HomeMy WebLinkAboutCA-02-14 Lloyd Kuck 1422 Everett StHISTORICAL DISTRICT
ITEM DATE SLMBITTED BY
HD- 1 Application ?t8'2=\t Wavn*'.o 3^kfLt-gytA v^il,r-
ID-2 Narrative 7rf2-'Y LLJo/\4.3'\4tWqAt-u?, lLZl KPHD-3 Wt / Pictures of Site 3^ | E-lo'q
rC ('+HD-4 Posting / Public Notice /C th+
T g.2ol-{(z-.3 -'2ll->ottHD-5 Agenda
3-1$'>vl [A-';r--',-1 5o-<6<"zfHD-6 Sample of material
lp-a-L3'lq a-'i{ID-7 Certificate of Appropriateness
oJ-HD-8 Meeting minutes 5-a1 u"(
\
CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
Meeting of March 24,2014 @ 6:00 P.M.
Call to order.
6:15 p.m.
Chairperson Maughan called the meeting to order at approximately
ll. Roll Call
Members Present. Chuck Randolph, De Etta L. Ewing, Lorene Oates and Steve
Maughan.
Members Absent. Elaine Carpenter, Kevin Manning, and Megan Dixon.
Others Present. Brian Billingsley, Planning & Zoning Director; and Jarom Wagoner,
Senior Planner.
Others Absent. April Cabello, Planning Technician; and Rob Hopper, City Council
Liaison.
lll. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF JANUARY 27,2014.
MOTION: Chuck R., SECOND: De Etta E., MOTION PASSED.
lV. Certificate of Appropriateness lnterviews. None.
V. AudienceParticipation.
Lacey Welt, Library Director, and lvladeline Buckendorf attended this meeting to
speak on the Carnegie Library subject.
Vl. Actions Since Last Meeting.
A. Jarom W. reported on Case Number CA-01-14. Applicant: Randy Bryan Fine.
Address: 1224 Evercll St. C of A was issued for an interior rear yard/ 192 sq
ft shed / Staff Level Approval.
B. Jarom W. reported on Case Number CA-O2-14. Applicant: Lloyd Kuck &
Ramona Sargent. Address: 1422 Evercll St. C of A was issued for re-roof /
Staff Level Approval.
Page 1
no -8
City of Caldwell Planning & Zoning - Upstairs Conference Room
621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ]D 83605
CH PC Meeting, March 24, 201,4
Vll. Old Business. None
Vlll. New Business.
A. Commissioner Randolph opened the discussion on the Carnegie Library.
Commissioner Randolph explained to the Library Director, Lacey Welt,
that the Historic Preservation Commission has met in the ldaho Room for
years and then found there was an on-going conflict with the room. The
Library Board Chair informed City Council that there was no space
problem at the Caldwell Public Library for storage of historical records or
meetings. Then to the surprise of the Historic Preservation Commission
the Library contacted them to remove some Historic Preservation files
from the Library. Commissioner Randolph then stated he has questions
about future storage of Library and the Historic Preservation files in the
ldaho Room, Equipment Storage Room, and the Library Directors office.
Commissioner Randolph expressed the importance of items at the Library
such as the Sandborn Maps, Polk City directories, and oral history
materials consisting of slide programs, family scanners, Zontas records,
CLG Grant Surveys and the locked cases in the ldaho Room.
Commissioner Randolph wondered what the Library's plans are for these
Historical materials.
Lacey Welt responded that she was asked by the board of trustees to
organize things better and to make better use of the space. Ms. Welt
stated that the Historic Preservation items will remain at the Library.
The Commission wondered if the Historic Preservation items at the
Library were documented or inventoried as to their location.
Ms. Welt responded that she has not been through everything in the
Library but staff members have a very good knowledge of where the
items are located.
Commissioner Randolph informed Ms. Welt that Jan Boles with the
College of ldaho has items that need to be placed at the Library.
The Commission and Ms. Welt continued their discussion on items to be
stored at the Library.
Commissioner Randolph wondered what is the Library Board's position
with the Historical materials and if the Historic Preservation Commission
should make an appearance before the board with their expectations.
tt4s. Welt stated that it would be helpful if the Commission was to make an
appearance.
Ms. Buckendorf expressed her concerns about the access to records, and
displaced records and wondered who at the Library or the City would be
in charge of receiving documents that need to be kept.
CHPC Meeting, March 24,20L4 Page 2
Chairman Maughan expressed the need to figure out how to transfer the
historical material into a secure repository using staff and folks who have
some knowledge of what is important and what is not.
Chairman Maughan stated that they need to ask the question, what do we
have and who needs to talk to the Library Board because there are
resources that are potentially in limbo.
The commission continued to discuss what the next step should be
whether it is digitizing and storage of documents and questioned if the
documents should be stored at the Carnegie Library or the Caldwell
Public Library. Ms. Welt and the commission stated it would be good to
have a commission member(s)attend an upcoming Library Board
meeting to discuss the commission's concerns.
Chairman Maughan and Commissioner Randolph agreed to attend an
upcoming Library Board meeting.
B. Jarom W. opened the discussion on Design Review for street mailboxes
mandated by the post office and explained why it came about. Jarom W.
further explained that when people move in and have a change of
address that will trigger the new requirement by the post office requiring a
mailbox to be placed by the sidewalk. Jarom W. wondered if the
commission wanted to stipulate a certain type and color of mailbox and
also requested that the commission recommend staff level approval to
avoid making the new homeowner wait.
Chairman Maughan wondered what the commission could do in the
Historic District which is identified under Federal Guidelines as a National
Historic District to push back against a mandate that physically affects the
appearance of the residences in the district. Chairman Maughan
wondered if Mayor Nancolas and the ldaho Congressional Delegation
would be willing to push back on this mandate.
The commission requested that Brian B. ask the Mayor to request an
exemption for the Steunenberg Historic District.
Brian B. stated he would ask Mayor Nancolas to call and push Rep
Labrador's office and both Senators' offices.
The commission discussed the possibility of cluster boxes rather than
individual boxes, in case the request for exemption fails.
Jarom W. shared with the commission that if the push back fails, the post
office would prefer cluster boxes. The post office has gone into other
subdivisions and told them if they agreed to do the cluster mailboxes the
post office would pay for it.
CHPC Meeting, March 24,201,4 Page 3
lX. Commission & Staff Reports
A. Brian B. gave an updated reported on the State legislative bills that would have
affected planning & zoning. The bills that Brian B. wanted to pass did and the
bills he opposed never made it out of committee or were voted down.
B. Chuck R. questioned curbs being painted red by the city. Brian B. explained
Blaine and Cleveland are ITD's jurisdiction not city roads but would ask Brent O.
X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 7:45 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
ROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAI RPERSON STEVE MAUGHANM
o
INU
Maughan Date
E;K>--5--t/
ATTEST: Brian Billingsley, Planning Director Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
CHPC Meeting, March 24,2014 Page 4
DATE NOTED BELOW.
A
Wt ty
!
-f Wq{'{,we{f
'rl
)
ii
ll
I G uotffi
"
qt e "f fuA te# rd a6@toe.ss
L[rytKucfr, st lRomona Sargent owner of site propertl focatef
ot 1422 Eeerett Street, Cdffiweff, IA 8i605, ftas 6een awarfef a Cert{icate of ,4ppropriateness
@ tlie Citl of Cat[weftl{istoricafQreservation Commission in conjunction
witfr Case No. CA-02-14- (gegegfl.
.,\lr1rr.ot'r'rl olr IIitx'lr l!), 201-t b.r'
( lt klrrtl I rrrrrrirrg tt Ttning i I listori<' l)tr,s<'rr';rtiott
'l'lris (l'r{il'it'rrlc ol' .\pprrrpriirtr,rross rr ill crpire orr ll:rrtlr l!). 20li-r
!
I
,li
ttrr
.,1
I.
