HomeMy WebLinkAbout1981-03-10city council minutesBook 22
REGULAR MEETING
March 10, 1981
12:00 Noon
Page 71
The Meeting was called to order by Mayor McCluskey.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members
present: Williams, Raymond, Mallea, Hopper, Carter, and Betts.
Absent: none.
(AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION)
The Mayor asked if there was anyone in the audience who cared to
bring anything before the City Council that was not on the prepared
Agenda. Since there was no one, the Mayor declared that the
Meeting would continue as outlined.
The Mayor stated that he would skip over the first part of the
Agenda and go down to the fourth item under New Business as there
was several employees present at the Meeting for this item.
(SAFETY COMMITTEE CERTIFICATES OF APPOINTMENT)
The Mayor explained that the City of Caldwell felt it was very
imperative that the City form a very active Safety Commission. He
turned the Committee over to Dennis Davis, the Building Inspector,
as Chairman along with Tom Burns, Fire Chief, acting as Co- Chairman.
They have done an excellent job in taking the Committee seriously
and have recommended the following City employees as members of
this Committee. The Mayor then asked the following employees to
come forward to receive their Certificates of Appointment to the
Safety Committee:
Ansil McCormick of the Irrigation Department
Kathy Hamilton of the Police Department
Randy Deardon, Water Department
Venton Howell, Cemetery
Bill Buchta, Fire Department
Ken Batt, Parks Department
Don Walton, Golf Department
Dave Garcia, Street Department
Gene Enebo, Engineering Department
Joe Franklin, Treatment Plant
Betty Jo Keller, Front Office of City Hall
The Mayor stated that he would hike to thank these employees for -
being willing to accept this appointment as he felt it was a serious
position.
OLD BUSINESS
(REPORT FROM PHIL LEAHY ON OFFICE REORGANIZATION)
The Mayor called on Phil Leahy to explain to the City Council the
need for dividers in the Front Office and his suggestions as to
the reorganization of the office.
Mr. Leahy was recognized and displayed an outline of his suggestions
as to how to remodel the Front Office. I-Ie explained that he would
be very happy to sit down with any of the City Council members to
give a more detailed explanation of his proposal on a scaled drawing.
Mr. Leahy felt it was important to have the cashier in a caged
structure close to the front door, and to have those who have
questions with regard to their bills directed to one of the other
girls. He also thought that the Treasurer should be towards the
back of the room and only those with specific questions to ask her
would be directed to her office. The Deputy Clerk would be towards
the front just beyond the cashier so she would be readily available
to issue licenses. The main idea was to keep those who do not need
as much access to the public -.as far back,as possible. He also
explained the necessity of having some portable dividers so to give
some privacy to the girls while they were working and eliminate
as much distraction as possible. He also said that the carpet was
in bad shape and was actually dangerous and some consideration
should be given to replacing it. His plans allowed for proper
Book 22
Page 72
exits with the doorways so to not cause any fire hazards, but would
also eliminate some of the traffic.
Councilman Hopper stated that he thought it was a great idea,
but would ask if the Chief Administrator and his Staff were in
agreement with the plan. He did not think that the City Council
should get involved except for the cost.
Mr. Leahy stated that he had talked with three contractors, but he
was not sure of any costs as yet. I-Ie was not sure what they would
find when they pulled the counters out and so far, much of what
he was doing was leg work. He had pursued the possibility of
buying some of the materials from the State.
The Mayor pointed out to the Council that Mr. Leahy had done
much of this work on h.is own time.
Mr. Leahy further commented that Ken Harward had informed the
Council some time'ago to get the cashier in some type of enclosure
and out of the open. A lot of people walk through the area where
the money was being counted. If the cage was put in, there would
be need for the other changes.
Councilman Hopper stated that he felt that if everyone was of the
opinion that it should be done, then the City should do it if the
money was available. There was $,000.00 budgeted for the petitions
The Mayor stated that he felt that $5,000.00 would not cover it.
Councilman Hopper then pointed out that perhaps all of the monies
budgeted for the new phone system would not have to be used for
that and there could be some surplus in that area.
Mr. Leahy also pointed out that there would be some money left
over due to cancellation of equipment. After further discussion
by the Council with regard to the costs, the Mayor stated that he
would have Donna. Talley tabulate what the figure would be with the
cancellation of the machines. It was Mr. Leahy's suggestion that
they do the front of the office first so that the cage for the
cashier would be accomplished.
It was then the decision of the City Council and the Mayor that
they proceed on the front portion of the renovation of the office
as long as it stays within the $5,000.00 budgeted. It would then
have to come back to Council if it goes beyond that figure.
Mr. Leahy stated that he would like to take advantage of the City
Council for input as to how to do the renovation. He would attempt
to get some definite answers as to the costs and would proceed with
the front portion first, then the Treasurer's Office and see what
monies were left after that was finished.
It was suggested that Councilwoman Williams and the City Engineer,
Mr. Lewis, could give some suggestions as they were working in the
City Hall when the office was changed previously.
(HARRIS APPEARANCE)
The Mayor stated that Mr. Harris was not present at the Meeting,
but that the letter to him was delivered informing him that he was
welcome to come to the Meeting to discuss the problem.
NEW BUSINESS
(RESOLUTION NO. 11 -81 - REHAB LOAN FOR. ELMER R. AND ETHEL IRENE
CIIAPMAN)
The Mayor stated that the Council members had copies of the resume
for this loan and he would read the Resolution by title only as the
full Resolution was the same as those previously passed:
RESOLUTION APPROVING A HOUSING REHABILITATION FOR ELMER R. AND
ETHEL IRENE CIIAPMAN, HUSBAND AND WIFE AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
D1-�TE .
Councilman Carter asked where the location of the house was. Mrs.
Wolfe informed him that it was located at 303 Denver.
Book 22
Page 73
MOVED by Carter, SECONDED by Hopper that the Resolution approving
this Hou.ing Rehabilitation for Elmer R. and Ethel Irene Chapman
be passed as presented by the Mayor.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Carter, Betts, Williams,
Raymond, Mallea, and Hopper. Those voting no: none. Absent and
not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(RESOLUTION NO. 10 -81 - REHAB LOAN FOR DOROTHY LOUISE FRAZIER)
The Mayor stated that the Council also had the resume with regard
to this loan which they have studied. He then read this Resolution
by title only as follows:
RESOLUTION APPROVING A HOUSING REHABILITATION FOR DOROTHY L.
FRAZIER, AKA DOROTHY LOUISE FRAZIER AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
MOVED by Carter, SECONDED by Williams that the Resolution approving
the Rehabilitation Loan for Dorothy Louise Frazier be passed.
Roll call vote. Those voting yes: Carter, Betts, Williams, Mallea,
and Hopper. Abstain: Raymond. Those voting no: none. Absent
and not voting: none.
MOTION CARRIED
(HARDSHIP REQUEST)
The Mayor informed the City Council that both he and Councilman
Raymond had looked over this hardship request. Councilman Raymond
was recognized and stated that he would recommend that this request
be granted.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Mallea that the hardship request
as presented to the City of Caldwell be approved.
MOTION CARRIED
(LETTER FROM THE EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION)
The Mayor stated that he would like to read the following letter
received from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission:
Re: George Dufur v. City of Caldwell, Idaho
Charge No. 101798069
Please be advised that the above captioned case has been
designated for administrative closure by the Commission. We
have deemed this case unsuitable for Commission litigation
because the Charging Party intends to file a private action
against the Respondent. Administrative closure of the
Commission's case will avoid duplication of effort. Please be
advised that this decision in no way represents a decision by
the agency to either rescind or modify our determination
(dated January 21, 1981) that respondent violated the Age
Discrimination in Employment Act by its termination of George
Dufur.
Should you have any questions, please call the undersigned at
(206) 442 -0696.
/s/ Elyette M. Weinstein
Trial Attorney
The Mayor further informed the City Council that he had turned
this letter over to the City Attorney, but felt that the City
Council should be aware of it.
(HEALTH AND WELFARE LETTER)
The Mayor read the following letter received from the State of
Idaho Department of Health and Welfare:
Book 22
Page 74
Subject: C- 16- 0201 -03 - Contract No. 2 - Second Ave - Belmont
Street Interceptor - House Services
Dear Mayor McCluskey:
I am writing concerning the house services which remain to be
connected to the new Belmont Street interceptor prior to the old.
interceptor being disconnected from the treatment plant and utilized
as a groundwater relief line.
Our funding of the subject project was based. on replacing the
existing interceptor, which is subject to excessive infiltration,''
with a new line in order to reduce infiltration flows into the
treatment plant. Naturally we expect all sanitary waste
connections to the existing interceptor to be disconnected and
connected to the new interceptor. As such., the plans and
specifications approved by the State and EPA on August 14, 1979,
included requirements that all ".live" house services be disconnected
and reconnected to the newly constructed interceptor.
