HomeMy WebLinkAbout2003-04-07city council minutesREGULAR MEETING
APRIL 7, 2003
7:00 P.M.
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor Nancolas.
The Invocation was offered by Pastor Don Brown of Caldwell Friends Church. Everyone remained
standing for the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. The Mayor asked that everyone join in a moment of
silence to honor those who have given their lives to defend the freedom of this great nation.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members present: Ozuna, Dakan, Wells,
Blacker, and Callsen. Absent: Hopper.
The Mayor excused Council President Hopper as he was in Hawaii on vacation with his family.
SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS
The Mayor presented Tim Scott of the Caldwell Fire Department for Employee of the Month. He read
letters of nomination that were submitted by Doug Brown and Russ Elsberry. Tim Scott was recognized for
his preparation, organization, coordination, and execution of the fire prevention month activities in 2002.
Through the home - escape plan activity for the school children, Tim provided an extremely important
message to our youth. The program was so successful that we had practically 100% participation from the
children that went home and completed home -fire escape plans and then brought them back to school. To
reward students, winners were selected and treated to a ride on a fire engine and pizza with the firefighters
at the fire station. Tim came in on his off -duty hours to take care of all luncheons. The Mayor commended
Tim for his commitment. It was his pleasure to present to Tim Scott with City of Caldwell Employee of the
Month in appreciation for his outstanding work ethics. Tim Scott was introduced and presented with a
plaque and gift.
Mayor welcomed and introduced Mrs. Moss of Caldwell High School who was present with some students.
Students were asked to stand and introduce themselves. Also, in attendance was a scout member that
introduced himself and was welcomed.
ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS TO THE AGENDA
MOVED by Ozuna, SECONDED by Callsen that Item No. 1 be removed from New Business and replaced
with a request by the Caldwell Night Rodeo Board.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, Blacker, and Callsen. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Blacker to approve the Agenda as amended.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION
Mayor asked if there was anyone present that wanted to address the City Council about an item that was not
on the Agenda. There was none.
CONSENT CALENDAR
The Mayor presented the following items on the Consent Calendar for Council's consideration:
1. Dispense with reading of the minutes of the March 17, 2003 Regular City Council Meeting and the
March 27, 2003 Special City Council Meeting and approve as written;
2. Approve acceptance of the minutes from the Caldwell Golf Board Meeting held on February 19, 2003
and the Caldwell Industrial Airport Commission Meeting held on March 20, 2003;
3. Approve the following Resolution to authorize execution of a Crossing Agreement with Pioneer
Irrigation District:
RESOLUTION NO. 24 -03 OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO ACCEPTING A CROSSING
AGREEMENT WITH PIONEER IRRIGATION DISTRICT FOR THE CONSTRUCTION,
OPERATION, AND MAINTENANCE OF MUNICIPAL WATER AND SEWER MAINS AND
STREET IMPROVEMENTS ACROSS THE LOW LINE CANAL, THE STEVENS LATERAL, THE
SOUTH BRANCH OF THE 15.0 LATERAL, AND THE NORTH BRANCH OF THE 15.0
LATERAL, WITHIN THE HOMEDALE ROAD AND MIDWAY AVENUE RIGHTS OF WAY.
BE IT RESOLVED that the City of Caldwell, Idaho hereby accepts and approves a "Crossing
Agreement" between the City of Caldwell and Pioneer District. Said crossing agreement entitles the
City of Caldwell to enter the Low Line Canal, Stevens Lateral, and 15.0 Lateral Easements for the
construction, operation, and maintenance of municipal sewer and water mains and street
improvements.
The Mayor of the City of Caldwell is hereby authorized to execute the crossing agreement, and a copy
of said agreement shall be forwarded by the City Clerk to the Engineering Department of said City of
Caldwell.
4. Approve acceptance of a Deed to the City of Caldwell from Donald K. Stritzke, Dirk Sypherd and
Catherine Sypherd for additional right of way;
5. Approve Order of Decision on Case No. SUB- 78F -02, Virginia Park No. 2 Final Plat approval;
6. Approve the following Resolution to authorize execution of a Crossing Agreement with the United
States of America Bureau of Reclamation:
RESOLUTION NO. 25 -03 OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO ACCEPTING A CROSSING
AGREEMENT WITH THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR BUREAU OF
RECLAMATION FOR THE CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION, AND MAINTENANCE OF A
POTABLE WATER MAIN WITHIN THE WILSON, ELIJAH, AND MOSES DRAIN
EASEMENTS, AND THE NOTUS FEEDER CANAL EASEMENT.
BE IT RESOLVED that the City of Caldwell, Idaho hereby accepts and approves a "Crossing
Agreement' between the City of Caldwell and the United States Department of Interior Bureau of
Reclamation. Said crossing agreement entitles the City of Caldwell to enter the Wilson, Elijah, and
Moses Drain and Notus Feeder Canal Easements for potable water main construction, operation, and
maintenance purposes.
The Mayor of the City of Caldwell is hereby authorized to execute the crossing agreement, and a copy
of said agreement shall be forwarded by the City Clerk to the Engineering Department of said City of
Caldwell.
7. Approve a request by the Idaho Department of Water Resources for the City of Caldwell to provide in-
kind assistance in the amount of $10,000 for a two -year Rebuild America Special Project Grant;
8. Approve the following Resolution to authorize execution of a Conditional Quitclaim Deed Agreement
with Brent G. Andrae for Milagro Subdivision:
RESOLUTION NO. 26 -03 OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO ACCEPTING A
CONDITIONAL QUITCLAIM DEED AGREEMENT WITH BRENT G. ANDRAE FOR THE
PURPOSE OF ACQUIRING RIGHT -OF -WAY FOR THE CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION, AND
MAINTENANCE OF A PORTION OF MADERA WAY, A RESIDENTIAL STREET IN THE
MILAGRO SUBDIVISION.
BE IT RESOLVED that the City of Caldwell, Idaho hereby accepts and approves a "Conditional
Quitclaim Deed Agreement' between the City of Caldwell and Brent G. Andrae, of 13945 Homedale
Road. Said agreement transfers to the City of Caldwell a five (5) foot wide strip of land to be used as
public right -of -way for Madera Way, a residential street in the Milagro Subdivision. The condition of
the agreement stipulates that said parcel shall not be used for the location of above ground utilities,
excepting City sewer and water facilities, until such time as the adjoining five (5) acre parcel is legally
annexed into the City of Caldwell.
The Mayor of the City of Caldwell is hereby authorized to execute the crossing agreement, and a copy
of said agreement shall be forwarded by the City Clerk to the Engineering Department of said City of
Caldwell.
9. Approve the following Resolution to authorize execution of a Consultant Services Agreement with
Montgomery Watson Harza:
RESOLUTION NO. 27 -03 BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the Mayor and Council of the City of
Caldwell, Idaho, that the Mayor and Clerk of said City are hereby authorized to execute that certain
"Amendment 7 to an Agreement for Engineering Services /Caldwell Wastewater Treatment Plant
Improvements ", which Agreement is by and between said City and Montgomery Watson Harza; and
which Agreement is for the performance of pre - design services related to a new Digester No. 4 at the
treatment plant; and which Agreement is attached hereto and made a part hereof as if set forth in full.
10. Approve the following Resolution to authorize execution of an Adjustment to Consultant Services
Agreement with Montgomery Watson Harza:
RESOLUTION NO. 28 -03 BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the Mayor and Council of the City of
Caldwell, Idaho, that the Mayor and Clerk of said City are hereby authorized to execute that certain
Attachment 1 to an agreement titled "Agreement for Consulting Services — Caldwell Wastewater
Treatment Plant Improvements ", dated May 5, 1997, and subsequent updates in May 1998, July 1999,
July 2000, and May 2001, by and between said City and Montgomery - Watson - Harza; which
Attachment is for the approval of changes in billing rates; and which changes to billing rates are
attached hereto and made a part hereof as if set forth in full.
MOVED by Blacker, SECONDED by Dakan to approve the Consent Calendar as presented
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Blacker, Callsen, Ozuna, Dakan, and Wells. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
OLD BUSINESS
NEW BUSINESS
(CONSIDER REQUEST FROM CALDWELL NIGHT RODEO TO MODIFY RODEO GROUNDS
BOUNDARY)
The Mayor explained that this is an item that the Caldwell Night Rodeo has discussed for the last several
years. It is their desire to slightly modify their lease to include a 27 foot by 181 foot piece of ground which
is on the southwest corner. This would square up the western boundary of the rodeo grounds so that they
can have a little more room for their booths along that side and also make the entrance in a more uniform
manner. As stated in the letter, if the request is approved they will extend the rod iron fence and the
masonry fence by one more section and will square up the front of the rodeo grounds and make it more
useable.
Requires approval of City Council and then the City would change the document as Attachment A to their
lease and include this as the Attachment A. The Mayor asked Council if there were any questions. There
were none. Mayor restated that this is something that has been talked about for a long time. It was his
recommendation that the City do this. The Caldwell Night Rodeo is struggling for room and their
attendance is growing year after year.
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Blacker to approve the request by Caldwell Night Rodeo to modify
the rodeo grounds boundary.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
(CONSIDER REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT BY MR. ALVIN
POWELL)
Mr. Powell's request has been moved to the next City Council Meeting. The Mayor discovered after -the-
fact that this needed to be noticed publicly. The Mayor thanked Steve for handling this and making sure it
was taken care of.
(CONSIDER REQUEST BY DR. ROBERGE FOR VARIANCE OF WATER CONNECTION
FEES)
The Mayor gave a brief background: he was contacted by the contractor for Dr. Roberge, who was in the
process of doing a landscaping project and connecting to City water services for a small landscaped area.
Dr. Roberge had addressed the issue with the City's Engineer Department and the prescribed fee for water
connection was around $500 for that connection. City Engineer, Mr. Law advised that the fees were set by
resolution and he did not have the authority to alter. The Mayor was also asked if there could be a variance.
