HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-02-05 CHPC MinutesAr�Y
VED
Date o2fl
CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
Monday, February 5, 2024, 6:00 p.m.
Caldwell Planning & Zoning Department, Conference Room, 621 Cleveland Boulevard, Caldwell, Idaho
ROLL CALL:
Commissioner Lyons welcomed those in attendance and called the meeting to order.
Present: Rand) Lyons, Julie Best, John Nothdurft, Geoff Williams, Nicole Bradshaw
Absent: None
Staff Present: April Cabello, Planner I and Morgan Bessaw, Deputy Director
Others Present- None_
Commissioner Lyons provided a review of the proceedings.
April Cabello asked to move an action item under New Business to the beginning of the agenda to vote
Chair and Vice Chair for 2024,
(ACTION ITEM: VOTE FOR CHPC CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR FOR 2024)
Chairman Lyons asked if we had any nominations for Chair. If there are none, he said he would like to
continue as Chair of the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission.
Commissioner Best nominated Randy Lyons as Chair for 2024. Seconded by Commissioner John
Nothdurft. MOTION PASSED
Chairman Lyons asked that since Commissioner Bradshaw was absent and could not state if she wanted
to continue as CHPC Vice Chair, could a vote made now would be appropriate and discussion could be
held at a later meeting. The commission agreed.
Chairman Lyons nominated Commissioner Bradshaw as CHPC Vice Chair for 2024. Seconded by
Commissioner Best. MOTION PASSED
CONSENT CALENDAR: (ALL CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS ARE ACTION ITEMS)
(ACTION ITEM: APPROVE MINUTES — December I8, 2023)
Commissioner Best moved to accept the December 18, 2023, minutes. Seconded by Commissioner
Nothdurft. MOTION PASSED
(ACTION ITEM: APPROVE MINUTES —January 8, 2024)
Commissioner Best moved to accept the January 8, 2024, minutes. Seconded by Commissioner
Nothdurft. MOTION PASSED
Page I 1
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 02-05-2024
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS INTERVIEWS. None.
OLD BUSINESS:
(ACTION ITEM: RECRUITING NEW COMMISSION MEMBERS)
Chairman Lyons shared that seeking new commission members has been very successful.
Morgan Bessaw shared that Meghann O'Berry who was recommended at the last meeting, met with the
mayor and will be at the next council meeting to consider the appointment to CHPC. She has a different
perspective of focus on preserving the environment, such as the historic trees in the area.
(ACTION ITEM: COMMISSION TO COORDINATE A STEUNENBERG RESIDENTIAL
HISTORIC WALKING TOUR)
Commissioner Best relayed she has the recording equipment that works with and two people should be
with Chuck during the recordings, one to guide the discussion and one to manage the equipment and
recordings.
Commissioner Best shared that she worked on the flyer. The flyer is currently one page, and it has more
room for extra content.
Chairman Lyons welcomed Commissioner Bradshaw, who arrived at the meeting late, and he shared
with her that they voted her as CHPC Vice Chair far the year.
Commissioner Bradshaw agreed.
Commissioner Bradshaw asked if anyone has talked to C of I to see if there were any marketing students
who would like to be involved in editing and helping with social media content.
Commissioner Best stated that we would also want to ensure closed captioning be added for
accessibility.
(ACTION ITEM: COMMISSION TO WORK ON NEW FLYERS 1 MAILINGS TO THE
STEUNENBERG RESIDENTIAL HISTORIC DISTRICT RESIDENTS.)
Chairman Lyons stated he talked to several people in the community who moved in the last couple of
years. None of these folks were aware that they moved into a historic district.
April Cabello shared that a letter could be created and be sent out as mailings have been sent by the
commission in the past. She could get a list from mapping.
Commissioner Best suggested they could include a walking tour flyer.
Commissioner Bradshaw suggested adding a QR code.
(ACTION ITEM: POSSIBLE DONATION FROM U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS —
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT FOR CULTURAL RESOURCES MITIGATION
THROUGH SECTION 106 FORA PROPERTYAT 3904 S INDIANAAVENUE THAT IS BEING
AFFECTED BY DEVELOPMENT ON THE ADJACENT PARCEL 3919 THATCHER LANE)
April Cabello shared that the next grant cycle is November of 2024 so we should have an idea of what
we want to submit for the grant for the CLG. The commission should think about what really should be
Page 12
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 02-05-2024
done with funds. Another item to think about is the garages in the district. They weren't part of the
survey when the district was brought in. Having someone survey garages in the district to identify the
ones that are truly national register type material or is it just part of the district and it is acceptable to be
demolished or replaced.
Commissioner Nothdurft stated he can help gather the information. Rather than only focusing on
garages, we could use a full assessment of the city in the historic district. He mentioned he isn't sure if
$1 Ok from SHPO would be enough to cover garages. He said when a grant application is written up, we
need to have detailed cost associated with what we want to do. As commissioners, do we go out or do
we get bids?
April Cabello shared that SHPO previously gave a list of contractors that can bid. The minimum is three
that must be sent out to get the RFP. From there the commission brings one in and votes.
Commissioner Best stated that the commission should have goals specific to historic preservation and
objectives associated with the CHPC — regarding garage surveys or signage or all of the things we would
want to accomplish.
Comm issioner Bradshaw asked if that is pact of the comprehensive plan of the city.
Morgan Bessaw replied not necessarily that there is a historic component giving some of the history and
character of the area, but it is light. This would be a plan specifically saying what the CHPC goals for
each of the coming years and activities you would do. Significantly more specific, kind of like a work
plan with projects that could be tackled one bit at a time.
Chairman Williams asked if our comprehensive plan has the historic areas noted and recognized so that
even in our commission planning, we are not going to be approving modern apartment buildings in
those districts.
Morgan Bessaw shared that the consultants working on the comp plan will be lookAng at transportation,
parks, airport, downtown master plans. They will look at the historic preservation plan if we have one.
We have three different things we are talking about: the comp plan, the historic preservation plan and
the code. The code talks about the historic district overlay and the requirements and design review. The
historic preservation plan would be very much your attention as a commission for priority places for
preservation or activities we want to undertake. We have money right now, and if we have a plan in the
fiiture, we could put it towards this as we have already identified. The comp plan will have a vision for
the historic district to protect the character, but not specifics as to how.
Commissioner Bradshaw stated just to further the conversation about the historic preservation plan,
she recalls it being bigger than just the Steunenberg district. This is the vision of what we would want
for the historic preservation of all of Caldwell as a whole,
Morgan Bessaw stated it would likely depend on what we put in our RFP or RFQ. If we were limiting
it just to the district, or wanted it to be city wide, we will need to identify that. Have a task of things
like expansion, moving the district boundaries. It will depend on what is listed in the grant as to what
we want. We can have discussions as there are other areas around town that could benefit.
Chairman Lyons mentioned signage for the district in downtown that have been taken off buildings on
the wall facing the plaza. To get those back on the buildings would be great for visiting people to show
why those buildings are important.
Page 13
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 02-05-2024
Chairman Williams stated that if the commission wanted to come up to a resolution to take to city
council that would be a good direction. Even recent historic items like Brother's Park should be
preserved. Make a recommendation to the commission and then take it up to the council.
Commissioner Best asked that we continue this discussion on another meeting so we can do the grant
and increase historical awareness in the community.
Commissioner Bradshaw volunteered to help with the resolutions.
Commissioner Nothdurft offered to put together an outline.
Morgan Bessaw stated she could share the outline of the comp plan and the connection to C of I.
NEW BUSINESS:
(DISCUSSION ITEM: TRAINING OR ENGAGEMENT WITH THE NATIONAL ALLIANCE
OF PRESERVATION COMMISSIONS)
Commissioner Nothdurft looked into the NAPC and it was $150 for the city to join and that makes all
of the commissioners members_ He is willing to reach out to find out more details and share at the next
meeting.
April Cabello stated that there are supposed to be t►►o training courses a year and if we could do the
training with NAPC, and SHPO it would cover the two for the year.
Chairman Nothdurft stated he investigated the training just now and if ►%.e join, they do a webinar each
month. Their featured webinar is Design Review with Limited Resources. There is another one about
creating a preservation realtor course. This could be a low-cost way of getting our training.
April Cabello mentioned there will be a Certificate of Appropriateness coming to the commission soon.
It will be two parts, but she does not have the submission yet. The application must be submitted one
month prior to the meeting so it will not be at the next meeting.
(DISCUSSION ITEM: COMMISSION & STAFF REPORTS) None.
ADJOURNMENT
MOVED by Bradshaw, SECONDED by Nothdurft to adjourn at 7:25 p.m.
MOTION CARRIED
Respectfully submitted by Jeri Muir, staff.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY Commission Vice Chair Bradshaw on the date noted below.
ZIB4 Date: �I r ! s — 7—o gy
Nicole Bradshaw, Vice Chair
ATTEST:— — Date: `
Morgan Bed aw, Planning & Zoning Deputy Director
Page 14
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 02-05-2024