Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2023-01-25 CHPC MinutesCALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES Meeting of January 25, 2023 6:30 P.M. qpp OVED Caldwell Planning & Zoning — Conference Ro 621 Cleveland Blvd, Caldwell, Idaho Call to order. Chairperson Lyons called the meeting to order at approximately 6: 2�_. f 2 �) � Members Present. Randy Lyons, Nicole Bradshaw, and Julie Best. Members Absent: Renee DeHaas, Steve Maughan, and Sue Schaper. Others Present. Elizabeth Allen, Senior Planner; April Cabello, Planning Technician; and Douglas Waterman, City Attorney. Others Absent: None (ACTION ITEM: APPROVE MINUTES). MOVED by Bradshaw, SECONDED by Best to approve the Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission minutes of the meeting held on September 28, 2022 as printed. MOTION PASSED (ACTION ITEM: CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS INTERVIEWS) None. (OLD BUSINESS) (ACTION ITEM: SET GOALS / 5 YEAR PLAN) Cont. from September 28, 2022. Moved on the agenda to after New Business Open Meeting Laws. (ACTION ITEM: SARATOGA HOTEL AND PUBLIC ART) — Continued to a future meeting. (NEW BUSINESS) (DISCUSSION ITEM: INTRODUCE NEW SENIOR PLANNER) April Cabello, Planning Technician introduced Elizabeth Allen, the new Senior Planner. Elizabeth Allen provided a brief overview of her employment background. (ACTION ITEM: VOTE CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR FOR 2023) MOTION TO ELECT RANDY LYONS AS CHAIR. MOVED by Commissioner Bradshaw, SECONDED by Commissioner Best to close the discussion. MOTION CARRIED MOTION TO ELECT NICOLE BRADSHAW AS VICE CHAIR. MOVED by Commissioner Lyons, SECONDED by Commissioner Bast to close the discussion. MOTION CARRIED Pagel of 5 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes 01/25/2023 (ACTION ITEM: OPEN MEETING LAWS AND WORKSHOPS) Mr. Waterman stated he was there to facilitate the general discussion of the plan and how to navigate it. He said he would also answer questions on how the board can set a workshop. The general rule is, if there is a quorum, it has to be an open meeting. If there is not a quorum it would not be an open meeting and the commission would not be able to make a decision. He noted that overall, the board can schedule a meeting and have a discussion. Mr. Waterman announced that he is now the Vice Chair of Nampa's Arts and Historic Preservation Commission and provided a short summary of the Commission. Discussion followed about workshop questions concerning open meetings, requirements, notices and locations. Ms. Cabello indicated that the commission wanted to work on the 5 Year Plan, however, the concern was getting staff time and doing open law meetings. She asked if there was another way to do it, i.e., to form a subcommittee. She stated that in order to have workshops, the commission would need to meet outside of a normal meeting schedule due to staffing limitations. She asked if staff would need to attend those meetings. Mr. Waterman responded no. He said the meetings could be held so staff did not have to attend, however, the meetings would need to be recorded and a staff member could take meeting minutes. He added that it would need to be an approximate representation of what was discussed, and if any decisions were made. The standard practice for the City Council workshop minutes is that there would be a single Iine that said "there was a workshop held concerning the Airport Commission, and ideas on how to amend their bylaws were discussed". Commissioner Lyons asked if that workshop meeting would need to be advertised. Mr. Waterman concurred and added, that an agenda would need to be posted, and it did not need to be published. Ms. Cabello asked how that would work, where could the meeting be held, since they would not be able to be in the building. Mr. Waterman replied that the meeting could be held at the Caldwell Public Library. Commissioner Lyons asked if they could meet on a Saturday morning at a coffee shop. It is a public building and there are no closed doors, or if it could be held at someone's home. Mr. Waterman stated, it could be held at someone's home as long as they leave the door unlocked, and post a note saying "anyone who wants to attend this meeting is welcome to come W'. He added, there is not an obligation that the space be a traditional public space. Ms. Cabello wanted the board to be clear that if the meeting was held at someone's home, the home address would be on the agenda, and the agenda would be posted on the window, bulletin board and on the web. She asked if the meeting was to be held at a coffee shop, would they need to get approval from them. Mr. Waterman concurred. In response to questions from Commissioner Lyons, Ms. Cabello said the requirement to post the agenda is 48 hours but as a courtesy, they post the agenda one week before. Mr. Waterman read a portion of the code that says "staff shall be secretary/clerk for the commission and shall be responsible for swearing those in. Taking/keeping minutes or recording all meetings and hearings, agendas, etc." He noted it could be argued that a staff member needs to be present to take minutes, however, he does not think it would be a problem to record the meeting and sign the meeting minutes after. Discussion was held on potential meeting places. Commissioner Best asked Mr. Waterman if he had any other advice for them, based on his experience, as far as conducting or planning these type of meetings with other organizations or entities. Mr. Waterman replied that the procedure is increasingly important when there is a decision to make. Decreasingly important