It was explained that with a resolution being passed by City Council, the Mayor did not have the authority,
anymore than Mr. Law did, to make any variance. They would need to make a request to City Council.
Dr. Richard Roberge stated his name and indicated that he was here for a variance on a hookup to his
medical office for water for irrigation. The total landscaped area is approximately 1200 square feet; the rest
is either the building or the paved parking lot. Because of the impossibility to irrigate through the Pioneer
Irrigation District's irrigation system, Dr. Roberge decided to put a pressurized automatic sprinkler system
in. He hired a professional to put the system in and was surprised to realize that the bill for just the hookup
was $585.00. He requested a lower fee since it's a small area and he won't be using potable water to the
degree that acres of landscaping would require.
Councilman Dakan asked if the building were already on City water. Dr. Roberge answered yes. Dakan
asked if he was required to have a separate water meter. Dr. Roberge thought that it did. The Mayor asked
Mr. Law if he could answer this question. Mr. Law could not address the question and did not know what
was included in the fee. The Mayor asked if he had an idea in mind what his variance was as far as his
request. Dr. Roberge thought that half the price would be an acceptable fee or something that he thought
would be agreeable.
Councilman Wells asked Mr. Law about the connection fee (and sounds like there is a misunderstanding
about whether a second meter was installed or not) and his assumption that it would include a new water
meter. Mr. Law stated that was not necessarily true. He did not bring information with him that would state
whether the $585.00 includes a meter; but, he suspects that it does not. Wells asked if Dr. Roberge connects
to his existing system, would that require a connection fee. Mr. Law stated that the nature of the use is
being added to here. It makes no difference whether you connect to a new system or not. Prior to this time,
use was for domestic use inside his facility and he is requesting an addition for irrigation uses. hi our fee
schedule we have separated the two and charged a separate fee for each.
The Mayor cautioned that when making a decision to grant a variance, consideration needs to be given in
establishing some precedence. In addition, these things are established by resolution so that you can have a
legal nexus to create the fee to begin with. The fee is attached to the burden of the water system for future
expansion, new wells, property acquisition, and those types of things. That is why there is a connection fee
that is associated with that so as the system grows and expands, you also have money to continue to expand
the system so that it doesn't come back to the existing users that are not expanding.
Councilman Blacker asked Mr. Law if the City had to go through any mechanics or work to hook this up or
is it just the flip of a switch. Is there any expenditure on the City's part? Mr. Law stated that if it requires a
meter, yes. If doesn't include a meter, there will be at least an inspection to make sure that the backflow
preventer and so forth is in place. As far as mechanics, the Council has established this by resolution
already. Any action, other than the established resolution, will be by resolution as well.
Councilman Wells questioned the granting of a variance that would set precedence and put into question
the fee schedule that was original put together. If the Council grants a variance, Wells does not believe that
there is enough information to make that kind of a decision tonight and consider all of the consequences.
MOVED by Wells, SECONDED by Blacker to defer the decision until next City Council Meeting.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wells, Blacker, Callsen, Ozuna, and Dakan. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
(CONSIDER BAD DEBT POLICY AND SET PUBLIC HEARING FOR MAY 5, 2003)
This was a workshop held tonight regarding a bad debt policy. The purpose of this as an agenda item is to
set a public hearing for May 5, 2003 and get it noticed. This bad debt policy is in regards to water bill fees
and the amount of bad debt that the City is incurring each month through that process and trying to
eliminate bad debt.
MOVED by Blacker, and SECONDED by Ozuna to set a public hearing to consider a new bad debt policy
for the May 5, 2003 regular scheduled City Council Meeting.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Blacker, Callsen, Ozuna, Dakan, and Wells. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
(PUBLIC HEARING [QUASI- JUDICIAL] ON CASE NO. SUB- 79F -02, REQUEST BY BILL
GILBERT FOR FINAL PLAT APPROVAL OF SKYWAY BUSINESS PARK
Mayor explained the public hearing process, the sign -up sheet to speak, and swearing in everyone who
wishes to speak. Everyone signed up to speak was sworn in by the City Clerk.
Joan Johnson, Community Development Planner for the City of Caldwell, 621 Cleveland Blvd.,
acknowledged that she had been sworn in. Ms. Johnson reported as follows: as was noted in the Staff
Report, the request for the applicant is requesting the final subdivision plat approval of Skyway Business
Park in order to develop 18 commercial lots and 3 common area lots on approximately 40 acres within an
M -1 light industrial zone. As noted in the Staff Report, we did get a few public comments back from the
Engineering Department. One of those would include the information in regards to the financial guarantee.
The applicant's representative, Kent Gingrich, has been working with Scott Woods of our Engineering
Staff. The Engineering Department can update you on the bonding status.
Gordon Law, City Engineer, had nothing additional to add with regards to bonding. The process usually
works it out before the signature is placed by the City Engineer. This has been a long time issue on this
particular item.
Bill Gilbert requested that Kent Gingrich speak before him. Kent Gingrich, 491 W. Pack Avenue,
Meridian, noted that he had been sworn in. They having been working with Mr. Woods in the Engineering
Department and he think they have arrived at financial guarantee with what remaining items they still need
to build. They have provided a plat and submitted it, there were a couple of small corrections that have
been made and turned back into Mr. Woods. All the plans originally in the Engineer record before the
original development plans, remain the same. Probably 95% of everything is constructed.
Bill Gilbert, 11476 E Linden, Caldwell. So far as the guarantee goes, I assure you it's there. I would prefer,
I don't know what the wording would be, but I would like to give you a letter of credit from one of my
banks. I understand that this could be done. As soon as we know what we need, the letter of credit will be
to you within 3 days of that time.
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Blacker to close the public testimony portion of the hearing.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Callsen, Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, and Blacker. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor presented the following Evidence List as follows: Staff Report, sign -up sheets, and the packet
that was presented to Council.
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Ozuna to approve the Evidence List as presented by the Mayor.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor stated that since a comprehensive plan analysis is done at the preliminary plat level, there is not
a need for one this evening. The Mayor asked for the Council's findings of facts.
FINDINGS OF FACT:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Blacker to accept the general facts outlined in the Staff Report and
published testimonies this evening, and there was no one here to testify against it.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Callsen, Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, and Blacker. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW:
MOVED by Ozuna, SECONDED by Callsen that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear
requests on final plats and to make the decision to approve or deny; the public hearing was noticed and
heard within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, Blacker, and Callsen. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDER OF DECISION:
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Dakan that based upon the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,
the Caldwell City Council orders that Case No. SUB 79F -02, a request by Bill Gilbert to develop Skyway
Business Park on approximately 40.19 acres within an M -1 zone was approved.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Callsen, Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, and Blacker. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Blacker to close the Public Hearing.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
(PUBLIC HEARING [QUASI - JUDICIAL] ON CASE NO. SUB- 82PF -02, REQUEST BY SALLIE
PALLERIA FOR PRELIMINARY AND FINAL PLAT APPROVAL FOR OHIO PLACE
SUBDIVISION)
The Mayor stated the above as the next item, and the term for this is a short plat. Sallie Palleria was the
only one signed up to speak.
Joan Johnson, Community Development Planner for the City of Caldwell, 621 Cleveland Blvd. noted she
had been sworn in. As noted in the Staff Report, this is a request by Sallie Palleria for preliminary and final
plat approval of Ohio Place Subdivision consisting of 2 residential lots in an R -2 medium density
residential zone. This request is being heard under the short plat process (Section 110207, Sub - Section 6 of
Subdivision Ordinance No. 1758 and Section 110204, Sub - Section 5d). In this case, the Planning & Zoning
Commission approved the preliminary plat on February 17 and recommended approval on the final plat.
The applicant has been working with the Engineering Department on the financial guarantee and bonding.
Sallie Palleria, 2511 Dorman, noted she had been sworn in. She would just like to have a final plat, a
preliminary and final at the same time. This is a parcel that they would like to split down the center. At this
time, they are constructing a 4 -plex on one side of it that has already received a special use permit. They
will be putting an apartment on the other side if and when this gets split.
The Mayor indicated the only question they would have is that whatever bonding, if necessary, would be
taken care of through the Engineering Department before the final plat is signed. Ms. Palleria stated that
she has spoken with engineering and has a bid being done on the sidewalk which has to be put in and also
where they are putting in the approach in the already existing curb and gutter.
MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Ozuna to close the public testimony portion ofthe hearing
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Callsen, Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, and Blacker. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS:
MOVED by Wells, SECONDED by Blacker to accept the Planning & Zoning Commission's
Comprehensive Plan Analysis.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wells, Blacker, Callsen, Ozuna, and Dakan. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
EVIDENCE LIST:
The Mayor presented the following Evidence List as follows: Staff Report, sign -up sheets, and City
Council packet.
MOVED by Blacker, SECONDED by Dakan to approve the Evidence List as presented by the Mayor.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Blacker, Callsen, Ozuna, Dakan, and Wells. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
FINDINGS OF FACT:
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Wells to accept the general facts outlined in the Staff Report, public
testimony, as well as there is no opposition to this.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW:
MOVED by Ozuna, SECONDED by Blacker that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear this
request and approve or deny; the public hearing was noticed and heard within the guidelines of applicable
state codes and local ordinances.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, Blacker, and Callsen. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDER OF DECISION:
MOVED by Ozuna, SECONDED by Dakan that based upon the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,
the Caldwell City Council orders that Case No. SUB 82PF -02, a request by Sallie Palleria for preliminary
and final plat approval of Ohio Place Subdivision was approved with the aforementioned conditions.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, Blacker, and Callsen. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Wells to close the Public Hearing.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
(PUBLIC HEARING [QUASI- JUDICIAL] ON CASE NO. ANN -79 -03 AND SUB- 84P -03,
REQUEST BY PINNACLE ENGINEERING FOR ANNEXATION OF 57.32 ACRES AS AN R -1
ZONE AND PRELIMINARY PLAT APPROVAL OF APPLE CREEK SUBDIVISION)
The Mayor indicated that these two items would be heard simultaneously and testimony on both items will
be heard concurrently. There will be separate findings for the annexation and the rezone and separate
findings and decisions for the preliminary plat. There were 4 people signed up to speak.
Steven Hasson, Community Development Director for the City of Caldwell, 621 Cleveland Blvd. This is an
application submitted by Pinnacle Engineering on behalf of Sawtooth Land Development and Caldwell
School District for the annexation of approximately 57.32 acres into the city as R -1 zone. This development
is exactly what the City is looking in terms of development plans for our city. As it comes into the city, it is
county agriculture and it would be rezoned R -1 and this would afford a development of 171 parcels. We
need to backup for a moment, we did have a notice defect. When we put the public notice out, we had the
time, date and place certain, but we did not have the correct body. We put reference to a hearing examiner,
when in fact it is the Mayor and Council. Our attorney, Mark Hilty, was of the same persuasion that there
was not any kind of a due process issue. A letter from Bill Gigray, III, the attorney for the applicant, has
concluded something similar. In absence of some concern on part of the Council or some person present,
I'll proceed with that declaration. [There was no concern raised by Council or persons present.]
Mr. Hasson continued: Laster Lane will be a major collector and it's a roadway that doesn't exist right
now, but it will punctuate through the property and connect with Montana On the south side of Laster Lane
will be constructed a new elementary school that represents about 16 acres of the 57 acres. The new
elementary school is about 6600 square feet and will serve 700 students. There will be a development
agreement that goes with this development application. There were some administrative determinations
with regards to a frontage setback dilemma, a height limitation —the school needs 30 feet instead of the R -1
zone of 25 feet, and a qualifier that some of the school playground could serve for purposes of landscape
for the whole development. They have provided a lot of walking paths and connectivity.
Clint Boyle with Pinnacle Engineering, 12552 W Executive Drive in Boise and noted he had been sworn in.
There are some key issues that still remain issues: the pressurized irrigation system, which the school
district would like to own and maintain for the school site. There are several reasons for this, presently the
site has two irrigation sources that are delivered through gravity irrigation and also one existing irrigation
well. The gravity irrigation to the site has some potential issues with Pioneer Irrigation that have essentially
made it to where Pioneer Irrigation is not willing to accept any sort of irrigation system that is connected to
those gravity lines. We have discussed this with the engineering staff and believe there is an agreement
whereas they would allow the school site to own and maintain their own pressurized irrigation system.
Clint Boyle continued: the irrigation system is referenced as being one that would be owned and
maintained by Pioneer Irrigation in a couple of different spots in the Staff Report (Engineering Item #5 and
Irrigation Item #2.18). When they went through the Hearing Examiner, the recommendation he made was
that they submit to Pioneer Irrigation and if they did not accept the pressure irrigation system for the
development that they work with the engineering staff to come up with a different entity for the ownership
and maintenance. Item #7 of the Engineering Comments related to the developer deeding right -of -way. His
understanding is that this is specifically for right -of -way that is outside of the bounds of this project. In
previous discussions with the engineering staff, over time this condition could be removed, so they would
like it removed for clarification for people reviewing the conditions.
Clint Boyle continued: a traffic impact study has been submitted on the project about a day or two ago,
which was another condition that the hearing examiner had applied and also the engineering staff was
recommending that was based on the elementary school, the size and scope of the development. There was
discussion about whether or not any of the intersections at Laster and Montana or Laster and 10"' would
need improvements such as signalization. Based on this traffic study, the traffic counts and traffic
movements are well within parameters for a non - signalized intersection. Finally, probably the largest issue
for tonight and the school district, is the fact that they are on very fast and timely schedule to commence
construction on the school to meet their needs and desires to have this school open in the Fall of 2004. With
this tight construction schedule, they are requesting that the Council consider allowing the school district to
submit for building plan review prior to the recordation of the final plat. The school district would make the
commitment that they would not pull a building permit prior to the plat being recorded. We have had
discussions related to State Code with regards to school districts and our understanding is the spirit and
intent of the Idaho State Statutes regarding public schools would allow for such a submittal for public
school site to occur prior to the plat being recorded.
Councilman Wells asked staff about the use for the administrative determination concerning the landscape
requirements, the buffering of the shift of the green space from the residential portion to the school site,
does that need to have some kind of development or agreement between the two that they acknowledge that
this will take place. Mr. Hasson answered no, he looked at this project as a residential development that is
framed around a school and that they are really an intricate part of each other and the design of the
development is a design that takes into account fully the school and its presence.
Councilman Wells restated his question, is there an agreement that is needed that says the school will be
able to go directly into through the micro paths into the subdivision area and vise versa Mr. Hasson stated
that from a application process, we have made it very implicit that there is a commonality and an agreement
between parties as to uses of both the school property and the residential property and there interrelation.
There are 83 conditions in the application that speaks to the many different points to include an
understanding about the walkways, the pathways and the connectivity. Based on the landscaping
requirements, we were slightly under, if you take out the school site, what would normally be required. In
meeting with the City staff and in discussions with the school, the understanding was that school grounds
would be available for public usage.
Councilman Wells asked Mr. Law if he saw the on -sight irrigation system as an issue for the City's water
rights and use issue for future location of wells. Mr. Law answered, with regards to the school site, the
request by the applicant to have a separate system operated by the school fulfills at least one primary
requirement we have for these irrigation systems, and that is when you don't have multiple ownership that
it is okay for the site to have its own irrigation system. For those portions where there will be multiple
ownerships, the residential portions, it would not be appropriate to have a private entity or a non - irrigation
entity operating the system. Thus, the school site is fine, the residential site does not have the support of the
Engineering Department except to handle it the normal way through Pioneer Irrigation District. With
regards to the source of the water, in this end of the valley we do have what we consider to be a limited
resource for pristine waters. If the school site chooses to produce from a well, we would request that that
well production zone not be in the pristine zones that we normally use. If an application for a well - drilling
permit is applied for, we are likely to make comment restricting it to the upper level, which are usually
compromised anyway. Councilman Wells asked if the school was going to use a service well would they
need to make this a part of the condition. Clint Boyle indicated that they have pulled the well reports on this
property and based on the well drilling reports, the existing irrigation well is 108 feet deep. His
understanding from Mr. Law is that this would be in the upper aquifer area that is outside what is
considered the pristine area. He does not know if they will change the point of diversion. Mr. Law stated
that 108 feet deep for a production well is not into the zone or area that we normally consider our primary
source, which generally would be below 200 or 250 feet and above 450 feet.
Councilman Wells asked Mr. Law if he agreed with the comments from the applicant about the traffic
study. Mr. Law answered that they had not reviewed the traffic study in detail at this point in time. He had
no reason to assume that Mr. Boyle had summarized it incorrectly or correctly. Mr. Law asked that
conditions be explained to him again. Mr. Boyle stated that the pressure irrigation comments were
specifically related to Item #5 of the Engineering Comments and referred to in Irrigation — Item 2.18 of the
Staff Report (page 9). The discussion under Item #5 is with regards to Pioneer Irrigation and they just
wanted a clarification that the school site was acceptable as its own entity to the pressure irrigation. Item #7
of the Engineering Comments where it indicates the portion of street right -of -ways not in the proposed
subdivision but owned by the developer should be deeded to the City. The owner of this property does not
own any contiguous land. Engineering Comment #25 was the traffic study. He wanted to point out that the
indication from the traffic study indicated that no improvements were necessary for signalization or
additional lanes, etc. at Laster and Montana or Laster and 10"'. Transportation Item #2.16 is just a
clarification; it states there are two connections from the school site when there are actually three (two
public access driveways for the parking area and then a bus only access for loading and unloading). Final
issue is Item 12.3, which specifically relates to the building permit issuance. Item 12.3 and also Fire
District Comments Item 12.17.13, he believes these items can go away because the request is for Council to
allow the school district to submit plans for review and then have the plat recorded prior to actually
obtaining or pulling the building permit. They are not asking for any deviations, just that they can submit
plans and keep the school district in the process and on track with their schedule.
Bill Hamlin, at 9 12"' Avenue S. in Nampa and he noted he had been sworn in. If we look at potential time
frame for signing a final plat and if we submit the plans subsequent to the signing, it does cause some
difficulties with condensed construction time. Notwithstanding some of the problems that can come up
during the construction with delays, we don't want to get into acceleration costs and additional expenses for
the district. We have already submitted building plans to the State and the State has already done their
preliminary review and given us their initial comments. Simply what we are asking is that we are able to
submit the plans, get them in the review process, get comments (if there are any), and address any
comments so when the plat is recorded that the permit can be issued promptly.
Mr. Law stated that is seems to be at the heart of a request here by the applicant, particularly on behalf of
the school district, that special dispensation be given to handling of a building permit for this particular
application. He asked that Council consider in their decision that we have applicants for building permits
who have met all of the conditions. Perhaps this request is suggesting that those applicants should take
second seat on their building permit applications when this particular applicant has not yet met all of the
conditions. This raises the issue of precedence, where would the application stop and who would not be
able to get this privilege and who would. This is a continuing concern for staff in any request like this.
Councilman Wells asked the City Attorney, Carl Hamilton if the Council could make a decision like this or
would this put us in a problem if we were to approve that. Mr. Hamilton asked Wells if he was talking
about the building permit. Wells answered yes, can we circumvent a process that is already in place? Mr.
Hamilton did not have an answer. Mr. Hamlin replied that his understanding of the current State Code is
that it already gives this to public schools. Public schools can "go to the head of the line." This intent has
already been indicated in the State Code, preference can and will be given to public schools. Mr. Hasson
weighed in that he believed this to be an administrative call.
Rita Earl with Earl, Mason, Stanfield and Engineering, 314 Badiola Street in Caldwell and she noted she
had been sworn in. They are the engineering firm on the residential portion of this development. They do
know and understand the irrigation for the residential development will be through Pioneer Irrigation and
they will be designing and submitting the appropriate plans and they will be taking over maintenance and
ownership.
The Mayor declared a short recess.
Bill Gigray, III, 1523 Dearborn, Caldwell and he acknowledged that he had been sworn in. He was
appearing as the attorney for the Caldwell School District. The district simply wants to be in a position so
that it can irrigate the 16 -acre parcel and it does have the staff and the capability to do that. In response to
Councilman Well's concern, he stated that the school has, in their operational process, had elementary
school sites available for recreational use and available for the public. They would ask your consideration
and at least the direction of the staff, that they would be able to at least facilitate the filing of the building
plan so that that review process could at least get in line to get in the review. He stated that in support of
our position, he believes it's within the spirit of Idaho Code Section 67 -6519 that, "provided, however, any
permit application which relates to a public school facility shall receive priority consideration and shall be
reviewed for approval, denial, or recommendation by the commission or the governing board at the earliest
reasonable time regardless of the timing of its submission relative to other applications which are not
related to public school facility."
Councilman Blacker asked Mr. Hasson how long the delay would be if there were no special timeframe
given. Mr. Hasson stated that there is nothing that precludes them from coming in now and taking the
initiative to get into the system. He doesn't think that we need to have a Council to agree to mandate that,
but leave it up to the staffs judgment that we work with the applicant. Mr. Hasson assured those present
and the Council that the City will do its best to speed things up and help the process along.
Councilman Dakan spoke to Mr. Hasson that he understood that they could get into the schedule without
having the process completed for the plat. Mr. Hasson answered yes, they could.
Clint Boyle had a rebuttal testimony. The only item of clarification is Item 12.3, which specifically states
that no building permit shall be accepted for processing until the plat has been approved and recorded.
They would request that this condition be modified. Mr. Hasson stated that staff would concede that point
and request to the Council that there be an amendment, which affords them the assurance that they need.
The language would be under Item 12.3, that "no building permit shall be issued" until the final plat has
been approved. Councilman Wells asked if this proposed change would be for just the school portion or for
the whole preliminary plat. Mr. Boyle stated that the request for the permits is specific to the school site.
The Mayor asked Mr. Law about Condition 5, if language stating that the school district would be
permitted to operate on its own system with the final approval of the engineering department would be
acceptable language for number 5. Mr. Law stated that with regards to the irrigation system and limit to the
school site only.
The Mayor asked Mr. Gigray regarding Item 7, the portion of the street right -of -way not in the proposed
subdivision but owned by the developer should be deeded to the City. Rita Earl yielded to the question. It is
her understanding that the current property owner only owns that one piece of property. She suggested that
staff agree to the word of "adjacent" being in there, she thinks that would clarify everything. Mr. Law
stated that that would be acceptable.
The Mayor stated the next item was Item 27, he felt that it was correct as indicated by staff that they did not
have time yet to review that impact study. They had no reason to suspect any kind of inappropriateness
with that study at all. In fairness to staff, some statement needs to be made there that staff had a chance to
review the findings of the study and make comment. The last item is under Item 12.3 (page 16) which
addresses the building permit process.
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Blacker to close the public testimony portion of the hearing.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor presented the following Evidence List for Case No. ANN -79 -03 as follows: the sign -up sheets,
Staff Report, Council packet, and the City of Caldwell zone map.
MOVED by Ozuna, SECONDED by Dakan to approve the Evidence List as presented by the Mayor.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, Blacker, and Callsen. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor stated that the first item is ANN- 79 -03, which is a request for annexation with a request to zone
the parcel of 57.32 acres as an R -1 single - family residential zone. In your packet is a Comprehensive Plan
Analysis for this portion.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS FOR CASE NO. ANN- 79 -03:
MOVED by Wells, SECONDED by Blacker that we accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as provided
in the Staff Report.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wells, Blacker, Callsen, Ozuna, and Dakan. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
FINDINGS OF FACT FOR CASE NO. ANN- 79 -03:
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Wells to accept the general facts outlined in the Staff Report, public
testimony with the changes to Items 5, 7, 25, and 12.3, and there was no one to testify in opposition of the
request.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW FOR CASE NO. ANN- 79 -03:
MOVED by Ozuna, SECONDED by Blacker that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear this
request and to make the decision to approve or deny; the hearing was legally noticed and conducted within
the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, Blacker, and Callsen. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDER OF DECISION FOR CASE NO. ANN- 79 -03:
MOVED by Ozuna, SECONDED by Callsen that based upon the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,
the Caldwell City Council orders that Case No. ANN- 79 -03, a request by Jeanne and Robert Slate to annex
approximately 57.23 acres into the City of Caldwell as an R -1 zone to include a development agreement
was approved with the aforementioned conditions.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, Blacker, and Callsen. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor stated that we move to SUB- 84P -03 which is the preliminary plat for the subdivision.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ANALYSIS FOR CASE NO. SUB - 84P -03:
MOVED by Wells, SECONDED by Blacker that we accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as stated in
the Staff Report under Roman Numeral V or SUB - 84P -03.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wells, Blacker, Callsen, Ozuna, and Dakan. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
FINDINGS OF FACT FOR CASE NO. SUB - 84P -03:
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Blacker to accept the general facts outlined in the Staff Report, public
testimony with the language changes to Items 5, 7, 25, and 12.3, and there was no one to testify in
opposition of the request.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW FOR CASE NO. SUB - 84P -03:
MOVED by Ozuna, SECONDED by Blacker that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear this
request and to make the decision to approve or deny; the hearing was legally noticed and conducted within
the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Ozuna, Dakan, Wells, Blacker, and Callsen. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDER OF DECISION FOR CASE NO. SUB - 84P -03:
MOVED by Wells, SECONDED by Dakan that based upon the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,
the Caldwell City Council orders that Case No. SUB - 84P -03, a request for preliminary plat approval for
Apple Creek Subdivision was approved with the conditions 12.1 through 12.19 as amended in the Staff
Report, and the amendments as described by Councilman Dakan in his Findings of Fact.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wells, Blacker, Callsen, Ozuna, and Dakan. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Blacker to close the Public Hearing.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Wells, Blacker, Callsen, and Ozuna. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor mentioned that Betty Jo Keller had retired and introduced Monica Jones as the City Clerk.
FINANCIAL REPORT
The financial report was missing from the packet. There was discussion about what process needed to be
followed to take care of this report.
MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Wells that the Financial Report be moved to the next regular meeting.
Dakan withdrew the motion. The Mayor requested that the City Clerk discuss with the Finance Director
and the City Attorney to make a determination whether a special meeting needs to be called. The Mayor
and Councilman Hopper will both be gone so there won't be enough members to conduct a meeting.
MOVED by Wells, SECONDED by Blacker to approve Councilwoman Ozuna as the backup Council
President in the absence of Mayor and Council President.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Wells, Blacker, Callsen, Ozuna, and Dakan. Those voting no: none.
Absent and not voting: Hopper.
MOTION CARRIED
COUNCIL REPORTS
Councilman Dakan reported that there is an organization meeting tomorrow (4/8/03) at 3:00 at the Animal
Shelter. He stated that there has been some turmoil but the new County Commissioner has taken care of the
situation. They have a new acting director. He commented on how nice the new shelter facility is.
Councilman Ozuna reported that April 26 is Community Pride Day. She suggested that the Council make
a team. She asked the Mayor about the status of impact fees, recycling, and emission testing. The Mayor
stated, with regards to emission testing, we simply need to schedule a workshop, which will probably be
coming up the later part of May with Compass. Greenleaf has already held a meeting and they have denied
it. The Mayor understood from the County that the conditions were that Nampa and Caldwell both had to
approve it and a majority of the remaining cities. The Mayor stated that we received the questionnaires that
the Chamber helped send on recycling, 75% were in favor of recycling and 25% against. This time we
presented the numbers at $2.18 per month and a $2.00 discount for seniors. We have not received back
those from the water bills that we sent out. He will check with the Finance Director to find out when those
will be coming in. On emission testing, there were 64 returned from the Chambers — 32 were in favor or 32
were against. If we decide to go forward with impact fees we will need to set up another workshop and
discuss with Mr. Hasson.
MAYOR'S COMMENTS
The Mayor stated that he will be out of town on Tuesday and Wednesday of this week He will be taking
vacation and going steelhead fishing.
The leadership conference starts this Sunday and is in Sun Valley.
We have a workshop on the Airport ordinance on April 21" at 6:00 and the City Council Meeting at 7:00.
On Tuesday, April 22 Debbie Willis and another Colonial from the Army Corp of Engineers is going to
be at City Hall conducting some informational workshops. Council members are welcome to attend. They
will start at 1:00 in my office and will take most of the afternoon.
The negotiations between Treasure Valley Transit Commuter Bus and Valley Ride have been worked out.
The documents have been signed and so your action taken has continued bus service in the valley at least
through the next six months and then we'll see what happens from there.
The Police station has a Centennial Celebration of the Police Department at 2:00 on April 25 We would
love for all to attend if you can.
On April 26 from 9:00 to 12:00 is a clean -up day. If you want to form a team as the Council that would be
great. I will be assisting the Youth Advisory Council with a clean-up project. Also, at 10:30 there is a
special flag ceremony at Pioneer Plaza. They are going to do a flag raising and a special ceremony like they
do each year on that day.
This year the Mayor's Old Guys were humbled, they went land 2 this year in basketball.
On April 29 at 7:00 p.m. there is a fundraiser over at NNU that the Mayor and Mayor Dale are officiating.
They are going to have the Harlem Globetrotter players playing staff and players from NNU. Everyone is
invited to attend.
May 3` is Cinco de Mayo and there will be celebrations and fun things to do all day long. They will
probably need assistance from us on Friday night and Saturday. Get a hold of Estelle Zammora or Janie
Archelta to see how you can assist.
ADJOURNMENT
Since there was no other business, it was MOVED by Blacker, SECONDED by Callsen to adjourn the
Meeting at 9:30 p.m.
�
i
do
■
4 - '
R
■
1
�I
ME
w
■
1
�I
i
i
I
I
w
i
i
I
I