HomeMy WebLinkAbout2023-05-24 CHPC MinutesCALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMI ION
REGULAR MEETING MINUTES $te
MINUTES
Wednesday, May 24, 2023, 6:30 p.m.
Caldwell Planning & Zoning Department, Conference Room, 621 Cleveland Boulevard, Caldwell, Idaho
ROLL CALL:
Commissioner Lyons welcomed those in attendance and called the meeting to order.
Present: Randy Lyons, Nicole Bradshaw, and Steve Maughan Absent: Julie Best, and Renee DeHaas
Staff Present: April Cabello, Planning Technician
Others Present: Karen Brown, Garth Claassen, Bill Hamilton, and Mike Job.
Commissioner Lyons provided a review of the proceedings.
CONSENT CALENDAR: (ALL CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS ARE ACTION ITEMS)
MOTION by Maughan, SECONDED by Bradshaw to approve the Caldwell Historic Preservation
Commission minutes of the meeting on March 22, 2023 as printed.
MOTION PASSED
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS INTERVIEWS.
(ACTION ITEM: CA-23-01: A REQUEST BY PROPERTY OWNERS GARTH CLAASSEN,
KAREN BROWN AND REPRESENTATIVE BELL HAMILTON FOR A CERTIFICATE OF
APPROPRIATES TO BUILD A 358 SQUARE FOOT ACCESSORY STRUCTURE / SHOP.
THIS SITE IS LOCATED AT 1823 FILLMORE STREET, PARCEL # R0732900000.)
April Cabello (Planning Technician) 621 Cleveland Blvd., presented the staff report and outlined the
facts within the report. She noted that the applicant would use the accessory structure for personal
hobbies and art. There would be no commercial use or living quarters. The structure would have some
of the exterior features and design as the house. Ms. Cabello stated staff reviewed the Secretary of
Interior Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitation Historic Buildings and found it
did not address the construction of accessory structures; however, the Steunenberg Residential
Historic District Design Guidelines (on page 25) did have a reference on accessory buildings. Ms.
Cabello indicated that staff recommends approval of this request. She remarked that requests to build
accessory structures on corner lots should be reviewed on a case by case basis.
Karen Brown (Applicant) 1824 Fillmore., spoke in favor of the request and stated that Mr. Claassen
needed a studio to replace the one he lost at work due to his retirement. He had exhibitions planned
and the accessory structure would be the best solution for them.
Garth Claassen (Applicant) 1824 Fillmore., spoke in favor of the request and reaffirmed Ms. Brown's
statement.
Bill Hamilton (Representative) 16142 Kootenai Place., spoke in favor of the request and indicated the
project would be a good solution for Mr. Claassen to continue his work after retirement. He mentioned
Page II
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 5-24-2023
the building would be built in compliance with all building codes and would not be a huge impact on
existing properties.
Mike Job 1900 Fillmore., signed in favor of the request but did not provide testimony.
Commissioner Maughan commended the applicants for submitting an excellent proposal and a very
thorough application.
In response to questions from Commissioner Bradshaw, Ms. Brown stated the structure would have
the same stucco composite as the second story portion of their home. She also indicated that the
structure would be located directly behind the house.
MOVED by Maughan SECONDED by Bradshaw to close the public testimony portion of the public
hearing.
MOTION CARRIED
EVIDENCE LIST FOR CASE NO. CA-23-03:
1. Staff Report and presentation documents
2. Applicant presentation documents
3. Sign-up sheets
4. Exhibit CA-1 (Presented by April Cabello part of the staff report)
COMMENTS FROM COMMISSION MEMBERS CONCERNING THE REQUEST:
Commissioner Maughan stated it was a really comprehensive proposal for a modest addition with
small foot print. The applicants made a clear effort to reflect the existing architecture of the main
house. Commissioner Lyons concurred.
Discussion followed concerning the windows on the structure.
MOVED by Maughan, SECONDED by Bradshaw to close the public testimony portion of the public
hearing.
MOTION CARRIED
ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO. CA-23-01
MOVED by Maughan SECONDED by Bmdshaw based on Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,
the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission hereby orders that Case CA-23-03, a request by
property owners Garth Claassen, Karen Brown and Representative Bill Hamilton for a Certificate of
Appropriates to build a 358 square foot accessory structure / shop. This site is located at 1823
1~illmore Street, parcel # R0732900000 is hereby approved with the following conditions:
Condition 1 Construction would be completed with all materials presented in the staff
report.
MOTION CARRIED
Page' 2
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 5-24-2023
OLD BUSINESS:
(ACTION ITEM: CONTINUED DISCUSSION 2023 COMMISSION GOALS, CLG GRANT,
COUNTY GRANT — UPDATE)
April Cabello provided an updated report and shared that the commission may form a subcommittee
with only two members; however, the Commissioners must vote on who the two subcommittee
members would be. The commission decided to wait until Commissioner Best was in attendance.
Discussion followed concerning Commissioner's availability, common timeline for a subcommittee
to meet, and the function of the subcommittee. The consensus was that the first goal of the
subcommittee would need to be set and followed through until the goal was completed.
Ms. Cabello stated that meetings did not need to be recorded, only main topics, and the vision would
need to be documented. Only one subcommittee member would make the presentation to the
commission. She also mentioned that Director Collins contacted a representative of M on the cost
to put together a Historic Masterplan so it could be included in the budget.
Commissioner Maughan stated it would be iznpezative the commission or subcommittee meet with Director
Collins in person. He noted that the director's vision of historic preservation is determinative how the
commission interfaces with the City, its resources, human resources, and monetary resources.
Commissioner Bradshaw concurred.
Commissioner Lyons asked when the subcommittee meets on a Saturday morning at a coffee house,
would it be appropriate to have Director Collins attend the meeting.
Commissioner Maugban stated that any Commissioner could speak with any member of staff the City Council,
any business person, there was no prohibition in doing it.
NEW BUSINESS:
(ACTION ITEM: LIST OF POTENTIAL MONEY FOR GRANT WRITING RESOURCES)
Discussion was held on the vision the City had for the Commission. It was decided to wait on
proceeding with grants, until the Chair had a discussion with the P&Z Director.
Ms. Cabello mentioned that the Finance Department told her they could not apply for SHIPO or CLG
grants as they were not in compliance. She was asked by the Commission to find out the reason why
they were not in compliance.
(ACTION ITEM: PROPERTIES IN THE DISTRICT WITH ITEMS AND EQUIPMENT IN
THE FRONT YARD. This item was not discussed)
DISCUSSION ITEM: COMMISSION & STAFF REPORTS: None.
ADJOURNMENT
MOVED by Maughan, SECONDED by Bradshaw to adjourn at 7:44 p.m.
MOTION CARRIED
Page J 3
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 5-24-2023
Respectfully submitted by Ellen Miller, Meeting and Records Clerk.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY CHAIRMAN LYONS on the date noted below.
/V� �' c� Zy' Date: ` ZG 1,,3
ue�lrai�
/U►c.o c � rc��d� �+e� ice C�.��- g • � �. � �3
ATTEST: Date:
Robin 1 oni ector
Page 4
Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 5-24-2023