HomeMy WebLinkAbout2023-02-22 CHPC MinutesCALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
Meeting of February 22, 2023 g 6:30 P.M. APPROVED
Caldwell Planning & Zoning — Conference Room
621 Cleveland Blvd, Caldwell, Idaho
Call to order. Chairperson Lyons called the meeting to order at approximately 6:35 t9 2
Members Present. Randy Lyons, Julie Best, and Steve Maughan
Members Absent: Nicole Bradshaw and Renee DeHass
Others Present. April Cabello, Planning Technician; Mike Dittenber, Caldwell Housing Authority; Maria Rachal,
SHPO; and Dan Everhart, SHPO
Others Absent: Robin Collins, Planning Director; Elizabeth Allen, Senior Planner
(ACTION ITEM: APPROVE MINUTES).
MOVED by Maughan, SECONDED by Best to approve the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission minutes of
the meeting held on January 25, 2023 as printed.
MOTION PASSED
(ACTION ITEM: CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS INTERVIEWS) None.
(OLD BUSINESS)
(ACTION ITEM: WORKSHOP SCHEDULED FEBRUARY 28, 2023 ON GOALS 15 YEAR PLAN)
April Cabello, Planning Technician noted that the Action Item was added to the agenda in case the Board
Members wanted to vote on it. The Workshop is scheduled on February 28, 2023 at 6:30 pm., to discuss the goals
and 5 year plan only.
(NEW BUSINESS)
(ACTION ITEM: CALDWELL HOUSING AUTHORITY — RICE HOUSE — MIKE DITTENBER)
Mike Dittenber, Caldwell Housing Authority stated that he approached the college to find out if the Housing
Authority could do something with the Rice house. The college has always held firm on their demand that any
type of negotiations would require the house to be moved. The college does not want the house there. He believed
the college has a master plan to carry out and it includes expanding one of the facilities in that area. Previously,
they were put on a short timeline to move the house, finally last month, the college agreed to give the Housing
Authority 18 months to move the house.
Commissioner Maughan indicated he had a brief conversation with the CFO about the house, and noticed that
most of the property has been cleared. He also mentioned that the college, as an entity, is not committed to
preserve any development in the house.
Commissioner Best commented that the trees were magnificent.
Commissioner Maughan replied they were not magnificent trees. He said they were all cottonwoods that were
old, and were starting to split. They were not oaks or hardwood.
Mr. Dittenber stated the agreement with the college was that the property had to be cleared in order to move the
house. He said the house would be moved to the corner of Chicago and Kimball, in downtown Caldwell. The
Housing Authority has owned that parcel of property since 2017. Mr. Dittenber added that the Housing Authority
was not a non-profit entity, they have statutory authority under the Idaho code. He noted that the approximate
cost to move the house would be close to $500,000. Mr. Dittenber also indicated he was hopeful that the College
Pagel of 5 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes
02/22/2023
and the City of Caldwell would support the Housing Authority with the funding mechanisms to be able to move
the Rice house.
Commissioner Maughan stated that the previous owners, in an effort to make it a viable bread -and -breakfast
residence, made significant structural changes to the house. He said the exterior of the house was beautiful, and
it ties to Caldwell's early history.
Mr. Dittenber noted for the record, he thought there should be another historic district in the City of Caldwell and
the old town should be another historic district.
Mr. Dittenber mentioned he has been in contact with Ron Rice, he was the Great Grandson of John Rice. The
family has committed to provide all the photos they have of the Rice house. Mr. Rice also indicated that most of
the furniture that used to be in the Rice house was with family members, and they would be willing to return some
of that furniture to the Rice house. Mr. Dittenber mentioned a documentary called The Levitated Mass. He said
the documentary was about a curator of a museum in Los Angeles that moved a 340 lbs rock from a California
desert to downtown Los Angeles. Mr. Dittenber said in the future, they would ask for financial contributions and
in -kind work from the community. He said they would let the community know that on a certain day, the Rice
house would be moved down the street. He also indicated they would get plaques to place in front of the house
giving thanks to everyone who helped move the house. He stated that in exchange for Urban Renewal money, a
commitment was made to the City, to consider making a couple units housing for public safety personnel, or
school teachers.
Commissioner Maughan reported that the house was completely gutted and it would be a perfect fit for the street
comer. With regards to the north Caldwell town site as a historic district, it was something that was considered in
the commission years ago, however, had concerns about the number of contributing structures with regard to how
large the district would be. In addition, the fact that at that point, many of the properties were rentals and it was
not clear there would be community support for it. That may have changed, and there have been some renovations
in that area. There are some beautiful houses, and possibly a limited district at some point may be an option. Since
there was an 18 month window, there might be a possibility to co -develop along with the moving of the house,
particularly since early city founders and college founders residences are the first college site right in that
neighborhood.
Commissioner Lyons mentioned that in some renovations done to the house dormers were added. He asked if the
plan were to remove the dormers and return the house to the original historic look.
Mike Dittenber responded they do not know yet what they would do. He presented pictures that show the windows
now and then. He indicated he would like to see the house as close to the original as possible.
Commissioner Lyons asked if there are any restrictions/regulations or union rules that if an electrician wants to
do electrical work for free, that would be possible.
Mike Dittenber replied that would be possible, and since they are a government organization they could give them
a certificate value of contribution so they can write it off on their taxes. He also mentioned that in 2015, he
approached the Mayor and City Council to inform them there was considerable need for attention in the north
end, consequently, a Resolution was created calling it "the North End Neighborhood Revitalization District". The
Housing Authority was given permission by the City, to take a lead role in establishing the North End
Neighborhood Revitalization District.
Dan Everhart, SHPO commented on the inappropriate changes that were made to the house, however, at the same
time, he said they can take full advantage of what was essentially a blank slate. He indicated they can have
freedom and flexibility, nonetheless, he does not want to imply they should not be careful with the form of the
building. He questioned how important was it to remove the dormer, since the dormer was going to help with the
square footage in the house. He added that maybe some of the window changes could be left the way they are. As
far as he knows, from some photographs that were taken in 2019, not only had the window locations changed in
some cases, in most cases, all the windows were removed and replaced. The windows that were replaced are
inappropriate and unattractive. He would encourage the Housing Authority to spend money where it makes the
biggest impact, in the exterior and replacing inappropriately placed windows. He would also suggested to open
up the back porch and to look at another house mover in the Valley, possibly they might offer a better rate.
Page 2 of 5 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes
02/22/2023
Mr. Everhart commented that the Housing Authority in downtown Idaho Falls, took on a large project with
historic property by using the historic tax credit program. Generally, it was not applicable to non-profit
government entities, however, in the case of Idaho Falls, they partnered with a for -profit housing developer who
was able to take advantage of the federal tax incentives. He said he could assist in exploring that program and to
connect them with the people who made that happen in Idaho Falls. He added that the tax incentive program was
the single largest financial incentive for historic preservation. He mentioned there are some hurdles with the
current and future location, and the alterations made to the house, however, he said they could possibly obtain
20% tax credit on the investment_ Ultimately, whether it was a tax credit project or not, or however it was funded,
he thinks this was an exciting opportunity. He believed the Northside of Caldwell does need the investment.
Lastly, he added that the relocation of historic buildings was not their first priority. They believe buildings have
some of their significance because of where they are and yet, when it comes right down to it, and are faced with
demolition of a building or its relocation, they would rather see the historic building somewhere and useful than
nowhere or in the landfill.
Commissioner Lyons asked if this home lost its national registry designation.
Mr. Everhart responded it has not. They do not make it a habit of removing national registry designation from
properties. There are buildings that burned to the ground 40 years ago and are still listed in the national registry
in Idaho. They do not have the staff capability to keep up with the regular workload, let alone, the time it would
take to go find places that no longer qualify for listing, and remove them from the list. The property was still
technically listed in the national register. He added that if they decide to pursue the tax credit program they would
need to look at it harder.
Commissioner Lyons stated that the structure was historic and not the actual ground.
Commissioner Maughan commented to look at the listing of the house online, that it shows where the house was
originally located, and it also shows the house was moved. He believed this was a grand opportunity to save a
beautiful structure from its original architectural form.
Commissioner Lyons remarked that what the Caldwell Housing Authority was doing is very significant and would
establishing a precedent to save this house.
Mr. Dittenber stated that the Housing Authority not only provides housing, rental housing or multi -family
housing, they also do community re -planning efforts. In addition, they were given broad statutory authority under
the law to investigate slum conditions. As a Housing Authority they have the right to issue revenue bonds for
housing. He was thinking of creating a blog or some sort of social media platform where it could be updated
regularly and tell people what was going on. He asked if they know of an organization or individual that might
be willing to champion that cause to get it going.
Commissioner Hest asked what the plans are for the bottom portion of the house.
Mike Dittenber stated that in order for the Housing Authority to get the square footage they need, they would
need to put a basement back underneath the house, however, the corner lot on Kimball and Chicago used to be a
Super Save gas station that left many tanks in the ground, therefore, that would prohibit them from building the
basement. Currently, a company from Montana was doing a plot environmental review. If everything goes as
planned, they would put a basement underneath the house and it would be an SRO (Single Room Occupancy),
meaning a studio apartment with a kitchenette and a bathroom. The upstairs could also have two SRO's. The
downstairs would be a coffee shop or something that still has an opening to the community. Downstairs might be
something more modern, the main entry floor for public access might be more original.
Commissioner Maughan noted that the changes made to the house significantly expanded the square footage in
the upper floor. The house needs to be a useful public building and there was no point in trying to preserve
something that was already gone.
Page 3 of 5 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes
02/22/2023
(ACTION ITEM: INTRODUCE NEW SHPO - HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNER — MARIA
RACHAL)
Dan Everhart (SHPO) stated that the City of Caldwell is a Certified Local Government (CLG). As a CLG, the
City of Caldwell was one of 40 communities (those are both Cities and Counties) around the state of Idaho.
These communities, have committed to passing an ordinance to seating a commission, and to represent the
interest of Historic Preservation around the state. Through their partnership, one of their commitments to the
national partners (at the park service, and the local partners at the cities and counties), was to have a certified
local government coordinator who manages the activities and programs they administer at the SHPO. They have
had a series of these certified local government coordinators over the last few decades, however, he introduced
Maria Rachal as the new certified local government coordinator.
Maria Rachal (SHPO) stated that her main task was to build relationships with those communities. She
indicated it was great to see what was happening at the local level. She mentioned this was the first commission
meeting she attends where there was an active movement to save a historic house. She previously met with
staff, and emphasized the main component of the program she runs was that they give grants and funding to
help achieve the goals. In addition to giving grants, they provide guidance and could be a resource to help
achieve the goals in Caldwell.
Dan Everhart SHPO pointed out that Maria has a goal to reach, and that was to meet with all 40 of the local
partners this year. Their other goal was to not let this be the only time they meet in person. While it may not be
achievable to meet with every single one of the 40 partners every year, there are some benefits to be closer to
the ones in the Treasure Valley. His expectation was they want to be someone who you see regularly enough to
know who they are, and while they might not make it to every single one of the meetings, they definitely want
to be a presence via email, and possibly at least once a year at a Caldwell meeting to hear what was going on
and build on and expand the relationship they built and move forward.
Maria Rachal SHPO emphasized that her job was to assist the local government, and to not hesitate to reach out
with questions.
Commissioner Best indicated the Board was embarking on doing a strategic plan, and they are looking for
resources and ideas. She asked if SHPO had any examples or ideas as to what a historic commission in Idaho
would do.
Dan Everhart SHPO stated there are ways they might help facilitate the planning process, and perhaps find
funding that could super charge that effort. There are ways they could get involved, there would be more
detailed conversations about that. He added that every community was unique, and the only sure method to
serve and protect our historic places in Idaho was to have a local Design Review program. He noted that
Caldwell was one of 10 that oversees and implements a Design Review program for Historic Preservation.
Places like Idaho Fails do not have a program to preserve or protect. Caldwell was doing a lot of things right,
the work that was done in the Steunenberg District was noticeable, and it was a beautiful neighborhood. He said
they can certainly point you in the direction of what other communities are doing, preservation plans from other
towns, and similarly sized communities.
Commissioner Lyons thanked SHPO for attending the meeting and added that this meeting was productive as
far as being able to share information and see what the future holds and would take advantage of any resources
provided.
(DISCUSSION ITEM: Commission & Staff Reports).
April Cabello announced that Sue resigned from the Commission and they have openings. She was unaware if
Dr. Kevin Talbert or Dr. Andrew Geddes are still interested to be part of the Board. She also mentioned that
Planning and Zoning has gone through another transition and they now have a new Director, Robin Collins and
a new Senior Planner, Elizabeth Allen.
Commissioner Maughan asked if it would be possible for either or both to be invited and be present at the planning
meeting set for February 28. Historically, the CHPC has done its most effective work when they have been in
Page 4 of S Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes
02/22/2023
i
close cooperation with the City planning staff. There was a past director who had been instrumental in seeking a
vision and funding, and it would be a real advantage for the commission if they are able to establish a relationship
like that.
(ADJOURNMENT)
Moved by Commissioner Maughan, SECONDED by Commissioner Best to adjourn at 7:30 p.m.
MOTION CARRIED
Respectfully submitted by Ellen Miller,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON LYONS ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW
C rs o Date
ATTEST: Planning & Zoning Representative Date
For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording.
Page 5 of 5
02/22/2023
Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes