HomeMy WebLinkAboutPUBLIC RESPONSE PUBLIC RESPONSE
ITEM DATE SUBMITTED BY
PR-1
"YrTh"
(�i/Y1A'k'� ✓
PR-2 �� " i �
c
n`v
PR-3crv� 1CJ `
iv
PR-4
Lori Colligan
From: Debbie Root
Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 8:03 AM
To: Jerome Mapp
Cc: Lori Colligan
Subject: FW: Case # CMP-20-05/ANN-20-03/SUB-20P-06: parcel R35276
For NORTH RANCH, needs to be added to file and provided to council.
Deb Root, MBA, PCED
Senior Planner
City of Caldwell Planning and Zoning
208-455-4662
droot@cityofcaldwell.org
From: candicelouise@aol.com <candicelouise@aol.com>
Sent: Wednesday, September 9, 2020 8:59 PM
To: Debbie Root<droot@cityofcaldwell.org>
Subject: Case#CMP-20-05/ANN-20-03/SUB-20P-06: parcel R35276
Greetings Ms. Root
My name is Candice Louise and I'm a homeowner in VOYAGE CROSSING Subdivision on
Concourse Ave. I'm writing in response to a Notice regarding the Caldwell City Council public hearing
scheduled for Monday, September 21, 2020 at 7:00 pm. The case number for this hearing is: CMP-
20-05/ANN-20-03/SUB-20P-06: with "BVA North Ranch LLC requesting to annex 115 acres on the
Northwest corner of State Hwy 20/26 and Smeed Parkway, a.k.a. parcel R35276."
This Notice reads in part, "The approximate 21 acres of frontage on Hwy 20/26 is proposed as C-3
(service commercial) zone and 94 acres is requested to be zoned M-1 (light industrial) requiring a
Comprehensive Plan amendment from Commercial and Service to Manufacturing
and Production."
My concerns are focused on:
1 . the request that 94 acres be zoned M-1, Light Industrial;
2. an "amendment from Commercial and Service to Manufacturing and Production."
On May 13, 2020, I attended a BVA "Neighborhood Meeting" via ZOOM. I believe I expressed
concern about the term "Light Industrial," especially with regard to whether Manufacturing and/or
Production would fall under the definition of "Light Industrial." Obviously, I'm concerned about what is
going to be allowed to be built 300 feet from my backyard (and many of my neighbors) which has
been beautiful farmland with a lovely view of the mountains.
This major change will now take away those amenities and will likely have a negative impact on many
property values as well, especially with the very long, vague, and sketchy list of businesses that are
already classified P = as permitted under the TABLE 1 of the LAND USE SCHEDULE: 10-02-02: M-
1 . For Example, under the M-1 PUBLIC SEMI-PUBLIC category, a Dirt-bike Track and an Indoor
i Oft(
Shooting Range are both labelk P = Permitted. Although unlikely, nraybe, these are still 2 of any
number of possible businesses that developers could be allowed to rent space to.
One consideration of property devaluation could be designing a comparative compensation schedule
for the homeowners from the developers, which would incorporate comparative
property assessments, appraisals, etc. This might be worth researching other models of similar
situations or acquisitions.
I also noticed a change in language from the August Notice to this most recent September Notice, in
the second sentence of the second paragraph. I have underlined and bolded the
change. The August Notice reads, "The approximate 21 acres of frontage on Hwy 20/26 is proposed
as C-3 (service commercial) zone and 94 acres is requested to be zoned M-1 (light industrial)
requiring a Comprehensive Plan amendment from Commercial and Service to Light Industrial."
The September Notice reads, " The approximate 21 acres of frontage on Hwy 20/26 is proposed as
C-3 (service commercial) zone and 94 acres is requested to be zoned M-1 (light industrial) requiring a
Comprehensive Plan amendment from Commercial and Service to Manufacturing and Production."
I understand that progress is inevitable and I have accepted the fact that 115 more acres of
agricultural land are going to be turned into businesses. I'm just not willing to accept that the
developers almost have a carte blanche as to what businesses they are allowed to rent or lease to.
