a Change of Zoning. Witness our signatures this 25th day of May, 1972: Mayor - Councilman Count Councilman Mayor Charles W. Carpenter presiding. Upon Roll Call, the following Councilmen answered present: Alfred H. McCluskey, C. A. "Chet" Davenport, Joe Gamboa and Lester E. Carter. Absent: Charles C. Banks and James R. Dakan. Zone change Agricultural to "CD" Commercial approved Mayor Carpenter informed the Council that Mr. Doane Wolfe had purchased 34.29 acres of land betwea Cleveland Boulevard and the railroad tracks, one half mile out of the city limits and was requesting from the County a change of zoning from agricultural to "CD" Commercial. He explained to the Council that it was nec- essary for the City to approve the action of the County Planning and Zoning Commission in allowing it to be changed from agricultural to "CD" Commercial. Upon question, Mayor Carpenter stated that Mr. Wolfe wanted to use the property for an automobile dealership, including auto repair, used car sales and related business. Councilman McCluskey moved, Councilman Carter seconded, that the acLibn of the County Planning and Zoning Commission, changing all property requested by Duane Wolfe, from agricultural to "CD" Commercial, be approved by the City. Upon vote, the motion carried. Sewer System Planning Report The Mayor then turned the meeting over to Mr. Earl Reynolds of CH2M for the presentation of the study of the sewer system. Mr. Reynolds stated that this study began about throe years ago when the J. R. Simplot Company, in connection with the City, began a rsconnaisance study of the sewer System. He then presented Mr. Jerry Eggleston who, with the use of visual aids, presented the sewer system planning of CH2M. Mr. Eggleston first showed maps depicting the existing sewer system and the proposed extensions• fl explained that the present Treatment Plant is a trickling flow filter -type plant, but that this type plant Is now approaching its capacity of 5,000 pounds of organic load, and added that, at times, this capacity is ex- ceeded. He stated that the plant presently is in good condition and had been wall maintained. Mr. Eggleston showed a graph depicting the monthly flow into the sewage system. This graph showed the average flow and the maximum flow, which during the peak months did exceed xapacity. Another graph illustrated the projected population and industrial growth in the future and the pro- jected increase of flow as a result. Mr. Eggleston added that not only was there an increase in flow, but the standards set up by the government have also increased. At present, it is required that there be an 85% removal of the organic material, and in the future this will be increased to 92 %; and he added that the slu system is capable of 90 to 95 percent removal. He further commented that the irrigation disposal Watem had been used by various industries to remove industrial wastes, such as Sumner disposal of wastes for canneries, and added that this system of disposal was more or less in the experimental stage, but that it had been used the year around; also it had been proven that the wastes can be removed to meet the present standards, and the "no pollutant standard" by the year 1985. Mr. Eggleston then added that the decision of whether to use the irrigation system was up to the Council; that this had been added to the study as in alternative, and the gh the system works well, it is still in the experimental stage, He mentioned that because the irrigation sys- tem and the sludge system were so close in cost, both systems were developed in the financing part of the 303 stud so the Council could see what would be charged and what kind of bond issue would have to be passed. He added that the projected total annual cost of treating the sewage of the Dairymen's Creamery would be slightly under $48,000.00 and for the Idaho Meat Packers it would be $77,000.00. Mr. Eggleston commented that several grant programs were available which could be utilized in the initial cost of the systems; and added that 50% of the cost would be provided by the Federal government and 25% by the State, with Federal money going as high as 80% if the facilities met the standards. Mr. Eggle also mentioned that there were two bills before Congress to modify the present grant formula --one is essen- tially the same as presently used, but would change the different uses between the State and Federal; the other would anticipate a maximum of 90% State and Federal grants combined, leaving the local at 10 %. Mr. Eggleston stated that the 75% grant is for the treatment facilities and the plant itself. He added that these grants also apply to the interceptor portion of the sewer. And for the lateral portion, t hi Department of Housing and Urban Development have funds - -50$ of the construction cost of the eligible facili- ty; and he mentioned that this is basically the system that is designed to provide capacity for future ex- tensions. Mr. Egglestion stated that 1.7 million dollars is the cost for the construction of the initial Sys tem. The anticipated HUD grant for the basic system would be in the amount of about $400,000.00. These two grants for the interceptor on 21st Street would be about one third of a million dollars. This w uld leave just under one million dollars to be raised by a bond issue. At capacity, this would serve 1300 acres, but would initially serve only 130 existing services of 9% of the people in that area. He added that, in addition to the bond issue and in order to finance Sias, there would have to be an increase in residential and commercial rates - -a monthly charge of 600 for connection and charge of approx imately 7;�O per square foot on a local Improvement District. Mr. Eggleston stated that 10$ of the summer flow to the Treatment Plant and 70% of the organic loa is contributed by Dairymen's Creamery and Idaho Meat Packers. 