HomeMy WebLinkAbout1978-05-16city council minutesBook 19 Page 122
REGULAR MEETING
May. 16, 1978
7:30 P.M.
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor Pasley.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members
present: - McCluskey, Olesen, Williams, Raymond; Hopper, and
Bauman.. Absent: . none.,.
(APPROVAL OF MINUTES)
MOVED by Williams, SECONDED by McCluskey to dispense with the
reading of the minutes of the Regular Meeting of May 2, 1978,
and approve them as. written. .. .
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Williams, Raymond, Hopper,
Bauman, McCluskey, and Olesen. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not .voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
The Mayor asked if.there,.was anyone from the audience who cared
to bring anything before the City.C.ouncil.that.was not on the
prepared Agenda. Since there was none, the Mayor declared that
the Meeting would proceed as outlined.
(ADDITIONS TO THE.AGENDA)
The Mayor stated that.he would like to request permission of the
City Council to add several items to the Agenda. They were as
follows:
1. Request of the Fire Department to send. several men
to the.Fire'School in Boise_:
2. Presentation of. the. Wilson .School, Project.
3. Claim for payment by Lasher Construction Company.
4. Appointment to the Housing Authority for replacement of
Merle Hamilton's unexpired term.
5. An agreement presentation by Mr. Shaw for benches
throughout the City.
MOVED.by McCluskey, SECONDED by Hopper to approve the request for
additions to the Agenda as presented by the,Mayor.
Roll call vote. Those.voting yes,: McCluskey;.Oles.en., Williams,
Raymond,.Hopper, and Bauman. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not - voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(REQUEST OF FIRE DEPARTMENT TO SEND MEN TO FIRE SCHOOL) -
The. Mayor read a letter from the Fire Department addressed to
the Mayor and City Council.. the letter was asking permission
to send men to the Idaho State Fire School which will be held in
Boise on June 28, 29, and 30. Since it was so .close to'home
this year, they wanted to send four men to it for the entire
three days and another four men when they were off duty. The
City would be paying for their meals, for -registration, and for
their mileage. They felt that $225.00 would cover all expenses.
They attached a copy of classes offered and they planned to have
the men all attend different classes to get as much knowledge
as possible.
Book 19
Page 123
MOVED by Olesen, SECONDED by Williams that approval be given to
send these men to the Fire School to be held in Boise on June
28, 29, and 30 at an expense of $225.00.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Olesen, Williams, Raymond,
Hopper, Bauman, and McCluskey. Those voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(PRESENTATION OF WILSON SCHOOL PROJECT)
The Mayor called on Councilman Hopper to present the proposed
Wilson School Project.
Councilman Hopper informed the City Council that the Parks and
Recreation people had spent some considerable time the past few
weeks putting together a new idea for Caldwell. The project
involves putting recreational facilities on school property which
would be costly and was the hurdle that the City Council would
have to address. The primary plan was that the School District
would furnish the real estate and the City of Caldwell would
furnish the recreational facilities, such as basketball courts,
tennis courts, playgrounds, and etc. He gave to the members
of the City Council a projected layout of the facilities at Wilson
School which was located at Linden and Tenth. There was a joint
service contract covering all phases of the playground area. The
projected cost was $124,300.00 for the project. The reason in
taking action tonight for the project was due to the B.O.R. grant
funds that were involved. This application for grant funds has
to be submitted by the end of May. This grant comes from the
Bureau of Outdoor Recreation and was a 50% grant. This project
includes tennis courts, a rest area, restrooms, hard surface
play area, grass play area, softball diamond and a sand area for
modular equipment. The equipment would be compatible with the
age group at Wilson School.
MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Bauman that the City Council accept
the Recreation Department's proposal for application for the grant
to B.O.R. and that the Recreation Director be authorized to apply
for the grant to the Bureau of Outdoor Recreation for a 50%
grant to help fund the project.
The Mayor remarked that in the discussion at the noon meeting it was
generally accepted by most members of the Council that before any
cash participation that it should be taken to the voters in the
form of a bond issue. Secondly, it was recognized that a bond
issue of this size was not economical so that there would need to
be other items added to the bond issue.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Hopper, Bauman, McCluskey,
Olesen, Williams,_ and Raymond. Those voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none..:
MOTION CARRIED
(PRESENTATION OF CLAIM - LASHER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY)
The Mayor explained that Lasher Construction Company developed a
subdivision called Starlight No. 1. Early in the development of
this subdivision, the City Council changed the water line extension
rate from $2.00 a running foot to $5.00 a running foot which Lasher
did not -pay until yesterday,. He paid it under protest; the amount
being $15,162.50 and was now submitting a claim to the City of
Caldwell for that amount which the Mayor assumed the Council would
choose to deny.' -
tsooK iy
Page 124
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Olesen that the claim presented by
Lasher Construction Company be denied.
Councilman Olesen inquired as to what Lasher's financial status
was as far as his obligations to the City were concerned. The
Mayor said that he was paid up to date but it was paid under
protest. Councilman Raymond said that he would like to offer a
substitute motion. He MOVED that this be referred to the City
Attorney for his advice.
The Mayor answered Councilman Raymond by stating that the City
Attorney was contacted and it was discussed with him. The City
Attorney's opinion was that he could find nowhere in the law
where the City was supposed to subsidize a developer.
MOVED by Olesen, SECONDED by McCluskey to call for the question
and that the debate cease.
Councilwoman Bauman questioned who had made the motion. The Mayor
explained that Councilman Olesen made the motion to suspend the
debate. The original motion was made by Councilman McCluskey.
Councilman Raymond stated that as a point of clarification; he had
made a substitute motion which the.Mayor was explaining or trying
to clarify at the point of time that debate was ceased on a
different motion.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Olesen, Williams, Hopper, and
Bauman. Those voting no: Raymond. Absent and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
A roll call vote was then called for the original motion which
was to deny the claim.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
and Hopper. Those voting no: Raymond and Bauman. Absent and
not voting: none -
MOTION CARRIED
Councilman Raymond requested that the City Council members be
given a copy of the City Attorney's opinion.
The Mayor stated that there was not a written opinion on it and
he did not plan to ask for one. There was a verbal opinion.
(APPOINTMENT TO HOUSING AUTHORITY)
Due to the fact that Merle Hamilton has moved to Boise and left a
vacancy on the Caldwell Housing Authority, it was necessary to
make a new appointment. Don. Downen, Chairman. of the Housing
Authority called the Mayor . and recommended that Dave Cornwell of
the First Security Bank be appointed to fill the unexpired term
of Merle Hamilton on the Caldwell Housing Authority. The Mayor
then said that he would place the name of Dave Cornwell in
nomination for the unexpired term.of Merl Hamilton on the
Caldwell Housing Authority and would ask for the Council's
approval.
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Williams that approval be given for
the appointment of Dave Cornwell to fill the unexpired term of
Merle Hamilton's on the Caldwell Housing Authority.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
Raymond, Hopper, and Bauman. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
Book 19 Page 125
(AGREEMENT PRESENTATION BY MR; SHAW - BENCHES)
The Mayor said that there was in the audience a gentleman from
Payette, a Mr. Shaw, that manufactured benches and he had an
agreement that he would like to present to the City Council for
approval. This was to construct and install benches throughout
the City of Caldwell. They weigh over two hundred pounds to help
prevent vandalism. They would pay a franchise tax of $10.00 per
.year per bench or a minimum of $200.00 per annum.
Mr. Shaw was recognized and said that they were asking permission
from the City Council to put the benches at the localities where
the businesses ask for them to be placed and the business would
pay for the advertising.
The Mayor said that copies of the agreement will be made and given
to the City Council for their examination and at the next City
Council Meeting a Resolution will be presented authorizing the
Mayor and City Clerk to sign the agreement if the City Council so
desires.
OLD BUSINESS
(BILL #14 - ORDINANCE NO. 1466 - REZONING FOR MONUMENT WORKS)
The Mayor stated that this was the time for the third reading of
Bill #14 which he asked the City Clerk to read by title only as
follows:
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING THE ZONING OF CERTAIN PROPERTY WITHIN
THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, FROM R -2T RESIDENTIAL ZONE TO
M -1T LIGHT INDUSTRIAL ZONE A:ND_DETERMINING THAT SAID CHANGE
- IN ZONING IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL,
IDAHO: REPEALING ALL LAWS, {ORD.INANCES, AND RESOLUTIONS IN
CONFLICT HEREWITH.
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Olesen that Bill No. 14 be passed
and entitled Ordinance No..- 1466.:
Roll call vote.:. Those voting yes: McCluskey, Olesen,, Williams,
Raymond, Hopper, and Bauman. Those voting no: none.: Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(BILL NO. 15 - SIDEWALK SPACE)
The Mayor asked the City Clerk to read Bill No. 15 in full as
follows:
AN ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE SIDEWALK SPACE WITHIN THE CITY
OF CALDWELL, CANYON COUNTY, IDAHO.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF CALDWELL, CANYON COUNTY, 'IDAHO:
Section 1: That when new curbs are constructed or
replaced a level and unobstructed area consisting of hard
packed dirt, mowed grass, gravel or material approved by the
City Engineer of the City of Caldwell, Canyon County, Idaho,
be maintained by the owner of the residence.for a distance
of four (4) feet back from the back of the curb line and
approximately level with the top of the curb. Where permanent
public utilities and irrigation facilities exist within the
Book 19. Page 126
four -foot area, they shall be allowed "to "iemain until replace-
ment is necessary after which they shall be moved back to
clear the four -foot public right of way.
(APPOINTMENTS TO THE HISTORICAL COMMISSION)
The Mayor 'presented "the following name's for approval for the
City of Caldwell Historical Commission. 'This' Commission was to
be composed of A minimum of five and'a maximum of "tern members. The
Mayor stated that he would present seven names and if any of the
City members had other names they cared to present they
should feel free to do so. The names were: Beverly Montgomery,
Lorene Thurston, Mrs. Jerry Sullivan, Betty Summers, Frank
Crookham, Paul Evans, and Bonnie Eismann.
MOVED by Bauman, SECONDED by Williams that these seven people be
contacted and that they be approved to serve on this Commission
subject ''to their acceptance.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Bauman, McCluskey; Olesen,
Williams, Raymond, and Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
NEW BUSINESS
(FINAL'PEAT OF SPRING MEADOW'SUBDIVISION)
The City Engineer explained that this was the Crookham property
North of`3effers6n Junior High S'cho'ol. The'Plat was accepted by
the Planning and Zoning Commission and• they recommended its
approval. Mr.'Lewis said that there was a deed'and an easement
which he would present with the plat. They were to go with the
'plat `to c'ompl'ete Spruce Street from Tenth to - the Dixie Drain.
One was a quitclaim deed from the School District and the other
was a right of way easement from the Wamplers.
MOVED by Olesen, SECONDED by McCluskey that the final plat of
Spring Meadow Subdivision be accepted along with the deed and
easement as presented by the City Engineer and that the Clerk be
instructed to have the deed and easement recorded.`
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Olesen, Williams, Raymond,
Hopper, Bauman, and McCluskey. Those voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(PUBLIC HEARING ON REZONING';ON NORTH INDIANA AND NORTH MICHIGAN)
The Mayor declared the meeting open fora" public hearing on
rezoning from R -1 to R -3 property on North Indiana and North
Michigan, Lots 10, 11, 12, 13, 33, and 34. The Mayor asked if
there was anyone from the'audience "who cared to comment regarding
this zoning change reques't'. ' S'ince there was none, the Mayor
declared the Public Hearing closed.
(BILL NO, 20 - ORDINANCE NO. 1472 - REZONING ON NORTH INDIANA AND —
NORTH MICHIGAN)
The Mayor then requested'the'City Clerk to read Bill No. 20
by title only. This was for the rezoning of the above property.
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING THE ZONING OF''CERTAIN PROPERTY WITHIN
THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, FROM R -1 RESIDENTIAL ZONE TO
R -3 RESIDENTIAL ZONE AND DETERMING THAT SAID CHANGE IN ZONING
Book 19
Page 127
IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO:
REPEALING ALL.LAWS,,ORDINANCES., AND RESOLUTIONS IN CONFLICT
HEREWIT H.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Williams to suspend the rules
requiring the reading of a Bill three separate days and that
Bill No. 20 be read the second time by title and the third time
in full, section by section.
Roll call vote_ Those voting yes: Raymond, Hopper, McCloskey,
Olesen, and Williams. Those voting no: Bauman. Absent and not
voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor directed the Clerk to read the Bill the second time by
title and the third time in full.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Williams .that Bill No. 20 be passed
and entitled Ordinance No. 1472.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, Hopper, McCluskey,
Olesen, and Williams. Those voting no: Bauman. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(PUBLIC HEARING FOR REZONING ON BLOCK 43 AT 11TH AND CHICAGO)
The Mayor declared the meeting open for a public hearing regarding
the rezoning of Block 43 at Ilth and Chicago from R -3T to C -2T
as requested by First Assembly of God Church. The Mayor asked if
there was anyone in the audience who cared to comment regarding
this 'rezoning. Since there was none, the Mayor declared the
Public Hearing closed.
(BILL NO. 21 - ORDINANCE NO. 1473 - REZONING BLOCK 43 at 11th AND
CHICAGO)
The Mayor requested the City Clerk Bill No. 21 by title
only regarding the above zoning as follows:
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING ZONING `OF "CERTAIN PROPERTY WITHIN
THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, FROM R- 3T'RESIDENTIAL'ZONE TO
C -2T COMMERCIAL ZONE AND DETERMINING THAT SAID CHANGE IN
ZONING IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL,
IDAHO: REPEALING ALL LAWS, ORDINANCES, AND RESOLUTIONS
IN CONFLICT HEREWITH.
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Raymond to suspend the rules
requiring the reading of a bill three separate days and that
Bill No 21 be read the second title and the third time
in full, section by section.
Councilwoman Bauman was recognized and said that she would like to
bring to the Council ° s attention what Commercial 2 would mean.
She read the list off which included trailer parks, trailer homes,
auto sales, bakeries, savings and loan, ''barber shops, bars, bowling
alley, car wash, and etc. It was her recommendation that the City
Council members consider the fact that these types of businesses
would be one : block from :a school and would be in a neighborhood
that now has neighborhood integrity.
Councilman McCluskey said that he attended the various meetings
when this rezoning was discussed -and it was the feeling of the
Planning and Zoning Commission that there was an unfair situation
existing where this was rezoned to a Residential Zone in the
first place. This was due to the fact that the people who had
this building'' -in the''first place, the Assembly of God Church,
BOOK IV
Page. 128
thought they were Commercial and with passage of the new
zoning Ordinance they were all of 'a sudden "residential and they
sold the building based on it being Commercial. It was with that
provision that Alpha Engineers asked this time for it to be
rezoned to Commercial.
C uncilman'Olesen also spoke for the motion. More discussion
followed among the Council members. Councilwoman Williams asked
if the house next to the church was Commercial. The City Engineer
informed her that it wa.s. Councilwoman Bauman again pointed out
that this was an area of about sixteen to twenty blocks here
and she still felt it should be left intact. Councilman Raymond
stated that he walked this route every day and felt it was not
a residential looking area.
The Mayor then asked for a roll call vote. Those voting yes:
McCluskey, Olesen, Williams, Raymond, and Hopper. Those voting
no: Bauman. Absent and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor directed the Clerk to read the Bill the second time by
title and the third time in full.
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Raymond that Bill No. 21 be passed
and entitled Ordinance No. 1473.
Roll call vote.. Those voting yes_: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
Raymond,,Hop,per. Those: voting no: Bauman. Absent and not
voting: none....
MOTION CARRIED
(PUBLIC HEARING FOR REZONING IN TEN HUNDRED BLOCK OF CHICAGO STREET)
The Mayor declared the meeting open for a public hearing on
a zoning change in the ten hundred block of Chicago Street from
R -3T to C -2T... The Mayor asked if there was anyone in the audience
who cared to comment: regarding. this ,.,;rezoning.,,, -Mr.., Lewis pointed
out that the property involved was between Chicago and Eleventh
and the alley.and it would extend the commercial area out to
include the six lots. It was right across Chicago. Street from
the church ,.
,discussedn the, previous_ rezoning request.
Mr. Wes Linscott was,xecognized ands,aid was one of the owners
of that piece of ground and all he,was wanting to do was to get
back the Commercial zoning that was there before.
Since there was no one else who cared to address the Council further
regarding this rezoningrequest,.the'Mayor declared the Public
Hearing closed. _
(BILL NO. 22 - ORDINANCE NO. 1474 - REZONING OF TEN HUNDRED BLOCK OF
CHICAGO)
The Mayor.re,quested .the.City,Clerk to read Bill No. 22 providing
for this rezoning by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING;THE ZONING OF CERTAIN PROPERTY WITHIN
THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO FROM'R -3T RESIDENTIAL ZONE TO
C -2T COMMERCIAL ZONE AND DETERMING THAT SAID CHANGE IN ZONING
IS IN THE,BEST.INTEREST.OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO:
REPEALING ALL LAWS, ORDINANCES, AND RESOLUTIONS.IN,CONFLICT
HEREWITH.
MOVED :by McCluskey,,SECONDED,by Raymond -:to suspend the rules
requiring .the reading of a hill three separate,,days and that Bill
No. 22 be read the second time by title and the third time in full,
Book 19 Page 129
section by section.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
Raymond, and Hopper. Those voting no: Bauman. Those absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor directed the Clerk to read the Bill the second time by
title and the third time in full.
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Raymond that Bill No. 22 be
passed and entitled Ordinance No. 1474.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
Raymond, and Hopper. Those voting no: Bauman. Absent and not
voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(ATTENDANCE AT A.I.C. CONVENTION IN SUN VALLEY)
The Mayor said that this was the Meeting that the City Council
must decide who will be going to the A.I.C. Convention being held
in Sun Valley and who the official delegate would be. A decision
should also be made as to what percent of the pre- 'registration fees
should be paid. If they were paid before June lst, the cost would
be less. The Mayor stated that Councilman McCluskey was going as
well as Councilwoman Bauman, the City Engineer, and that he was
planning to go. The Mayor had received a letter from the Chief of
Police requesting that he be given approval for his attendance at
the A.I.C. Convention this year. The reason being that he
inherited Secretary of the Idaho Chief's of Police and also was
elected as President of the Idaho Traffic Safety Correction
Association. Their meetings would be held during this time.
The registration fee for delegates was $70.00 and for spouses was
$40.00. The Mayor recommended that the City of Caldwell pay the
delegates registration fee and the delegates pay the spouse's fee.
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Raymond that approval be given for
the City of Caldwell to pay the delegates registration fee and that
the delegates pay their spouse's fee and that approval be given for
attendance of the Mayor, the City Engineer, the 'Chief of Police,
Councilman McCluskey, and Councilwoman Bauman.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: McCluskey; Olesen, Williams,
Raymond, Hopper, and Bauman. Those voting no: none, Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by'Will "iams,'SECONDED by McCluskey that Mayor Bob Pasley
be the City of Caldwell's official delegate at the Association of
Idaho "Cities Convention in Sun Valley.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes:- Williams, Raymond; , Hopper,
Bauman, McCluskey, and Olesen. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
_ MOTION CARRIED
(CHANGE IN WORDING OF WATER LINE EXTENSION POLICY)
The Mayor informed the City Council that in the water main
extension policy it says, "the remaining 50% upon notification of
the completion of this system." It needed to be changed to read,
"the remaining upon notification of the completion of the
water main extension."
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Hopper that approval be given for
this change in the water line extension policy.
Book 19 Page 130
Those voting yes: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,.Raymond, Hopper,
and Bauman. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting:
none.
MOTION CARRIED
(SET DATE FOR FIRST COUNCIL MEETING IN JULY) "
The Mayor pointed out to the City Council that the first Tuesday in
July - ,was on the Fourth of July, This was the, ,time set for the
first Regular City Council Meeting in July. It was'the Mayor's
proposal that the_offici.al meeting time be changed to July 5,
1978_ This would be on a Wednesday.
MOVED by_Bauman,:S by McCluskey.,that the..first regular
City 'Council Meeting in'Ju1y be on the 5th:,;of 'July due 'to the
Fourth beingan Tuesday:
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Bauman, McCluskey, Olesen,
Williams, Raymond, and.Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(LETTERS, OF. RESIGNATION FROM FIRE,CHI.EF,AND ASSISTANT FIRE .CHIEF)
The Mayor read the following letter addressed to Harold Perfect,
Fire Chief:
It is with mixed emotions that I hereby announce my. plans to
retire from the Caldwell Fire Department. I.feel -that
retirement., is that everyonie. for and looks
forward to; however, after 225 years of service, the fire
.service has : become a- major, part of my. life and I have many
sad feelings. when I even think of leaving this profession.
I guess however, that this point in time comes in everyone's
life., 1 might;, add that I, feel the past 25 years have been
interesting,.chalengin.9,and exciting.,
Please make the effective date of this retirement June 16,
1978,,, at 1700,,, hours
I,would also like to °express, y appreciation to th
m pp e Caldwell
Fire Department, the Mayors and City Council Members, both
past and ; present, for, making ,this job--possible ,the. - 25
years, and for the security and knowledge it has given me
and -my family.,
/s/ Don Machos
MOVED by Olesen, SECONDED by McCluskey that the resignation of
Don Machos, Assistant Fire Chief, be accepted with reluctance.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes:, Oles,en� Williams Raymond,
Hopper, Bauman, and McCluskey. Those voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor then read the following letter addressed to the Mayor
and City Council from Harold Perfect, Fire Chief:
I have some very mixed feelings about what I am about to
announce. ,
In the past 26 years and 2 months, I have been employed by
the..City,of Caldwell in the Fire Department. Nine years ago
I was appointed to the Fire Chief's position by Mayor Coley
Smith. During these 26 years I worked under three different
Book 19
Page 131
Fire Chiefs and several Mayors and Councils.
I appreciate what the present Mayor and Council and, also, the
past Mayors and Councils have done to help me in my job. The
Department Supervisors we now have are an excellent group of
people and my association with them has, and will be,
cherished by me for a long time to come.
In my position as Fire Chief, I've gotten acquainted with a
tremendous number of the citizens of Caldwell and have enjoyed
being able to help people through the Fire Department and
enjoyed the association I've had with a great number of the
local business people.
Working this many years in a profession such as the Fire
Department has given me a variety of blessings, a number of
obstacles to get over, a lot of friends and it truly has been
a challenge for the nine years.
There comes.a time in everyone's life, however, when they feel
that they'd like to do some other things and I've reached that
point in my life.
I'd like tar ,.announce my retirement from the Caldwell Fire
Department effective June 28, 1978, so that my wife and I
will be able to do some other things.
Again, I'd like to say that the knowledge I've received
through my work in the Caldwell Fire Department has meant a
lot to me and my family over the years.
. /s /_,Harold.E. Perfect
Fire Chief
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Bauman that the,resignation of
Harold Perfect, Fire Chief, be accepted with thanks and with
reluctance.
Councilwoman Bauman stated that the resignation should be accepted
with thanks for a very fruitful• well disciplined group of
people at the Fire Department which Harold was a.good part
responsible for.
Roll call-vote. Those voting.- yes:.. McCluskey, .Olesen,.Williams,
Raymond, Hopper, and Bauman. Those voting no:. none— Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
Councilman Raymond said that he would like to comment that he
didn't think that anyone realized the dedication of these two men.
Councilman McCluskey pointed out that these two men in their
particular, positions were in a situation that was very detrimental
to them financially. Most of the firemen Were allowed.to take
outside jobs, but neither of these two men._were.allowed _ to do this
becau se of the positions that they hold. He wanted them both to
know that he personally appreciated what they have done.
The Mayor stated that an Executive Session would.be held
immediately following the .Regular _City.Council Meeting to discuss
the hiring of a new Fire Chief.
(DECISION OF DAMAGE _BILL FROM DR._.WATERMAN)LL
The Mayor stated that last week he was called to Dr. Waterman's
Office to be shown broken glass throughout his waiting room. The
Mayor told Dr. Waterman that he felt there was nothing more the
Book ty
Page 132
City could do on the Golf Course. The City had put up a screen,
moved the tee and felt that the City had done everything they could
to him. If there was anything more done, the Mayor felt Dr.
Waterman 'should have it. done such as a'screen put'over the windows.
Dr`. Waterman had safety glass put in which consisted of twelve
panes' at $24.00 a pane which . made` a' bill totalling` $288.00. Dr.
Waterman brought the "claim in and asked`the'Mayor to present it
to the City Council,for their reaction. These windows were in
small' panes''whieh' was the "rea "son for "so many panes. The golf
ball broke only" one` of these little panes`.'
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Hopper that this claim be
refused as presented by Dr. Waterman.
Councilwoman Bauman asked if the purpose bf him putting in this
safety •glass was` to protect patients in the wair"ing room. The
Mayor informed ler - that this was correct.
Councilman McCluskey said that regardless of this, if the City
had an� thi
y n to - say_ ab' mesh c , put across these
out "it c have been
windows to protect them from 'the golfers.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
Raymond, Hopper, and','Sauman. .Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION - NO.'30 -78 - 'AGREEMENT WITH - TDAHO STATE BUREAU OF SURPLUS
PROPERTY)
The Mayor explained that this Agreement with the Idaho State Bureau
of Surplus Property was necessary for the Departments to get
anything from there. The Parks Department had purchased a
sprayer and they were asking that this Resolution be passed. It
was as' follows
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY'` CLERK.' TO EXECUTE
AN AGREEMENT WITH IDAHO STATE BUREAU OF SURPLUS PROPERTY
MOVED b y McCluskey; SECONDED by Hopper that Resolution No. 30 -78
be passed.
Roll call vote. Those voting.yes: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
Raymond, Hopper,.and Biuma.n Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: ''none:
MOTION CARRIED
(REQUEST FOR AN ADDITIONAL MAN'IN`THE PARKS : DEPARTMENT)'
The next item on the Agenda was a request by the Parks Department
for an additional man until the middle of September. This man
was not budgeted'for and it would cost approximately $2,000.
The Mayor felt that the 'Parks Department did need one in order to
keep'up with the work. This was due to the increased plantings
and - new areas of responsibility and also because the City lost
their Forester.
Councilwoman Williams inquired as to whether the forester had
been replaced. The Mayor stated that one of the other men in the
Department had moved into his position. No one had been hired as
yet to take the other man's position. Councilwoman Williams
questioned as to why they would run over the budget if there was a
man short in the Parks Department anyway.
Book 19
Page 133
Councilman Hopper pointed out.that this.was a temporary man and
replacing the short -man would be a permanent position or a year
around job.
MOVED, by Bauman,_ SECONDED by Hopper that this additional man in
the Parks Department until September 15th be allowed.
Councilman Hopper questioned if asking those working currently in
the Department to .work overtime to accomplish what needed to be
done would be more economical. Perhaps there wasn't a need for
another man if they worked those in the Department longer hours.
The Mayor, said that this would mean paying time and a half and he
felt this would cost more than having an additional man until
September 15th.
Councilwoman Williams stated that she felt somehow that..Department
budgeted short and this. should be kept in mind.
Councilman Olesen asked if the Stadium Board could hire someone to
take care of their plantings.- Councilwoman Williams said she felt
now that the plantings were done, only some weeding and the
watering would have to be done.
Councilman McCluskey suggested that a decision be delayed until the
Stadium Meeting on Friday at noon. He felt that there might be a
possibility.to make some kind of a joint effort with the Stadium.
MOVED by McCluskey that the City Council delay this action until
after the Stadium Board Meeting on Friday.
It was pointed out to Councilman McCluskey,that there was already
a motion on the floor. Councilman McCluskey then withdrew his
motion.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by McCluskey to:table: the motion
originally made.
Roll call•vote. Those voting yes: Raymcnd;:Hopper, Bauman,
McCluskey, Olesen, and Williams.. Those - voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION NO. 31 -78 - REJECT BIDS FOR GRAVEL CRUSHING)
The Mayor requested Finance Director:to read the memo :of bid
results as follows:
Bids were opened at 2:OO P.M. May 1, 1978 for the.purchase
of crushed gravel.
The results of the bids were as follows:
Bryan C. Rambo Crushing Co., Inc. $ 15,900.00
Boise Paving &.Asphalt:.Co., Inc.. 15,900.00
Nelson- Deppe, Inc, Alternate bid
Due to the "savings under the proposal of Nelson- Deppe, Inc.,
the Finance Director recommends by resolution to reject all bids
and accept Proposal No. 1 as follows:
10,000 tons 1" Minus State Spec. Crashed Aggregate for
'Base at $1.20 per ton .($12,000 lump sum) in a separate
stockpile at our Karcher.Pit on South 10th Avenue approx-
imately 4.5 miles from Caldwell City Hall. Payment upon
completion of crushing. Crushing would be .completed prior
to May 16, 1978.
Book 19
Page 134
This item has'been reviewed by the Engineerin& Department who
favor this contract on a one time basis.
The item is budgeted under Line Item 32 - Special Departmental
..Supplies - Gravel -'.Street Department in the amount of
$50,000.00. The approximate cost will be $12,000.00/
Mr. Horan stated that he had consulted with -the City Attorney on
this subject and had his approval. The Engineering Department felt
it was the economical way to go:
MOVED by McCluskey,.SECONDED by Hopper that Mr. Hofau's
recommendation be approved.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
Raymond, Hopper, and Bauman. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none..
MOTION CARRIED
Councilman McCluskey then read the Resolution in full as follows:
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE CCALDWELL CITY COUNCIL TO REJECT
BIDS FOR GRAVEL CRUSHING.
WHEREAS, The City of Caldwell received and opened bids
for gravel crushing at 2:00 P.M., May 1, 1978; and,,
WHEREAS, the City of Caldwell found the bids not to be
to the advantage to the taxpayer.
NOW,.THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED That in accordance with
Idaho Code 50 -341, Paragraph. J, the City of Caldwell rejects
all bids and authorizes the Mayor and City C1erk.to execute
said agreement between the City of Caldwell and Nelson-
Deppe, Inc., as follows:
10,000 tons T_" Minus State Spec. Crushed Aggregate for
Base at $1.20 per ton ($12;000 lump sum) in a separate
stockpile at our Karcher Pit on South 10th Avenue
approximately 4.5 miles from Caldwell City Hall.
Payment upon completion of crushing. Crushing would
be completed prior to May 16, 1978.
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Hopper that the Resolution as
read by Mr. Horan be passed.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
Raymond, Hopper, and Bauman. Those voting no; none. Absent
and not voting: nm e.
MOTION CARRIED
(BID RESULTS - TRI PLEX MOWER FOR GOLF DEPARTMENT)
The Finance Director read the memo regarding the bid results
for the Tri Plex Mower for the Golf Department as follows:
Bids were opened at °2;00 P.M..May 4,,1978 for the purchase
of a tri -plea mower for the Golf Department.
The results of the bids were as follows:
Turf Equipment_ Company $ 5,175.00
Cliff Carlson Company No bid
Bids were reviewed by Gordon Crockett, Supervisor of the Golf
Book 19
Page 135
Department, and it was found -that two bids were submitted. Cliff
Carlson Company was unable to meet specifications therefore,
submitted a 'No Bid'. The bid of'Turf Equipment Company did meet
all specifications 7 in their entirety. The Finance Director
recommends that the Mayor and Council except the bid of Turf
Equipment Co. in the amount of $5,175.00.
The equipment Schedule of the Golf Department is attached herewith.
MOVED by Olesen, SECONDED by McCluskey to accept the bid of
Turf Company in the amount''of $5,175.00.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes Olesen, Williams, Raymond,
Hopper, Bauman, and McCluskey. Those voting no: `none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(FEDERAL FUNDS STATUS REPORT)
Finance Director presented a federal funds status report which
was attached to these Minutes.'`'Each member of the City Council
was given a copy of this report for their study. Mr. Horan asked
that the City Council defer discussion regarding the Jefferson .
project for ninety days.
(SET COMPENSATION GRADE FOR RECREATION PROGRAM SUPERVISOR)
The Mayor stated that this would be the time to set the compensation
for the position of Recreation Program Supervisor. It was the
recommendation'Of - both. the Finance - Director.and The Recreation
Director and the Mayor that this be Step Seven which would be
$684.00 a month. This was a beginning step level and the City
would have to advertise for the position.
MOVED by McCluskey, SECONDED by Bauman that this position of
Recreation Program Supervisor be classed as Step Seven with a
salary of $684.00.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: McCluskey, Olesen, Williams,
Raymond, Hopper, and Bauman. 'Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(FINANCIAL STATEMENT)
Councilwoman Williams reported that there was warrants totalling
$319,787.95 from all funds and:a payroll in the amount of
$138,729.63.
MOVED by Williams, SECONDED by Bauman that warrants.be issued for
the requests for payment and for the payroll and that the requests
for_.payment.be filed.i the Clerk's,Office....
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Williams, Raymond, Hopper,
Bauman; McCluskey,; and Olesen. Those. .voting no :_;:none.. Absent and
not voting ::. none.
MOTION CARRIED
(COMMITTEE REPORTS)
Councilwoman Williams had no reports.
Councilman Olesen thanked everyone for the cards while he was in
the hospital.
Councilman McCluskey had no.;reports.
Councilwoman Bauman reported,that the Community Development
Commission met unofficially but with no chairman. She
Book 19
Page 136
stated that she'thought everything around - town was looking very nice.
Councilman Hopper had no report to make.
Councilman Raymond had no- report to make.
(COMMENTS FROM THE CITY COUNCIL)
Councilman Raymond asked Finance Director,:how many.responses he
had received from the businesses regarding the grant for the down
town project since. the last meeting. Mr. Horan said that two
people had contacted halm to come to their business to discuss
it with them. Councilman Raymond stated that he had conversation
with a gentleman the night before who was willing to- provide an
area for a walk through from the railroad parking lot to the
Main Street.' The Mayor added that there was -a gentleman from
the real estate department of the Union Pacific Railroad Office
in Salt Lake that was in and thought it was a fine project and
would do all he could to get the - railroad to cooperate.
Councilman.Raymond then commented': that he would request that
there should be City Attorney's opinions presented to the City
Council when necessary. The Mayor answered that if there was
anything important, the City Attorney would give a written opinion
and all would have a copy.
There being no further business, the Meeting was then,
at 8:50 P.M. for a five minute recess before the Executive
Session was to convene.
APPROVED AS THIS 6th DAY OF June 1978.
'Mayor
,� , . ��(' . e rg .F. � ;/ Ste, /�✓�r� .� - -�/�
Co _,CouncilTw(n'
ATTEST,
Councilman Councilman
C uncilma Councilman
City rk
EXECUTIVE SESSION
May 16, 1978
9:00 P.M.
The Mayor called the Executive Session of the City Council to
order:
(APPOINTMENT OF FIRE -CHIEF -- ESTABLISH. THREE NEW'POSITIONS)
The Mayor reported to the City Council' that he had conversation
with'varibus'bf "the' firemen concerned as to'what some :of the
problems were in the Fire Department. He said that he had a
very definite opinion as to his recommendation to the City
Council after visiting with the firemen. He interviewed Tom
Burns, Olen Waner, and Jim Hanks, the three Captains for the
position of Fire Chief. Galen Woods and Travis Fleetwood were
the two Lieutenants - to be considered to`be'moved'zap when the
Chief was 's'elect'ed. Tim Johhton'; had been 'on'the Fire Department
staff since January, 1977, applied for Chief's job.
Much discussion followed among the'City Council the
many problems existing in the'Fire It was pointed out
Book 19
Page 137
that most of the firemen have second jobs, but when they have the
position of Chief and Assistant Chief they were unable to hold
down the second job which made a definite hardship financially.
It was necessary at this point in time to appoint both a Fire
Chief and an Assistant Fire Chief. The Mayor stated that both
Fire Chief_Harold.Perfect and the Assistant- Fire Chief Don Machos
pointed out that there should be a position of Fire Inspector to
take some of the load off the Fire Chief's position and the
Assistant Fire Chief. All of the other officers that the Mayor
visited with agreed that there should be :a full time Fire Inspector.
Two of the Captains were not interested in the Fire Chief's
position due to the fact that they had a- business on the side and
also did not want.the additional responsibility. Tom Burns was
willing to accept the job and give it a try even- though it would
be a financial loss for him. I t was the Mayor's recommendation
that Tom Burns be appointed the Fire Chief to become effective
June Ist even though Harold Perfect will not be leaving until
the latter.part.of June. Tom Burns has never worked with a budget
and the..Mayor felt that Harold could go over -this with him before
leaving:the.:Department. There would, of course, be a great deal
of other things that he will need to be instructed in for the
transition.
The Mayor then further recommended to the City Council that they
authorize the two jobs at the same pay, the Assistant Fire Chief
and the Fire Inspector. The Mayor further stated that he felt in
filling these two positions the newly appointed Chief should be
consulted as to his, recommendation for the man to be appointed to
each position. He further commented that Tom Burns had-no desire
to be Fire Chief unless the position of Fire Inspector was
authorized.
Much discussion followed among the City Council members regarding
the replacement of the positions that will become available if
several men were advanced and if the new position should be
authorized.
The Mayor then asked if the City Council would approve the
appointment' of Tom Burns as the new Fire Chief and the position of
the Assistant Fire Chief, the same as has been and add at equal
rank with the Assistant Chief, the new position of Fire Inspector
on a fulltime basis effective the first of June.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by McCloskey that three positions be
established at the Fire Department: Fire Chief, Assistant Fire
Chief, and Fire Inspector to be effective as of June 1, 1978.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Raymond, Hopper, Bauman,
McCluskey, Oleseu, and Williams. Those voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by McCluskey to approve' the Mayor's
recommendation to appoint Tom Burns as the City of Caldwell's Fire
Chief.
Roll call vote. ,Those voting yes: Raymond,. Hopper,, Bauman, McCluskey,
Olesen, andWilliams. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting:
none.
Since there was no further business, the Mayor declared the Meeting
adjourned at 9:40 P.M.
APRROVED' AS° written THIS 6th °DAy OF- June' 1g78,,.
ou 2° o�i man -- `
���xn�lxna �—
_ ATTEST:
uncl m i '� ounce m n / ,t