HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-11-10 CHPC minutes CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION A 11ilgEsAPPROVEDp
Meeting of November 10,2021 @ 6:30 P.M. ( ---
Caldwell Police Department—Community Room Date
110 S 51'Avenue,Caldwell,Idaho
I. Call to order. Vice-Chairperson Lyons called the meeting to order at approximately 6:30 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present.Randy Lyons, Steve Maughan,Nicole Bradshaw and Sue Schaper.
Members Absent.
Others Present.Jerome Mapp,Planning&Zoning Director;and April Cabello,Planning Technician.
Others Absent. Rob Hopper,City Council Liaison.
III. Approval of Minutes. Action Item.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF AUGUST 11,2021.
MOTION Commissioner Maughan SECOND: Commissioner Schaper,MOTION PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.Action Item.None
V. OLD BUSINESS: Discussion Item. None.
VI. NEW BUSINESS: Discussion Items.
Transferring the 501(c)3 entity over to someone on the Historic Preservation Commission.
Rachelle Castleberry, City of Caldwell, Accounting Services Specialist stated they are here
tonight on behalf of the Caldwell Historic Society. The Caldwell Historic Society was created in
conjunction with the City while Brian Billingsley the previous Director of Planning&Zoning
was with the City, currently,they are a 501(c)3. The Historic Society is made up of Chuck
Randolph, Elaine Carpenter and a few other board members. The Society was to go after grant
funding to improve the Van Slyke museum for the City of Caldwell. Brian Billingsley for several
years in a row applied and received funding through the Canyon County Historic Preservation
grant. When Brian Billingsley left the City of Caldwell, there was a couple years' worth of grant
funding that she had helped the society work through spending out there at the balance. The
society is at a point where many of the members have dropped off as far as participating in
meetings and being involved. Chuck and Elaine who are the treasurer and Chuck is the legal
owner of the 501(c)3 but want to dissolve it or transfer over to new ownership. They want to
retire it and let go of it. The society is in the process of spending down any remaining funds that
they have out there at the Van Slyke. The City of Caldwell has grant funding that they go after as
well, for the Van Slyke museum. The City of Caldwell has a small grant that they are trying to
spend out and had an idea of having somebody take over that 501(c)3 ownership. Someone who
could get more involved with the grant writing, specifically with Canyon County, and other ones
Page 1 of 4 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes
where they will only administer funds to a nonprofit entity, rather than a government entity. The
City itself when we have the staff and the time will probably continue to look for funding through
grants that can be applied through as a government entity. But the Canyon County grant
specifically will halt if the 501(c)3 three dissolves. She has been working a lot with the County
and the society to move these grant funds forward. They have design work to show what they
want to do out at the Van Slyke meseum. We just do not have the individuals who have the time
to go after more funding, which is what would be needed to go further on the project. The Van
Slyke family themselves have also donated to this project and the last time she had checked with
Chuck it was about$12,000.00 to $13,000.00 contributed along with about$3,000.00 that was
contributed by other miscellaneous individuals and through a little bit of funding that was
received on the Fourth of July. That money is currently held within the Historic Society. The
society is working to spend that money down with the direction of the Van Slyke family. The
society is saying they want to be done. They want to spend this money and then close out or
transfer. The society is currently working with a contractor that does signature signs and they
want to get a wall designed that has a plaque and signature in relation to the Van Slyke history
and their contribution to the pieces in that museum. The city has a$10,000 Idaho Heritage Trust
grant that they are trying to spend down with a$5,000.00 match from the City.
Debbie Geyer, City Clerk shared that her connection is with the Train Depot and they have the
Friends of the Depot already established as a nonprofit for the purpose of promoting education,
the museum and that type of thing that's located at the at the Train Depot. We collaborate as part
of our board with the Caldwell Model Train Club. The Historic Society and the Caldwell Model
Train Club worked together restoring the caboose at Van Slyke museum. Van Slyke museum has
a reefer car that needs repair and this is where the Idaho Heritage Trust grant would come in. The
Caldwell Model Train Club are more than excited and willing to continue working on that
because their members are about 50. The Caldwell Model Train Club is excited to take on those
types of projects and it would help with the expensing down those funds. Ms. Geyer stated that
she had talked to Dave Wilson, who is with the Model Railroad Club about this in the past,long
before the city really took this on as a project itself. The Kiwanis Club used to every year open up
the facility;they cleaned it up and held an open house during the July 4ffi celebration. They would
have tours and stuff behind the gates. The initial funding sought by Brian Billingsley helped to
repair the Van Slyke cabins. They reappointed the log cabins and made them so that,they would
not crumble. Susan the Mayor's secretary at the time was very instrumental in getting that started,
as well as the first go around and rehabbing one of the train cars. The Caldwell Model Train Club
does not feel like there would be any opposition for them to continue working in partnership with
the City and finish out the second car on the site. The Caldwell Model Train Club maybe willing
once a year to open up Van Slyke museum and conduct tours at the facility on July 4th,but the
club has not gotten back to her.
Rachelle Castleberry stated that the finance director for the City has expressed concern with
ongoing staff time and audit positions that requires a lot of extra paperwork. The Van Slyke
family has been very vocal and excited about being involved. The funds from the Idaho Heritage
Trust,being used more for the second car and the master plan that was just recently redone. The
grant funding we had from the County could only use it a certain way. We had to redefine what
we were going to do at the Van Slyke museum. Brian Billingsley had identified to do three
concrete slabs. Since the construction work was done, it is not walkable,because they had to dig
Page 2 of 4 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes
up a lot of the dirt to get the concrete laid. We are trying to get gravel or pavers put in. When
Brian left, she helped take over and now oversees the grant funds for the City on the finance side
and if they go after grant funding she would take it and manage it. So if the 501(c)3 ceases to
exist that means only operational funding will be Idaho Heritage Trust. We could potentially go
for funding from a couple of other entities. If the 501(c)3 continues to exist,the biggest piece is
the Canyon County funding.
Commissioner Maughan stated that the reason that we created the Historic Society in the first
place was precisely to get funding that could not be granted to a governmental entity. That was
quite specific for the downtown signage, signage, Justice Park, a number of other of those
activities. That was the reason for its existence. He does not think the commission is in a position
now. He is not prepared to be an officer of such Foundation, especially when we do not have a
goal. The Historic Preservation Commission is currently trying to reassess their strategic approach
to what we do as well. If there were a clear reason for us to take this on, and we had a plan and a
goal, it would make sense. Is this an instrument that the Historic Preservation Commission thinks
could be useful? Does the Historic Preservation Commission want to take on the responsibility
but not as a commission but as individual members?The Caldwell Historic Society would have to
transfer the ownership and the responsibility of the foundation to members of the commission,but
not the commission as an entity,because that is not legal.
The Historic Preservation asked for 1 year to further look into if they as individuals could legally
take on the 501(c)3 and or if it would be useful for the Commission.
CLG Grant Discussion.
April Cabello, Planning&Zoning shared that as a commission,we used to apply for the CLG
funding for surveys,but have run out potential districts. The problem is the CLG grant requires a
50%match and the Mayor funds it. The Commission has to match that with time and the problem
we have is keeping commissioners and not having the commissioners attending meetings and
trainings to meet the match. We also have to look at the staff time, who handles the grant. We do
not have the time and even though we are getting more staff,it is still not going to be enough to
help cover that time.
Commissioner Maughan asked what the commission's direction is. There is nothing problematic
about not taking the CLG grant a given year. We might be in a position where we can wait just a
bit and maybe do a year of pass on the CLG Grant.
April Cabello respond at this time the commission should wait until they have a better direction of
what they want to do.
Commission& Staff Reports.
Jerome Mapp, Director of Planning&Zoning shared that Tim King had resigned from the
commission. One of our highest priorities is finding some other residents of the City who are
interested in being members of the commission.
Page 3 of 4 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes
VII. Meeting adjourned at approximately 7:45 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY VICE-CHAIR LYONS ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
Vice-ChaiCV04 Date
ATTEST: Jerome Mapp, Planning frectll Date
For detailed minutes,please request a copy of the digital recording.
Page 4 of 4 Caldwell Historic Preservation Minutes