Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2023-03-22 CHPC MinutesCALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION C( REGULAR MEETING MINUTES MINUTES Wednesday, March 22, 2023, 6:30 p.m. Caldwell Planning & Zoning Department, Conference Room, 621 Cleveland Boulevard, Caldwell, Idaho ROLL CALL: Commissioner Lyons welcomed those in attendance and called the meeting to order. Present: Randy Lyons, Nicole Bradshaw, and Julie Best Absent: Renee DeHaas, Steve Maughan Staff Present: April Cabello, Planning Technician Others Present: Pat Reeve, Guest, Robin King and Dean King, Applicants Commissioner Lyons provided a review of the proceedings. CONSENT CALENDAR: (ALL CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS ARE ACTION ITEMS) 1. Approve Minutes from February 22, 2023 & February 28, 2023 MOTION by Best, SECONDED by Bradshaw to approve the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission minutes of the meetings on February 22, 2023 & February 28, 2023 as printed. MOTION PASSED CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS INTERVIEWS. (ACTION ITEM: CA-23-01: A REQUEST BY ROBIN KING FOR CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS TO -ENLARGE HS-F,KIST-ING342-SQUARE-F00T-GARAGE T-038 SQUARE FEET. THIS SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 1901 DEARBORN STREET, PARCEL # R0722500000) April Cabello (Planning & Zoning Department) 621 Cleveland Blvd., presented the staff report and outlined the facts within the report. She noted that with the current dimensions and condition of the garage, it would only function as a large storage shed. The existing garage would be lengthened along the present line by 12' so it can hold two vehicles and allow for added storage. The applicant felt the changes to the garage would not change the aesthetic vibe of the district. Ms. Cabello made reference to the Secretary of The Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation and stated the request was consistent with the Steunenberg Residential Historic District Design Guidelines. Staff understood the need for off-street parking and agreed with the request to expand the garage; however, would leave the character defining determination to the Commission. Robin King (Applicant) 1901 Dearborn St., spoke in favor of the request and stated his request to expand the garage would be more functional. He clarified they were not looking to change the exterior appearance; however, they were open to suggestions from the Historic District, since they want to do it right. Page I 1 Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 3-22-2023 Dean King 1901 Dearborn St., spoke in favor of the request and provided an explanation on why rafters needed to be inside and why they use rafters and not a truss. Robin King stated the garage door that was included with the original plans was a galvanized door and would like to change it and use a different garage door with windows on the top grid. Commissioner Lyons asked if he contacted the City Engineers to ask for suggestions. Robin King responded he only contacted the street engineer concerning water issues. Commissioner Best asked if the color scheme would stay the same as the house trim color. Mr. King concurred. Commissioner Bradshaw asked applicant to speak about the actual elevation plans, particularly on the expansion of the building and the roof. Robin King responded they were going to go along the same lot line and make it 12' deep into the rear yard and the height of the structure would increase by 3'. Commissioner Bradshaw asked if the intention with the addition was to have living space. Mr. King responded no, that was only for ease of access. Discussion followed concerning the front and rear doors, the different type of windows on the house and the garage door. Commissioner Bradshaw noted she did not see any corbels on the new design and asked if they would stay. Mr. King concurred. Commissioner Lyons asked if the extension would cause any significant existing trees or bushes to be trimmed. Robin King responded that the general contractor indicated they would probably need to remove one Juniper located on the side of the alley. Discussion followed concerning Hardie Plank siding, paint colors, and construction materials to be used. Commissioner Lyons stated the Department of the Interior indicated that the use of Hardie Plank was not preferable but it was allowable. He also asked for clarification on the type of garage door and if it would have windows. Robin King responded they did not intend to put a regular garage door, they preferred a Craftsman style garage door with windows. He presented pictures of the proposed garage door. Ms. Cabello labeled the three pictures Exhibit CA-2. Commissioner Bradshaw thanked Mr. King for the pictures and mentioned the pictures helped them see the trim around the frame of the garage. She also mentioned the Commission wanted to maintain the integrity of the historic part of Caldwell and expressed concern on the pitch of the roof. Page 12 Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 3-22-2023 Discussion followed concerning the pitch of the roof. Commissioner Lyons asked the applicant to give a description of the windows to be used. Dean King provided a description of the windows to be used. Commissioner Lyons asked the applicant if his plan was to also add a bathroom and a utility sink. Mr. King concurred. Commissioner Lyons asked if the applicant was planning on putting a cement walkway and if the fence would remain the same. Robin King responded his plan was to put some type of walkway; however, was not sure if it would be concrete, pavers or brick. He indicated the fence would remain the same. MOVED by Bradshaw, SECONDED by Best to close the public testimony portion of the public hearing. MOTION CARRIED EVIDENCE LIST FOR FOR CASE NO. CA-23-01 1. Staff Report and presentation documents 2. Applicant presentation documents 3. Sign-up sheets 4. Exhibit CA-2 (Presented by April Cabello) COMMENTS FROM COMMISSION MEMBERS CONCERNING THE REQUEST: Commissioner Bradshaw commented the applicant did a nice job staying with the integrity of the Craftsman style, as well of trying to incorporate the modern day functionality. She noted that the Commission members need to pay attention to what the expansion would look like from the road and _public view. April Cabello mentioned that this request did not meet the standards requirements; however, staff understood the reason to enlarge the structure. She also added that the French door would not be visible from the street side. Discussion followed on the possibility of the fence getting removed later in the years. Staff suggested to put a recommendation on the Certificate of Appropriateness concerning the fence. Commissioner Lyons stated that siding was significantly important and would like to see a sample of what the Hardie Plank siding would look like. He also noted the plans did not show the windows or lighting; therefore, they would not accept the plans that were submitted, since the windows or lighting were not included in the drawings. Commissioner Best concurred. Commissioner Best mentioned that the adopted design guidelines were consistent with the Craftsman's style. Commissioner Bradshaw mentioned that the pitch of the roof was not in compliance with the guidelines; however, she did not believe it would be a concern. Page 13 Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 3-22-2023 MOVED by Bradshaw, SCONDED by Best to re -open the public testimony portion of the public hearing. MOTION CARRIED Questions were posod to the applicants regarding description and size of the siding. Discussion followed concerning the description and size of the siding. It was decided they would keep the new siding at seven inches (T). Subsequently, there was additional discussion on the corners, windows and doors. MOVED by Bradshaw, SCONDED by Best to close the public testimony portion of the public hearing. MOTION CARRIED ORDER OF DECISION ON CASE NO. CA-23-01 MOVED by Bradshaw, SECONDED by Best based on Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission here by orders that Case CA-23-01, a request by Robin King for a Certificate of Appropriateness to enlarge his existing 342 square foot garage to 580 square feet located at 1901 Dearborn Street is hereby approved with the following conditions: • Condition 1 They would reference the look and design of the garage door based on Exhibit CA-2. The garage door would be metal and would have four 3 over 3 windows, and lights on each side of the door. • Condition 2 — The corbels would be added into the design since they don't show on Exhibit CA-2. • Condition 3 — The trim and corners would be included around the windows as described by the applicant. Windows facing the home would be a set of three, over three, over one, with a singl-uhung-louk. — • Condition 3 -- The Commission would like to see a larger display of the proposed siding to sec how the 7" overlap would look. • Condition 4 — Roofing would be architectural shingles Timberline NS Charcoal color. MOTION CARRIED OLD BUSINESS: ACTION ITEM: 2023 COMMISSION GOALS, CLG GRANT, COUNTY GRANT — UPDATE FROM WORKSHOP HELD FEBRUARY 28, 2023. April Cabello provided an updated report. She stated that Robin Collins, P&Z Director was not able to speak with the Mayor concerning the grant, therefore, they night not be able to meet the deadline to apply for the grant in 2023. She also confirmed the Historic Society was still together, and would still be a viable option for another funding source. Page 14 Caldwell Historic Preservation Conunission Minutes 3-22-2023 NEW BUSINESS: DISCUSSION ITEM: COMMISSION & STAFF REPORTS April Cabello discussed properties within the District with items in the front yard that would need to be removed. She stated there were quite a few houses in the District that have that issue, and asked if the Commission would like to take over that concern. She said a Commission member would go to the district and identify the homes with issues, make a Iist and send to Planning & Zoning to mail a courtesy letter addressing the concerns. Discussion followed concerning the different options. Commissioner Lyons volunteered to identify the homes. Commissioner Best mentioned the opportunity to apply for mini grants for neighborhood clean-up activities. ADJOURNMENT MOVED by Best, SECONDED by Bradshaw to adjourn at 8: 15 p.m. MOTION CARRIED Respectfully submitted by Ellen Miller, Meeting and Records Clerk. MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY CHAIRMAN LYONS on the date noted below. Date: S 2,q - Z p? Date: 3irector Page 15 Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 3-22-2023