when only having discussions. He added, that when meetings go wrong is when the quorum falls apart, The Chair is responsible for maintaining the quorum meeting. The quorum falls apart when there are a lot of participants who are upset. Page 2 of 5 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes 01/25/2023 Commissioner Lyons indicated that sometimes he meets with board members to have coffee and discuss what is going around the neighborhood or downtown. That is only a common discussion and is not a meeting. He understands they need to be cautious on what is discussed. He asked if there is something wrong with saying "I really enjoyed some ideas you talked about the other night". Mr. Waterman stated it all depends on whether or not they are undertaking the business of the Commission. This is a gray area. He said the main thing to avoid is to discuss an open application. The consequence of not having a quorum is that is not a meeting and no decisions could be made. Ms. Cabello asked if a meeting could be open even if there is not a quorum. Mr. Waterman stated it would not be a meeting. He said a recording could be kept of the conversation between the members of the board, and make it available to the public. If there is not a quorum the commission can't do anything. Commissioner Best asked for clarification, if they have a quorum when they open the meeting and a decision needs to be made, then someone has to recuse themselves, you would still have the quorum, since you only need to have the quorum to open the meeting, correct. Mr. Waterman concurred. Commissioner Bradshaw said she was under the understanding that if there was a discussion with another board member about an application, they need to disclose the conversation at the next meeting. Ms. Cabello asked if the commission wanted to go look at a site before a hearing would they be able to. Mr. Waterman responded they could, however, it would need to be an open public meeting at the site. This would give them an opportunity to see what the board is seeing, and they could comment on that. He gave an example of a meeting that was held on a bus. The bus route was mapped out on the agenda, there were no decisions to be made, however, it had to be an open meeting, and they had to have enough room on the bus so that if anyone else wanted to participate in the meeting, they could board the bus. Commissioner Bradshaw said that in the past they had a couple of trainings with Idaho State and Chuck Randall and did them as walk -around tours and understanding different architectural effects. She asked if those had to be public hearings. Ms. Cabello affirmed those were public hearings, and said they were recorded. Commissioner Best said she understands they are not allowed to have a discussion about a specific project outside of the hearing, however, if it does happen, to make sure they disclose it at the next hearing. Commissioner Bradshaw asked if they are in a meeting, and there is an applicant present, can they pull up their information or look at google pictures since it was not presented as part of the package. Mr. Waterman stated the obligation of an ex-parte matter is separate from the open meeting. The obligation is that a decision is made based upon the evidence presented. As a general practice rule, if somebody pulls up an overhead, the Chair would say something on the lines of "we will label the overhead as Exhibit...." and include that on the record. Commissioner Best pointed out that if there is not enough information provided, they could also ask for the hearing to be continued. (DISCUSSION ITEM: COMMISSION AND STAFF REPORTS) April Cabello informed the commission that the annual update report presentation to the City Council for 2023 has been cancelled. A presentation would not be required from the commission this year. In addition, the position for City Council Liaison has been removed from the Historic Preservation Commission. Commissioner Lyons commented on the Liaison position being removed from the City Council. He said he did not want to see any less value or significance taken away from any commission. He did not want that to become Page 3 of 5 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes 01 /25/2023 * a weakness in the protection of the Historic Districts of Caldwell. fn his opinion, it would weaken their stance since they no longer have that relationship with the City. Commissioner Bradshaw asked how the City Council would know what the Historic Preservation Commission is doing. Ms. Cabello mentioned that in the past, the Chair would submit a yearly report prepared by the commission and the Liaison would report back to the City Council at the workshops, Commissioner Best stated that one of their objectives could be to submit written evidence of the projects they have done over a period of time. Commissioner Bradshaw asked if there would be an opportunity for them to go give a summary of what is going on to the City Council. Mr. Waterman explained that any person is entitled to go to City Council meetings. Although, he said the Certificates of Appropriateness that the Historic Preservation Commission issues, are pre -building permits. For the most part, they are not pre -development applications, the development occurring in the district is not the type of project that would go in front of the City Council. The decisions made would occur after the City Council makes development decisions. He understands that without a Certificate of Appropriateness a building permit could not be issued, however, they could connect with the City Council on more general historic planning items. If