HomeMy WebLinkAboutRe_ Clarification on Landscaping Ordinance for Peregrine Estate Project
Thank you, Matt. I will add it to our records.
[cid:2a4ee377-adb5-4403-977b-2fe30e96caad]
________________________________
From: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com>
Sent: Monday, February 17, 2025 3:57 PM
To: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>
Subject: RE: Clarification on Landscaping Ordinance for Peregrine Estate Project
Here is the revised exhibit.
Matt Price P.E.
Project Manager
J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
2760 W. Excursion Lane, Suite 400, Meridian, ID 83642
e mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com> w www.jub.com<http://www.jub.com/>
p 208 376 7330 c 208 869 2545
From: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>
Sent: Monday, February 17, 2025 2:37 PM
To: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: Clarification on Landscaping Ordinance for Peregrine Estate Project
External Email - This Message originated from outside J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
________________________________
Hello Matt,
Upon reviewing the open space exhibit in accordance with the terms outlined in Ordinance 2428, I have determined that 1.37 acres of this phase meet the criteria for qualified open space.
If you concur with my calculations, could you kindly make the necessary adjustments to the open space exhibit to reflect this figure and email the revised document to me?
Thank you,
Garline
[cid:image001.jpg@01DB8154.93415550]
________________________________
From: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>
Sent: Monday, February 17, 2025 12:42 PM
To: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>; Morgan Bessaw <mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org>>; Robin Collins <rcollins@cityofcaldwell.
org<mailto:rcollins@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Shawn Brownlee (shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>) <shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>>; Cory Lockwood <clockwood@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:clockwood@trilogyi
daho.com>>; Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: RE: Clarification on Landscaping Ordinance for Peregrine Estate Project
Good afternoon Garline,
Thank you for your e-mail and the cities understanding that requirements to code ordinances that took place after the agreement should not be used.
We will work on getting this issue taken care of. In light of the e-mail below I would like to ask that the open space exhibit for Peregrine 8 be re-reviewed for compliance. We do want
to resolve this issue as soon as possible for everyone’s benefit and without a meeting etc.. to save time. I have attached the previously re-submitted Open Space exhibit for Peregrine
8.
Matt Price P.E.
Project Manager
J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
2760 W. Excursion Lane, Suite 400, Meridian, ID 83642
e mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com> w www.jub.com<http://www.jub.com/>
p 208 376 7330 c 208 869 2545
From: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Sent: Monday, February 17, 2025 10:03 AM
To: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>; Morgan Bessaw <mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org>>; Robin Collins <rcollins@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:rcollins@cityo
fcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Shawn Brownlee (shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>) <shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>>; Cory Lockwood <clockwood@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:clockwood@trilogyi
daho.com>>; Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Clarification on Landscaping Ordinance for Peregrine Estate Project
External Email - This Message originated from outside J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
________________________________
Good morning Matt,
I apologize for the recent complications that have hindered the approval of phase eight of the Peregrine Estate project. Please be assured that Planning and Zoning has no intention of
complicating your timeline; we are committed to resolving this matter as swiftly as possible.
We also do not wish to impose any requirements beyond what was previously agreed upon. In that spirit, we understand your position regarding adherence to code ordinances that took effect
after Peregrine's approval. We have reviewed the Peregrine Estates Development Agreement (ANN-132-06 & SUB-156P-06) to determine the applicable landscape ordinance. Under Article II,
Section 21 of the Development Agreement, it is stated that the development shall adhere to the City's Landscaping Ordinance No. 2428.
For your convenience, I have attached a copy of the Development Agreement, as well as a copy of Landscaping Ordinance No. 2428. As you correctly pointed out, this ordinance differs from
the one currently observed. It requires a minimum of 5% of the total project acreage to be dedicated to open space. You will also find a more straightforward definition of open space
criteria in Section 10-07-05.
I hope this information clarifies the requirements and simplifies the process for you and your team. We would appreciate it if you could gather and provide documentation showing compliance
with Ordinance No. 2428.
Thank you for your insights and collaboration. Please do not hesitate to contact us with any additional concerns or questions.
Best regards,
Garline
[cid:image001.jpg@01DB8154.93415550]
________________________________
From: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>
Sent: Friday, February 14, 2025 8:59 AM
To: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>; Morgan Bessaw <mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org>>; Robin Collins <rcollins@cityofcaldwell.
org<mailto:rcollins@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Shawn Brownlee (shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>) <shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>>; Cory Lockwood <clockwood@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:clockwood@trilogyi
daho.com>>; Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: RE: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
Good morning,
We would like to meet with the city to discuss the Peregrine project. We are hoping next week on Wednesday afternoon or the week after on Wednesday or Thursday if possible.
The subdivision pre-plat was approved in 2007 and we are wondering why we are being held to the changes in code that have happened since that one was approved. I have sent over the extension
letter from mayor Wagoner, let me know if you would like me to resend it.
Please let me know what times would work for you to meet.
Matt Price P.E.
Project Manager
J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
2760 W. Excursion Lane, Suite 400, Meridian, ID 83642
e mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com> w www.jub.com<http://www.jub.com/>
p 208 376 7330 c 208 869 2545
From: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Sent: Tuesday, February 11, 2025 4:47 PM
To: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>; Morgan Bessaw <mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Shawn Brownlee (shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>) <shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>>; Cory Lockwood <clockwood@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:clockwood@trilogyi
daho.com>>; Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
External Email - This Message originated from outside J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
________________________________
Hello Matt,
Thank you for providing the updated open space exhibit for Phase 8. However, I would like to bring a couple of points to your attention. According to the city's code, any lots or portions
of lots used for drainage purposes cannot be counted towards the qualified open space requirement. Consequently, Lot 7 of Block 21, Lot 8 of Block 29, Lot 8 of Block 31, most of Lot
1 of Block 28, and most of Lot 1 of Block 30 will not be considered qualified open space.
Section 5, Chapter 7, Article 10 of the city's code outlines the criteria for both non-qualified and qualified open space. Please refer to this list to update the open space exhibit
for Phase 8 and to classify the qualified open space for the previous phases.
Thank you for your understanding and assistance.
City of Caldwell, Idaho (2024) § 5-7-10
[cid:image002.png@01DB8154.93415550]
[cid:image001.jpg@01DB8154.93415550]
________________________________
From: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>
Sent: Tuesday, February 11, 2025 2:31 PM
To: Morgan Bessaw <mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org>>; Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Shawn Brownlee (shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>) <shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>>; Cory Lockwood <clockwood@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:clockwood@trilogyi
daho.com>>; Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: RE: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
Good afternoon,
Attached is a revised Open Space to reflect the earlier Open Space standards. The biggest change is the area above Seepage areas should count as useable.
Please let us know if this Open Space Exhibit for Phase 8 is acceptable and we will get to work on the other ones requested.
Matt Price P.E.
Project Manager
J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
2760 W. Excursion Lane, Suite 400, Meridian, ID 83642
e mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com> w www.jub.com<http://www.jub.com/>
p 208 376 7330 c 208 869 2545
From: Morgan Bessaw <mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Sent: Monday, February 10, 2025 2:46 PM
To: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>; Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Shawn Brownlee (shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>) <shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>>; John Jr <johnjr@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:johnjr@trilogyidaho.com>>;
Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] RE: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
External Email - This Message originated from outside J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
________________________________
Hi Matt,
Okay, we look forward to receiving your open space exhibits.
Thanks,
[cid:image003.png@01DB8154.93415550]
From: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>
Sent: Monday, February 10, 2025 12:51 PM
To: Morgan Bessaw <mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org>>; Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Shawn Brownlee (shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>) <shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>>; John Jr <johnjr@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:johnjr@trilogyidaho.com>>;
Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: FW: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
Good Afternoon Morgan,
I do see the 5% requirement you were talking about. Condition #37 in the Development Agreement says:
[A close up of a text Description automatically generated]
The applicant mentioned 9.3% which is actually listed as common space, and shown that way on the Preliminary Plat, not open space. Since we were conditioned to have 5% open space (As
described above in 2007) we will go with that number and provide the appropriate documentation”
Matt Price P.E.
Project Manager
J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
2760 W. Excursion Lane, Suite 400, Meridian, ID 83642
e mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com> w www.jub.com<http://www.jub.com/>
p 208 376 7330 c 208 869 2545
From: Morgan Bessaw <mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Sent: Monday, February 10, 2025 8:56 AM
To: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>; Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Shawn Brownlee (shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>) <shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>>; John Jr <johnjr@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:johnjr@trilogyidaho.com>>;
Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] RE: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
External Email - This Message originated from outside J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
________________________________
Hi Matt,
We actually did require open space in 2007, a minimum of 5% was required. The order of decision for Peregrine states that the applicant is proposing more than the minimum required at
9.3%. We are just asking that you prove to us that you are meetings what your application promised, which is that you would provide 9.3% useable open space across the project and we
can not do that without more information from you on what open space has already been completed. Please let me know if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
[cid:image003.png@01DB8154.93415550]
From: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>
Sent: Thursday, February 6, 2025 2:53 PM
To: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>; Morgan Bessaw <mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:mbessaw@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Shawn Brownlee (shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>) <shawn@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:shawn@trilogyidaho.com>>; John Jr <johnjr@trilogyidaho.com<mailto:johnjr@trilogyidaho.com>>;
Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: FW: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
Good afternoon Garline,
This is an older project. This project was granted an extension in 2016 per this attached letter. The letter allows for a Time Extension of a preliminary Plat that was approved in 2007.
The open space code was not adopted until 2008.
With the Open Space requirement being adopted after approval of this subdivisions approved pre-plat, the exhibits we submitted for open space are not helpful, even though we did try
to submit.
We are happy to meet you to discuss further if you would like.
Matt Price P.E.
Project Manager
J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
2760 W. Excursion Lane, Suite 400, Meridian, ID 83642
e mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com> w www.jub.com<http://www.jub.com/>
p 208 376 7330 c 208 869 2545
From: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Sent: Wednesday, January 29, 2025 1:53 PM
To: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>
Cc: Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
External Email - This Message originated from outside J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
________________________________
Good afternoon, Matt,
I have received several updated plans from your office via Projectdox. I appreciate your team's efforts to address all the issues I had highlighted. I will review the provided updated
documents for code compliance.
However, I still require documentation of the usable open space for the seven previous phases. After consulting with Morgan, we concluded that we cannot include the numbers in the Peregrine
Estates No. 7 final plat staff report. Please inform me when the open space documentation is ready, and I will include it in my report.
Thank you for your understanding and assistance.
Best regards,
Garline
[cid:image001.jpg@01DB8154.93415550]
________________________________
From: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Sent: Wednesday, January 22, 2025 10:11 AM
To: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>
Cc: Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: Re: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
Hi Matt,
I have worked with Katie Wright on reviewing the prior reports. The figures in the Peregrine Estates No. 7 report do not reflect the actual qualifying open space, as the information
necessary for the calculation was not provided. Therefore, I will not be able to include those numbers in my report, as they were originally incorrect representations of the qualified
open space.
I highly recommend you provide us with the details on the qualifying open space for the previous phases of the project so the record can show an accurate and true representation of your
project. Thank you for your assistance.
Best regards,
Garline
[cid:image001.jpg@01DB8154.93415550]
________________________________
From: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>
Sent: Wednesday, January 22, 2025 9:59 AM
To: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Cc: Alex Jones <agjones@jub.com<mailto:agjones@jub.com>>
Subject: RE: Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
Hi Garline.
The numbers were calculated by city staff in the previous phases and the numbers are available in the Peregrine Estates No. 7 final plat staff report.
Matt Price P.E.
Project Manager
J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
2760 W. Excursion Lane, Suite 400, Meridian, ID 83642
e mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com> w www.jub.com<http://www.jub.com/>
p 208 376 7330 c 208 869 2545
From: Garline Davis <gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org<mailto:gdavis@cityofcaldwell.org>>
Sent: Monday, January 20, 2025 4:10 PM
To: Matt Price <mprice@jub.com<mailto:mprice@jub.com>>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8
External Email - This Message originated from outside J-U-B ENGINEERS, Inc.
________________________________
Good afternoon, Matt,
My name is Garline, and I am the newest planner for the city of Caldwell. I am reviewing the final plat application for Peregrine Estates - Subdivision No. 8.
I am contacting you regarding the open space information for the Peregrine project. I appreciate the open space exhibit included in the final plat application for phase 8. However, I
am unable to verify the open space information for the previous phases. Could you please provide documentation of the usable open space for the seven previous phases?
Thank you for your assistance.
Best regards,
Garline
[cid:image001.jpg@01DB8154.93415550]
Disclaimer
Note: This e-mail and any attachments involving J-U-B or a subsidiary business may contain information that is confidential and/or proprietary. Prior to use, you agree to the provisions
found on the Electronic Documents/Data License, which can be accessed from the footer on the J-U-B home page. If you believe you received this email in error, please reply to that effect
and then delete all copies.
This email has been scanned for viruses and malware, and may have been automatically archived.
[JUB_Image]
________________________________
This email has been scanned for spam and viruses by Proofpoint Essentials. Click here<https://us1.proofpointessentials.com/app/report_spam.php?mod_id=11&mod_option=logitem&report=1&type=easyspam&k=k1
&payload=53616c7465645f5fc9457d0cb380360411e9f72ff6e2906bde5981661dde7e9816cd487995abe7b6af1866343007b0dfb27b6173ff482af207cab21d4ff526109863f06563ac1ea6cc87462f58b3ca5bb58603cf42c1ec91b56d6998fa81f6
b556b2c5ce6a508976b93cedf2106fc648a48d8813c9d32345dd1d62171df50b8c551b16091a4623454d03665fe0e7b9aa21d2944420eca5e8d21ece3873f3e976> to report this email as spam.
________________________________
This email has been scanned for spam and viruses by Proofpoint Essentials. Click here<https://us1.proofpointessentials.com/app/report_spam.php?mod_id=11&mod_option=logitem&report=1&type=easyspam&k=k1
&payload=53616c7465645f5f17d78cae45feeb142368d85b87a572419ed239de77044088ea6fd0f212cc322a3868ef6c8ee4eabf14da0eababb21d59a33989ba97032c4d9f45d9fb68c469cc0ce6553fd1f19382e3c9f82362bdde110ac3f8f557dd14
d7ad9efdd0a52a19bdb320d21a18afbdf39b25f7f694127a1e7797f9a472da9899e0cc41908c5559418c9626f271bd70454e6df8030a69e95ca9c845de2e82eea8> to report this email as spam.
________________________________
This email has been scanned for spam and viruses by Proofpoint Essentials. Click here<https://us1.proofpointessentials.com/app/report_spam.php?mod_id=11&mod_option=logitem&report=1&type=easyspam&k=k1
&payload=53616c7465645f5fd63ca7538fc1dd64858860075934ed32a7e64823f4c98392b80de3b0adf96fa699cf2335817770d731236189e0a91f511cbabb2f16e64110159161cc662c98232f9e02fcd0c742a9ecbbcc123e6bfd2c63e11569cbf25a
31b519a3a0351832b0fc154c383427fac9105939b076902ab799375610419e9c47a8c7b27a06d9c6a178c11d274d3e311bdfb0d67902a8ac35a70468f0da99626a> to report this email as spam.
________________________________
This email has been scanned for spam and viruses by Proofpoint Essentials. Click here<https://us1.proofpointessentials.com/app/report_spam.php?mod_id=11&mod_option=logitem&report=1&type=easyspam&k=k1
&payload=53616c7465645f5f4f85ef5dcfdd7de4119402ba5a03398e4e0f5bbb9f3c9b990ad5a4e882e06d9457dd1b348a9e5c887e99ce7bac2f1c0f4300187d5dfc1e8bc1ba0299131bd91e804031a005e1dbe9ea512c83c7e76ef6e516c6b7327e21
65fd85f9229919a00ad7aaa6d9f7ab4a8ba7b3c40def89a03af46ff2d1e01a5c3358140039b1f1823f2606df703b83cd1f7e8f0fe985a327bbee8158e294a6ee05> to report this email as spam.
________________________________
This email has been scanned for spam and viruses by Proofpoint Essentials. Click here<https://us1.proofpointessentials.com/app/report_spam.php?mod_id=11&mod_option=logitem&report=1&type=easyspam&k=k1
&payload=53616c7465645f5fd607b6c8603f2bcd00c7057d829cc0b8770ad63474ae920b9b440c11b29b7604675af7c60bf2a2b833d34b8425b7db8c1d515e7d89b197f959e9278e42d4aaa84d1048a89c0163b23f12e8b670500ea411af7cb73362ec
a8fbe39f0700c3d68e2c7161a5a785257a7efd17a2cbdac33543eea7e8e02e6d390474cf218c3ffc44384f12ec4eb94d89319238d2fd01131b272506e92fc9e757> to report this email as spam.