Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2009-04-06city council minutesBOOK 50 REGULAR MEETING APRIL 6, 2009 7:00 P.M. PAGE 38 The Mayor reported that a public workshop was conducted at 6:30 p.m. for the purpose of discussing energy efficiency and a climate protection agreement with representatives from the Sierra Club and the Snake River Alliance. The Mayor asked that everyone stand for the invocation given by Pastor Greg Primrose of the Living Waters Worship Center and remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag, which was lead by Kyle Watson from Boy Scout Troop No. 277. The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members present: Blacker, Oates, Hopper, Callsen, Dakan, and Sobba. SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS The Mayor acknowledged Mrs. Jackson, U.S. Government teacher from the Caldwell High School. The students from her class introduced themselves. The Mayor informed the students of the Caldwell Pride Day on Saturday, April 25"' and invited them to attend. Andrew Figueroa and Daisy Ambriz from the Mayor's Youth Advisory Council (MYAC) reported on their recent trip to Washington, D.C. to attend the National League of Cities Conference. They expressed their appreciation to the City Council for allowing them the opportunity to attend and reported on what they learned from attending the conference. The Mayor noted that the MYAC trip was completely paid for through fund raising events conducted by MYAC members and donations from the community to include Hamilton, Michaelson & Hilty, Idaho Power, Home Federal Bank, and Allied Waste. Contributions exceeded $6,000. The Mayor acknowledged Anastasia (Stacy) Vazhnova a Caldwell l High School exchange student and Nancy White, Area Representative for exchange students from the former Soviet Union. Ms. White expressed the need for additional host families for students. ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS TO THE AGENDA MOVED by Blacker, SECONDED by Oates to amend the agenda by adding Item #11 under the Consent Calendar to read: "Approve Resolution authorizing the execution of a Professional Services Agreement with Negotiation Services, LLC for negotiation and property appraisals in connection with the Biking - Walking Trail Project." The Mayor reported that there were two other requested additions to the agenda from staff which were declined because they were not time sensitive needs or emergencies. The professional services agreement was allowed as an amendment since it was a dated item relating to a grant proposal. Those voting yes: unanimous. MOTION CARRIED AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION None. CONSENT CALENDAR: The Mayor presented the following items on the Consent Calendar for approval by Members of the City Council: 1. Approve acceptance of the minutes from the Special City Council (Workshop) Meetings held on March 11, 2009 and March 16, 2009; the Regular City Council Meeting held on March 16, 2009; the Caldwell Planning & Zoning Commission Meetings held on December 9, 2008 and February 10, 2009; the Caldwell Hearing Examiner Meetings held on January 27, 2009 and March 10, 2009; the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Meetings held on January 26, 2009 and February 23, 2009; and the Caldwell Golf Board Meeting held on March 18, 2009; 2. Approve Order of Decision for Case No. SUB- 84(4)F -03 (Apple Creek Sub #4 final plat); 3. Approve Resolution No. 53 -09 requesting a waiver of the plan review fees for the new Wolfe Field batters eye fence; 4. Approve Resolution No. 54 -09 adopting a Business Ethics Policy for the City of Caldwell employees and setting an effective date of April 7, 2009; 5. Approve Resolution No. 55 -09 adopting incentives for development in the City Center District; 6. Approve Resolution No. 56 -09 authorizing the execution of a Memorandum of Understanding with Southwest District Health concerning the use of the O'Connor Field House in the event of a public health emergency; 7. Approve grant submittals by the Caldwell Police Department for the Edward Bryne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant in the amount of $216,289 and the COPS FY2009 Hiring Recovery Program Grant (CHRP); 8. Approve request for a Taxi Cab Driver License for Rod Hall from Cab It; BOOK 50 PAGE 39 9. Approve request for a Taxi Cab Driver License for Thomas Clark from Canyon County Cab; 10. Approve Resolution No. 57 -09 authorizing vacation of a portion of unopened Walker Lane Right - of -Way at Logan Street in the Impact Area by Canyon Hwy. District No. 4; 11. Approve Resolution No. 58 -09 authorizing