On February 28, 1980, we informed the City that we could not fund
the reconnection of the service lines on private property. However,
we did agree to fund an 8 -inch sewer line as proposed in Parametrix'
February 1, 1980 proposal for service reconnections.
In August of 1980, Jim Walker of Parametrix told Dan Blust of our
office that the services had not yet been connected to the new
interceptor because of high groundwater conditions. However, Mr.
Walker indicated that it was.his understanding the services would
be connected by December, 1980. In a recent meeting with City
staff, we learned that the City has still not reconnected these
services.
The old interceptor cannot be utilized for groundwater relief
until such time as all sanitary service connections are disconnected
and connected to the new interceptor. Hence, infiltration will
continue to enter the treatment plant and the intent of the grant:
funded interceptor cannot be met and the project cannot be
considered complete. Therefore, we must request that the City
submit a schedule for the necessary construction to effect connection
of all existing sanitary services to the new interceptor. This
schedule shall insure that all work will be complete by this summer
such that the old interceptor may be disconnected from the treatment
plant by that time. This schedule should be submitted to this
office by March 17, 1981.
If the City does not submit a reasonable schedule and proceed with
construction in accordance with that schedule, we will request that
EPA withdraw grant funds paid on the interceptor contract until such
time as the reconnection of services and the subsequent
disconnection of the old interceptor from the plant is complete.
If you have any questions, contact me at 334-3823.
/s/ Tom ICorpalski
Environmental Engineer
The Mayor explained that he read this letter for the City Council
so if they have any questions to ask the City Engineer they could
do so at this time.
The City Engineer explained that this was a project that the
City of Caldwell was attempting to do themselves as it was not _
grant eligible and the problem of having the time to do it was the
issue at this point. Mr. Lewis further commented that he would
respond to the letter.
(LETTER FROM E.P.A. REGARDING THE TREATMENT PLANT)
The Mayor stated that he would like to read the following letter
received from E.P.A.:
RE: C -16 0201 -03, Pretreatment Program
I have received a copy of a revised phase 1, part I of the
Book 22 Page 7S
pretreatment program from your consulting engineers,
Parametrix, Inc. The Division of Environment, Idaho Department
of Health & Welfare has recommended that we allow the work
to proceed as an eligible cost. Thus, this letter will provide
the City with the assurance that reasonable costs associated
with the proposal will be reimbursed under their existing
grant.
The State has also noted that there are some details with
regard to the engineer agreement which need to be resolved
prior to their approval of the contract. The State tells me
that they are contacting you directly in this regard. Good.
luck on the pretreatment program.
/s/ Warren T. McFall, P.E.
EPA Project Engineer
Mr. Lewis, City Engineer, was recognized and said that the day
before he had two discussions with Jim Walker on the telephone.
Mr. Lewis informed him that the City wanted the monitoring that was
to go on in the lines identifying the loads to proceed. The rental
samplers were on the way and should be here at the end of the week
or the first of next week. Mr. Lewis asked them to get the program
approved so they can start. Mr. Lewis stated that he further
understood that the Engineering Agreement part was something that
the City was going to get from the State that says that the City
agrees to the monitoring task being added to the pretreatment
program. That part of it was authorized both for'the engineering
on the part of Parametrix and for the work involved an the part
of the Grant.
(PREVENTATIVE MAINTENANCE)
The Mayor read the following letter received from Jim Keesee with
regard to preventative maintenance:
Allow me to express my appreciation to the City for the
opportunity to completely service all of your electric type -
writers. This also presents an excellent time to consider an
alternative to your present system of machine maintenance.
Preventative Maintenance
Periodic on location POWER AIR cleaning with complete
lubrication, adjustment check, inspection and replacement
of worn parts.
Service Calls
Unlimited service calls to repair any machine malfunction.
Parts
ALL parts are included in the contract price. (Note:
exclusions paragraph of contract applies to this proposal)
Cost
Standard price per unit per year $ 60.00
Less discount for 10 units or more (4.00)
Less $30.00 per unit for service on work
recently performed* 30.00
Net total cost per unit 26.00
On your ten machines the total savings at this time would
be $340.00, total cost would be $260.00
*This discount is allowed because the work done will count
as the first years' preventative maintenance.
Benefits of Quality Office Products service:
20 years experience, local service, Caldwell based, power
air cleaning, complete stock of replacement parts, as the
IBM representative, I serviced your machines for several
years. Many of the city employees will remember the
quality of service I render.