20,% of tie summer flow is sewage and 70% is ground water, which is infiltrated into the sewer system. Without the infiltration, the flow into the plait would be about 10 million gallons per day by 1990, and the organic load will be about double from teat it is now. He added that the irrigation system could meet the current standard and also t1m projected long -term standard. He stated that the average monthly charge for the average residence would be about $4.45 for the sludge system and about $5.10 for the irrigation disposal system. He added that the charges for Dairymen's Creamery would be from $42,000.00 to $47,000.00 per year under each system. For the Idaho Moak Packers, the charge would be under $40,000.00 per year for the irrigation disposal system and about $37,000.00 for the sludge system. He cited the decisions that the City had to make. The first was whether to participate in the con struction of the initial sewer system located southeast of the City and to North Ustick Road. He stated the CH2M had suggested that this might be financed with a charge of 600 per month, plus a local Improvement Dis- I trict assessment. In order to develop the Treatment Plant, he stated that CH2M had suggested that the City adopt a program for systematic testing of the effectiveness with which the infiltration into the system can be rem d so that the final design criteria can be based upon maximal removal of the infiltration into the system. In Order to put the City's name in the priority system of applications, he stated that CR2M recom- mends that the Council authorize an amendment to the 1971 application which was made jointly with J. R. Simplot Company in order to update that, since J. R. Simplot Company is no longer involved. He added that the application would have to be in preliminary form as there would be the sludge system and the alternate irrigation disposal system. Mr. Eggleston noted that the cost to industry with these facilities was very high, but that induct would have time to look into the problem and investigate the alternates open to them, such as individual treatment of their wastes. After this had been done, then further testing could be done to see what their 304 load would be at that time. He stated that Idaho Meat Packers had already lessened their load since the teAt ing was done in 1971, and that likely further changes would be made by the time this plan would be ready to proceed. He stated that another decision was whether the Council would want to accept the alternate irriga- tion disposal system, and added that this could be delayed until Congress does something on the two bills before it so that the fttuts standard& could be ascertained. Mr. Eggleston then told the Council that following this decision and the above steps, a prs imina design report stating the changes that industry has made, an evaluation of the irrigation disposal system would have to be made and more detailed work on the irrigation disposal system would have to be done if the Council chose to follow that line. He then stated that upon completion of the pre - design report, the amount of the bond issue to pro- vide the facilities would be known, and after the passage df the bond, the final design of the facilities would be undertaken. He stated that the proposed schedule for the sewer system was a Bond Election in RTovember of 1973, with construction beginning in the fall of 1974 and continuing through the fall of 1975. Councilman McCluskey inquired how far the land would be located from the disposal site if the irri- gation disposal system were used. Mr. Eggleston replied that it would be at least five miles away as it would be necessary to go that far in order to obtain the required acreage of 500 to h,000 acres. Councilman Davenport then inquired as to what kind of crops could be raised on this land. Mr. Eggleston answered that forage, hay, possibly sugar beets could be raised. He added that any crop that was processed to remove the bacteria could be raised, also beef cattle could be raised, however, dairy cows could not be pastured on this for very long. Counoilman Banks asked if this sytem of irrigation disposal was in use ary place in Idaho, to which Mr. Eggleston replied that he didn't think so. Councilman Carter asked if this wasn't a very new system in sewage disposal, and Mr. Reynolds re- plied that this system had been used in Idaho during the summer to take care of industrial wastes. Councilman