there are individual concerns or as the Chair collectively, they could reach out to the Mayor and talk about it. Commissions are viewed as staff support and not direct Council support. Mr. Waterman also added that the City would fill the position of Planning and Zoning Director. The P & Z Director would meet with all the department heads, and the Mayor to talk general economic development, and also general City topics. Once the new P & Z Director is appointed, the board could express their desires and objectives to him, and that would serve the purpose of keeping the commission relevant and plugged in. Commissioner Lyons thought it would be beneficial for one board member to attend the City Council meetings, that way, they can report among themselves the development of the town. Commissioner Bradshaw asked about the 5 Year Plan and what resources they have to get it done, or if it's only a vision. She feels it has become so convoluted because of the gaps and has lost the original reason for this plan. She feels they need guidance and direction to have a discussion about the 5 Year Plan, Commissioner Best asked if currently, there was a Historic Preservation Plan in place. The answer was no. Commissioner Lyons indicated that one has been in the works for a couple of years. Commissioner Best asked if the Strategic Plan was something different than the Historic Preservation Plan. The answer was no. Ms. Cabello mentioned that is what brought up the question about the workshops. They can get together as a commission to figure out what kind of things they would like to put on this plan, then take it back to the commission to vote. Possibly, put the ideas down and take it to the director to see what can be done or what resources they would have. Commissioner Lyons talked about raising funds. He said there are agencies that give out money to continue the cultural diversity and historic preservation. He added that Caldwell has really good signage and would like to add to the signage. He also noted that their mission statement is to preserve and protect the integrity of the Historic District. Mr. Waterman informed the board members he emailed them the link to Nampa's Historic Preservation Plan for their reference. He noted it was adopted in 2020, and it describes the history and the objectives going forward. Commissioner Best mentioned that the previous Director had a vision for the board members to try to extend beyond the Steunenberg to historical structures in the area, and increase awareness like the Saratoga. Page 4 of 5 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes 01 /25/2023 Ms. Cabello asked since the Historic Preservation Commission was formed for the CLG, can they legally branch out to do surveys of other neighborhoods. Mr. Waterman responded to the question and said, they can only do what the City Council allows them to do. In terms of Certificate of Appropriateness, the only way anybody is obligated to obtain one of those, is if the City says they need one. The City could go through a Certificate of Appropriateness process that wasn't historic preservation specific, which is done with Design Review and could, in theory, assign the responsibility for that to the commission without it being in a historic district. Commissioner Best asked if they could go ahead and schedule a workshop. Commissioner Bradshaw concurred. Commissioner Lyons asked if it would be considered a meeting, if they met at a bookstore on a Saturday morning. Ms. Cabello concurred and said, if there are going to be two or more members present, they need to let her know so she can put the agenda on the bulletin board and post it on the website. (ACTION ITEM: SET GOALS 15 YEAR PLAN) Cont. from September 28, 2022. The Commission held discussion and decided to have a separate workshop to discuss setting the 5 Year Plan and include the topics in New Business as part of that discussion. Discussion followed about different possible grants available to the community for renovations at museums or historical places. Ms. Cabello stated all the information she would need to know is that it would be a workshop, she does not need to state anything else on the agenda. Mr. Waterman concurred and said the agenda is only supposed to provide notice to the public of what is going to be talked about or discussed. If it is going to be the 5 Year Plan, the agenda would say "discussion on the 5 Year Plan". He also added that the board should email any ideas to Ms. Cabello and ask her to distribute them to the group. Commissioner Best suggested the members look at the plan Mr. Waterman sent to them, and maybe look at some other historic preservation plans to obtain ideas. Mr. Waterman commented on the 502(c)(3) application. He said the board could obtain collaboration with Kiwanis, the Rotary, or the Lyons Club that have a regular membership out of which they can draw three people and then they can sort of keep this a non-profit directorship populated. He noted, if the only thing they need is a 501(c)(3) as a funding vehicle, they are not hard to generate, particularly if their revenue is going to be less $50,000 a year for the first three years. It is an easy application on the IRS website. (ADJOURNMENT) Moved by Commissioner Bradshaw, SECONDED by Commissioner Best to adjourn at 8:06 p.m. MOTION CARRIED Respectfully submitted by Ellen Miller, MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON LYONS ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW For detailed minutes, please request a copy of the digital recording. Page 5 of 5 01/25/2023 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes