HomeMy WebLinkAboutCA-137-09 Richard Crowley 1724 Cleveland BlvdHISTORICAL DISTRTCT
SUMBITTED BYITEMDATE
$'\-) -c1 fi";bda Sco tp^iI
(,tcl,ud, r rro.)\r-x-
HD- 1 Application
\t Ir
LJ
ID-} Narrative
(\HD-3 Site Plan / Pictures of Site
ul \ \t7r)\\hHD-4 Posting / Public Notice
\')-.t o\HD-5 Agenda
oPl'L./v vHD-6 Sample of material
g- \Dd
M1' )\-o'lHD-8 Meeting minutes
(
C"r/
t"v
*->
J0', (
du*^l^lltJlJD,-7 Certificate of Appropriateness
c
C;$ "f CoIrhre.f'f
ll
fttr
)
tRicfrarf,Cmub owner of stte prcpat1 focate[
nt1724 Cfuhnt$htd, fias 6een a'warf,e[ a Qertificate of Appropriateness
fu tfte City of Cat$weffl{istoicafQrcssrvation Commksion in conjunction
'witft Case t\to. CA-1i9#- (g?&oqfl,
Approvetl on August P0, 2009 by tz
Eietorical Preservation
This Certi-ficat€ of Appropriat€ness will e{pire on: August 20. 8010
Chai4rerson
I
-. \I
CALDWELL HISTORIC PR-ESERVATtrON COMMISSION VIINUTES
Meeting of .dugust 24 2009 6:00 P.M
Caldwell Public Library - Idaho Roorn
L Call to Order. Chairperson Chuck Randolph called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.rn.
II. Roll Call
Members Present. Chairperson Chuck Randolph, Elaine Carpenter, Jan Boles, Gina Lujack,
Anita Shore, Eileen Davidson, Megan Dixon, Vice-Chair Lorene Oates.
Members Absent. Elaine Leppert, Steve Maughan
Others Present. Brian Billingsley, Planning & Zoning Director, April Cabello, Planning
Technician, Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison.
Others Absent. None.
IIII. Approval of Minutes. MOTION TO CONTINUE July 27,2OOg minutes
MOTION: ANitA S., SECOND: JAN B., MOTION PASSED.
fV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews. None'
V. Audience Participation. None
Actions Since Last Meeting. Chuck R. stated he signed six C of A application and gave a
brief background on the following applications.
A. CA-135-09 - l3l8 Everett - C of A was issued to DeAnna Dimond for a Home
Occupation.
B. CA-136-09 - 1313 Dearborn - C of A was issued to Boone Memorial Presbyerian
Church for Demolition.
C. CA-137 -09 - l9O2 Fillmore - C of A was issued to James Morfitt for a Re-Roof of the
lrome and garage.
D. CA-131-09 - 1414 Dearborn - C of A was issued to Donald Lay for a window resize and
replacement.
E. CA-138-09 - 1823 Cleveland - C of A was issued to Eric Thomas/Summit Account
Group for a Re-Roof.
F. CA-139-09 - 1724 Cleveland - C of A was issued to Richard Crowley for a Re-Roof.
VII. OId Business.
A. Report on the" Hat" Project. - Jan B. gave an updated report on the progress of the Hat
and stated that he would like the Commission to send a Thank You Letter. - ACTION:
Jan B. rvill draft a Thank You Ietter and will bring it to the next meeting for approval.
Brian B. to verifo account balance with Eljay.
vI.
CHPC Meetirrg August 24,2009 dn6
B. Willful Neglect Ordinance. - Brian B. stated that the City of Boise has a rvell rvritten
Willful Neglect Ordinance for their historic district. Brian suggested that the Caldwell
Historic Preservation Commission should put together a sub-committee to review the
ordinance and to update the current City of Caldwell WillfulNeglect section of the
Historic Preservation Ordinance. This sub-committee will meet on September i 6tl', 4pm
at the P & Z office. - ACTION: Commission designated Anita S., Gina L., Megan D.,
Lorene O., Eileen D., as the Willful Neglect Sub-Committee'
C. Walradt Family Photo Album/CHPC Webrit" - (continued from July 27'l' meeting)
Jan B. asked to have this item continued to the next meeting. - ACTION: The
Commission agreed to continue this item to the next meeting
D. Open meetings law - Brian B. reviewed the Open Meetings Law with the Cornmission
and Rob Hopper suggested changing the wording under section 9 from "For the Good of
the Commission" to "Commissioner Reports" to avoid any conflict with the new law. -
ACTION: April C. to change the agenda under section 9 to read "Commissioner
Reports".
E. 20i0 CLG GRANT - April C. stated that the 2010 CLG Grant Application needed to be
submitted to SFIPO. April C asked the Commission what project the commission would
like to submit. The commission decided on a Reconnaissance Level Survey of Idaho
Street and part of Ash Street. - ACTION: April C. will submit the 2010 CLG Grant
Application.
F. Zfjdq CLC Grant - April C. informed the Commission that the finished David Dorsey
2009 CLG Grant product and invoice had been submitted to SHPO. - No action was
taken by the Cornmission'
VII I\ew Business. None.
X. For the Good of the Commission. None'
XI. Adjournment. Chairman adjoumed the rneeting at approximately 6:50 p.rn.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello
MINUTES APPROVED AND SGINED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON CHUCK RANDOLPH ON
THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
l/
Chuck Randolph, ChairPerson Date
a
E.G l_l
ATTEST: Brian Billin gsley, P &Z Director
CHPC Meeting Augtrst 24,2009
Date
v
1.
\r/ AGENDA \'
Historic Preservation Commission
Monday, August 24,2009 6:00 P.M.
Caldwell Public Library - Idaho Room
l0l0 Dearborn, Caldwell, Idaho
I. Call to order
II. Roll Call
III. Approval of Minutes
. July 27,2009
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews
o None
V. Audience Participation
o None
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting
o CA-135-09 - 1318 Everett- C of A was issued to DeAnna Dimond for a Home Occupation.o CA-136-09 - 1313 Dearborn - C of A was issued to Boone Memorial Presbyterian Church for
Demolition.c CA-137-09 - 1902 Fillmore - C of A was issued to James Morfitt for a Re-Roof of the home and garage.o CA-131-09 - l4l4 Dearborn - C of A was issued to Donald Lay for a window resize and replacement.o CA-138 -09 - 1823 Cleveland - C of A was issued to Eric Thomas/Summit Account Group for a Re-Roof,o CA-139-09 - 1724 Cleveland - C of A was issued to Richard Crowley for a Re-Roof.
VII. Old Business
. Report on The Hat project - update- Jano Willful Neglect Ordinance - Brian - continued from July 27th meeting.o Walradt Family Photo Album/CHPC Website - Jan - continued from July 27th meeting.. Open meetings law - Brian - continued from July 27th meeting.o 2010 CLG GRANT - Need decision and direction from the Commission. The grant application to must
be submitted to SHPO. - Aprilo 2009 CLG Grant - Finished product and invoice has been submitted to SHPO. -April
VIII. New Business
a None
IX. For the Good of the Commission
a None
r
X. Adjournment
Next meeting will be held on Monday, September 28,2009
-\.t}.)Ao
-o
o
-seFI)a
I
tfo,
,#,,.,r
a
I rN\il.F
L,.:l;
t:lr
I
lIIf.!,'It't,I ;t'j it:.
l'
I
I
t
I
:._.
ir
\
I
fl
I'
S.n
hI
7-
t
/'4
b.)cOsht-
r/
,/
mt[ '*urilNN\'Ir
I
I
I
1 \\
f
I
&-l/r
Pr, /
K,,/
- z'/
J"Vc7.a- $Xz )l'fz,O/< t:
c7v3 273
//o y'/;r,(., n7, nff/f
Z.r/nt "*// r';.i")*-7
--+<-_-...
4; 2.- t'/r,'- lxzt(Z
CZZ Zzu,sle""/""-t /'
/ z zzV 7t u-szrt- /1*,- Z/.t.21a,y'o*-o4r;_
//to {r7,t)- 1 4o,r. /t L+-.''
7-il$
0ts/06/e00E 'r 6 : 0E 2084554050 f600 r F. 002/00I
\-- CITY OF CALDWELL
621 Cleveland BIvd., Caldwell,II) 83605
?lanning end Zoning Department (208)4513021
Ilistoric Preservation Com mission
Application tbr Certificate of App ropriateness
l.Certilicate of Appropriateness Informatiou
e understand that a Certificate of
must be issucd to mc I bc$tr work on arry of the items listed
rePatl
Nerv or rcplacemcnt awnings aod cauopies
Penestralior arrd fascia modifications, including dccorative fuim
Fencing adjaccnf to a puhlic street (wrought iron aod picket funcing are
exempltom rcquiring a Certificate of Appropriateness)- Also please
note that alieys aro NOT strccts ald thus fcncing a{acent to an alley
does not required a Ceilificate of Appropriateness
New siding wtrich i.s not a rcplacenrent of t-he original materials or
consistent'n'ith the ori ginal building profiie
WalIs
Step or riser imProvement$
Non+xempt radio towers
Tl,
below.
I am hereby applymg for issuanoe of a Ce*ificate of ApPlopriateness for one or more of the
following|te,il. (?kose ckeck all ttemsfor which you aru applying')
Any change or imptovcmcnt visible from any public right-olway (which
inctudes srreers and alleys), inciuding but not limitcd to the followhg:
Decks or Porches
Change in nrmber, size, stylc, materials or location of ury enerior doors
orwindows
Paintins of any brjck or ltrasonry surface aot prcviously painted
x
Pagc t of 6
Rrvistd 92/08Application for CcilliEato rrl Apgroprituerr'rss
\+D-I
\
08/08/200s '1 E : 09 2084553050 #603't P.000/007
\-,
Signs
Construction of any new building or stnrcture visible frorn any public right-ol'-
way (includes strcets aud alleYs)
Landscaping tbat block views of the principle building or skucture frour any
public right-of-way (includes $treets aad alleys)
Dernolitiou. removal or reloetion of aJly rusidence, building or stnircture
Change iu Use (includcs spcciai ue permits and houe occupations)
$tate requested rise or home
Change in Zone
State requested zone: -
2, APPlicant Information
Property Owner N,
Propcrtv Owner Address, City, State-\*r/
Propertry ownff Paorv. )<;T - /.'T \'TfW, '
ApplicantName
ApplicarttAddrees,City,state, Zrpt ,, fl-t t ?= W
\./
-Applicant
Site
'fax Parocl Nruaber(s
Dimcnsioffi of the Parcei
\*t +'l-l-)rLr^ .d bt/
P.rgc 2 of 6
Rwiscd 9/?/0Enpplicatioo lbr Ccrti{ir:.rrc o I Apptoptialcrtess
0a/q8/20a8 16:0e 208455305A
,r\\v v
#6031 P 004/007
fage 3 ol C
Rcviscd 9/?ltB
3
C--
A&liell!.
ln;tid6g/
Attachments
IF,e fouowins.ltems MusT-BE SUSMIIIpp-with th9 sDDlicstioh o.R THE
arriicAtron wu,t, xor rn AccBprro=
Pe,z St Ct
;sitlrfir
pleasc uotu Tho completgoes$, qualif; and details of yow artachmeats n'ill
lugely determinc the outoome of ihs dscision of the Comnission' Please
inctude every detail Possible.
A witten, bullet-point outline ofovery srngle r19ry *,at is bcing proposcd to be
changcd, added, replaced or repaired as Part ofthis request.
o [nclude riimensious
' [oclude materia]sr lncludc architectrral daails
s
ng A sitc plan of the propcrty oa I I xI? papcr ftat shows the following:
House
All
NI
AII
AlI
horv they connect u'ith thc strects and alleys
AllErrchcs.
Label ali sb'ects aod artjoitirig the propertYgCr.:uerrt photographs of tbc fol lowiug:
o AJI exterior sidcs of the house. All drive*aysr All outbuildittgs. AII garages, sheds, carports, etc.. All iaadscaping. AII porchcs, patios, etc-
y S *--.p
Mrst include
calports, etc
allI
a
a
a
a
Must include aI[ materials proposed
show J.ettering, symbols, pictures ud any type of lighling for sigl:age
rcquest3
Nfust show cvcrything relating to the proposed changes
Must be clear and legibte and readable
App!icotion for Cl+rtill'cirle of Apnropriatcncss
t
o
t
a
a
I
a
08/08/?00s rE:'r0 2084553050 #603'l P.005/00?
*,., a rron--, EM *LI T ioN o R
RELOCATION OF A BUILDING, iN ADDITION '1'O TI{E ABOVE ITEMS,
PLEASE ATTACH THE F.OLLOWB,IG:
cnPY ofall pages crfthe reoorded deed for the rnay be obtaineci tioln
floor of &e CountYthe Canyon Coi.rnry Recorder' s 0fftcc on the
if yor-t dor.'t have a your files)
List 300 feet ofthe site with names, addresses and ID
numbers (o the Canyon County Plat Room on tle 3d floor of the
County
redrrced copy of thc plat map for tho ontirc sectiou, township arrd
be obtained from thc Canyon County
9.il\V 4,
range in whjch the proPertY resid
Plat Room on the 3'o floor of the Counry Cor.uthousc)
Acknowledgemeut of Section AZ-fi-Ot through 02-77'33 of Caldu'ell City
Code
By initialing each of tha iteurs below, I acknowledge that I have read the statement and
understand that said state,ment is a portion of Sectiort 02-I7'0I ttuough 02-17-33:
AppliGrnt
lnitisb
T historical aad architectural value that conuiburc to the cultural and economic rvelfare of
L /' its oitizsrs. lt is imporAnt that an awareness of this heritage be developed and lhat ar:
cffort to Frresffvc ttresc cnvironmcntal assets is perpcffated by the dul;; appointed
CALDWELL HiSTORIC PRBSERVATION CO\d}'f]SSION.
purposes of the Comrnission are: to encourage harmony in ttre planning of new'
n buildings arrd devoiopments n'ith existing historicbuildings irr the proximity; to
( " -- or.ur*i and enhence the eavironmsfltal quality of neighborhoods;to promote thev/ gcation of historic districts; to streogtben the City's economic hase hy the stimuiation
of consewation and reuso; etrgage in a program of Historic Preservation lo encotrage
protection and prescn'ation of historic buildings and sites.
Defrnition of Exterior Features: Sball iuclude the architectural style, gvrrerai design aod
n general anarrgcment of tire extcrior of abuilding or other structrlre, the kind and texture
( -
IltUr Uuila;ng -a typc ar:d stylo of windows. doors. Iieht fixturcs, sigps and other\--' appurtennnr d,at r""*a natural ftatures srrch as treos and shrubbcries- In thc case of
outdoor advertising sigrrs, "exterior features" shall bc coostrued to mean the stylc,
rnateria), size and location of such signs'
Definiliorr of Historic District; any residential neighbttrhood or buqiness seciion
; detennined by CiU Courrcil to eocompass sites, buildings Qr structures ol'historical'
(> culturai or architectural v,rlue worth;,or record,ing on the localregister of histcric
propeily'
Alplicaf ian for CcnifiHto of Appropriuttncs:, *r.ii.?fd;f
a
0E/08/2008 IS: j0 2084553050 #6001 P.008/00?
9*
U
nv
O
u
&
U
Definition of llistoric Property: any buiiding, struotu'c, area. or sitc determinod lty the
City Couneil to be :iignificant in the history, architecture, arctraeology or culture within
the City of Caldwell.
A-ftcr the designation by ordinance of a local historic tropery* or locai historic district,
no exterior feature crf any building or other stnrcture ufiich is a part of such a property
or disuict shall be alured or restorcd oor shalJ it be moved or demolished r:atil aftcr
applicatiou for a Certjficate of Appropriateness is subraitted to and approved by the
Calaweil Historic Prceewation Commission. Restrictions also apply to apPutenant
featurcs of the building such as abovegrormd utility sEuchres, outdoor advertising
signs, walls-
A Certificate of Appropriatcacss shall be required regardless of any other Pcrmit,
including a building paroit that is requircd by the City.
In ordsr to prcscrve fhe integrity of historic buildings, stuctures and sites within a
designatcdiocal historic distic! a.ad to enstrrc that any lew buildings, improvernentg or
structues consfirctd within a designated local historic district shall bc compatible
within such disrict, no e)$eriot portion or featr:re of any building, site, stuchre or
objcct within the district shall be demolishsd, restored or alrcred; no new constructiou
s6all be undertaken; and, no site improvcment made without first obtaining a Certiticate
of Appropriatcncss.
For improverneflt of changes that require a building permit,lhe Certifrcatc of
Appropriateness must be graured prior to the Plaruring and Zo"in8 Deparhnent
approving au applioation for a building permit.
For improvemcnts or changes that do not require a burlding Plrmit, a Certificate of
appropriateness must be graated prior to constructiotr of thc improvcnent or chaage.
I, as the applioant, arn solely responsible for submitting A COMPLETE
APPLICATION AT LEA$T FOURTEEN (14) DAYS BEFORE THE N$(T
MEETING OE THE CA.LDWELI., HISTORTC PRESERVATION
COMIV'ISSION.
6- t?""?
s siguatuc-+
)€Ut D,rQtz-t-1
Dtrte
€-.' 'a{
Date
on bchalf oftho aPPlicant
l)ege 5 of 6
Itevised 9/ili)$53pz-{
c77-72ff
0E/06/200S 18:11 2084553050 #8041 P 007i00i
(}LOSSARY OF TERM$
Au 6sFg ccftcot.watci: 6 i
rixtrrrc of l$rtliod c.lnerttt ,td (cr fibtr) ffiI wTrrr(inrx cruSld gooc for wrturol &is la'm
.[!l oru of tI I
rrEH rlof ht g,3nrrii8 bst}06o twc loed booinij ra[r,dsD{fllly, tsrslcs ,T. !5sl
tqwE :g r corntr of a :!(?ig,
ll[r to th! stfiOr ,uprotlgd by o6lutns,(r pr)tli;
ellrd piaa in rarta lrtcrtril A Dletod i$rn ir p+rol{ r)t&q3lr irx mminf, urully it
Pagp 6 oL 6
Re.;iscd 9/2/08
r!6.Dt1auy
lbnslr,Oil{
arrl
I bui'ldirrg or *rcchrft; lis otcn rsrcs tlw fq,rtion of <rbusrrin8 Ihe joinr *'orrrrrd whBn ts!
tl!crvcs ln (h0nl
ol DIITCS0E top 0tl oo
I
a podt tlrol slppaB 3
or i, th€
e r.l
srkce$aoftol rDolI 16 ftE oo s sld0. A t8y u4tt&w ls a PrqjccdoS wiDlhw wltl at atgulat
a a aarlDtrimafilEiy
Frrlhcy
double hug
ue oflo d€rerib{at !o tlE DumbrG€IGI O'Dry br 0l!uPport
o!.'vcfl;CAl Aoparc 0[s.3!TqgJCI
A i!r!$0.d€ lsuiliy tn op€nOE ODC tEn dle8tr
l0il trcalcd toOlprctEtrgparlg
!Itly qx!'cllttlcg sroP.F Iu OI0r
raoi Ilrr t?coltc n.eDc of8 doruff i5 llcqucntly daeflliDcd by tbc
t
shap ot tyr ol
+rOE
ilg e a0te
imludc rsy typt of futblt
t€rrD ohdding i.l ofiao usod
usdd fo
ir*lu&g unoruy.
v0r)d,tg'ID
cgrtnnFl
to
(*itb tlrcOvtrirg On
lo d{reihE
r tsaoc bsildior
afiy catoor mUi0
,l !a
tOT
uail .a c aIhG llE lgwer es8 !lll. AtD
e lstici tt fi AJri)onuJDaGlIt tut Er ml ts
criyinS ofwslor
EVal
@ drtl usod for wntihtin3, rni* o
otircf sDasGg.
I
Applir;ation for Ccrtifi catc of Appropriateness
0s/06/200s l6:09 2084553050 *80 3 r P.00r/o0l
621 Clcttllard Blvd.
cddFll, lD CtE06
City
4ffi0s0lar
ftr lQvin Frtm, Aprll Csbello
F.,o 454# lls PrgE: 7
PlEru Drt r 86lo9
Rtr C€lt of AEptt9llaton€88 Applidtion c(t
tr UErrr E Pcr irvtrw il Plqr Gornrnmr tr Florl r+ly tr PlE r'Gydc
a Commrrttr
Hi Kevtr,
Attach.d ts tltte Goillflctt of Appropdgtrnoss applkdo,| tratwill
nacd to ba comPletoly lllbd out. Pbare mak' lutt ell ltonrs on
pagr 3 ilc rubmltt d wlth tfir appllcatlon tloilg wilh a sample of
tte roofing materlel trat b to be utrd.
Gall mo wlth any qucltlonr rcOafittng tlrG applicatlot All mu't bo
conrplGtc lor thc .ppllcatlon to bo tubdrlttod and rccoPtr'
Thanks, Apri! .
Planning & Zoning
Department