II.
III.
IV.
v.
VI.
-
AGENDA
Historic Preservation Commission
Monday, March 24,2014 6:00 P.M.
City of Caldwell - Planning & Zoning
Upstairs Conference Room
621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, Idaho
Call to order
Roll Call
Approval of Minutes
o January 27,2014
Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews
. None
Audience Participation
Actions Since Last Meeting
Case No. CA-01-14. Applicant: Bryan Fine. 1224Everett St., Certificate of Appropriateness was
issued for an interior rear yard/ 192 sq ft shed / Staff Level Approval.
Case No. CA-02-14. Applicant: Lloyd Kuck & Ramona Sargent, Certificate of Appropriateness was
issued for a Re-Roof / Staff Level Approval.
VII. Old Business
VIII. New Business
. Discussion on Carnegie Library.o Discussion on Design Review for street mailboxes mandated by the post office.
IX. Commission & Staff Reports
X. Adjournment
Next tentative meeting will be held on Monday, April l4r 2014
Next tentative meeting will be held on Monduy, April 28r 2014
a
a
a
a
a
Any person neoding special accommodations to participate in the nreeting should contact the City Office at 208-tt55.f667 prior to the meeting.
Cualquier persona necesitando comodidades especiales para participar en la reuni6n debe contactar al las oficinas de la Ciudad o llame a 208 455- 4667 antes de la reuni6n.
"*
nrH
ttfruil
ru
H
,l
5
:
nl--/
I
l
T
-t
--G
l,
w
7
;-x
'{.
(,
-L@
N)o
-As
N)
N)!
-II
II
I
I
t.
I
br
t
i
t.,J
/.
$r
I
T ir
3 ^l g' ?o tl
^)ft,pt ,nq
\l
tuh
lA"
tec**r3
roo I C+,.. "X+ ''' )
|oZL, .[r,'fi'-oool Yy"
a\\ Jw<
cr(.
d,-fo
0t(
uui-th a
p w€*a rnal<
Sno'^lt
o bl
*n
F F,^o '" o\)7 t5t(
fd
h
foa
f "{l)
c
f 6r t't
b {tn
(JJ\-
f ea.ut tnq h
s . F t"!oi
S J', ''^, /t S
ol.s ,' \
h"- r.
e^i)s
O, t
UJ' n )
)'1 Ad
I o ccow \
I
D".. io
(o n i"g L^
-/. ^'n
2-.c1 ld"Yet^ o
S "-t
6
5
rao
,lK
D
t+@->
+
R^*^'^
r
L lanning & Zoning lpartment
Historic Preservation Gommission
62{ Gleveland Blvd.
Galdwell, lD 83605
Phone: 20g1455-4667 or 2Ogl455-3O21 Faxt 2O8I455-3O5O
Website: www. cityofcaldwell.com
Gertificate of Appropriateness -
Steunenberg Residential Historic District Application
Please trll out all sections of this application. Only complete applications will be accepted. If deemed incomplete by the
Historic Preservation Commission, the application may be denied. If a question does not pertain to your request, please mark it
N/A.
'dL -\Cross Referenced Cases:
This box for office use only
Case #:
This application is a request to construct, add, alter, demolish, or change the use of the property as
follows:
Q"- Ooo€
Applicant lnformation Applicant:
.1\ar e
Phone:
Owner tr
Applicant's Mailing Address:
Purchaser X Lessee
17ar Ltt e.rdl t#tilc ll zip: (3 /zd€
Applicant's E-mail Address:),et4
Agent/Representative :fl"Phone:
Agent/Representative's Mail i n g Add ress :zip,,
Agent/Representative's E-mail Address:
Contact Person (if different from above):Phone:
Address of Subject Property:r /-l- sl {
Have you reviewed the City's Historic District Design Guidelines?fv".trNo
3brq
1
a
A. Development lnformation
1. Size of Lot:
Footpri nt of structures:
2. Description of Site
3. Description of Setting
Dimensions:
4 A. This application is a request to construct, add or change the following:
(Check all that apply)
Add Change Demolish N/A
Roor QL-V\*
Walls
Fascia
Windows/Doors
Trim
Porch
Other (describe)
Does the application propose a change in use? D/
What is the current use?
ES
lf yes, what is the proposed new use?
(home occupation, rezone, subdivision, special use, temporary use) Circle one.
n
tr
n
tr
tr
n
*
tr
tr
n
tr
tr
n
tr
tr
tr
tr
n
n
tr
tr
tr
tr
n
tr
l
n
B. Futly exptain the nature of your request: RrrF : t )roU ,' ^g *lr,^ kolL1
u.lar)en\nolcs ec^sJull-cinales e
5.
B. Building lnformation
The following information needs to be ind
1. Number of structures:
Residential:
Outbuildings:
below and y referenced on plans submitted
2. Square footage of existing i-ructures:
Floor Gross Souare Feet
First
S
Third:
Other:
3. Square foota
Floor
of proposed structures or additions:
sS uare Feet
First:
Second:
Third:
Other:
Square footage of existing s hereof) to be removed:
Floor Gross S
First:
Second:
Third:
Other:
4. Existing Height to Buildi Eave:
Existing Height to Bu ing Peak:
Proposed Height Building Eave:
Proposed Hei t to Building Peak
N u mber tories:
5
6. Exterior Building rials:
Roof:
Walls:
Doors:
Fascia, T
Other:
This existing building is a:
Msinole-Familv dwellinon-lDuplex ffriplex f]4-Plex [Other:
Existino Prooosed
ctures (or pa
Feet
, etc
Windows (Existing)
ng Material:
Existi
Existing
Even site lines?
Brick molding?
Windows (Proposed)
Proposed Material:
Proposed Sill Depth:
Proposed Type:
Type:
Size (Height):
Location:
Sill Depth:
ingle Hung
! Fixed lDivided light: How man (e.9. 4 over1,3 over 1)
! Yes
Yes
No
No
I ! Double Hung lSingle Hung
ght: How many?_(e.g. 4 over 1,3 over 1)
For proposed d uding width, whether it is flat or contoured:
wiil th erior trim remain on the replacement windows? ! Yes E No
C. Site lnformation
1. Fencing
ded lights, please describe grid
ent ! Sl
txed
,l
!Divid
Exi n
! Casement ! Slider ! Double Hung
Chanqes Prooosed
D Additional lnformation
Are there other changes not yet covered? ! Yes ryd"
lf yes, please explain:
Signature of ApplicanURepresentative Date
Any revisions to this application request must be received 20 days prior to the hearing date, or your
application will be deferred to the next meeting. The staff will determine whether the application can still be
heard on the scheduled date, which depends on the degree of modification.
Note: When an application has been submitted, it will be reviewed in order to determine compliance with
application requirements. A hearing date will be scheduled only after an application has been accepted as
complete.
'/s -
L,D 3- t s'Aa ltt
Signature of Property Owner (if other than Applicant)Date
0)/
1. ACo lete bui Elev to scale.p n o
x 11"
s must i all pro uilding
Application Su bmittal Requirements
The following information must be submitted along with the application form.
u
2. A Detailed Site Plan to scale (not smaller than 1" = 30' unless otherwise approved). Two (2) copies
and one (1) 8112" x 11" reduction must be submitted. The site plan must include:
mate ls One ust be
Existing and pro
Adjoining stre all
n).
North arrow, scale ng, property li ES name of pland l.
tructures.
and private
Parking layo includi g spaces,VES, CU ts, cir latio erns an pedestrian walks
Existing/pro utilit service.
Locations a widths of ht.of-y, easements, canals, ditches and subdivision lines.
ge areas and mechanical equipment with purposed screening method.
for exterior lightino pedestrian, vehicle, security and decorative)
3. Photographs. Provide photographs of the following. Clearly label each photo.
North, South, East and West elevation of main dwelling
North, South, East and West elevation of each outbuilding
Photos of adjacent properties to the North, South, East and West (including across alleys and streets)
View of both block faces to show s un
e
f.
s
h
s
3, a- rrt"'H*-,. 5+4k-
'Fglu .b I bugw4\/lll.a-lV.)