Thank you for your time and consideration,
Respectfully,
Candice Louise
415 Concourse Ave.,
Caldwell, ID 83605
208-871-0899
Total Control Panel Login
To: droot(a,cityofcaldwell.org Message Score: 10 High(60): Pass
From: candicelouise(caol.com My Spam Blocking Level: High Medium(75): Pass
Low(90): Pass
Block this sender
Block aol.com
This message was delivered because the content filter score did not exceed your filter level.
2
September 15, 2020
RE: Case#CMP-20-05/ANN-20-03/SUB-20P-06
Dear Honorable Mayor Garrett L. Nancolas; Respected City Council Members; and Respected Members
of the Planning and Zoning Department:
Thank you for allowing me to share my concerns as a homeowner directly impacted by the BVA North
Ranch LLC project now developing on Hwy 20/26 and Smeed. I live in Voyage Crossing Subdivision on
the East side of Concourse Ave., Block 1- Lot 22. My backyard fence shares the west boundary of the
BVA North Ranch development.
It is my intention to testify against a Comprehensive Plan Map Amendment from Commercial,C-
3 zoning, to Manufacturing and Production, M-1 zoning, due to the close proximity to my
property. There are uses that are allowed in an M-1 Zone that could negatively impact my property and
my enjoyment of activities on my property, as well as all my neighbors in Voyage Crossing,especially
living on Concourse Ave.
Such M-1 Uses could include but not be limited to:
1. Grain/crop Storage; 2. AutomotiveTow Yard; 3. Body Shop; 4.Truck&Tractor Repair&
Service; 5.Truck Stop; 6.Crematorium: 7.Aircraft Repair&Service; 8. Factory Assembly Plant; 9.
Monument Production; 10. Recycling Operation; 11. Contractor's Shop/Storage Yard; 12. Public Utility
Yard; 13.Trucking Terminal Yard; and 14. BMX DIRT-BIKE TRACK.
Therefore, I respectfully request that the Council maintain a C-3 Zoning of the entire 115 acre parcel. if
the Council approves a zoning change to M-1, could the developer be limited to what kinds of
businesses/uses will be allowed, adjacent to the residential developments?
This development is already negating the open mountain view to the East that my neighbors and I have
enjoyed for the past three and one half years. With the major residential growth in the Treasure Valley,
I'm disappointed this 115 acre parcel of land is being developed as a Light Industrial area, bordering
much residential zoning. I hope this new zoning provides at least as much tax revenue as could have
been generated by residential zoning.
Thank you for your time and your kind consideration.
Respectfully,
Candice Louise
415 Concourse Ave.
Caldwell, ID 83605-4814
208-871-0899
tfp v
September 15, 2020
Dear Mr. Mapp
Thank you for sending me these two attachments. I just sent you my email letter of concerns
and requests to be presented at the Public Hearing on Monday, Sept 21, 2020 at 7:00 pm in the
Community Room at the Caldwell Police Department.
I've been continuing to study the North Ranch - Staff Report and can't seem to find the actual
footage between their West boundary and the front of Building A, which is the largest
proposed building of over 273,000 square feet. This one "Building A" runs along
approximately 2/3s of the North to South border of the entire Voyage Crossing East boundary;
with "Building E" (approximately 84,000 square feet) sharing almost the remainder of
that boundary with the South East border of Voyage Crossing shared with Parcel R35276.
Also, I am unable to find the dimensions of either (any) of these "proposed" buildings, A and
E. Looking at the "PROPOSED / CONCEPT SITE PLAN"just Building A alone seems to dwarf
a large section of our residential properties on both the East and South boundaries of two
phases of the Voyage Crossing subdivision. I'm struggling to imagine what kinds of businesses
could occupy that much space without there being some kinds of incongruence between the
Residential and M-1 zonings being just a few yards of each other. Again, I would like to
know what that distance would be from Buildings A and E to the residential fence lines.
All I have found so far is a 5' high and 30' wide buffer berm that is to be positioned on the
Voyage Crossing fence line shared with Parcel R35276. I haven't been able to find out the
dimensions of the the parking lot(s) between the berm and the building fronts either. This could
make a significant difference with regard to how close cars will be driven / parked and business
will be conducted from the back yards and patios of the residents on East Concourse Ave. The
5' height of the berms will be lower than our already existing fence height of about 6', therefore
it's difficult to imagine how these berms could provide the concealment/ privacy as was
indicated in the North Ranch Staff Report.
I will also study the attachments you sent to familiarize myself with the "2040
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FOR THE CITY OF CALDWELL". I am finding this all very
interesting and I appreciate your time in communicating with me. Thank you again for taking the
time to read this most current email. I'll be looking forward to meeting you and the City Council
members next week. I will have my questions concisely listed so as to be mindful of the
time. Sometimes brevity is not my strong suit!
Respectfully,
Candice Louise
415 concourse Ave.
Caldwell, ID 83605-4814
208-871-0899
J3
Greetings again, Ms. Root& Mr. Mapp
I have spent most of the afternoon reading and studying the North Ranch - staff report.
Thanks to Mr. Mapp,who directed me how to access this report, almost all of my
questions were answered and my concerns addressed. I am still wondering how the
impact of changing the zoning of the 94 acres from C-3 to M-1 might negatively affect
the residential communities, especially the closest neighborhood of Voyage Crossing,
specifically the properties on the East side of Concourse Ave.
However, at the end of the day, I learned an enormous amount of information regarding
this proposed project and what a very detailed undertaking this is. Due to this report, I
feel much more confident about how this project will evolve. Although, I still admit to
much disappointment of losing the entire view to the East, including the mountains, from
my backyard. This view was a major deciding factor for me when I purchased my home
3 +years ago.
Thank you both again for contacting me and helping educate me. I will still be attending
the Public Hearing on September 21, 2020 @ 7:00 pm to familiarize myself more with
how this process works. Ms. Root,please disregard my second email, sent earlier today
requesting additional information. After reading the staff report, I was able to understand
a lot more of the language and the process.
Respectfully,
Candice Louise
415 Concourse Ave.
Caldwell, ID 83605
208-871-0899
Thank you for responding so promptly to my email. However, I really struggled with trying to
understand much of the information you provided, especially with regard as to how it relates to my
concerns as a property owner.
I am very confused with regard to the first paragraph and "the change in language" reference.
You wrote:
"In February the a new Comprehensive Plan was adopted and some of the Land Use Map designations
changed "titles" with anticipated changes to the zoning ordinance "zones"[additional zones to be added
to better differentiate growth areas] in the future."
I'm really not sure what that means. I don't understand what you're trying to convey.
Could you Please send me:
1. "February Comprehensive Plan"
2. "Land Use Map designations"
The next paragraph only exacerbated my confusion!
You wrote:
"The notice you received most recently correctly identifies the designation of the underlying
Comprehensive Plan title of"Manufacturing and Production" as it is listed in the adopted plan. The zone
that is being requested is "M-1" (Light Industrial) because that is the comparable zone that is currently
available in the zoning ordinance."
What is the "adopted plan"? And what is the "comparable zone that is currently available in the zoning
ordinance"?
The September Notice reads:
an amendment from Commercial and Service to Manufacturing and Production."
As I wrote previously, my concern is that this "amendment" will allow the developers to rent/lease to
Manufacturing& Production businesses.
These, &other businesses,could become noisy, smelly, "neighbors"that work all night with their lights
on just 300 feet from the backyards of all the houses on Concourse Ave. The far northwest corner could
also become a catch-all for trash given the wind pattern changing due to buildings blocking the air-flow.
My questions are,why can't the entire 115 acres be zoned C-3 =Commercial?Why should the
developers have the option of leasing to any manufacturing businesses?
Again,thank you for your kind consideration regarding my concerns & my lack of understanding&
knowledge regarding zoning.
I've wondered if that land was developed as Residential how the tax base would compare. Too bad it
couldn't be turned into a nice friendly housing community with a grocery store, some nice shops, a
couple of restaurants, & maybe even a small park with a water feature. Oh well, one can always dream.
Thank you for your time.
Respectfully,
Candice Louise
415 Concourse Ave.
Caldwell, 83605
208-871-0899
Sent from my iPhone
On Sep 10, 2020, at 8:02 AM, Debbie Root<droot@cityofcaldwell.org>wrote:
Candice Louise,
Thank you for your well thought correspondence. I will forward to the Director as he has taken the lead
on this particular case.
I wanted to address the change in language of the notice: In February the a new Comprehensive Plan
was adopted and some of the Land Use Map designations changed "titles"with anticipated changes to
the zoning ordinance "zones"[additional zones to be added to better differentiate growth areas] in the
future. The notice you received most recently correctly identifies the designation of the underlying
Comprehensive Plan title of"Manufacturing and Production" as it is listed in the adopted plan. The zone
that is being requested is "M-1" (Light Industrial) because that is the comparable zone that is currently
available in the zoning ordinance.
Deb Root, MBA, PCED
Senior Planner
City of Caldwell Planning and Zoning
208-455-4662
droot@citvofcaldwell.org
From: candicelouise@aol.com <candicelouise@aol.com>
Sent: Wednesday, September 9, 2020 8:59 PM
To: Debbie Root<droot@cityofcaldwell.org>
Subject: Case#CMP-20-05/ANN-20-03/SUB-20P-06: parcel R35276
Greetings Ms. Root^'
My name is Candice Louise and I'm a homeowner in VOYAGE CROSSING Subdivision on Concourse Ave.
I'm writing in response to a Notice regarding the Caldwell City Council public hearing scheduled for
Monday, September 21, 2020 at 7:00 pm. The case number for this hearing is: CMP-20-05/ANN-20-
03/SUB-20P-06: with "BVA North Ranch LLC requesting to annex 115 acres on the Northwest corner of
State Hwy 20/26 and Smeed Parkway, a.k.a. parcel R35276."
This Notice reads in part, "The approximate 21 acres of frontage on Hwy 20/26 is proposed as C-3
(service commercial) zone and 94 acres is requested to be zoned M-1 (light industrial) requiring a
Comprehensive Plan amendment from Commercial and Service to Manufacturing and Production."
My concerns are focused on:
1.the request that 94 acres be zoned M-1, Light Industrial;
2. an "amendment from Commercial and Service to Manufacturing and Production."
On May 13, 2020, I attended a BVA"Neighborhood Meeting" via ZOOM. I believe I expressed concern
about the term "Light Industrial," especially with regard to whether Manufacturing and/or Production
would fall under the definition of"Light Industrial." Obviously, I'm concerned about what is going to be
allowed to be built 300 feet from my backyard (and many of my neighbors)which has been beautiful
farmland with a lovely view of the mountains.
This major change will now take away those amenities and will likely have a negative impact on many
property values as well, especially with the very long,vague, and sketchy list of businesses that are
already classified P =as permitted under the TABLE 1 of the LAND USE SCHEDULE: 10-02-02: M-1. For
Example, under the M-1 PUBLIC SEMI-PUBLIC category, a Dirt-bike Track and an Indoor Shooting Range
are both labeled P= Permitted. Although unlikely, maybe,these are still 2 of any number of possible
businesses that developers could be allowed to rent space to.
One consideration of property devaluation could be designing a comparative compensation schedule for
the homeowners from the developers,which would incorporate comparative property assessments,
appraisals, etc. This might be worth researching other models of similar situations or acquisitions.
I also noticed a change in language from the August Notice to this most recent September Notice, in the
second sentence of the second paragraph. I have underlined and bolded the change. The August Notice
reads, "The approximate 21 acres of frontage on Hwy 20/26 is proposed as C-3 (service commercial)
zone and 94 acres is requested to be zoned M-1 (light industrial) requiring a Comprehensive Plan
amendment from Commercial and Service to Light Industrial."
The September Notice reads, "The approximate 21 acres of frontage on Hwy 20/26 is proposed as C-3
(service commercial) zone and 94 acres is requested to be zoned M-1 (light industrial) requiring a
Comprehensive Plan amendment from Commercial and Service to Manufacturing and Production."
I understand that progress is inevitable and I have accepted the fact that 115 more acres of agricultural
land are going to be turned into businesses. I'm just not willing to accept that the developers almost
have a carte blanche as to what businesses they are allowed to rent or lease to.
Thank you for your time and consideration,
Respectfully,
Candice Louise
415 Concourse Ave.,
Caldwell, ID 83605
208-871-0899