HomeMy WebLinkAboutCA-39-05 Kirk Anderson 1622 Everett St\#
HISTORICAL DISTRICT
ITEM DATE SUBMITTED BY
HD - I Application Ut}l0s Kirk Anderson
HD -2 Narrative yt0l05 Kirk Anderson
HD - 3 Pictures of Site Ut0los Kirk Anderson
HD-4 SitePlan U10105 Kirk Anderson
HD - 5 Post Site Notice Ut0t0s Kirk Anderson
HD - 6 Agenda Ut2l0s Staff: Jacqueline Hemandez
HD - 7 Public Hearing Comment sheets t lnlor Staff: Jacqueline Hernandez
HD - 8 Certificate of Appropriateness I /rr /os Chqir ?crr.'€leine CarP-#t
HD-9 MeetingMinutes
lfnloE Qhqirpqso n A bin< C*P''nl*
m.
Iv.
Historic Preservation Committee
Minutes
January 19,2005
Caldwell City Hall
I. Call to Order Elaine Carpenter, Acting Chairman called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM
il. Roll Cal| Members present: Elaine Carpenter Acting Chairman, Jan Boles, Betty Jo Keller,
Chuck Randolph, Tom Ensley, Anita Shore, Lorene Oates, City Liaison Rick Wells, and City Staff
member Wendy Kirkpatrick. Members Absent: Steve Maughan, Joey Masar, Elaine Leppert, City
Staff Jacqueline Hernandez.
Approval of Agenda. . Motion/ Anita Shore Second Betty Jo Keller. Accept the
Agenda.
Approval of Minutes
NEW BUSINESS
1. Certificate of Appropriateness Interuiew (CA -37-05):
(David Kirk Anderson - l622Bverett)
David Kirk Anderson presented the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the Installation
French doors replacing a window and opening onto a twelve foot redwood deck. There would be an
arbor visible from the street.
Tom Ensley suggested that the rails on the deck should tie in with the design of the house.
MOTION Chuck Randolph/ Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness with the stipulation that the
railing tie in with the design of the house. Second/ Anita Shore. Motion passed
2. Certificate of Appropriateness Interview (CA -38-05):
(David Kirk Anderson - l622Bverett)
David Kirk Anderson presented the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the Installation of
a window either side of the existing fireplace. There were windows in this spot at one time. This
would restore the house to it's originat appearance. Trim would be as the trim on the rest of the
house.
MOTION Tom Ensley/. Approved the Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of the
windows. Second Chuck Randolph. Motion passed.
3. Certificate of Appropriateness Interview (CA-39-05)
@avid Kirk Anderson - 1622Evetett)
David Kirk Anderson presented the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the removal of
cinder rocks and the installation of lawn and trees.
Hp- ?
\F.
Recommended he discuss trees with the City Forester.
MOTION Chuck Randolph /. Approved the Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of the
windows. Second. Betty Jo K Betty Jo Keller. Motion passed'
OLD BUSINESS
I Elaine asked Chuck Randolph and Elaine Leppert to work on a map to recognize Historic Sites as
they relate to the City Compiehensive plan. Lorene Oates volunteered to help on this.
Elaine Carpenter reported that SHPO has informed us that the Arlington District did not have
enough contributingio,rr. to establish a historic district We could put some of them on the National
Regis-ter or form i Conservation district. They, also, felt that the downtown area did not have
eno.rgh to form a district. It was determined to roll this into the next meeting. Commissioners were
asked'to review the Conservation District handout before the next meeting.
We need to form a planning Committee to form plans to commemorate the Steunenberg Event. Jan
Boles said that it was his op-inion that Bill crookham, a descendent of Governor Steunenberg, did not
want a celebration of his assassination. The Albertson College of Idaho would like to plan a
historical symposium. Lorene Oates idea of 100 Days of History could tie events in Caldwell at that
time into what was going on nationally at the time. Chuck Randolph and Tom Ensley explained that
at the past Indian Clekiestival, they had had a conversation with Bill Crookham and felt he would
like to see us have a video show presentation at the next lndian Creek Festival, honoring the
Steunenberg & Crookham Families and other people whom Bill has recorded with their memories of
Caldwell and the surrounding areas. We needlo iponsor something at this event and put together a
time line, ask Bill Crookham to do the video *d *. put together both, also ask the City to make
some kind of marker at the site of the assassination. Jan Boles will push ahead to do this.
Elaine Carpenter reported that Mr Cortland Walker, owner of the proposed Plymouth Subdivision
called a couple of weeks ago. He would really like to sell the property. He would move the
buitdings. He wants $150,000.00 for this property'
Mr & Mrs Michael Frank of l7l2 Dearborn were here to address the installation of the metal roof
on their home. They purchased this property eight or nine years ago. The roof was in poor
condition He reportei he had u.onlo.rrution with ro*.or. at City Hall about installing a metal roof
and they had no problem with this. This past fall the roof started leaking. He again spoke to
,o,,.on. at city Hall. They, again did not have a problem with the metal roof' There was no
Building permii issued. tvir riant< pointed out there were several homes in the District with
metal roofs.
Elaine Carpenter explained our situation on this. It goes against the guidelines set for the District and
the ordinance under which we serve. We cannot overlook this. The other homes in the District
which have metal roofs were done before the forming of the District'
2.
J
4.
5
City "f olchreII
I ;j'
I
4
I
Gu rttficote "f ffilf roJpriatene.tat
Kirk Anderson owners, of site property located
at 1622 Everett Street have been awarded a Certificate of Appropriateness
by the City of Caldwe!! Historical Preservation Commission in conjunction
with Case No. CA-39-05 (Landscapinq).
\\2oo( by 3,t",;Approved on
HISTORICAL P COMMISSIONER CHAIR PERSON
Ioa
CB
PUBLIC HEARING COMMENT SHEET
(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
Opposed/
wish to speak_
do not wish to speak_
NAME:
STREET ADDRESS:
CITY/STATEZIP:
ln favor/.
wish to speak_
. do not wish to speak_
a
6.!-
NAME OF CASE BEING HEARD:o.L D
Mffi
Check the appropriate line:
Applicant or Representative-(Neutral/
wish to speak_
do not wish to speak_
tln
Written comments may be attached to this form or you may write them in below.
FID.7
T+
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
VI
,,*O*" PRESERVATION COMMISSION
January 19, 2005 - 6:00 p.m.
Caldwell City Hall
621 Cleveland Blvd
AGENDA
Call to Order
Roll Call
Approval of Agenda
Approval of Minutes
. December 8, 2004
Old Business
1. Historic Sites as they relate to Comp Plan / Next Step by HPC
2. Arlington District
3. Steunenberg Event: Volunteers for a Committee to Plan
4. Plymouth Subdivision Update
5. Michael Frank Metal Roof Resolution
6. Friends of the Depot - Betty Jo
7. CLG Grant Amount
8. Meeting with Diane Kushlan on Text Amendments - Jan and Elaine
New Business
1 . Certificate of Appropriateness lnterview (CA-37-05):
(David Kirk Anderson - '1622 Everett) - lnstalling a Deck with connecting
French doors and side lighting
2. Certificate of Appropriateness lnterview (CA-38-05):
(David Kirk Anderson - 1622 Everett) - Window replacement
3. Certificate of Appropriateness lnterview (CA-39-05):
(David Kirk Anderson - 1622 Everett) - Landscaping
4. Preservation ldaho Meeting in Caldwell May 13 & 14, 2005
5. ldaho Magazine - Lorene
6. Election of Officers for 2005 (Chair, Vice Chair and Secretary)
Adjournmentvil.
t-\D-u
t.
il.
ilt.
tv.
E{istorir-Pres ervation C ommis sio q
Caldwell Depot Facing SeventhAve' (1906)
621 CLEVEIAND BLVD.
CALDWELL, IDAHO 83605
TEL (208) 45s'3A21
fa( 455-3003
NOTIG
lS HEREBY GIVEN that the Caldwell Historical Preservation Commission will conduct a
meeting at the Caldwell City Hall located a|621 Cleveland Blvd. - Caldwell, ldaho on
Wednelday, January 19, 2OO5 at 6:00 p.m., in order to hear the following request:
To hear concurrently Case Nos. CA-37-05, CA-38-05 and CA-39-05 requests by David
Kirk Anderson for Ceftificates of Appropriateness applications. The residence at 1622
Everett Street, is located within the Steunenberg Residential Historic District.
you are being notified in accordance with ldaho Statutes, Title 67 Chapter 46, which
states that the Historic Preservation Commission shalltake action as may reasonably be
required to inform the owners of any property likely to be materially affected by a
Certificate of Appropriateness application, and shall give the applicant and such owners
an opportunity'io be heard. borrespondence regarding the propos-al is to be
submitted to the Community Developmen_t Department no later than five (5)
working days prior to the meeting and will be made a part of the public record
during the meeting. '
Case files and exhibits relative to this request are on file at the Caldwell Community
Development Department and are available for retiew during the hours of 8:00 a.m. to
5:00 p.m. Monday through Friday. Further information can be obtained by calling 455-
3021'. A person wnp is visually and/or hearing impaired, or needs an interpreter should
contact City Hall if they. have any special needs.
HD-<
T
aIt/
,-r);sAt.I t J1( ,.- .- '
?a"ytt,
T,,Ufdy e(
.4 ,, rt, !l _ rO, ,!. & .a. -.. I (.- u.
.I
I
)
W.
)
GIL
a
:
4'.
t*1
rJ
Tf
r-1
I,l1
r:l
t-:
Jb
F\:
UJ
i:J
c
.€-
o
Fr.,
f t, |"1
r_ t-^_
\7*
oJ
R
e
g
s*Pa
.Nt
&
$\-*
ilP
. K0.'U JJd:3x
ffi
o
aa
.t{t
A.
I'(rj\./'-
t
.f
fil* dev- l-1 a{
e
fus- * 11*€ ttrrrvw Fr,,
HD-3
----- -'
.-.;fgr,\- -',-
-r#fi1
.n,,lGl
,i'
t.,\
-i
.
**,''ij
-*g[it l
i
l
:':=.-;=5-.-..<
I
h"{. are oF tWrE- W drnrOaPez
To a,W,o{ freq,W
Wei $w'VW fravkl W-*WY,
(-'l
i,..
5J
,,
I
I
n '..
I
i'l
I
\-/
2o.tV,-qDa uetL -G\e4a6
s".ltJde;r fuvtL lTtt
\,
\'
\
i t-rl
-I
.-_.L
)
r
S-l-an
4er^l (gt l1*.r -sfrlf.,tl ttvWfrfiaY)
axr,w tuuvw# (aaqfi*'
\
li-E -i
a
,7
.t\
'': .,-
I
I
l!!It
!ti
..4*.ffi-:-'*-;A#;F *,EHM
J';* "
I
I would like to propose changes to my home in the historical district. This is
my primary residence. I like my home and desire the following
improvements. I would like to add french doors and adjoining side lights to
my dining room. These doors constructed of wood french panes on the
inside and forest green aluminum on the outside will lead to a 12 x 21 foot
deck. To the side of the french doors will be two side lights of the same
height that will have screens window openings. As far as the deck, it will be
constructed of redwood built to code by Glen Day construction.
Originally there were two windows to the side of the fireplace in my living
room. I would like to replace these windows. They will measure, glass size,
18 x2l inches. On the inside of these thermo panes will be flush mounted
leaded glass of a design yet to be created.
The last change would be the removal of the lava rock on the city right of
way. In its place I would like to replace and landscape with trees and grass
The trees have not been determined-I am open for sugestions that will
reinstate a desired historical look.
&r,r-/\-
llD'z
CA- 31- o{
City of Caldwell
His tolic Pres eroation Co m mis Jio n
Certificate of Appropriateness Applica ,JAN lo 2aa
I, the undersigned do herebY aPPIY for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the
affect the Steunenberg Residential Historic District's historical, architectural,or scenlc
atfiibutes.
I have been furnished, and have reviewed, the Stepby-Step guide for
Certilicate of APProPriateness.
please be thorough in completing the checklist. The decision of the Caldwell Historic Preservation
Commission will be based on the completed checklist. Any anticipated or unidentified changes not
shown on the list will need to be discussed with staff and possibly returned to the Commission for
approval. Work completed without the Commission's approval is in violation of the Municipal code and
suii"ct to reversal. ih" Co*.unity Development staff is available to answer questions or assist with
putting together an application. You may contact them at 455-3021'
I
overview 6tu-+f atD4OaSo?S
The Caldwell Historic preservation Commission reviews land use activities that may affect the
Steunenberg Residential Historic Dishict's historical, architectural, ecological or scenic attributes.
The Caldwell Historic preservation Commission has prepared a checklist to assist you in applying for the
Certificate of Appropriateness. If you need a COA, please fill out the checklist. The checklist is not a
substitute for other materials required by the Commission Required materials include:
{'A written narrative describing the reason for ttre alteration and fully describing the
treatment of each item you have ihecked on the list. Removal of existing material is also
subject to Commission ieview. If you can document to the satisfaction of Commission staff
thai changes will be in-kind using like materials, then no further review shall be necessary.
Vfr, d"t^il"d site plan notating all structures, landscaping, and driveway locations accessing
the property. Site plan should be I 1 x 17 in sizn''
( A drawng, sketch or other graphic representation annotated with dimensions, materials
and, where aipropriate, letterin[ and lighting of the proposed change(s). Graphic material
should be l tii7 in size and readable when copied in black and white.
ffi1xterior photographs are required in every case to document existing conditions or to
determine the location of the alteration on the building or site. Corner lots must include
photos from each street.
Information Auzg*ea{Ftur> hrro-Owner
Address
Phone Number
Name
Address
Phone Number
Site Address
Tax Parcel Number(q)
Dimensions or acreage of the property
t{D-\
llo% F-,+qA,lh @hNfuEL A leclfriltlnb h*nL AttL I
ot,Ittfx I
Comptcted application and cheJHist must be rcceiued by Cownunity -Deuefiment, at kas:!:rteen
(14) tlays before ttr" ,"srrl,ly t"i"iiii Cidwell Ilisoric PreservatiDn Commission meetiag'
Check the items that best describe your intended actions'
Vdteriot Alteration
dteriot Altetatiorr (which afec* exterior)
E Ecological or Scenic Attributes
(trees or landscaPing)
D Olhet (Please exPlain)
ROOFS
D configuration
E materials
I eaves
E ehimneYs
E other
WINDOWS,
tsdim.nsions
d^terials
D frames, decorative details
E muntins, mullions
DOORWAYS
D dimensions
E materials
E frames, decorative details
w{oou
g'Kdlditioo o, N.* construction
E Demolition
t PukrngLot (additton or alterations)
E Relocation of a Structure
E parapet walls
E cresting curbing or railings
D slcylights, ventilators, etc.
D drainage system, gutters, downspouts
D glazing
O awnings, canoPY
O shutters
B other
D awnings, canoPY
t glazng
D hardware
Checklist of Exterior Changes
All exterior changes, including additions, should be described in materials accompanying this form and/or
nresented at rhe public hearing. If ;;;;;,t.tp*d exterior changes that are not shown in the current
piopo.ul, pt."t.'include them on this checklist'
Are there any proposed changes to or additions of:
2
E other
D other
PORCHES and/or BALCONIES
E configuration
E materials
D framing
EXTERIOR STAIRS
D configurations
E risers
*(eaas
LANDSCA?E FEATIJRES
D Paving materials
E retaining walls
D walkwaYs, sidewalks' terraces
D other
SIGNS
O location
E dimension
O material
DEMOLITION
O home
E outbuilding
n"tr,* -(> ,liltr*l hU@E CF BJL
D surface cleaning
D mortar johts
O flooring
D railings, balusters
od** E'X 2.t' ft(PtDooo g€tJL
D materials
E raililgs, balusters, newels
B rightof-waY
D fences, Pergolas
B fees, landscaPing
D lighting
D method of attachment
D other
D garage
E other
3
EXTERIORWALLS
D materials
D architectural details
E other
PARKING LOT (OFF.SITE)
O pavmg D paving materials
E parking, watkwaYs, sidewalks
Does your Pending Project require a Federal or State license' permit or approvzl? (Circle one)Y orN
SPECIAL USE PERMIT
B PurPose:
HOMEOCCUPATION
E PurPose:
OTHER LAND.USE APPLICATION
E Type:
Aooeal Procedure:
ffi :l'J:?'"T,',"11Hy#:til:$tffi '"Hli#l#"ff *H":;]ff ::"#"iilt:Hil"''n'
'&ffi,iffi;;;r'opi*t b"p"**iio"o"a in the caldwell citv Hall'
4
Date
Applicant Signaturc
Date Receivcd
Approved
osDate
l4r^-SignatucCHPCChairperson
Ollicc Use Oa
t
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
ttilu"a -o *torrcs Pointed structural mcmber to span an opning'
X'rl!L"0,'o.jr"o", ,latform found abovc ground level on a building'
Baluster lPrights that support a hsndrail or coping'
Onc of a serics of short Pilla$ or other I
Balustrad€ ,-- by coping or a handrail and somctimEs on thc bonom by a button rail; usod oo stailcase$
A series of balustcrs connccted on toP
porshes, etc.'I""{r."
,oi.,rdi"g fi.om thc cxte or ,,a, $at may contain a window; a compartment of about 15 fcet on a side' A bay window
ir i ffiJ"rg ;,'a"w with an ansular Plan'
3fr""jit *o*" tembcrs found undcr eaves or other ovcrhangs; mav be Plah or dccora&d'
Caiement '-..- fixed on is vertical cdge' A casement window contains two casrments separatcd by a
A wiodow sash tbal oPcns on hmges
multion (vertical dividing bar)'
flirr#:."r, :,l,#a-"rl* ", *r* *u * rhicker on oDe edgr than thc othe4 thc bonom (thick) edge of onc board ovcrlaps
ttre toiithinl cagc ofthe board bclow'
iio'ii,,'Xil"r.r,r'*lar h ptar Thc Pafis of a oblumr in classical srchi'ctral a," thc basc' shaft and capitar
:;:[" *" P*i'ltv or otallv sunoundcd bv walls or buildings'
?o.1T,".1, *inao* ,.jecting tom thc stopc of a roof; usually providcd with is own roof' Tbc specifc name of a dormer is
il;l':;; ;#ffiiv tt'"-'t'ap' or tvpc or is roor'
oouble hung window
reabte by means ofsash cords ald weighs'
A window with t$'o sashcs' each mol
?ij"**"" "r*" ,*f which Projc{'ts bcyond the talls Eavcs that are without gutters are often rcfened o as dripping eavcs'
Facadeiifiii.ipor r"." ot &ont clcvadon ofa building'
Gable 'l in a building with a ridged roof'
The riangular cnd of an cxtenor uar
c"ut" roor ' -ts al one or both eDds in a gable' Also known as pitchcd roof' ridgc roofor comb roof'
A sloping (ridgcd) roof that lermnat
Gutter
A channcl ofwood or metal runnng along thc eaves ofa housc; used for catchhg and c8rryilg of water'
fl"tl"*.u o, ,"* pitcherl morsurfaccs'
Louver tcn with wood stats' uscd for vcntilating attics or othcr spaccs'
A small lantem or otier oP€nln& on
Masonry -'-- stonc, brick, concretc block$ tiles or sirnitar materials'
Work constructed bY a mason uslllg
#IT;t -"*:tr$#?,r.ffiTffi'JsiJ'ff"xH:'TJr'or
aDd exterior or a buding or stu*ure; arso
Mullion ood' betwceD fic lights of a window
A verticrl membcr, &s ofstonc or u
Ilii"ti",o,,, *t cdgcs of windows or panes \f,ithin tt,c sssh'
Newel *Er rhal cuoDorts a hardrail ar th8 botlom or ar thc landing of a staircase'
A vcnicsl suppolt ar ths centcr ot a circular $aircase; a Post $ar suPports a
lft.i"{rr-+}****"':*# 'Tr'"iTi,.Tt"H3li:
llt;'rli1". *r, ", tlcvadon' as of earth or srone' in a fortification'
tr#i'fer-. A structure usually consisting of parallel colonnadcs supporting an opcn roof of girders & cross raftsn'
5
Pilaster ' - -'acYed o a wail; frequently decoratively tcatcd to rcprlrit a classic column'
A rcctangular coturm or shallow Pler a!
Porch
A covered cntance or scmi.elcroseo spac,c pmjcaing from the fagade of a building may be opcn-sidcd scrcened or glass
"n"tos"a. e srAt po,ch may be callcd a stoop'
Porticoitrli"a *urt o, porch supponed by columns or pillars'
Sash
ihe fiamcwork into which Paues arc set'
in:l#:rlr** ,
"ne
inctined.p)anc. Unlikc a teaD-to roo{, a shcd roof need not be canicd by a higber walt (i c" it mav sewe
as the primary roof form for a bulldmg'
il'm#,mitx,;1lxl+liffig.,;t*'r":,.gn*:m;""1'i:"*:1*T*"'"=ff
*.:lB
s - .. lowcl sidc of 8n opening such as a door silt. A window sill forms thc lower' uzually
Tt. frrmin! mcmbcr that fo s thc
#G;;;'fii;;t"' "utidc
facc of awiDdow'
:Xt3r1t;H,t*". -itlr a lathq userl as gablc or porch tsim' Alo known as tumcd wood omaments'
'iloiiln",
*r, .,,,,,r:-"::*:,"1i#'ffiSgmffi;HTi*Tf"l;fi1;'-1f[ffiimld
ccmenl sard
hair (or fibcr) and sometimcs crushco
I'lii, ,, ",**,r, 1LTil1:"5j,j,#J"ffi:fif#"#-:f,ffi#",TffiTS'J#-frfi-8ffi'1"?;
spanniDg bctwccn two load bcanng v
Get
Turret r; often located ar a comer of a building in which case' it is oflEn refcrred to as a comEr
A small and somcwhat slcnder towe
turrctveranda :rior wal or a housc '''d *PryITy,ff.ffi:l1#t"if#;#';l"tJffiffI'*
A oofcd spac'e nP"h:q t?.9:Xlrl
"rli.i,d
-;;.".t g ,iuary i' *
literature. A ctosrly rclEt'd tcIm ls p
6