HomeMy WebLinkAbout1981-04-28city council minutesBook 22 Page 114
REGULAR MEETING
April 28, 1981
12:00 Noon
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor McCluskey.
The Mayor requested that everyone stand and give the Pledge of
Allegiance to the Flag.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members
present: Williams, Mallea, Hopper, and Carter. Absent: Raymond
and Betts.
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
The Mayor asked if there was anyone in the audience who would care
to bring anything before the City Council that was not on the
prepared Agenda. Since there was no one, the Mayor declared that
the meeting would proceed as outlined.
OLD BUSINESS
(BILL NO. 9 - AMEND CODE REGARDING ANIMALS IN CITY LIMITS)
The Mayor asked the members of the Council if they had reviewed
the Bill now that it was typed in Ordinance form. Councilman Carter
stated that he had studied it carefully.
The Mayor stated that what makes the Bill democratic and fair was
that it allows an individual that does have some reason for keeping
a couple of animals in their yard in a sanitary and secure manner
the right to do so. In the event that there was a complaint from the
neighborhood and it was a justified complaint, the animals have to
be removed. If the complaint was not justified, it gives the
individual two boards to appeal to. The Mayor further said that he
felt our rights were stepped on enough through the laws and felt that
this was a fair way to proceed and give the people of the community
an opportunity to express themselves. The Mayor then stated that he
would read Bill No. 9 by title only as follows:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND TITLE IX, CHAPTER 2, SECTION 29 OF THE
MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, STATE OF IDAHO,
REGARDING ANIMALS BY ADDING CERTAIN LANGUAGE REGARDING
MAINTAINING ANIMALS IN THE CITY LIMITS, PROVIDING FOR A
NUISANCE COMPLAINT, AND PROVIDING FOR AN APPEALS BOARD; AND
REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, ORDERS OR PARTS THEREOF
IN CONFLICT HEREWITH.
The Mayor then declared that this would be the first reading of
Bill No. 9.
Councilwoman Mallea was recognized and stated that when people live
in the City they should give up farm animals. However, this was a
reasonable compromise and she would support it.
(MILK ORDINANCE DISCUSSION)
The Mayor stated that the next item on the Agenda was with regard
to the milk ordinance. He further said that he would like to read
from the Caldwell City Code the portion dealing with the sale of
raw milk. It was as follows:
7 -2 -2: PERMITS: From the date on which this Chapter takes
effect, no milk or milk products shall be sold to the final
consumer, or to restaurants, soda fountains, grocery stores,
or similar establishments, except certified pasteurized and
grade A pasteurized; provided, that when any milk distributor
fails to qualify for one of the above grades, the Health Officer
is authorized to suspend his permit.
The Mayor commented that the City of Caldwell was not in the
health business as there was not a Sanitation Officer qualified to
make the determinations. He suggested to the City Council the
Book 22
Page 115
possibility of eliminating this particular paragraph just read and
putting in that the product would be labeled, not individually,
but on the front of the display case stating that raw milk was
hazardous to your health or something in that order. The Mayor
further said that he contacted Nampa and they have no restrictions
in their Code with regard to the sale of raw milk. Boise does have
an extensive raw milk ordinance, but to the point where the Mayor
felt it was infringing on the public's .rights. The Mayor then
stated that he would open the meeting for any comments from the
audience.
John Wieting was recognized and stated that he would like to share,
with the Council and the audience his experience of the last
eighteen years as a Health Official. I further stated that he
was a Registered Sanitarian, A Registered Milk Inspector, and
also aformer Chief Milk Inspector. He said that he would like to "` - "
commend the Council in the past for their wisdom in originating a
ban on raw milk, and he was sure that the present Council would. show
the same wisdom. He also said that he had a Bachelor of Science
Degree from Washington State University. Mr. Wieting then explained
to the Council and Mayor his reasoning for upholding the ban on raw
milk. He informed them that the national vital statistic reports
that forty percent of all food poisonings are due to staphylococcus
and the most common carriers of this disease are organisms from man
and raw milk. Most of his testimony was with regard to Salmonella
and Q Fever. Mr. Wieting then gave a series of statistics and
information with regard to the danger of these diseases and their
connection to raw milk. He pointed out that there has been extensive
studies done on Salmonella and cattle and it was found that the
cows tend to have Salmonella in their system and for some reason
that was unexplainable, the cows shed the disease. No matter how
many tests were run, t'her was still the possibility of the cow
shedding this organism and the cow may shed it for a day or for a
week as the time varies. Mr. Wieting stated many statistics with
regard to the findings that raw milk was unsafe regardless of
inspections. Mr. Wieting said that as the Council andz ;Mayor could
see by the information he presented that it was extremely
difficult or impossible to insure that every bottle of raw milk
does not have pathogens in it. It was Mr. Wieting's recommendatic'
that in view of the testimony that he presented, he would strongly
suggest that the City of Caldwell continue to ban the sale of raw
milk. He pointed out that publicity for the City of Caldwell with
regard to a serious illness or death from drinking raw milk would
not be welcome.
Councilwoman Mallea was recognized and asked Mr. Wieting if he was
employed at this time as a milk inspector. Mr. Wieting stated that
he was not; he was Director of Membership Relations for Dairymens
Creamery Association. Councilwoman Mallea also asked Mr. Wieting
if he could assure them that there was no pathogens in pasteurized
milk. Mr. Wieting stated that there was not.
Steve Rose of the I-tealth Department was recognized and presented
the following information:
1980 - Southwest District
Salmonella 40 cases
Shigella 84 cases
1980 - Cases with Caldwell address
Salmonella. 12 cases
Shigella 35 cases
IIistorically, many other diseases have been transmitted
through milk. However, area physicians are not required to
report these disease statistics.
23 States that totally prohibit raw milk sales
11 States that allow only raw milk sales at the farm
34 sub -total (686)
13 States that allow sale of raw milk
3 States that have no law concerning milk
16 sub -total (326)
Book 22
Page 116
After some discussion and questions by members of the audience,
testimony was given by Pat Tate, General Manager of Associated
Dairies, who stated that pasteurized milk was invented many years
ago which was a life saver around the world as it contained no
pathogenic bacteria and further did not decrease the food value of
the milk. He was in support of the City retaining the ordinance
restricting the sale of the raw milk.
Frank Krone from Dairymens Creamery was recognized and stated that
he supported the ordinance on raw milk. He was shocked when moving
to Idaho to find that there was not a State law in Idaho preventing
the sale of raw milk in the stores. He was a strong advocate of
the restriction of raw milk in the interest of the consumer. He
felt it was a mistake in the State of Idaho to allow the sale of
raw milk in the grocery stores alongside pasteurized milk as the
consumer does not understand the difference. He did not feel that
a sign informing them of the hazards of the raw milk was the answer.
This might hurt the sale of all milk. Mr. Krone further stated that
an organization such as Dairymens has the best quality control
program and has constant surveillance of quality. They never sell
raw milk to the consumer because they do not believe that it is in
the best interest of the consumer or the dairy industry. If someone
wants raw milk, they should go to the farm to purchase it. He
believed that Caldwell could be an example to other communities in
the State of Idaho by retaining the raw milk ordinance. It could
be the first move towards some State Legislation in the interest of
the consumer.
Lowell Grim was recognized and stated that he was a dairy farmer
and was concerned about the quality of the product he produces.
It was his feeling that if there was problems with the raw milk,
it could cause negative reactions to all milk and consequently,
harm the dairy business. He would like to see the best quality
possible presented to the consumer and was in favor of enforcing
the Code as it was now stated.
Dale Pline was also recognized and stated that he was a dairy
farmer and also President of Dairymens Creamery Association. He
commented that as he was listening to the testimony presented, he
wondered why we have people educated to learn these facts and yet
do not seem to listen to them. As a dairy farmer, he knew that
those pathogenic organisms were in milk when it was produced. He
knew that there was no way to guarantee that there would not be
those organisms in the raw milk. Mr. Pline further said that for
the public's interest there was only way as an industry to guarantee
that the product was safe and that was through pasteurization. He
would just like to echo those comments that were made with regard to
the threat made to the dairy industry by allowing the raw milk.
Eventually, he felt there would be some kind of a health problem
as a result of drinking the raw milk. He would encourage the
enforcement of the ordinance which was on the books and felt that
it was time the problem was dealt with as it was most certainly going
to grow.
Rod Stark from Payette was recognized and stated that he guessed it
was his product that they were discussing. He felt that he had a
good product as a lot of people buy it. The State inspected his
milk and if there was something wrong with it, he was sure the State
would stop them. As far as the raw milk being in the stores, the
public should be given credit to be able to read as to whether it was
raw milk or not. Mr. Stark stated that the problem was coming from
the small dairies who were not inspected. He felt that if people
want the raw milk, then they should be allowed to buy it.
Several other people from the audience spoke with regard to the
raw milk including Nell Wolfe and Sam Bass who both were in favor of
the raw milk being allowed since there seemed to be some demand for
it.
The City Council members discussed the problem at some length and
asked the gentlemen present many questions. Councilwoman Williams
was recognized and stated that she did not like to see people not
allowed to buy what they want, but after hearing all of this expert
testimony she felt there must be some danger in having the raw milk.
She was raised on a farm, but in those days it was not handled to the
extent that it was today so there was less danger then. She did not
Book 22 Page 117
want to take a chance of some kind of epidemic.
Councilman Carter stated that the ordinance was on the books and
was certainly put there for a good reason and that the City should
get back to the enforcement of it. The industry has come a long
way in processing milk and he certainly felt the testimony given
was something the Council should be aware of.
Councilwoman Mallea was recognized and stated that she was a "free
choicer" by choice, but the City Council was charged with the safety
and protection of the citizens of Caldwell and she would like to
see the ordinance enforced.
Councilman Hopper stated that he supported Councilwoman Mallea's
comment when the safety of the citizens was at stake. He would.
point out that he would hope that there would still be the option
for those who wanted the raw milk: to be able to buy it on a :farm.
The Mayor stated that he would also like to rescind what he had
said earlier. Due to the knowledgeable and well documented testimony
given, he would have to state that he would also like to see the
ordinance enforced.
It was the concensus of the City Council and the Mayor that the Code
would be left as it stands now and the City would ask the State to
start enforcing the Ordinance as of the lst of May. The Council
determined that they would give some study to the Ordinance to see
if there should be any other changes made.'.,
(RESOLUTION NO. 21 -81 - AGREEMENT WITH BLAKLEY ENGINEERS)
The Mayor explained that the next item was a Resolution authorizing
the Mayor and Clerk to execute an Agreement with Blakley Engineers.
I-Ie read the Resolution in full as follows:
RESOLU'T'ION AUTHORIZING MAYOR AND CITY CLERIC TO EXECUTE AN
ARCHITECT /ENGINEERING AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CALDWELL
AND BLAKLEY ENGINEERS, INC.
BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and Clerk of the City of
Caldwell be, and the same hereby are, authorized to execute
that certain Agreement attached hereto and made a part hereof
as if set forth in full by and between the City of Caldwell and
Blakley Engineers, Inc., for the purpose of revising completed
plans and specifications and providing inspection for
construction of Industrial Way, Industrial Court and Commercial
Way as platted in Industrial Site No. S Subdivision, which
project is to be funded by a Grant from E.D.A.
The Mayor stated that the Council was aware of this Agreement as it
was discussed at the previous Council Meeting.
MOVED by Carter, SECONDED by Hopper that Resolution No. 21 -81 be
passed.
Mr. Lewis, City Engineer, was recognized, and stated that he would
suggest leaving the Agreement until it was approved by E.D.A. and
then he would submit it for signatures. Also, if the Grant does not
mature, under this Agreement the City would be paying for engineering
He wanted the Council to be aware of this.
Collacilman Carter stated that he would amend the motion to read
subject to E.D.A. approval. The Second approved.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Carter, Williams, Mallea, and
Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent and not voting: Betts and
Raymond.
MOTION CARRIED
NEW BUSINESS
(DATE OF CALDWELL DAY AT THE FAIR)
The Mayor informed the Council that the Chamber of Commerce needed
to know what day Caldwell would like to have for their day at the
Fair. The Chamber suggested keeping the same day as last year; the
29th of July. Council agreed that Wednesday, the 29th of July was
Book 22
to be Caldwell's day at the Fair.
Page 118
Councilwoman Mallea asked the Council that if they do have the
dinner, she would like to have them be thinking of a name for it
instead of barbecue as last year they were wondering where the
barbecue was.
(ROADS AND STREETS DUMP TRUCK)
The Mayor informed the Council that Dennie Shippy of the Street
Department had a dump truck budgeted for this year and Dennie
felt that he would be way ahead if the Council would retain that
money this year and let him budget for another dump truck next
year and then just purchase one. He would then purchase a
fourteen yard dump truck which would be a diesel rig which would
save a driver, fuel,, and insurance.
It was agreed that the City Council would take a look at this
request.
(RESOLUTION NO. 12 -81 - REHAB FOR SANTOS D. PENA AND VIRGINIA V. PENA)
The Mayor stated that the next item on the Agenda was a Resolution
approving a Housing Rehab for Santos D. Pena and Virginia V. Pena
and he would turn this over to Councilman Carter for a brief
discussion.
Councilman Carter reported that the Committee appointed to go over
the loans met and voted to recommend to the City Council that this
Housing Rehabilitation be approved.
The Mayor read Resolution No. 12 -81 by title only as follows:
RESOLUTION APPROVING A HOUSING REHABILITATION FOR SANTOS D.
PENA, JR. AND VIRGINIA V. PENA, IIUSBAND AND WIFE AND
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE..
MOVED by Carter, SECONDED by Williams that Resolution No. 12 -81
be passed approving the housing rehabilitation for Santos D. Pena
and Virginia V. Pena.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Carter, Williams, and Hopper.
Those voting no: Mallea. Absent: and not voting: Betts and
Raymond.
MOTION CARRIED
(POLICE DEPARTMENT REORGANIZATION)
The Mayor asked Police Chief Dormois if he would care to make
a brief statement on the reorganization of the Police Department.
Mr. Dormois was recognized and stated that the Department when
he arrived on the job appeared to be unbalanced in organizational
structure. After serveral weeks of consideration, the two ranking
men were appointed Division Commanders; the Captain was put in
charge of the bulk of the operation of the troops. The Lieutenant
was then put in charge of the investigative division which now has
four people instead of five.
He felt that the new structure was going to work well and submitted
a chart of the organization for the Mayor and City Council.
Several members of the Council commended the new Police Chief for
his talk presented at noon at the Chamber of Commerce luncheon.
(BICYCLE WEEK)
The Mayor informed the Council that next month was American Bike
Month and also Caldwell's Bike Training Month. On April 9th
the City was planning to start the bike safety and licensing
program through the Fire Department. He was hoping to get adequate
coverage from the newspaper to make it a success.
The Mayor asked the Police Chief if he could put together the number
of bicycle related accidents for 1977, 1978, and 1979.
Kook 22
(MAYOR'S COMMENTS)
Page 119
1. Law Day. The Mayor said that. :he was to ask how many of
the Council were going to attend the luncheon on Friday noon
at the Elks. The Chief Justice of the Idaho Supreme Court
was going to speak. Mr. Miller needed to know how many would
attend. Due to a number of conflicts, the Council members
did not believe they could attend the luncheon.
(CATERING PERMITS)
The City Clerk presented a catering permit requester]. by the
Cimmaron to cater-for the Eagles on Saturday, May 2nd. The fee
was paid to the Office of the City Clerk and she asked for
approval of the Catering Permit subject to the Police Chief
giving his approval and signing the permit.
MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Mallea that approval be given for the
Catering Permit as presented by the City Clerk subject to approval
by the Chief of Police.
MOTION CARRIED
(CONTINUATION OF MAYOR'S REPORT)
2, Mayday Dance. The Mayor reminded the Council that the tickets
for the Mayday Dance were for sale at the City Hall. I-Ie
would like to see more support for the dance as it was this
coming Friday night.
Fillmore Drain. The Mayor informed the Council that he
distributed copies of the Fillmore Drain report to each. of
them and would ask that they give it some study.
4. Electrical Inspector. The Mayor said that he had a call
from one of the local builders complaining about the
electrical inspections The City's electrical inspector
was lost when Mr. Dufur left. He informed the Council that
he talked with the Inspector at Nampa and also to Ken
Harward. and hopefully made arrangements for the City of
Caldwell to use their Electrical Inspector.
Great Rice. The Mayor explained that this was a cross
country race with teams from the Los Angeles Police Force
and the Los Angeles County Fire Department and they will
arrive in Caldwell at 5:43 a.m. on the 17th of July. This
was for informative purposes.
6. Music Week. The Mayor informed the City Council that he
had proclaimed the week of May 3rd to May 10th as Music
Week.
7. Shop Mechanic. The Mayor explained that the City doesn't
have a Shop Mechanic and the Mayor stated that he would
like to contract with a part -time shop mechanic for
evenings. It could be someone who was not working or
someone who would care to work nights even though they
have a day time job.
Councilwoman Mallea reminded the Council members and the Mayor
that they were to leave at 10:45 a.m. on Thursday for Hewlett
Packard.
Book 22
Page 120
Councilwoman Williams said that she had two questions with regard
to pre- writes. One was the two payments that were made to Jim
Keesee with regard to the maintenance of the typewriters in the
City Hall. The Mayor stated that he would look up the contract
and check it out. She also had a. question about a petty cash
check in the amount of $200.00
There being no further business, the Meeting was adjourned at
1:25 p.m.
APPROVED AS written THIS 5th DAY OF May 1981.
r
C u c�1 tea.
_.
(Co-�Jnc lman.
Councilman.
ATTEST:
' �; l 1 ,