the execution of a Professional Services Agreement with Negotiation Services, LLC for negotiation and property appraisals in connection with the Biking - Walking Trail Project. MOVED by Blacker, SECONDED by Hopper to accept the Consent Calendar as amended. Those voting yes: unanimous. MOTION CARRIED OLD BUSINESS: (CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING [LEGISLATIVE]: CASE NO. OA- 107 -08 A REQUEST BY THE CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT FOR AN ORDINANCE AMENDMENT TO CHAPTER 11 OF CITY CODE TO REPLACE THE EXISTING SUBDIVISION ORDINANCE WITH A NEW SUBDIVISION ORDINANCE) Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Cleveland Blvd, presented the staff report and outlined the proposed changes to the Subdivision Ordinance. She noted that there were two public workshops held with Council concerning this item. Two new items have been added to the current document: 1) a clause requiring proof that the engineer or developer has worked with the local school bus company regarding placement of school bus stops, and 2) requirement of the developer to coordinate with the U.S. Postal Service regarding placement of mail receptacles. She stated that the accompanying ordinance and summary will be presented at the next Regular City Council Meeting on April 20, 2009. MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Blacker to close the public hearing. Those voting yes: Callsen, Dakan, Sobba, Blacker, Oates, and Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent and/or not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED NEW BUSINESS: (CONSIDER BILL NO. 5 [ORDINANCE 27881: "INITIATIVE AND REFERENDUM ORDINANCE" TEXT AMENDMENTS AS REQUESTED BY THE CITY CLERK WITH THE REQUEST TO WAIVE THE RULES, PASS ON THE FIRST READING, AND APPROVE THE SUMMARY FOR PUBLICATION) Mark Hilty, 1303 12"' Avenue Road, Nampa, presented the staff report and noted that the existing ordinance was reviewed for compliance with the Idaho State Code in case an initiative or ballot measure is brought forward for the November 2009 election. He stated that there were only a few minor changes. The Mayor expressed appreciation to the City Clerk for keeping abreast with the upgrading of such ordinances. The Mayor read the ordinance by title only: AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CALDWELL, IDAHO, PASSED IN ACCORDANCE WITH IDAHO CODE §§ 50 -501, AMENDING CALDWELL MUNICIPAL CODE SECTION 01- 07 -03, SUBSECTIONS (2), (3) AND (5), TO ADD WARNING LANGUAGE TO EACH PETITION TO BE CIRCULATED, TO CHANGE THE SIZE OF PAPER ON WHICH INITIATIVE AND REFERENDUM PETITIONS ARE REQUIRED TO BE PRINTED, TO LENGTHEN THE TIME FOR PERFECTION OF INITIATIVE AND REFERENDUM PETITIONS WITH THE REQUIRED NUMBER OF CERTIFIED SIGNATURES TO SEVENTY FIVE (75) DAYS, AND TO MAKE OTHER MINOR AND GRAMMATICAL CHANGES TO MAKE THE SECTION CONSISTENT WITH IDAHO CODE; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND REPEALING ALL ORDINANCES, RULES AND REGULATIONS, AND PARTS THEREOF, IN CONFLICT HEREWITH. MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Blacker to waive the three reading process and consider Bill No 5 on its first reading by title only. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Hopper, Callsen, Dakan, Sobba, Blacker, and Oates. Those voting no: none. Absent and /or not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Blacker to sponsor Bill No. 5, move for its passage, and approve the summary for publication. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Hopper, Callsen, Dakan, Sobba, Blacker, and Oates. Those voting no: none. Absent and /or not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED BOOK 50 PAGE 40 (PUBLIC HEARING [QUASI - JUDICIAL]: CASE NO. SUB- 160P[E] -06 A REQUEST BY KEVIN HOWELL AND GARY LEE APPEALING THE CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION'S CONDITION OF APPROVAL, IN THE ONE -YEAR TIME EXTENSION APPROVAL FOR SIERRA RIDGE SUBDIVISION, WHICH STATES: "ALL THE PERIMETER LOTS, WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THOSE LOTS DIRECTLY ADJACENT TO FARMWAY ROAD OR USTICK ROAD, SHALL BE INCREASED TO A MINIMUM 8,000 SQUARE FEET IN SIZE. ") The Mayor outlined the public hearing process and declared the public hearing open. He asked the City Clerk to swear in those who would be giving public testimony. Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., acknowledged being sworn in and presented the staff report. She noted that the applicant requested a one -year time extension on an approved preliminary plat for Sierra Ridge Subdivision. The Planning & Zoning Commission approved the one -year time extension with conditions on February 10, 2009. The owner is appealing the condition that all perimeter lots, with the exception of those directly adjacent to Farmway or Ustick Road, be increased to a minimum 8,000 sq. ft. in size. The original application was approved April 16, 2007 and consists of 64.27 acres with 221 buildable lots in an R -1 residential zone. The dwelling units per gross acre are 3.44 and the average lot size is 7,730 sq. ft. No final plat for any of the four phases has been recorded for the project. In response to questions from Councilman Hopper, Ms. Skinner reported that there are four perimeter lots that are larger than 8,000 sq. ft. In response to questions from Councilman Callsen, Ms. Skinner reported that new code amendments have altered the minimum lot size, lot width, lot frontage, and set -back requirements as well as the landscape requirements. Up to this point, requirements to change a preliminary plat associated with a time extension request has not be required. In response to questions from Councilman Callsen, Mr. Hilty stated that it is difficult to impose conditions at this point in the process. Often times the conditions of an extension are worked out prior to the application coming to this level. There have been times in the past where extensions have been approved based upon conditions, which were agreed to by the developer. When the developer is not agreeable to those conditions, he advised Council to possibly extend the preliminary plat with the originally imposed conditions of approval or let the plat expire, which would require re- platting. The codes that are in place at the time of re- platting would be applicable. Gary Lee, 4822 H. Rosepoint Way, Suite C, Boise, acknowledged being swom in and spoke in favor of the request. He presented pictures of a similar development in the City of Meridian, which the Mayor labeled as CC -1000 and a packet of information concerning the proposed Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions, which the Mayor labeled as CC -1001. He noted that if the lots were reconfigured to accommodate the 8,000 sq. ft. minimum requirement, eleven lots would be lost on the development, which would be a significant financial impact on the development. He noted that the development would have very strong Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions associated with the development. He noted that he had concerns regarding the requirements to increase the lot size of the parcels along the west boundary since those lots are already buffered by a landscape strip. In response to questions from Councilman Oates, Mr. Lee clarified that he is requesting the extension be approved based on the original submittal and the written negotiations /agreements that were approved at that time. In response to questions from Councilman Blacker, Mr. Lee stated that they did not move forward on the development after the initial approval due to negotiations with other developers to construct a regional water booster station for the City. They were negotiating with the City Engineering Department concerning the sharing of costs and location of the booster station while the City was finishing the water model, which delayed construction. Phase I construction plans were submitted and approved by the Engineering Department when the market took a down turn. The developers determined they should wait to see if the market recovered before proceeding with construction. In response to questions from Councilman Callsen, Ms. Skinner responded that the Subdivision Ordinance provides for two time extensions: one before the Planning & Zoning Commission and the other before City Council. In response to questions from Councilman Hopper, Mr. Lee stated that if a choice existed to either concur with the additional condition or accept denial of the time extension request, they would work with the required condition as determined by Council. Councilman Oates clarified that the Planning & Zoning Commission approved the time extension with the addition of Item 6.7 under the Conditions of Approval. Mr. Lee has appealed Item 6.7 but technically has the time extension already in place. Does Council have the authority to outright deny the extension? Mr. Hilty stated that Council, sitting in an appellant capacity, has the authority to review the case, determine the time extension request, and what conditions are associated with the application. The City Code notes that plat approvals may be extended. There is not discussion in that portion of the Code regarding conditions. The discussion concerning conditions comes up as a practical matter. BOOK 50 PAGE 41 Mr. Hilty continued by expressing his concern with imposing additional conditions within a framework different from the process that existed at the time of the original application. Conditions of Approval typically come out of a significant process that includes round table session discussions, reviews by City staff, and public hearings. This process is generally not repeated with time extension requests. He reported that he leans to a conservative approach by stating that Council may not have the authority to impose additional conditions when considering an extension. However, if a developer concurs with the noted concem(s), then Council may be more comfortable in imposing additional Conditions of Approval. He emphasized that Council does have the authority to deny the request, thus allowing the plat to expire. Councilman Hopper stated that Council has the opportunity, with minimal effort by the applicant, to make the current preliminary plat proposal more acceptable and certainly more harmonious with potential development, which would occur at its boundaries. This condition by Planning & Zoning effects 47 lots out of the 221 lots or 21 percent of the total lots in the proposal. This would give an opportunity for compromise rather than denial and having the applicant start over. Mr. Lee noted that if there was an opportunity to negotiate which lots would be changed, he requested that only the lots which border Mr. Higer's property be altered. Norman H. Higer, 3702 Farmway Road, acknowledged being sworn in and spoke in opposition to the request. He stated that the 8,000 sq. ft. lots would be more compatible with the surrounding area He noted that his parcel is approximately one acre in size. In rebuttal, Mr. Lee commented that the area was zoned for residential, low density development in the Comprehensive Plan. He stated that the philosophy of larger lots containing more attractive homes is not necessarily true, but rather architectural control by the developer plays are large part in the appearance and quality of the residences. Discussion followed by Council concerning the original application, the recommended Conditions of Approval, and potential compromises. Councilman Dakan expressed his concern about changing the rules after the development has already been approved. MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Oates to close the public testimony portion of the hearing. Those voting yes: unanimous MOTION CARRIED EVIDENCE LIST FOR CASE NO. SUB- 160P(E) -06: The Mayor presented the Evidence List: staff report, Subdivision Ordinance, preliminary plat sign -up sheets, CC -1000 (pictures regarding construction standards submitted by Mr. Lee), and CC -1001 (sample CC&R packet for Sierra Ridge Subdivision from Mr. Lee). MOVED by Oates, SECONDED by Blacker to accept the Evidence List as presented. Those voting yes: Unanimous. FINDINGS OF FACT ON CASE NO. SUB- 160P(E) -06 MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Oates to accept the general facts as outlined in the staff report, the public testimony that was given in this matter, the evidence list that was presented, and note there were objections from the current property owner adjacent to the property for compliance to the current standards. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Hopper, Callsen, Dakan, Sobba, Blacker, and Oates. Those voting no: none. Absent and /or not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ON CASE NO. SUB- 160P(E) -06: MOVED by Oates, SECONDED by Blacker that the Caldwell City Council has the authority to hear this case and to make the decision to approve or deny; and the public hearing was noticed and heard within the guidelines of applicable state codes and local ordinances. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Oates, Hopper, Callsen, Dakan, Sobba, and Blacker. Those voting no: none. Absent and /or not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO. SUB- 160P(E) -06: MOVED by Dakan, SECONDED by Oates, based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Caldwell City Council hereby orders that Case No. SUB- 160P(E) -06, a request by Kevin Howell and Gary Lee to overturn the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission's condition of approval, for the one -year time extension approval for Sierra Ridge Subdivision, requiring 8,000 - square -foot minimum lot sizes in all perimeter lots, with the exception of those directly adjacent to Farmway Road or Ustick Road, is approved. BOOK 50 PAGE 42 Mr. Hilty clarified that the motion would approve the extension without Item 6.7 listed under the Conditions of Approval. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Dakan, Sobba, Blacker, and Oates. Those voting no: Hopper and Callsen. Absent and /or not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Oates, SECONDED by Dakan to close the public hearing Those voting yes: unanimous. The Mayor called for a five minute recess. MOTION CARRIED (CASE NO. APP -01 -09 A REQUEST BY JERRY GALAWAY APPEALING THE ACCESSORY USE ORDINANCE TO ALLOW AN ACCESSORY BUILDING (A SHED) TO REMAIN EIGHTEEN INCHES FROM THE PROPERTY LINE RATHER THAN RE- LOCATING THE SHED TO THE REQUIRED MINIMUM FIVE FEET FROM THE PROPERTY LINE. THE SHED IS LESS THAN 120 SQUARE FEET IN AREA. THE SITE IS ADDRESSED AS 11440 SARANAC STREET) The Mayor declared the public hearing open. Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., acknowledged being sworn in and presented the staff report. She reported that she received a phone call from Mr. Jerry Nash; neighbor to Mr. Galloway, concerning the subject shed not meeting the setback requirements. A code enforcement officer visited the site and confirmed that the shed was located only 18 inches from the property line and was therefore in violation to City Code. Code Enforcement Division personnel requested that the shed be moved to conform to the City Code. Mr. Galaway responded by appealing the determination. Ms. Skinner read into the record correspondence from Mr. Jerry Nash who was unable to attend the meeting. She presented a packet of information from Mr. Galaway with supporting documents concerning the storage shed, which the Mayor labeled as CC -1000. In response to questions from Councilman Hopper, Ms. Skinner verified that the shed is less than 120 sq. ft. and therefore did not require a building permit. There are no utilities within the easement. Jerry Galaway, 11440 Saranac Street, acknowledged being sworn in and spoke in support of the request. Mr. Galaway presented a packet of pictures of neighboring sheds that are in non - compliance with the City's set -back requirement, which the Mayor labeled as CC -1001. He noted that he sought permission from the property management association for placement of the shed. It was painted to match his residence with matching shingles and used for yard equipment. In response to questions from Councilman Hopper, Mr. Galaway verified that Mr. Nash had spoken with him concerning the location of the shed needing setback approval through the City of Caldwell. Councilman Hopper noted that correspondence dated February 26, 2009 from the Delaware Park at the Colonies Subdivision Manager, Michael Farlow, to Mr. Galaway indicated that he had been approved for construction of the shed with the understanding that he would be responsible to comply with City or County Codes. Patricia Galaway, 11440 Saranac Street, was sworn in by the City Clerk and spoke in support of the request. She reported that Mr. Nash did speak with Mr. Galaway concerning the five -foot setback requirements approximately two years ago. Mr. Galaway expressed his desire to abide by City regulations and noted his retirement after serving with the U.S. Navy where he was awarded with many metals for his honored service. In response to questions from Councilman Hopper, Ms. Skinner confirmed that the five -foot setback requirement has been in place for many years. In response to questions from Councilman Oates, Ms. Skinner noted that the Code allows for an administrative exception to the policy. This procedure involves notifying the immediate adjacent property owners. If there are no objections, then the Planning & Zoning Director may grant up to a 25 percent variance ofthe setback. The Mayor stated that a 25 percent variance would not bring the shed into compliance with the setback requirement. In response to questions from Mr. Galaway, the Mayor stated that the Code Enforcement Division would research other parcel owners who have sheds within the subject area that are not in compliance with the City Code. Councilman Oates noted the need for the City to be consistent in the enforcement of City Code. Mr. Hilty confirmed that Council needs to establish the Evidence List along with their determination. He will work with Ms. Skinner in preparing the Order of Decision associated with this item. BOOK 50 PAGE 43 MOVED by Oates, SECONDED by Blacker to close the public testimony portion of the hearing. Those voting yes: unanimous. MOTION CARRIED EVIDENCE LIST FOR CASE NO. APP- 01 -09: The Mayor presented the Evidence List: staff report, sign -up sheets, CC -1000 (packet submitted by Gallaway) and CC -1001 (pictures submitted by Mr. Galaway). MOVED by Oates, SECONDED by Blacker to accept the Evidence List as presented. Those voting yes: unanimous. ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO. APP- 01 -09: MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Hopper, SECONDED by Callsen, based on the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Caldwell City Council hereby orders that Case No. APP- 01 -09, a request by Jerry Galaway appealing the accessory use ordinance and allowing an accessory building (shed) to remain eighteen inches from the property line rather than re- locating the shed to the required minimum five feet from the property line is denied, with the provision of directing staff that the shed would be moved within the 30 days. Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Hopper, Callsen, Dakan, Sobba, Blacker, and Oates. Those voting no: none. Absent and /or not voting: none. MOTION CARRIED MOVED by Oates, SECONDED by Blacker to close the public hearing. MOTION CARRIED (FINANCE AND HUMAN RESOURCE REPORTS) Councilman Callsen reported that the Finance Committee has reviewed current accounts payable in the amount of $1,361,683.11 for the pay period ending March 25, 2009 and a net payroll in the amount of $269,702.51for the pay period ending March 14, 2009. MOVED by Callsen, SECONDED by Blacker that accounts payable in the amount of $1,361,683.11 represented by check numbers 59260 through 59527 and the total payroll in the amount of $269,702.51 presented by check numbers 17329 through 17396 and direct deposits be accepted, payments approved, and vouchers filed in the Office of the City Clerk. Those voting yes: unanimous. MOTION CARRIED (COUNCIL COMMENTS) Councilman Dakan reported that he recently attended the Sage Community Resources meeting where discussion was held concerning the Stimulus Package and how those funds would be distributed through their agency. He noted the concern expressed for loss of funding for senior programs dealing with health care and the Meals on Wheels program. Councilman Oates commented on the success of the Local Legends program at the O'Connor Field House. The Mayor expressed his appreciation to Mr. Oates for operating the sound system during performances. Councilman Sobba reported that in addition to the funds that Council appropriated for the Senior Center stove, a grant of $7,000 was received from Fred Meyers. The center will now receive $12,000 worth of new equipment for their kitchen. (MAYOR'S COMMENTS) The Mayor distributed a memo to Council from himself and Dennis Cannon regarding the placement of a historic clock along Blaine Street. The item was purchased by the Lions Club. The item was approved by the Planning & Zoning Commission. Discussion followed concerning the fixture. The Mayor requested that Anne Marie Skinner distribute the information to the Design Review Committee for their information. He noted that a current staff member will be assigned the task of coordinating community development applications through the round table process. This person would be the point of contact concerning upcoming development within the City and will be the liaison between the applicant and departmental staff to relay information. The intent of this assignment would be to improve customer service. The Mayor reported that the City of Nampa has posted their budget expenditures (with the exception of payroll) online to be viewed by the public. A request has been made that the City of Caldwell post such information as well. This item will be researched by staff concerning feasibility with our existing finance program and if there will be any cost associated with this task. Councilman Hopper recommended that all expenditures include a brief summary for clarification purposes. The Mayor read a letter from Jordan Ozuna who has served as the National League of Cities Youth Education and Families Council Representative. She recently attended her last meeting to serve in this BOOK 50 PAGE 44 capacity. The Mayor read a letter from Ms. Ozuna expressing her appreciation for the opportunity of attending the NLC Conference. The Mayor reviewed upcoming calendar items to include: Easter (April 12"'); the Mayor's Old Guys Basketball Game (April 27 at 7:00 at Middleton High School); and the Caldwell Pride Day, Spring Bling Car Show at the Memorial Park, and the Family Day on Indian Creek (April 25"'). (ADJOURNMENT) MOVED by Oates, SECONDED by Blacker to adjourn at 9:29 p.m. Those voting yes: unanimous. MOTION CARRIED APPROVED AS written THIS 20th DAY OF APRIL 2009. Mayor Councilperson Councilperson Councilperson Councilperson Councilperson Councilperson ATTEST: City Clerk