Thank you for your consideration. If you have any question,
please call.
/s/ Jimmy P. Keesee
Book 22
Page 76
The Mayor asked Mr. Keesee to give a .brief explanation of his
proposal to the City of Caldwell. Mr. Keesee explained that the
City Hall has ten typewriters that were under very heavy usage.
In the past, maintenance has been done on a "as needed" basis.
fie felt that this was not a good practice as the operators tend
to let the small repairs go rather than call to have the repairs
taken care of. With most companies, the hourly rate was about
$35.00. What he was proposing was to put the machines on an annual
service contract. He would come around once a year and completely
clean and service the machines. If there was service calls in the
meantime, there would be no extra charge. Under this type of progra
he felt that the City could keep their machines in good working
condition. Due to the work that he just did in putting the
machines into good shape, he would offer a $30.00 discount per
machine for the work that was done. This would bring the price
down to $26.00 per machine for one year service.
The Mayor stated that he felt it was a viable situation and felt
that the City should be doing more of the preventative maintenance.
He would suggest that it be turned over to the Finance Committee
for determination as to where the financing would come from.
The Finance Committee informed the Mayor that they would be meeting
in the near future and would let him know.
(PURCHASE ORDER PROCEDURES)
The Mayor stated that he would take this item out of the City
Council's hands and handle it under an Administrative level. Mr.
Lewis had given him some recommendations and he would meet with
Mr. Lewis and make the decision as to how the Purchase Orders should
be handled.
(CURTIS PARK COMMITTEE REPORT)
The Mayor stated that the next item was with regard to the Curtis
Park Committee report. He called on Councilman Carter to respond:
to this report.
Councilman Carter read the recommendation from the Committee
as follows:
It is the unanimous recommendation of the Parks and Recreation
Commission Curtis Park Committee that a usage agreement
between the City of Caldwell and the Elks Lodge X1418 be
drawn up for the area known as Curtis Park.
However, due to the uniqueness of this non - renewable resource
and in spite of our eagerness to see Curtis Park "blossom ",
this committee feels there are some areas of concern which
warrant careful consideration. Zf addressed, the resulting
agreement should prove mutually beneficial to families of
Elks and to future citizens of Caldwell.
1. Legal responsibility
a. Liability
b. Lease agreement. Should specifically include
annual renewal of policy with City Park Department
C. Ownership of property. Title clear and boundaries
defined
2. Development
a. Submit plan to Parks Dept. pertaining to
proposed and on going development and
maintenance.
b. Parks Department responsible for final approval
of planning
C, No alterations of natural state to be made without
City Park Dept. approval
3. Sanitation
a. Meet Seate Health Dept. requirements.
The above recommendation was submitted to the Parks and
Recreation Commission on March 2, 1981 and received the
unanimous approval of the Commission.
Book 22
Page 77
Councilman Carter further informed the City Council that the
Committee consisted of: Dee Palrang, Walt Berkenbile, Phil
Morford, Jack Raymond, Harry Huffer, LeAnn Simmons, Jess Payne,
and Dave Gipson.
Councilman Raymond was recognized and stated that the Committee took
the recommendation before the Parks and Recreation Commission as
they felt that the Commission should have some input before it
was presented to the Council for action. They did talk to the City
Attorney with regard to the recommendation. It was Councilman
Raymond's recommendation that the City draw up a Resolution offering
- this to the Elks to be operated as a public park. It was agreed by
Councilman Raymond and Councilman Hopper that the Lease Agreement
should be approved by the City Attorney before bringing it before
the Council for final approval.
Councilman Hopper stated that there was some areas of concern with
regard to legalities and the City Attorney seemed to think that as
long as it was still a public park for public use and not being
set aside for the restrictive use of the Elks, that it was within
legal bounds. Councilman Hopper felt that some concerns would be
clarified if the City offered the Elks the contract. He also
suggested that there be a flexible clause included with regard to
the rates.
(COMMITTEE REPORTS)
(a) OFFICE TRAINING OVERTIME.
Councilman Betts was recognized and informed the Mayor and
Council that the Committee did go over this request and
determined that they would pay the overtime costs, but not
until April when the training was completed. They did not
feel that they should pay in advance. This pay would be
straight time with no Comp Time.
Councilwoman Williams also commented that they felt there
should be some control of documentation in the future on
Comp Time. This money would have to come out of the Contingency
Fund because the salary budget could not handle this extra pay.
The Mayor stated that the fact still remains that the City did
not anticipate what it was going to cost to make this change.
(b) INSURANCE REPORT.
The Mayor reported that this item was in Committee. Council-
woman Williams and Councilwoman Mallea were planning to go to
Boise to obtain some further information. They will plan to
report at the next Council Meeting.
(c) GRADING OIL TREATED STREETS.
The Mayor stated that there was a meeting held with regard
to this item. The general policy was verbal and the Mayor
stated that he would prefer that this would be in writing.
People were oiling their streets on their own and the City
comes in and grades them which destroys the oil. The people
have been irate about this, but the City was right in doing the
grading. The City was going to pick up the tab for $70.00 that
the Mayor had promised a woman that she would be notified prior
to grading as he thought this was the policy. It was not the
policy and was a misunderstanding on the part of the Mayor
as he felt sure this was what he had been told. The Street
Department Supervisor claims that the alleys have to be graded
regardless of their condition. This was also the decision of
the Committee and the Mayor stated that he would stand behind
it.
The Policy was to be as follows:
The City will permit dustcoating of gravel streets and alleys
as follows:
Book 22
Page 78
Any application of dustcoating materials will be considered
temporary.
Dustcoating will not interfere with the normal street and alley
maintenance.
The Street Department will, upon request, grade a street or
alley to a smooth condition prior to the application of dust -
coating materials.
The streets and alleys will be graded normally during the fall
and spring months in. optimum moisture conditions to provide
a smooth surface.
Applications in the spring and summer will be protected
until the late fall or spring maintenance period.
The City will not assume the responsibility for replacing
any dustcoating applications to streets and alleys.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Carter that the City Council adopt
this Policy as presented by the Committee.
MOTION CARRIED
(MAYOR'S REPORT)
The Mayor reminded the Council members to get their pictures taken
for the frame in th e City Hall.
The Mayor also reported that they were having some problems getting
the downtown merchants to sweep their sidewalks. He announced it
on the radio and also informed the Retail Merchants of this
problem.
The Mayor also read a letter from Jackson, Messuri and Bates which
was to confirm their engagement to perform certain auditing
and special services for the City of Caldwell. The letter
specifically identified the services and asked the Mayor to sign
the copy where indicated if the 'Letter correctly expressed what
the City desired. The Mayor then asked the City Council if the
letter expressed their understanding and if so, he would sign the
letter and send it back to Jackson, Messuri and Bates. The City
Council agreed that the Mayor should sign the letter as it expressed
what they requested.
It was announced by the Mayor that the Spring Cleanup would be the
week starting the 13th of April. He also reported that he had a
call from a woman that was a. licensed, school trained dog catcher
from California who was willing to volunteer for the job with the
hopes of getting on permanently. Mayor McCluskey also informed the
Council that he was receiving calls from the Legislators with regard
to certain bills, so felt that they were responsive to the fact
that he had informed them that they did not listen to the City's
problems.
The Mayor said that the Chamber of Commerce appointed a Committee
that morning to try to push for an old time Fourth of July
Celebration. This would be down in the park with the various
Service Clubs having stands, picnics in the Park, fireworks
somewhere and basically a midway concept in the Park. The Mayor
felt that the public will have to determine what was wanted with
regard to this type of celebration and where the fireworks should
be held. The Mayor was really interested in the midway approach
where the Service Clubs would be involved. He just wanted the
Council to be aware of the proposed celebration.
Councilman Betts reported that the Lions Club was planning to send
the City $300.00 for a light at the Park and committed themselves to
a second light and were working ona third light. Councilwoman
Williams also stated that the Zonta Club purchased one light.
The Mayor said that he would like: very much if the Club would present
this to the Cougar Connection.
Book 22
Page 79
The Mayor also informed the Council that he attended the ribbon
cutting ceremony at the new Press Tribune Open I -louse on Saturday.
He also reported that his trip to Washington, D. C. was very
worthwhile. He found out things that he felt he would not have
had knowledge of without going. Mr. Greeno was to be here this
week from the H.U.D. Office to discuss the report that the City
has to make.
Councilwoman Williams was recognized and stated that both she and
Councilman Setts had looked over Mr. Keesee's letter and they did
not feel that it was necessary for the Finance Committee to review
this offer. She felt it was an excellent offer and they could go
ahead and approve the offer for this year. They would have to give
it consideration for the new budget year.
There being no further business, the Meeting was adjourned at
1:20 p.m.
APPROVED AS written THIS 17th DAY OF March 1931.
Councilman
ATTEST:
City Clerks