HomeMy WebLinkAbout06-11-2025 P & Z MINUTESPLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES
Wednesday, June 11, 2025 @ 6:00 pm
City Hall, Council Chambers, 205 S. 6'h Ave, Caldwell, Idaho
Vice Chair Harman called the meeting to order at: 6:00pm.
ROLL CALL
Present: ❑ Zamora ICJ Harman ® Boutros ® Larson ❑ Whitbeck
Absent: ® Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros ❑ Larson ® Whitbeck
CONFLICT OF INTEREST DECLARATION (if any).
Vice Chair Harman asked if there were any conflict -of -interest declarations. There were none.
SPECIAL PRESENATIONS.
None
CONSENT CALENDAR: (ALL CONSENT CALENAR ITEMS ARE ACTION ITEMS.)
1. Approve minutes for the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission for the May 14, 2025, hearing.
MOTION BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Hannan ® Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
SECONDED BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros N Larson ❑ Whitbeck
MOTION CARRIED
REVIEW OF PROCEEDINGS (OPENING STATEMENT)
Vice Chair Harman opened the public hearing and outlined the public hearing procedures.
Vice Chair Harman proceeded to public hearing items on the agenda.
OLD BUSINESS:
ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Quasi-judicial) Case Number ANN24-000014, CPM24-000005,
SPP24-000005, SUP24-000022: The applicant, Brent Orton, on behalf of Royal Pro-C, LLC, is requesting
an annexation of approximately 13.1 acres of land with initial zoning designations of C-1 (neighborhood
commercial) and R-2 (medium density residential). Concurrently, the applicant is requesting special use
permit and preliminary plat approval for The Caine Center Subdivision, a mixed use development with 26
multi -family residential lots and 5 commercial lots. The multi -family residential portion of the project would
include no more than 158 dwelling units and the commercial area is conceptually shown to include a gas
station, a drive through facility, and 3 other commercial shell buildings. The site is addressed as 1020 E.
Homedale Rd., (R3272100000) and is located on the southwest corner of E. Homedale Rd. and S. Montana
Ave. in Caldwell, Idaho.
Staff requested this application be continued to the July 9, 2025, P&Z Commission hearing.
MOTION BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ® Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
SECONDED BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros ® Larson ❑ Whitbeck
Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Minutes June It, 2025
MOTION CARRIED
NEW BUSINESS:
ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Quasi-judicial) Case Number SPP25-000006, ZON25-000001:
The applicant, Treasure Valley Development LLC, on behalf of Enclave Partners LLC, is requesting a
zoning map amendment for a portion of parcel R3279500000 from H-C to R-2 as well as a preliminary
plat approval for Enclave Subdivision, a mixed -use subdivision with 152 single-family residential lots
and 5 commercial lots. The site is designated Community Center in the Comprehensive Plan Future
Land Use Map, which is compatible with R-2 zoning as well as the remaining H-C zoning. The
development is located on the South side of Karcher Rd., directly across from the intersection with
Celeste Ave., between Midway Rd. and Lake Ave., in Caldwell, Idaho.
Sta ff resentation:
City Associate Planner, Joe Dodson, 205 6TH Ave., Caldwell, Idaho, presented the staff report by use of a
PowerPoint presentation. He noted:
• Surrounding area
• Exiting plat that is valid right now
• Could not sell so wishes to replat
• Proposing new prelim plat reducing units by half
• Removed storage and maintained commercial
• Development modification is required but will only go through City Council
• Amenities
• Landscaping will be updated to new code by City Council
Applicant Presentation:
Applicant, Sabrina Durtche, 5179 S. Baren Ave, Boise, Idaho presented the applicant's request by use of a
PowerPoint presentation:
• Density
• Surrounded by medium density neighborhoods
• Transportation
• Access points
• Utilities
• 3 phases starting in Fall 2026 or Spring 2027
• Open Space — four parks
• Changed from high density to medium density
Commission Questions for Sta and Applicant:
There were none.
Public Testimony:
Dominic Rossi, 12847 Lignite Dr., Nampa, Idaho signed up in favor of the application:
• Will there be abridge built over Wilson Creek?
• Traffic
Troy Junier, 12686 Slatestone Way, Nampa, ID 83651 signed up in favor of the application
• Traffic
• Bridge
Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Minutes June It, 2025
Dyanne Riggs, 12402 Karcher Rd., Nampa, ID 83651, signed up in neutral of the application but did not
wish to speak.
Chris Frasure, 12247 Karcher Rd, Nampa, ID 83651 signed up in opposition of the application:
• Traffic
• Roads
• Trespassing on his property
• Type of commercial businesses allowed
Applicant Rebuttal:
Sabrina Durtche spoke in rebuttal to the above comments:
• Stub road will be taken care of by builder
• Traffic
• Roads
• Perimeter of subdivision will be fenced
• Commercial use zoned for H-C
• Reducing density by half from previous preliminary plat
Commission Questions for Staff and Applicant:
• Work with public on fencing along stub road
• Bridge will be fully funded by the developers
• Timing with Hwy 55 project
• Donation to Vallivue School
o Only used for capital improvements
• Traffic — anticipates Karcher access being utilized
Motion to close public discussion:
MOTION BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros ' Larson ❑ Whitbeck
SECONDED BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman X Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
MOTION CARRIED
Evidence Lis_ t
Staff report and presentation documents
Applicant presentation documents
Sign-up sheets
Commission Discussion and Deliberation:
• Traffic is concern
• Notes this modification reduces density
ORDER OF DECISION:
Based upon the testimony and evidence in record in this matter, and upon the findings of fact and
conclusions of law set forth herein, do hereby determine and move as follows:
❑ Zamora ❑ Harman 0 Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
MADE A MOTION AS FOLLOWS:
Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Minutes June 1 1, 2025
The request for Case No. ZON25-01 for the REZONE of a portion of parcel R32795 with a zoning
designation of R-2 (Medium Density Residential), as well as a preliminary plat approval, SPP25-6 for the
ENCLAVE subdivision is recommended for approval, subject to the conditions of approval as
presented/amended
MOTION WAS SECONDED BY:
❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros Z Larson ❑ Whitbeck
ROLL CALL VOTE:
Zamora
❑
Yes ❑
No
Harman
Z
Yes ❑
No
Boutros
Z
Yes ❑
No
Larson
Z
Yes ❑
No
Whitbeck
❑
Yes ❑
No
MOTION CARRIED
ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Quasi-judicial) Case Number ANN25-000004, SPP25-000005: The
applicant, Bonnie Layton of NV5, on behalf of Endurance Holdings LLC, is requesting annexation of parcel
R3280700000 with a proposed zoning of R-1, where the current City comprehensive plan future land use
designation is Neighborhood 2. Additionally, the applicant is requesting approval of a preliminary plat for
Peregrine East Subdivision, a residential subdivision with 48 single family residential lots. The 20.83 acre
development is located on the North side of Orchard Ave., approximately 2,100 feet east of the intersection
with Lake Ave., in Caldwell, Idaho.
Staff Presentation:
City Associate Planner, Joe Dodson, 205 6TH Ave., Caldwell, Idaho, presented the staff report by use of a
PowerPoint presentation. He noted:
• Open Space — over 3 acres which is twice that which is required
• Amenities — 3
Applicant Presentation:
Bonnie Layton, 690 S. Industry Way Ste. 10, Meridian, Idaho, presented the applicant's request by use of
a PowerPoint presentation:
• Zoning requested R-1
• Surrounding property
• Single Family Homes
• No duplexes
Commission Questions for Sta and A licant.
• Compatible with Peregrine Estates
• 3 units per acre
• Phasing of project and development to the north
• Drainage and Irrigation
• Fencing
• Landscape buffer
• Larger lots and homes
Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Minutes June 11, 2025
Public Testimony:
Robert McCulley, 12643 Lignite Dr., Nampa, Idaho, signed up in opposition of the application but wishes
to remove his opposition.
Donna McCulley, 12643 Lignite Dr., Nampa, Idaho signed up in opposition of the application but did not
wish to speak.
Shane Jensen, 15088 Impact Lane, Nampa, ID, signed up in opposition of the application but did not wish
to speak.
Charity Jensen, 15088 Impact Lane, Nampa, ID signed up in opposition of the application but did not wish
to speak.
Applicant Rebuttal:
Applicant did not speak in rebuttal to the above comments:
Motion to close public discussion:
MOTION BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros ® Larson ❑ Whitbeck
SECONDED BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ® Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
MOTION CARRIED
Evidence List
Staff report and presentation documents
Applicant presentation documents
Sign-up sheets
Commission Discussion and Deliberation:
• City Council direction regarding density
• Good open space
ORDER OF DECISION:
Based upon the testimony and evidence in record in this matter, and upon the findings of face and
conclusions of law set forth herein, do hereby determine and move as follows:
❑ Zamora ❑ Harman N Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
MADE A MOTION AS FOLLOWS:
The request for Case No. AIVN25-04 the request for annexation ofparcel R32807 with a zoning
designation of R-1, as well as a preliminary plat approval, SPP25-05 for the PEREGRINE EAST
SUBDIVISION is recommended for approval, subject to the conditions of approval as
presentedlamended.
MOTION WAS SECONDED BY:
❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros N Larson ❑ Whitbeck
ROLL CALL VOTE:
Zamora ❑ Yes ❑ No
Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Minutes June 11, 2025
Harman
®
Yes
❑
No
Boutros
®
Yes
❑
No
Larson
®
Yes
❑
No
Whitbeck
❑
Yes
❑
No
MOTION CARRIED
ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Quasi-judicial) Case Number ANN25-000005, SPP25-000004: The
applicant, Bonnie Layton ofNV5, on behalf of Endurance Holdings LLC, is requesting annexation of parcel
R3280500000 with a proposed zoning of R-1, where the current City comprehensive plan future land use
designation is Neighborhood 2. Additionally, the applicant is requesting approval of a preliminary plat for
Peregrine West Subdivision, a residential subdivision with 45 single family residential lots. The 16.59 acre
development is located on the North side of Orchard Ave., approximately 630 feet east of the intersection
with Lake Ave., in Caldwell, Idaho.
Staff Presentation:
City Associate Planner, Katie Wright, 205 6TH Ave., Caldwell, Idaho, presented the staff report by use of a
PowerPoint presentation. He noted:
• Frontage
• Surrounding area
• Requested zoning R-1
• Single Family Homes
Apjplicant Presentation:
Bonnie Layton, 690 S Industry Way Ste. 10., Meridian Idaho, presented the applicant's request by use of a
PowerPoint presentation:
• Surrounding area
• Density
• Landscaping
• Open space
• Amenities
Commission Questions for Staff and AMplicant:
There were none.
Public Testimony:
Scott Glubay, 12814 Orchard Ave, signed up in opposition of the application:
• Exhibit 100 was handed to clerk
• Requesting sidewalk and gutter
• Irrigation questions regarding ditches
• Exhibit 101 was handed to clerk
• Property pins need to be determined
Applicant Rebuttal:
Bonnie Layton spoke in rebuttal to the above comments:
• Frontage issues addressed in conditions of approval
• Irrigation reviewed by city staff and the irrigation district
Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Minutes June 11, 2025
Motion to close public discussion:
MOTION BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros N Larson ❑ Whitbeck
SECONDED BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman N Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
MOTION CARRIED
Evidence List
Staff report and presentation documents
Applicant presentation documents
Sign-up sheets
Commission Discussion and Deliberation:
• Concerns about jurisdiction regarding Exhibit 100
• City can address dedication of right of way
ORDER OF DECISION:
Based upon the testimony and evidence in record in this matter, and upon the findings offace and
conclusions of law set forth herein, do hereby determine and move as follows:
❑ Zamora ❑ Harman N Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
MADE A MOTION AS FOLLOWS:
The request for Case No. ANN25-05 for annexation of parcel R3280 with a zoning designation of R-1, as
well as a preliminary plat approval, SPP25-04 for the PEREGRINE WEST SUBDIVISION is
recommended for approval, subject to the conditions of approval as presented/amended.
MOTION WAS SECONDED BY:
❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros N Larson ❑ Whitbeck
ROLL CALL VOTE:
Zamora
❑
Yes ❑
No
Harman
N
Yes
❑
No
Boutros
N
Yes
❑
No
Larson
N
Yes
❑
No
Whitbeck
❑
Yes
❑
No
MOTION CARRIED
ACTION ITEM: Public Hearing (Quasi-judicial) Case Number ANN25-000006: The applicant, Caldwell
Housing Authority, is requesting annexation of parcels R3465800000, R3465801100, and R3465801000,
with a proposed zoning of R-2, where the current City comprehensive plan future land use designation is
Neighborhood 2. Additionally, the applicant is requesting approval of a Development Agreement with
approvals for specific uses to accommodate their master plan for Farmway Village, an affordable housing
residential community. The 78,92 acre development is located on the southeast corner of Highway 44 and
Farmway Road., in Caldwell, Idaho.
Staff Presentation:
City Associate Planner, Katie Wright, 205 6TH Ave., Caldwell, Idaho, presented the staff report by use of a
PowerPoint presentation. He noted:
Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Minutes June l I, 2025
• Frontage
• Surrounding areas
• Recent annexations into city
• Approved uses
• Density
• Amenities
• Site access
• Conditions
Applicant Presentation:
Mike Dittenber, 22730 Farmway Rd, Caldwell, ID 83607, presented the applicant's request by use of
PowerPoint presentation:
• History of Farmway Village
• Amenities
• Always been a PUD
• Operate under Idaho Code Section 50-1 4
• Engineering Team present
• Connected to City Sewer and Water
Commission Questions for La and Applicant:
There were no questions.
Public Testimony:
Dominique Moreno, 3806 Stonegate Way, Caldwell, Idaho, signed up in favor of the application but did
not wish to speak.
Alex Nuttman, 2540 N. Julia Place, Meridian, Idaho, signed up in favor of the application but did not wish
to speak,
Motion to close public discussion:
MOTION BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ❑ Boutros ® Larson ❑ Whitbeck
SECONDED BY: ❑ Zamora ❑ Harman N Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
MOTION CARRIED
Evidence List
Staff report and presentation documents
Applicant presentation documents
Sign-up sheets
Commission Discussion and Deliberation:
• Approving the M-I two months ago provided the path to annex this project.
ORDER OF DECISION:
Based upon the testimony and evidence in record in this matter, and upon the findings offace and
conclusions of law set forth herein, do hereby determine and move as follows:
Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Minutes June 11, 2025
❑ Zamora ❑ I larman ❑ Boutros ® Larson ❑ Whitbeck
MADE A MOTION AS FOLLOWS:
The request for annexation of parcel R34658, R34658011 and R3465801 with a zoning designation of R-2
and associated Development Agreement for Fornnvay Village is recornrnended for approval subject to the
conditions of approval is recommended for approval, subject to the conditions of approval as
presented/anrended.
MOTION WAS SECONDED BY:
❑ Zamora ❑ Harman ® Boutros ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck
ROLL CALL VOTE:
Zamora
❑
Yes ❑
No
Harman
®
Yes ❑
No
Boutros
®
Yes ❑
No
Larson
®
Yes ❑
No
Whitbeck
❑
Yes ❑
No
MOTION CARRIED
ADJOURNMENT
MOTION BY: ❑ Boutros ❑ Harman ® Larson ❑ Whitbeck ❑ Zamora
SECONDED BY: ® Boutros ❑ Harman ❑ Larson ❑ Whitbeck ❑ Zamora
to adjourn the meeting.
MOTION CARRIED
Meeting adjourned at: 7:52 pm
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Respectfully submitted by Sarah Davis, Planning and Zoning, Planning Technician
MINI JUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY CHAIRMAN ZAMORA: on the date noted below.
Aterandro Zam
V
-1 � q � 7- Date:
r
. . ) -Y/
ATTEST.
Robin o ins, Community Development Director
Planning and Zoning Commission Hearing Nhimies June 11. 2025