4. An application seeking Demoliti location shall provide the following:
a. A written statement as to why the building, site, structure, or object should be demolished.
b. Photographs of the building, site, structure, or object to be demolished, as well as of adjacent
properties.
c. lf applicants wish to be considered for Finding 4 under Section 2-17-13.02 Demolition or
Relocation - Findings, they shall provide the following additional information:
Two (2) written reports, prepared, stamped, and signed by currently-licensed ldaho
design professionals appropriate to the nature of the project, at least one of which shall
be disinterested, stating the structural soundness of the building or structure proposed
for demolition and suitability for reuse.
An analysis of the cost to rehabilitate the existing structure plus construct the additional
square footage and other goals of the application. These costs shall be completed to
include the cost of demolishing any existing structures and the equivalent new
construction and shall be completed, signed and stamped by a currently-licensed ldaho
design/contract professional appropriate to the nature of the project.
Decision Matrix for Level of Decision: At Staff or Commission's discretion, any staff-level
item can be moved to a commission-levelapp.
Section 2. ltems Requiring or not Requiring a Certificate of Appropriateness
\-/
REASON FOR CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS COMMISSION
LEVEL
STAFF
LEVEL
1. Fencing Contributing Non
2. Zone chanqes, changes in use x
3. Gonstruction or installation of new primary structure x
4. Demolition of primary structure x
5. Construction or installation of garages or accessory
structures
Contributing Non
6. Demolition or removal of garages or accessory structures Contributinq Non
7. Re-roofs where the material being used to replace existing
material is architectural style
x
8. Sidewalks other than detached x
9. Exterior light fixtures x
10. Alterations to primary structure as visible from public
right-of-way (alterations and public right-of-way as defined in
chapter 2, article 17 of city code)
x
11. Alterations to accessory structures as visible from public
right-of-way lalterations and public right-of-way as defined in
chapter 2, article 17 of city code)
Gontributing Non
12. Any other site alterations not specifically listed herein as
visible from public right-of-way (alterations and public right-
of-way as defined in chapter 2, article 17 of city code)
Contributing Non
As adopted by Resolution by the Caldwell Historic Preseruation Gommission
DECISION MATRIX FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS
THE FOLLOWNG ARE TTEMS WHTCH @REQUTRE A CERTTFTCATE OF
APPROPRIATENESS OR STAFF APPROVAL:
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
'16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
Accessory structures less than 200 square feet and not visible from public right-of-way.
Doors with no change in size, location, or material and not visible from public righfof-
way.
Wrought iron fence, wood picket fence.
Garage doors and related hardware, not visible from public righ[of-way.
Hose reels.
I n-ground irrigation systems.
Maintenance and ordinary repair of exterior features.
Type and color of paint on any exterior surface, unless it's going on unpainted stucco,
unpainted brick or any other type of unpainted masonry product.
lnterior arrangement of any building or structure or any interior features, colors, or
fixtures.
Removal or installation of any landscaping, vegetative or non-vegetative ground cover,
plants, flowers, bushes, shrubs, trees, grass, sod, trees, etc. regardless of location.
Basement egress windows not located on the front elevation.
Hot tubs and swimming pools not visible from public right-of-way.
Fountains not visible from public rightof-way.
Barbecues not visible from public right-of-way.
Driveways.
Exterior fireplaces or fire pits not visible from public rightof-way.
Playground equipment, including tree houses, not visible from public right-of-way.
Detached sidewalks.
Statuary not visible from public righfof-way.
Animal enclosures not visible from public rightolway.
1
2
3
4
5
o
7
a
I
10
NOTE: Alleys are rellconsidered part of public rightof-way for purposes of this Decision Matrix
As adopted by Resolution by the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission