HomeMy WebLinkAbout1981-02-24city council minutesBook 22 Page 58
REGULAR MEETING
February 24, 1981
12:00 Noon
The Meeting was called. to order by Mayor McCluskey.
The Roll of the City Council was called with the following members
present: Williams, Raymond, Mallea, Hopper, Carter, and Betts.
Absent: none.
OLD BUSINESS
(DISCUSSION ON TRUCK PARKING ORDINANCE)
The Mayor asked the members of the City Council if any of them
had the time to look over the truck parking ordinance.
Councilwoman Williams was recognized and stated that she would
suggest that the City Council table this issue until the new Police
Chief arrived. She felt that the Council should talk with him and
get his suggestions "af.ter he had a chance to study the Code.
Councilman IIopper stated that he agreed with this concept.
It was then MOVED by Williams, SECONDED by Hopper that the City
Council delay any action on the truck parking ordinance until the
new Chief of Police arrives and has had the time to look at the
Code regarding the truck parking and could make his recommendation
to the Council.
MOTION CARRIED
(VACATION POLICY)
The Mayor stated that the next item on the Agenda was discussion
with regard to the vacation policy suggested and he would open the
meeting for the Council's discussion. The Mayor informed the
Council that if they do not address this policy, it will be
assumed by the Superintendents in the City that the City Council
approved it.
Councilwoman Mallea was recognized and stated that it was her
feeling that a worthy employee will put in a small amount of time
here and there so that, with the discretion of the Supervisor, if
they had an appointment with the doctor or dentist -they should be
allowed to go. The bookkeeping involved in the taking of vacation
time at an hour at a time for such appointments would be
prohibitive.
The Mayor stated that he felt this was excellent logic and if a
Supervisor hasn't enough ability to organize his own crew whereby
they were not taking advantage of him, he should not be in that
position.
MOVED by Mallea that the Council not accept the vacation policy
dealing with the taking of vacation time one hour at a time.
SECONDED by Williams.
Councilwoman Williams stated that she did not know if it would be
worthwhile to go back to a committee to discuss the employee's
policy. The policy that the City Council adopted didn't seem to
be acceptable to the employees. There was no way, Councilwoman
Williams further commented, that she could vote to give vacation ?.
an hour at a time.
The Mayor further commented that there was some items in the policy
that he had not been f'ollowing. One of them was Comp Time as he
thought Comp Time was a viable tool for anybody in an administrative
position.
The Council discussed the revision of policy at some length.
Councilman IIopper stated that he felt that the one hour vacation
idea was an attempt to discourage people taking advantage of taking
the hours for personal need. Because it was not productive time,
he felt that it was Mr. Leahy's :recommendation to count it as
vacation time. Now, the concept was that someone might take a full
two weeks an hour at a time.
Book 22
Page 59
The Mayor said that he felt the Council was in agreement that the
Supervisor should have the prerogative to allow an employee an hour
off to do personal business or go to the doctor and handle it
however he felt was best; but not to count it as vacation time.
The Mayor further said that as he understood it, the Council
would not accept the recommendation of the Committee involving time
and policy as regarding the one hour time stipulation. He further
stated that he would inform the Superintendents of the Council's
action. He then called for a vote on the motion as made by
Councilwoman Mallea.
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor commented that he felt the Council should take another
look at the rest of the policy and that he would review it and
discuss it at a later time with the Council. Councilwoman Williams
pointed out that the policy now stated that Comp Time will be taken
at the discretion of the Mayor, but she did feel that the Comp Time
should be looked into further. 7'he Mayor also commented that he
did not agree with the employees not being allowed to take one day
at a time.
NEW BUSINESS
Councilman Hopper suggested that the first item on the Agenda
be delayed until the City Engineer arrived at the meeting. This
was with regard to a recommendation from the Planning and Zoning
Commission on a variance request..
(INSURANCE REPORT)
The Mayor stated that the next item was on the .insurance report.
What it amounted to was that there was a question in the mind's
of the Council as to the possibility of getting a four month
extension or of having the present insurance broken down into four
months. This was accepted by the firm and if the Council wants to
ask for bids, that was the prerogative of the Council. Some work
will have to be done to getting them all due at one time.
Councilwoman Williams commented that if the City could get all of
their policies due at one time before they put it up for bid, the
City would be in a better position. She then asked if it would be
possible to get a list of all the policies and when they come due
so the Council would have something to work from.
The Mayor asked Donna Talley if she would get this list and he
would go over them with her.
Councilman Hopper said that he understood that often municipalities,
school districts, and other units of government have a joint
underwriting and the only person that gets anything extra was the
one they do business with. He gets an administrative fee and the
business was passed all around the community.
The Mayor stated that he would pursue this. He felt that the way
to do this was to get the same dates due as Nampa and then work
at putting something together between the two cities.
(REPORT ON NAMPA TREASURER ASSISTANCE)
The Mayor informed the Council that he called Ken Harward and he
was still supposed to come back to Caldwell with an agreement
regarding Alan Caba for his time given to the City of Caldwell. He
had not heard anything more from Nampa, but would keep the City
Council informed.
(HARDSHIP DISCOUNT)
Councilman Raymond reported that he did investigate the party
requesting the hardship discount and would recommend that it be
accepted by the City Council.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Carter that the hardship discount
as requested be granted.
MOTION CARRIED
Book 22 Page 60
(REPORT ON "OLD AIRPORT" ARMORY PROPERTY)
The Mayor reported that he checked on the old airport Armory
property and it was all federally owned so that the City of Caldwell
had no control over it.
(BLOCK GRANT LABOR STANDARDS COURSE)
The Mayor read the following letter:
To All Community Development Block Grantees:
The enclosed brochure describes a course offe
Department of Labor entitled "Labor Standards
Construction Contracts." Previous courses on
given participants valuable information which
them in their attempts to interpret and apply
Standards Regulations.
red by the
for Government
this subject have
greatly assists
the many Labor
Mr. Ed Woodruff, the instructor of the course, has been with the
Department of Labor for many years; and we have found him to be
exceptionally knowledgeable and Helpful in the area of Labor Law.
The last page of the brochure explains the sign -up procedure. In
addition, please let Bill Headley, Director of the Housing and Urban
Development's Labor Relations Section know if you are interested
in attending. If there is enough participation from individuals
involved in HUD programs, the Department of Labor has indicated that
additional material designed specifically to address the needs of
Block Grant recipients and local housing authorities in their
efforts to comply with I - IUD's Labor Standards procedures will be
offered.
/s/ Williams C. Headley, Director
Labor Relations
The Mayor explained that this letter came from the Department of
Housing and Urban Development in Portland, Oregon. The course wa<
to be presented in Boise on April. 14th. There was a note from
the City Engineer stating that someone from the City should
attend who was responsible for construction contracts. The
meeting was in Boise at a cost of $60.00. Mr. Lewis suggested that
his name be sent in if approved and that his replacement be
substituted if he was on the job at that time. If not, he would
make the information available.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Williams that the City Council
authorize one person from the City of Caldwell to attend the
meeting.
MOTION CARRIED
(911 SYSTEM)
The Mayor informed the Council that there was not much to report
except that he was getting feedback all of the time. He felt that
the general intent at this time was for the City of Caldwell to
proceed by not proceeding until the County determines what they
were going to do with their communication system. The County was
having a meeting today with the City Council of Nampa about the
communication. The County was very anxious to get the joint use
facilities started and they have already bought a gas tank. There
would be two pumps; one for the City and one for the County.
Councilman Hopper questioned as to whether the City shouldn't
have some written agreement. The Mayor answered that he did have,;,,
a written agreement, but was waiting for the new Police Chief.
(FINANCIAL REPORT)
The Mayor requested that Councilman Betts give the financial report.
Councilman Betts reported that the Finance Committee went over all
the Requests for Payment. There was checks to be issued in the
amount of $309,616.02; a payroll of $161,561.00 of which $33,417.00
was fringe benefits.
It was then MOVED by Betts, SECONDED by Williams that checks be
Book 22
Page 61
issued as requested and the Requests for Payment filed in the Clerk's
Office and approval be given for the Payroll.
MOTION CARRIED
(AVIGATION EASEMENT)
Councilman Raymond reported that the Airport Commission recommended
to the City Council that they accept the Avigation Easement from
Caldwell Unlimited.
It was then MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Carter that the City
Council accept the Avigation Easement from Caldwell Unlimited as
recommended by the Airport Commission and that the City Clerk be
instructed to have the easement recorded.
(MAYOR'S COMMENTS)
MOTION CARRIED
The Mayor reported that he passed out slips at the Chamber of
Commerce to try to get some support for his Protect Our Parks
Project and had several people state that they would contribute
to it. It was also discussed having the Junior High students sell
oranges which looked like a good program. The Mayor was to have a
meeting on March 4th with the Cougar Connection to see if they
would be interested in supporting this. He also informed the
Council that there was plans to rejuvenate the old fountain at the
Park and he would keep them informed regarding this.
Councilwoman Williams informed the Mayor that the lights were on
now at the park and they looked very nice,'although not as bright
as she had hoped they would be.
(REQUEST FOR VARIANCE RECOMMENDED BY THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION)
The City Engineer, Mr. Lewis, arrived at the Meeting and the Mayor
requested that he address the request for a variance from Paul
Billeci for a second building permit in less than a year of an
original tract.
Mr. Lewis explained that at their regular meeting on Thursday,
February 19, 1981, the Planning and Zoning Commission passed a
motion to recommend that the City Council grant a variance from the
subdivision ordinance to Paul Billeci to obtain a building permit
in less than a year on an original tract located southeast of the
intersection of Marshall Avenue and Ash Street. Mr. Lewis further
explained that the variance was subject to Mr. Billeci's agreement
to covenant the property for future participation in providing a
sewer system to the property when it becomes available. The
covenant requires the property to pay its pro rata share in the costs .
of sewer mains and laterals, to pay a monthly fee which will be
set aside and credited to those costs, and to participate in and
become a part of the subdivision when the tract was platted.
Mr. Billeci was present at the meeting and when asked if these
stipulations were in agreement with him, he said that he was in
agreement with those requests.
MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by Hopper that the City Council accept
the recommendation of the Planning and Zoning Commission and grant
the variance for a second building permit in less than a year of
an original tract requested by Mr.. Billeci with those stipulations
as outlined by the City Engineer„
Mr. Lewis stated that there was just this kind of agreement written
by the City Attorney for another situation. It was his suggestion
that in the case of Mr. Billeci that they reinstitute the same
agreement as it was approved and written by the City Attorney.
The Mayor then requested a vote on the motion as made.
MOTION CARRIED
Book 22
Page 62
The Mayor suggested that this type of agreement become a policy if
there was going to be other situations :coming up in the future.
(DISCUSSION REGARDING, BOILER AT THE TREATMENT PLANT)
Mr. Lewis, City Engineer, was recognized and stated that after the
meeting that morning with those involved in the Treatment Plant
construction, they were no closer to an agreement than before. As
he saw it, there was a couple of alternatives. The problem at hand
was the boiler at the Treatment Plant and it just was not resolved
as to how this was to be done.
In explanation, Mr. Lewis stated that the City gave the contracto7
a stop order when he was ready to install the boiler last
November because there was a possibility of an advantage of
relocating the boiler out of the present room. It was thought -
that it would be an advantage to get the boiler into the chlorine
room which was adjacent. This was not in the original contract and
therefore, the contractor was claiming extras. It appeared to Mr.
Lewis that it should be investigated for the advantages of relocatint
the boiler. The temperature.in: the room -was one item.to be
considered and Mr. Hollis also pointed out that there was a
possibility of waste gases in that room that can affect the
electrical equipment. Also, as pointed out by one engineer, it
probably has some measure of safety. Some of the facilities around.
the boiler have to be moved to get the tolerance required by the
electrical code between the electrical equipment and the boiler
equipment. The Engineers pursued these advantages . of moving the
boiler with the contractor in the form. of Change Orders. They
proceeded to get the estimate of costs. It started out at $52,000;
it then went to the State and they said they would not make any
figures such as that grant eligible. Subsequently, somewhere in
the order of $22,000 to $25,000 was deemed to be grant eligible.
In the meantime, the contractor came down to $42,000. The engineers
were then asked to try to resolve; that difference and it has not
been resolved and they do not seem to be any closer to resolving
it.
There was three major areas in which the costs were occurring.
One was the direct relocation of the boiler, what has to be done
to the heating system to change it and in the meantime, it was
discovered that some of the heating system now was either well
worn out or so old that it would not be expected to operate another
twenty years. The third major area was the gas regulatory and pipinc
equipment and there was some replacement there..
If the City still wants to relocate the boiler, change the heating
and gas equipment, the contractor still says it will cost the
City $42,000. The grant eligible part of that was around $21,000
which leaves a balance of $21,000. Realistically, the State may
change this figure so it might be reduced to $18,000.
If it was decided to not relocate the boiler, the contractor was
still going to charge $28,000 in extras. That probably could. be
cut some. The grant eligible part of that, which was mostly the
heating equipment and gas equipment, was around $15,000 leaving a
balance of $13,000. This probably could be reduced to $10,000.
There was going to be extras just the way it was. The State will
look at these items very carefully to justify them. Mr. Lewis
further said that he was sure that the $28,000 has in it about
$7,000 or $8,000 of costs because the stop order was issued.
The City of Caldwell would be obligated for something there in
regard to the stop order. It may have to be arbitrated, although
he felt there was an obligation as a result of the stop order
which the City recognized when they gave it. When Mr. Lewis first
discussed this with the engineers, it was felt that it could be
resolved in about two weeks. This was the early part of December
and it was now almost March and. it was still not resolved. The
contractor, with all of this added time, says that he still has more
to talk about.
The City Council discussed this with Mr. Lewis at some length.
Mr. Lewis informed the Council that the figures were argumenti_ve
and not sacred. Mr. Lewis further stated that if the City approved
the going ahead of relocating the boiler, the City could anticipate
the non grant eligible costs to amount to about $1.8,000. If it was
Book 22
Page 63
decided to not relocate the boiler and put the rest in as good a
shape as possible, it would appear that there was going to be some
$10,000 that would not be grant eligible. He could not see why
there was costs that were not grant eligible other than the stop
order. Mr. Lewis also stated that if the change order was issued
there would be an agreement.
Mr. Capestany from Parametrix was recognized and stated that one
thing that was highly unusual in this particular situation was
that it was the first time he had seen the State take a dollar
position arbitrarily. They rule normally on the concept of a
change being eligible for grant or not. They ruled everything
that was being talked about was grant eligible; then turned around
and stated that it was too expensive. He felt they were not
qualified to say that. Mr. Capestany further said that he felt
there was a chance of an exposure of $18,000. On the other hand,
he felt that they could document every invoice and fight with the
State for eligibility for monies spent. He said that Parametrix
would do their best to make every cent spent grant eligible and
there was no question that there would be a fight. Once the work
was documented, he felt they would have to fund it. Mr. Capestany
further commented that he could not tell the City exactly what the
exposure would be, but he could tell them that they were going to
do their best to bring that exposure down to what it should be or
ten percent of cost. He did not want to proceed with some of the
changes because the plant was costly and he would not care to short
change the facility.
Councilman Raymond stated that he did not think the City of
Caldwell had any choice but to go ahead with the changes. It was
obvious that the plant would be better served with the boiler being
moved and it also seemed obvious that the heating equipment would
have to be changed as it may not last. There was going to be a
cost anyway and he was prepared to go ahead and vote for the change.
The Mayor also stated that if the boiler was left where it was
that there was an excellent chance that the digester would be lost
which would be an expense. There: would be a gamble in that respect.
Councilwoman Mallea agreed with Councilman Raymond. Cottneilman
Hopper also stated that he supported the concept, but would like to
know if Parametrix was in a position to share some of the expenses.
The Mayor further said that he felt that part of the problem was
due to the engineering and that the City should not be responsible
for all of the cost when it was not a mistake the City made.
Councilman Hopper was recognized and said that he really did not
want to address it as a mistake, but something that was seen as
an improvement to the system after getting into the construction.
He was inviting Parametrix to share in some of the expenses caused
by this extra burden.
Mr. Capestany stated that their position as the City's consultant
was to advise the City of improvements that were needed as the
construction advanced. If they had been aware of some of the
needed changes, they would have put them down in:the original
contract. They discovered quite a few things after the contractor
began the work and did not feel 'rhatit was their fault.
Councilman Hopper said that he was not addressing it under the
concept that anyone was at fault. They were recognizing the
improvements, but it was costing the City more because of the
delay. There was a lot of time that has elapsed.
The Mayor said that Mr. Walker mentioned in their morning meeting
that it was all probably a lack of coordination.
After more discussion, it was MOVED by Raymond, SECONDED by
Williams that the firm of Parametrix be advised to proceed with the
change order for the relocation of the boiler and the additional
needs of the Treatment Plant and negotiate with the State authorities
to the best interest of the City of Caldwell.
Book 22
Page 64
Councilwoman Williams informed the Council that there would have
to be a Finance Meeting to determine where the funds would come
out of.
Councilman Raymond then stated that the City of Caldwell got the
money originally for the City's share from a service charge to
the users of the Treatment Plant. If the City was expected to
complete the plant properly, he was not going to hesitate to add
the service charge again. The problem of where the funds would
come from would have to be resolved.
The Mayor then asked for a vote on the motion.
MOTION CARRIED
There being no further business, the Meeting was adjourned at
1:10 P.M.
APPROVED AS written THIS 3 rd DAY OF March 1981.
Counci n�
I ,o
Fo}hnc�ilma
ATTEST:
��� -4,
City Clerk
Councilman