HomeMy WebLinkAbout2023-09-13 CHPC MinutesCALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
Wednesday, September 13, 2023, 6:30 p.m.
Caldwell Planning & Zoning Department, Conference Room, 621 Cleveland Boulevard, Caldwell, Idaho
ROLL CALL:
Commissioner Lyons welcomed those in attendance and called the meeting to order.
Present: Randy Lyons, Nicole Bradshaw, and Julie Best 00APPROVED
Absent: Steve Maughan and Renee DeHaas octe
Staff Present: April Cabello, Planner 1 and Morgan Bessaw, Deputy Direc ete
Others Present: Gregory Arnold — Applicant
Commissioner Lyons provided a review of the proceedings.
CONSENT CALENDAR: (ALL CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS ARE ACTION ITEMS)
MOTION by Bradshaw SECONDED by Best to approve the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission
minutes of the meeting on August 9, 2023 as printed.
MOTION PASSED
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS INTERVIEWS.
(ACTION ITEM: CA-23-06: A REQUEST BY PROPERTY OWNERS GREGORY ARNOLD
AND JANICE CHAPMAN REQUEST FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS TO
EXTEND THE EXISTING FRONT DECK ACROSS THE FRONT OF THE HOUSE. TAIS
SITE IS LOCATED AT 1614 DEARBORN STREET, PARCEL # R0728100000)
April Cabello (Planner 1) 621 Cleveland Blvd., presented the staff report and outlined the facts within
the report. She noted that the applicant removed the request for roof modification; therefore, the roof
line would remain the same.
Gregory Arnold (Applicant) 1614 Dearborn Street., spoke in favor of the request and stated that based
on the Commission's suggestion, he re -designed the project to not extend the roofline. He provided a
description of the materials that would be used to build the deck.
Discussion followed concerning painting the arbor and stair railing, and putting caps on the posts.
Commissioner Lyons expressed concerns with the height of the railing of the deck.
Commissioner Best reviewed the five conditions and noted that the applicant complied with all of the
five conditions.
Mr. Arnold used 1615 Dearborn as an example and exhibit of the front porch.
Commissioner Lyons closed public testimony.
MOVED by Best SECONDED by Bradshaw to close the public testimony portion of the public
hearing.
Pagel
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 09-13-2023
MOTION CARRIED
EVIDENCE LIST FOR CASE NO. CA-23-06:
1. Staff Report and presentation documents
2. Applicant presentation documents
3. Sign-up sheets
COMMENTS FROM COMMISSION MEMBERS CONCERNING THE REQUEST:
Commissioner Best asked if the materials presented today would be implemented.
Ms. Cabello responded that would be part of the Certificate of Appropriateness, and would be listed to
see the attached site plans and renderings.
Commissioner Bradshaw said she would ask for a condition to put a cap on the top rail post.
ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO. CA-23-06
MOVED by Bradshaw SECONDED by Best based on Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission hereby orders that Case CA-23-06, a request by property
owners Gregory Arnold and Janice Chapman request for a Certificate of Appropriates to extend the
existing front deck across the front of the house. This site was located at 1614 Dearborn Street,
parcel # R0728100000 is hereby approved with the following requirements/conditions:
• Condition 1— Meets the design shown on sheet A-2 and renderings.
• Condition 2 — Use paint colors as presented, cream color and brownish tone to match the
house.
• Condition 3 — Applicant to present for staff review, the proposed cap as shown on sheet A 1
at the top of the steps and start of the new deck.
MOTION CARRIED
OLD BUSINESS:
(DISCUSSION ITEM: COMP PLAN) HISTORIC PRESERVATION SECTION UPDATE.
Morgan Bessaw, Deputy Director gave an update on Historic Preservation Comp Plan and explained
the process.
Discussion followed concerning the Historic Preservation Comprehensive Plan from Coeur d'Alene,
and some possible grant opportunities that could assist with the conception of the Comprehensive
Plan.
NEW BUSINESS:
(ACTION ITEM: MOVING MEETINGS BACK TO MONDAY EVENINGS AT 6:30 PM)
April Cabello, Planner 1 noted that the Historic Preservation meetings would be on the 2" a (as
needed) and 4 h Monday of the month starting in October. The September 27, 2023 meeting would be
cancelled due to no quorum available. The next meeting / hearing would be on October 9, 2023 to
hear a Certificate of Appropriateness application.
Page 12
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 09-13-2023
(ACTION ITEM: ARTS COMMISSION)
Morgan Bessaw, Deputy Director commented that the City of Caldwell's vision was to have the
Historic Preservation Commission also be the Arts Commission. She mentioned that by combining
the two Commissions, more people would be interested to serve on the Commission. She added that
the Ordinance would need to be revised, and would hopefully be in place by spring of 2024.
(ACTION ITEM: RECRUITING NEW COMMISSION MEMBERS)
The commission members discussed possible contacts, and how to publicize the need for more
commission members.
Morgan Bessaw, Deputy Director stated she would check with the City Clerk to see how it could be
published in the paper.
(DISCUSSION ITEM: COMMISSION & STAFF REPORTS)
Discussion followed concerning the need for Commission members to attend conferences or receive
specific training. Per code, all Commissioners were required to attend at least two trainings per year.
Commissioner Bradshaw would like the following added to the next Commission agenda: Walking
Tour and Flyers.
ADJOURNMENT
MOVED by Best, SECONDED by Bradshaw to adjourn at 7:54 p.m.
MOTION CARRIED
Respectfully submitted by Ellen Miller, Meeting and Records Clerk.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY CHAIRMAIN LYONS on the date noted below.
Date: 10 - o c( — Zc,Z
1 1
ATTEST:
organ F�ess w, Planning & Zoning Deputy Director
Page 13
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 09-13-2023