McCluskey asked if there would be any harmful bacteria or odor in regards to this system Mr. Reynolds replied that it would have harmful bacteria in the primary step and would have to be heavily chlorinated before being used for irrigation. He added that the only way there would be an odor would be if in the summer, the fun off collected and it got hot enough, then there might be an odor. Mr. Reynolds said that in the purchase of the land it may be less expensive to go further than the five miles out in that the land would be cheaper as it is gust grassland now and relatively inexpensive. He added that one of the bills before Congress provided for Federal funds to help pay for the cost of the land, if the irrigation disposal system were adopted and, this would be a factor in the decision. He concluded that it might be at least two more years before the Council would decide just which proposal to accept. Mr. Keith Burnquist of Dairymen's Creamery inquired as to where CH2M had acquired their figures. He stated that the Creamery had run a survey with the Arey Corp of Engineers, and the result was much lower than what the CH2M report showed. Mr. Reynolds replied that the test was run in November, 1971, and was run on the two main waste streams that go into the City sewer system. This was sampled on a 24 hour basis, once an hour. The composite samples where then analyzed by standard methods used by Treatment Plant personnel. Mr. Burnquist stated that the Creamery had run about 300 tests on their sewage and had never come up with figures that CH2M had provided. Mr. Reynolds sid that the study had been made with City employees under the instruction and supervision of CH2M and the State Health labs, as well as the labs of CH2M. He added that variation was quite possible, particularly if the tests were done in a short time period. Mr. Burnquist stated that the Army Corp of Engineers had been at the Creamery for a period of three weeks, he added that they had their own pumps for water for the coolers and the amount that was pumped into the cooling system and the subsequent flow into the sewer were not in correlation with the findings of CH2M. Mr. Reynolds stated that this was going to be a burden on the industries but with the time there might he alternate solutions to their sewage problems. 305 Mr. Reynolds stated that it should be stressed that a firm policy must be made by the City and i completely supported by the County in that these are the areas of the County where sewers are required, and the public cannot afford willy hilly, uncontrolled development where sewers are required outside of fixed areas. Mr. Ralph Snead inquired what was meant when in the report, "load into the sewer", was referred to Mr. Reynolds answered that the liquid flow into the sewer was one factor and the bio- chemical oxygen was the 1 � second. Mr. Smead asked how much the cost went up when the solids were put into the sewer. Mr. Reynolds v answered that there was quite a bit of difference in allocation between the Idaho Meat Packers and the resi- dent customer and between the irrigation disposal system and the activated sludge system. He added that under the irrigation disposal system, about the only thing that makes any difference is that the amount of flow determines how big the pipes have to be, how much land has to be purchased, how many acres have to be put under the sprinkler system and how much waste has to be pumped. He added that it didn't make much dif- ference how strong the waste was. He added, however, that in the activated elude system the solids made a great deal of difference; once this waste is received into the treatment plant; the volume of the digesters if functioned with the strength of the waste, then the number of aerators is increased and also the electri- city to run the aerators. Mr. Snead asked why homes were not assessed for garbage disposals. If this method was used in homes, they were contributing more wastes into the sewer system. Mr. Reynolds replied that the amount put into the garbage disposal was not of great significance and that it would not be economically feasible to run tests on the amount of waste that was run into the sewer. Mayor Carpenter stated that in the use of a garbage disposal, water had to be run, and the present method of determining the sewage bill is through the water usage so, in actuality, the person with the disposal would be paying more than the one without. Councilman Gamboa asked if the time element was just the same as was shown on the last chart. Mr. Reynolds replied that it was. He explained that there was a great cost in testing and evaluating and this had not been budgeted; that it would be necessary to wait until nerd year so funds could be budgeted, and then the evaluation would have to waint until there was the high water level period. Councilman Gamboa stated that this was a long time and he questioned if there were not some way to speed it up. Mr. Reynolds replied that it would take at least two years from the time of design to completi n. I Councilman Gamboa stated then that it was going to take six years to get this job done. Mayor Carpenter said that actually the project was started in 1970 and Mr. Reynold,, added that originally this project was with the J. R. Simplot Company. Councilman Gamboa stated that it appeared that this whole project had been done piece meal. Mayor Carpenter replied that this was what the Council had set the Morey up for. When the budget was set in 1970, the Council had no idea of what the cost would be; this was before any proposal or estimate was received. Councilman Gamboa stated that now the cost is known, would their be any way to out down on the time. Mayor Carpenter replied that there would have to be a Bond Election, and than the City would have to read the top of the priority list. Re added that it was unlikely that the State would put Caldwell at the top of the li when they already had a sewer system, though not adequate, when there were other cities in Idaho that had none. Mr. Reynolds added that cities with the least effective form of treatment have the highest priority as they are greater polluters. Mayor Carpenter, in repsonse to question, stated that there would be Federal funds for the trunk lines, but not on the laterals, and that funds had to be provided for the whole System. He further explains that the Canyon Hill poject is a $120,000.00 project and before the City could acquire any Federal funds, they would have to find some way of financing their g)are. of the $120,000.00, there is $10,000.00 eligible for grant which would amount to $5y000.00, and that was all. He added that the rest would have to be financ d by the people of Canyon Hill, and that before any money would be granted, the City had to complete the whole - project. He stated that on the application he is presently filling out, a house count had to be made of how 306 many people it would serve, and also it had to be determined how many would be low income houses. He con- cluded that this is where the project is at the present time. He added that if the Council decided next year to do Area 1, the whole area would have to be done in a year's torte; the City would receive the grant, but would have to find some way to get the other $115,000.00, and it would not go just for the trunk lines. Councilman Gamboa stated that he understood that Nampa's application was always open, and that it never closed from year to year. Mayor Carpenter mentioned that it was his understanding that each project ha 3 to be completed in a year, then each system would be given a grant on its own merits. 1 Mayor Carpenter then stated that he had had a call from the State Planning Agency stating that the had a letter of intent that was mailed early in the year and are in the process of filling out the form. He added that the next thing they want to know is the area or areas that the City wants to do this year, and what is planned for next year. He added that as soon as the City gets that information to them, the next at is the clearing house for the Council of Government who have forms to fill out and would need to make a state ment. He stated that the County would have to make a policy statement as far as water and sewer regulations were concerned, and the City Council world have to pass on the County policy. He added that as yet, the Council of Government did not have a policy. There being no further business to come before the Council at the meeting, Councilman Carter moved, Councilman McCloskey seconded, that the Council would adjourn. Upon,*'6t ,,the motion carp10�_, Mayor - - / Daputy Cly Clerk COUNCIL CHAMBERS June 5, 1972 8x00 P.M. The regular monthly meeting of the City Council met in the Council Chambers of the City Hall with C. A. "Chet" Davenport, Prudent of the Council, presiding. Upon Roll Call, the following Councilmen answered present: Joe Gamboa, James R. Dakan, Laster E. Carter, Alfred H. McCloskey and C. A. "Chet" Davenport. Bid opening on Hydraulic Sewer Cleaner For the first order of business, Acting Mayor Davenport required City Engineer Mel Lewis to open the bids on the Hydraulic Sewer Cleaner for the City. Mr. Lewis mentioned that he had received four bids and proceeded to read the bids and the attached letters as follows: 1. FLEXIBLE PIPE TOOL COMPANY Milwaukie, Oregon _ June 2, 1972 City of Caldwell c/o City Engineer, City Hall Caldwell, Idaho Subject: High Velocity Sewer Cleaner Gentlemen: We wish to take this opportunity to thank you for writing us to bid on the above mentioned machine. We are bidding on two machines, our 601 and 701, that meet or exceed all of the specifications 100%. The Third bid meets or exceeds the specifications except that the unit goes on a 72" C.A. Truck rather than 84" and it does not have the rear door and canopy. Please find enclosed, users lists, warranty page, Truck Specifications (General) and individual bids on three separate machines. Our representative will be in attendance at the bid opening and later, should any questions arise. Very truly yours, FLEXIBLE PIPE TOOL CO. /s/ Peter L. O'Brien Division Manager One new high velocity sewer cleaning T unit as per specifications $ 10,855.35 Name of Manufacturer Flexible Pipe Tool Division of Rockwell Mam:facturing Company I Location of Factory Lima, Ohio